Palmer v Premiair Aviation Maintenance Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Palmer v Premiair Aviation Maintenance Pty Ltd [2022] FCA 185

File number: NSD 423 of 2021
Judgment of: YATES J
Date of judgment: 7 March 2022
Catchwords: COSTS – discontinuance of proceeding – whether costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law, Schedule 2 of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 21

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 40.02(a)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Colgate-Palmolive Pty Ltd (No 5) [2021] FCA 246; 151 ACSR 26

Palmer v Gold Coast Publications Pty Ltd [2013] QSC 352

Razzy Australia Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2021] VSC 409

Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd [2009] FCAFC 166; 182 FCR 160

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 25
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr D Jones of Jonathon Shaw Solicitors
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr M Mackrell of Norton White Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 423 of 2021
BETWEEN:

CLIVE FREDERICK PALMER

Applicant

AND:

PREMIAIR AVIATION MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ACN 078 994 564

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 MARCH 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to r 40.02(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the costs awarded under Order 2 made on 3 December 2021 be paid by the applicant on an indemnity basis.

2.For the avoidance of doubt, Order 2 made on 3 December 2021 is to include the costs of seeking Order 1 made above.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

YATES J:

INTRODUCTION

  1. Pursuant to consent orders made on 3 December 2021, leave was granted to the applicant to discontinue this proceeding, with the applicant to pay the respondent’s costs.

  2. The respondent seeks its costs on an indemnity basis: r 40.02(a) Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). The applicant opposes that application.

  3. Procedural orders were made for the determination of that question, with the application to be adjourned for hearing on a date to be fixed by the Court or to be determined on the papers.

  4. Having received and considered the parties’ submissions, I have determined that it is appropriate that this question be determined on the papers.

    BACKGROUND

  5. The proceeding (NSD423/2021) was commenced on 10 May 2021.  It concerns work carried out by the respondent on a Cessna Citation X aircraft, which the applicant owns.

  6. On 23 November 2020, prior to commencing the proceeding, the applicant’s lawyer wrote to the respondent, stating amongst other things:

    1. My client understands that you are presently in possession of his aircraft and that you have been performing work on the aircraft.

    2. My client has not engaged your company to perform any work on his aircraft.

    3. My client has not entered into a contract with your company in respect of any matters relating to the aircraft.

    4.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Palmer v Premiair Aviation Maintenance Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 185
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Palmer, brought a proceeding against Premiair Aviation Maintenance Pty Ltd, the respondent, concerning work carried out on a Cessna Citation X aircraft owned by the applicant. The proceeding was commenced on 10 May 2021, but subsequently discontinued by the applicant on 15 October 2021. The respondent sought indemnity costs in relation to the discontinued proceeding. The court was required to determine whether costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, given that the proceeding had been discontinued by the applicant.

The court considered the submissions of both parties and found that the applicant’s reason for discontinuing the proceeding was that he was not aware of the existence of a Lease, which was in his possession, custody, or power, and which he had executed just three months before the letter of demand of 23 November 2020. The court found that, had the applicant been aware of the Lease, he would not have commenced the proceeding in the first place. The court also noted that the applicant’s submissions, which sought to support the underlying merits of the proceeding, were difficult to reconcile with the terms of the letter itself and the applicant’s unilateral decision to discontinue. The court concluded that, in those circumstances, it was unreasonable to expect that the respondent should bear the costs consequences of the applicant’s own forensic decisions, which subjected the respondent to completely unnecessary cost.

The court held that the respondent, as an unwilling party to the proceeding, should be protected, as far as possible, from the adverse costs consequences of the applicant’s decisions. For these reasons, the court awarded the respondent’s costs on an indemnity basis. The applicant was ordered to pay the respondent’s costs on an indemnity basis, and the costs of seeking the order were also to be included.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 40.02(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the costs awarded under Order 2 made on 3 December 2021 be paid by the applicant on an indemnity basis.

2. For the avoidance of doubt, Order 2 made on 3 December 2021 is to include the costs of seeking Order 1 made above.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Having received and considered the parties’ submissions, I have determined that it is appropriate that this question be determined on the papers.BACKGROUND The proceeding (NSD423/2021) was commenced on 10 May 2021. It concerns work carried out by the respondent on a Cessna Citation X aircraft, which the applicant owns. On 23 November 2020, prior to commencing the proceeding, the applicant’s lawyer wrote to the respondent, stating amongst other things: 1. My client understands that you are presently in possession of his aircraft and that you have been performing work on the aircraft.2. My client has not engaged your company to perform any work on his aircraft.3. My client has not entered into a contract with your company in respect of any matters relating to the aircraft.4. My client understands that a former employee of Mineralogy Pty Ltd, Mr Carlo Filingeri has been giving instructions to you regarding work to be performed on the aircraft.5. My client has not authorised Mr Filingeri to give any instructions on his behalf. Mr Filingeri is employed by Mineralogy, not Mr Palmer.6. Mr Palmer has not authorised Mineralogy (nor Mr Filingeri) to act on his behalf in respect of work to be performed on the aircraft. On 4 December 2020, the respondent’s lawyers responded, stating amongst other things: It is sufficient to point out at this stage that Mr Filingeri was authorised to act on behalf of Mineralogy and in all likelihood on instructions given by Mr Palmer. In any event, the work that has been carried out was pursuant to written agreements between PremiAir and Mineralogy and that Mr Palmer, if he is the owner of the aircraft as you contend, entrusted the aircraft to Mineralogy. The scope of the work to be undertaken was dictated by the instructions given by your clients and the circumstances including, in particular, the fact that the aircraft had not been operated for many years and had been left in the open for most of that time, and obviously was not in an airworthy condition.Relevantly, you have referred … in your letter of 23 November 2020 to the costs that Mr Palmer will incur in having the aircraft repaired and made airworthy. The confirmation that Mr Palmer wants to have the aircraft made airworthy is consistent with the instructions given by Mr Filingeri. The work that PremiAir has undertaken is necessary to achieve that end. The suggestion that your client can have the benefit of the work carried out to make the aircraft airworthy without paying for the work is absurd. In a Concise Statement filed on 10 May 2021, the applicant alleged, somewhat inconsistently with the position stated in the letter of 23 November 2020 that, in 2020, Mr Filingeri was, in fact, his agent and that Mr Filingeri had entered into contracts with the respondent to carry out work on the aircraft. The applicant alleged, however, that Mr Filingeri had entered into the contracts outside the authority and scope of the agency he had been given. The applicant alleged that the contracts were entered into on 22 June 2020, 27 July 2020, 19 October 2020, and 5 November 2020. He alleged that, between about June and November 2020, the respondent obtained possession of the aircraft in accordance with the terms of the contracts, and dismantled it. He alleged that this constituted damage. He advanced claims in trespass and conversion, detinue, and unconscionable conduct within the meaning of s 21 of the Australian Consumer Law. Amongst other relief, he claimed the estimated cost of reassembling the aircraft ($932,107.92) or, alternatively, its value if not returned ($2,000,000.00).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the applicant submits that there is no “special or unusual feature in the case”; it is not “almost certain” that the respondent would have succeeded if the matter had been fully tried; and he has not acted “so unreasonably that the other party should obtain the costs of the action”.CONCLUSION In the absence of evidence from the applicant himself, I conclude, from the terms of the letter dated 15 October 2021, that the applicant’s reason for discontinuing proceeding NSD423/2021 was that he was not aware of the Lease, even though the Lease was in his possession, custody, or power, and even though he executed the Lease for himself and on behalf of Mineralogy just three months before the letter of demand of 23 November 2020. I also infer that, had he been aware of the Lease, the applicant would not have commenced the proceeding in the first place. Contrary to the applicant’s submission, there is no other rational conclusion, given the terms of the letter itself, which speak of the necessity to discontinue. The applicant’s submissions—that his claims in respect of contracts up to 25 August 2020 are unaffected by the Lease; that there has been no determination that, under the Lease, Mineralogy could have, or should have, entered into maintenance contracts with the respondent; that there remains an issue as to Mr Filingeri’s authority; and that the proceeding, at the time of its commencement, and at the time of its discontinuance, had good prospects of success—are difficult to reconcile with the terms of the letter itself and the applicant’s unilateral decision to discontinue. In any event, these matters—which seek to support the underlying merits of the proceeding—are really beside the point because they do not engage with the fact that, having commenced the proceeding, the applicant chose not to pursue it. In those circumstances, it is unreasonable to expect that the respondent should bear the costs consequences of those decisions. This, it seems to me, justifies a departure from the ordinary rule that, usually, costs are ordered on a party and party basis. The respondent, as an unwilling party to the proceeding, should be protected, as far as possible, from the adverse costs consequences of what were the applicant’s own forensic decisions, which subjected the respondent to completely unnecessary cost. For these reasons, the applicant should pay the respondent’s costs on an indemnity basis. Orders will be made accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.