P and Child Support Registrar M OTHER PARTY

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

[2014] AATA  229

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/3820

Re

P

APPLICANT

And

Child Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

And

M

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

Date 17 April 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is set aside and substituted with a decision that the existing determination for the percentage of care be revoked as of 8 January 2013 and from that date the applicant’s percentage of care for A is 55% and the second respondent’s percentage of care is 45%.

..........................[SGD]..............................................

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

Publication of this decision is approved by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal pursuant to s 110X(4)(h) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – court orders for equal shared parental responsibility - factors relevant to the determination of actual care - child weekly boarder at school - payment of school fees - how care should be apportioned between parents for periods spent at boarding school - determination of new percentages of care in a period – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 35A, 40C, 50, 54A, 54H, 54F, 55C

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 89, 103VA

CASES

P v Child Support Registrar and M [2012] FCA 1398

P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
The Father and the Child Support Registrar [2012] AATA 39
Confidential v Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] AATA 426

Polec v Staker (2011) 253 FLR 339

SECONDARY MATERIALS

The Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms J L Redfern, Senior Member

17 April 2014

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant and the second respondent are the parents of three children. They are divorced. Two of the children, C and A, attend a private boarding school in Sydney. The applicant seeks review of a decision by the Social Security Appeals Tribunal (SSAT) made on 23 July 2013 to affirm a decision of the Child Support Registrar, the first respondent, not to revoke an existing determination setting the applicant’s percentage of care for his child, A, at 50%. Their oldest child, C, has previously been the subject of a disputed percentage of care determination by the first respondent.

  2. Pursuant to orders made by consent by the Federal Magistrates Court on 6 June 2011 (the consent orders), the applicant and second respondent have equal shared parental responsibility for their children.

  3. It is common ground that A is a weekly boarder at St Joseph’s College and lives with his parents on alternate weekends and during school holidays. Under the orders of the Federal Magistrates Court, the applicant and/or his mother are responsible for payment of boarding, education and tuition fees.

  4. On 8 January 2013, the applicant applied to the first respondent for a variation in the assessment of his percentage of care for A for the purposes of the child support scheme. In making his application, the applicant relied on the financial support provided, or to be provided,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read P and Child Support Registrar M OTHER PARTY and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of P and the Child Support Registrar, the Tribunal was called upon to reassess the percentage of care provided by the applicant to his child, A, who is a weekly boarder at St Joseph's College. The dispute centered on how to accurately determine the applicant's percentage of care given the unique circumstances of A being a weekly boarder, and the implications this had on the calculation of child support payments. The second respondent contested the applicant's claim that he should be attributed with a higher percentage of care due to his payment of A's school fees. The matter was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which had to balance the relevant factors to arrive at a fair determination of the actual care provided.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was how to properly assess the applicant's percentage of care for A, especially during the periods when A was a weekly boarder at school. The Tribunal had to consider whether the statutory methodology under section 54A(1) of the relevant Act was applicable or whether a different approach, informed by the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Assessment Act), the Child Support (Assessment) Guide, and relevant case law, should be adopted. The Tribunal also had to evaluate the evidence presented regarding the nature of care provided by both parents during the periods A was boarding and whether this care should be attributed differently.

The Tribunal found that the statutory methodology under section 54A(1) was not suitable for this case due to the specific circumstances of A being a weekly boarder. Instead, the Tribunal adopted an approach that considered a range of factors, as suggested in Polec v Staker and the Assessment Guide. The Tribunal noted that attributing nights to either parent during the boarding periods would be artificial and arbitrary. The evidence showed that both parents were involved in A's care in various ways, despite neither having physical custody during the boarding periods. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant's payment of school fees should not be the sole determinant of his percentage of care, as it did not account for the significant level of care provided by the second respondent. By considering all relevant factors, the Tribunal determined that the applicant's actual care percentage should be reassessed.

The Tribunal revoked the existing determination of the applicant's percentage of care, which had been set at 50%, and substituted a new determination of 55% for the applicant and 45% for the second respondent, effective from 8 January 2013. This reassessment also impacted the cost percentages for each party, with the applicant's cost percentage adjusted to 55%. The Tribunal's decision was based on a comprehensive evaluation of the evidence and the unique circumstances of the case, ensuring a fair and accurate assessment of the actual care provided by each parent.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the applicant and the second respondent regarding the custody and child support arrangements for their three children. The two older children, C and A, attend St Joseph's College as weekly boarders. The youngest child is still in primary school. The applicant and the second respondent have been in dispute about their custody and child support arrangements for a number of years, with multiple proceedings before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal and the Federal Magistrates Court. The consent orders made in 2011 in the Federal Magistrates Court, which have remained in place, establish the custody and care arrangements for the children. There has been ongoing dispute about compliance with these orders.

During the periods when A is boarding at school, there is a significant dispute about the care provided by each parent and the nature of payments made for A's school fees. The applicant argues that since he pays the school fees, he should be attributed with more care, while the second respondent contends that she is also actively involved in A's care despite not having physical custody. The evidence also includes correspondence from the school about fees, statements from various individuals, and bank documents.

The case came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of a decision made by the Child Support Registrar. The Tribunal considered documents lodged by the first respondent, statements from various individuals, and evidence given at the hearing. The applicant sought to rely on evidence from a previous proceeding before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, but this was not pressed. The Tribunal examined the evidence and made findings on contested factual matters, while recording the essence of uncontested facts. The Tribunal's decision set aside the existing determination of the applicant's percentage of care and substituted a new determination based on its assessment of actual care.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Finally, the applicant sought to rely on evidence served by the second respondent in proceedings before the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, apparently relating to the disputed custody issues. The first and second respondent objected to the tender of this document and the applicant did not press its tender. THE EVIDENCE The evidence before the Tribunal comprised documents lodged by the first respondent under section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, a statement from AP, a statement from a friend and business associate of the applicant, SH, a loan agreement between the applicant and SH dated 8 January 2014, bank documents from the applicant’s bank (said to be relevant to the repayment of a loan from AP to the applicant) and correspondence from St Joseph's College about fees. In addition, the applicant and the second respondent gave evidence at the hearing and AP and SH were cross examined on their statements. There was significant dispute about the care provided by each parent while A was boarding but this dispute largely focused on the nature of the payments made for A’s school fees and whether these should be attributed to the applicant for the purposes of assessment of his percentage of care of A during the period A was boarding. There was also dispute about compliance with the consent orders and there was evidence about recent events following the 2013 Christmas holidays which, according to the second respondent, are the subject of proceedings, or contemplated proceedings, before the Federal Magistrates Court. These alleged changes in circumstances are also the basis for the applicant’s most recent application for variation in his percentage of care. The applicant and the second respondent have been in dispute about their custody and child support arrangements in respect of their children for a number of years. This is evident from the various proceedings before this Tribunal and the proceedings before the Federal Magistrate Court, which are a matter of public record. Notwithstanding these disputes, which are acrimonious, there was no contest about many of the key facts. Where there was a factual contest about a matter which is relevant to the questions for determination in the proceedings, I have identified the evidence and made specific findings. I have otherwise adopted the approach of recording the essence of the uncontested matters. The applicant and the second respondent have three children, now aged 15, 13 and 9 years old. The older children (C and A) attend St Joseph's College, where they are weekly boarders. The youngest child is still in primary school. The second respondent is employed part-time and lives in Gladesville, which is close to St Joseph's College. The applicant also lives in Gladesville. On 6 June 2011, the applicant and the second respondent agreed to consent orders in the Federal Magistrates Court. AP was joined as a party to those proceedings. These orders have been in place from the time they were made until the time of the hearing in this matter and, while proceedings have been foreshadowed, there is no evidence that the orders have been revoked or varied. The consent orders cover the custody and care arrangements between the applicant and the second respondent in relation to their children. There has been dispute between the applicant and the second respondent about compliance with these orders over the years but the orders evidence the agreement between them about the custody and care arrangements for their children.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the balance of the periods, either the applicant or the second respondent is solely responsible for care, and given they share custody equally, their respective percentage of care for A is 50% each. This is not in dispute. When these percentages are combined with those applicable to the period when A is boarding, it produces a result that the applicant would be assessed overall as having actual care of A of 55% and the second respondent 45%. This does not correspond to the existing percentages of care determined by the first respondent. Furthermore, if the existing percentages of care for A were changed to reflect my assessment of actual care of A during the care period, this would affect the respective cost percentages of each of the applicant and the second respondent. Under section 55C of the Assessment Act if there is a percentage of care in the range of more than 52% but less than 65%, the cost percentage will be 51% plus 2% for each percentage point over 53%t. Thus, given my assessment of actual care, the cost percentage for the applicant would also be 55% rather than 50% as currently determined. Conclusion Having found that the actual care of A by the applicant for the care period does not correspond with the existing determination and that there would be an impact on the applicant's cost percentage, I am satisfied the existing determination must be revoked, effective from 8 January 2013 (s 54F of the Assessment Act). As provided by s 50, if a percentage of care determination is revoked, the responsible person’s percentage of care for the care period must be determined in accordance with s 50(3). I therefore set aside the decision under review and substitute a decision that the existing determination for the percentage of care be revoked as of 8 January 2013 and from that date the applicant’s percentage of care for A is 55% and the second respondent’s percentage of care is 45%.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

While I accept that I am not bound to follow the findings of Senior Member Bell on the percentage of care for C, I am persuaded by her approach to the question. Senior Member Bell did not make an assessment about actual care for C by reference to nights under s 54A(1) but considered a range of factors. Those factors are the matters identified in the Guide and in Polec v Staker, which apply equally to A. There is no evidence to suggest otherwise. The approach adopted by Senior Member Bell was accepted by Wigney J in P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312. Having regard to the circumstances of this case, I am also of the view it is inappropriate to attempt to make an assessment of actual care using the methodology provided by s 54A(1). I have therefore assessed care for A by reference to a range of factors consistent with the Guide and the decision in Polec v Staker but have come to a different conclusion about the relevant percentage of care for A. My reasons follow.Consideration of how actual care should be assessed Section 54A(1) provides a methodology for assessing actual care. However, it is clear from the decision of Wigney J that use of the methodology is not mandatory and in a case where the child is at boarding school and not staying overnight with either parent, is of little guidance or assistance (at [57] – [63]). In my view, it is not useful or appropriate to attribute nights to either parent during the period that A is boarding at St Joseph’s College and to do so in the circumstances of this case would be artificial and arbitrary. Neither parent has physical custody of A during these periods yet there is evidence both are involved in his care. The applicant contended that A is entirely in the care of St Joseph’s College when he is boarding, and thereby the applicant, because he pays or is responsible for the school fees. If this is a contention that actual care should be assessed on nights and all nights should be attributed to the applicant while A is in boarding school, I reject it. This contention does not recognise the importance of certain aspects of care for A, other than those relating to his accommodation, food and clothing, and ignores the level of care provided by the second respondent during this time. She sees or speaks to A everyday during the week while he is at school, is involved in parent-teacher meetings and is listed as one of A’s emergency contacts. No major decisions about A’s health care, medical treatment or education could be made during this period without reference to the second respondent. Having found that s 54A(1) is of no assistance in this case, I must nonetheless make an assessment of actual care for A to determine the issues in dispute. As noted by previous Tribunals and the Federal Court, “actual care” is not defined in the Assessment Act, other than by reference to s 54A(1). Even though the applicant seeks a precise formulation for assessing care, namely by reference to days, nights or even hours, I have already found this method of calculation is not appropriate given A is living away from home. In the absence of a statutory test, the expression “actual care” should be given its ordinary meaning and will be informed by the Guide and any relevant case law. This was the approach taken by Senior Member Bell in Confidential v Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] in a similar context. Assessing care when a parent has physical custody of a child, particularly when the parents have agreed to yield care to the other during certain periods, is unarguable. Assessing care when a child is living away from home is more difficult.