Oswal v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 62 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Oswal v Commissioner of Taxation [2013] FCA 745

Citation: Oswal v Commissioner of Taxation [2013] FCA 745
Parties: RADHIKA PANKAJ OSWAL, PANKAJ OSWAL and PANKAJ OSWAL AS TRUSTEE OF THE BURRUP TRUST v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
File numbers: NSD 850 of 2012
NSD 851 of 2012
NSD 852 of 2012
Judge: EDMONDS J
Date of judgment: 31 July 2013
Catchwords: INCOME TAX – Part 3-1 Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) – capital gains – exercise of special power of appointment by trustee of discretionary trust in respect of part of corpus for absolute benefit of some but not all objects – whether trust created over assets by “declaration” of trust or “settlement” under s 104-55 (CGT event E1) – whether objects became absolutely entitled to assets so appointed as against the trustee under s 104-75 (CGT event E5) – whether disposal of an asset (CGT event A1)
Legislation: Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 104-10, 104-55, 104-75, 108-5, 855-15, 855-20, 995-1
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) Pt IVC
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) Div 6
Finance Act 1965 (UK) s 25
Stamps Act 1892 (Vic) Part VIII of the Schedule
Trustee’s Act 1962 (WA) s 28
Federal Court Rules 2011 r 30.01
Cases cited:  A & G Lamattina & Sons Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue (1996) 96 ATC 4474 cited
Burns v Leda Holdings Pty Ltd [1988] 1 Qd R 214 distinguished
Buzza v Comptroller of Stamps (Vic) (1951) 83 CLR 286 cited
Byrnes v Kendall (2010–11) 243 CLR 253 cited
Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW)v Buckle (1998) 192 CLR 226 discussed
Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Q) v Hopkins (1945) 71 CLR 351 cited
Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) v Livingston [1965] AC 694 cited
Commissioner of State Revenue v Lam & Kym Pty Ltd (2004) 10 VR 420 approved/followed
Davidson v Armytage (1906) 4 CLR 204 cited
DKLR Holding Co (No 2) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) (1981-82) 149 CLR 431 discussed
Foakes v Jackson [1900] 1 Ch 807 cited
Herdegen v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 84 ALR 27 cited
In re Hancock [1896] 2 Ch 173 cited
Inland Revenue Commissioner v Cookson [1977] 2 All ER 331 cited
Kafataris v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 172 FCR 242 followed
Kemtron Industries Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties [1984] 1 Qd R 576 distinguished
Kent v SS “Maria Luisa” (No 2) (2003) 130 FCR 12 cited
Massereene v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [1900] 2 Ir R 138 cited
Oswal v Yara Australia Pty Ltd [No 3] [2011] WASC 255 not followed
Roome  v Edwards [1982] AC 279 distinguished
Stephenson v Barclays Bank Trust Company Ltd [1975] 1 WLR 882 cited
Thomson v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1949) 80 CLR 344 cited
Underhill and Hayton: Law Relating to Trusts and Trustees (18th ed, LexisNexis, 2010)    
Date of hearing: 29 and 30 April 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Oswal v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 745
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Oswal v Commissioner of Taxation involved Mr Pankaj Oswal, a trustee of the Burrup Trust, and the Commissioner of Taxation. The dispute centered on the creation of a trust over shares in Burrup Holdings, the timing of certain capital gains tax (CGT) events, and the subsequent tax implications for the 2007 income year. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues the court had to resolve included whether the resolution dated 13 March 2007 constituted a "declaration" of trust or a "settlement" under the relevant statutes and whether this resolution led to the creation of a trust over specific shares in Burrup Holdings. Additionally, the court had to determine the timing of capital gains tax events E1 and A1 in relation to these shares and the resultant tax obligations for Mr Oswal for the 2007 income year.

The court examined the nature of the 13 March 2007 resolution and concluded that it constituted both a declaration of trust and a settlement. The court found that the resolution created a trust over the shares that were vested in Mr Oswal at the time of the resolution, although it did not extend to shares that were not vested until later. The court also found that a CGT event E1 occurred in respect of 902 shares in the 2007 income year. Regarding the Commissioner’s argument about CGT event A1, the court found that no such event occurred as there was no actual disposal of the shares in question. The court ultimately decided that the resolution did not result in a merger of legal and equitable interests in the shares, and thus no CGT event A1 took place.

Based on the court's findings, it was determined that Mr Oswal was not liable for the taxes the Commissioner sought to impose for the 2007 income year. The court ruled that the resolution did not create a trust over all the shares at the time of the resolution, and no CGT event A1 occurred. The court did not find in favour of the Commissioner’s arguments regarding the tax events, thereby absolving Mr Oswal of the tax liabilities in question for that year.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the face of my conclusion that the 13 March 2007 resolution constituted both a “declaration” of trust and a “settlement”, I am of the view that the resolution did create a trust over the shares in Burrup Holdings that were vested in Mr Oswal, a trustee of the Burrup Trust, at the time of the resolution. I hasten to add, however, that the trust so created, did not extend to the 246 shares in Burrup Holdings which were not vested in Mr Oswal at that time. No trust was created over those shares by the 13 March 2007 resolution until such time as they were vested in the trustee in September 2008, notwithstanding the date of vesting was backdated to 13 March 2007, and subsequently to 26 April 2007.Conclusion on CGT event E1 It follows, in my view, that CGT event E1 happened in respect of 902 shares in Burrup Holdings in the 2007 income year.CGT EVENT A1 In the 2007 income year, CGT event A1 was in the following terms:104-10 Disposal of a CGT asset: CGT event A1(1)CGT event A1 happens if you *dispose of a *CGT asset.(2)You dispose of a *CGT asset if a change of ownership occurs from you to another entity, whether because of some act or event or by operation of law. However, a change of ownership does not occur:(a)if you stop being the legal owner of the asset but continue to be its beneficial owner; or(b)merely because of a change of trustee.(3)The time of the event is:(a)when you enter into the contract for the *disposal; or(b)if there is no contract—when the change of ownership occurs.Example: In June 1999 you enter into a contract to sell land. The contract is settled in October 1999. You make a capital gain of $50,000.The gain is made in the 1998–99 income year (the year you entered into the contract) and not the 1999–2000 income year (the year that settlement takes place).Note 1: If the contract falls through before completion, this event does not happen because no change in ownership occurs.Note 2: If the asset was compulsorily acquired from you: see subsection (6).(4)You make a capital gain if the *capital proceeds from the disposal are more than the asset’s *cost base. You make a capital loss if those *capital proceedings are less than the asset’s *reduced cost base.Exceptions(5)…(6)…(7)… The Commissioner’s reliance on CGT event A1 was put in the alternative to his reliance on CGT event E1 and was limited to the appointment of that part of the corpus of the Burrup Trust to Mr Oswal for his absolute benefit, namely, 574 shares in Burrup Holdings. The Commissioner’s case was predicated on the basis that the Court found, contrary to the Commissioner’s primary submission, that the 13 March 2007 resolution created two separate trusts, one over 574 shares to be held for Mr Oswal and one over 574 shares to be held for Mr Oswal; the Commissioner’s argument being that in that event, the 13 March 2007 resolution did not create the second trust (for Mr Oswal) but resulted in a merger of the legal and equitable interests in “his” 574 shares giving rise to a disposal by Mr Oswal as trustee of the Burrup Trust to Mr Oswal in his personal capacity, resulting in the happening of CGT event A1.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I propose first to consider whether the appointment made by the 13 March 2007 resolution, and the words which follow, constitute a “declaration” of trust or a “settlement”. If they constitute neither, then that is the end of the matter because, in the absence of there being a transfer of property, and it is common ground that there was no transfer of property in the 2007 income year, no trust could be created. On the other hand, if the appointment made by the 13 March 2007 resolution, and the words which follow, do constitute a “declaration” of trust or a “settlement”, then it is difficult to see why a trust over the relevant assets then vested in Mr Oswal, as trustee of the Burrup Trust, was not thereby created.A Declaration of Trust? The 13 March 2007 resolution is not, in express terms, a declaration of trust by Mr Oswal. Mr Oswal, as trustee of the Burrup Trust, does not “declare” that he holds the shares in Burrup Holdings, as to 574 shares on trust for himself, and as to 574 shares on trust for Mrs Oswal. In that regard, it is to be contrasted with the instrument in DKLR Holding Co (No 2) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) (1982) 149 CLR 431 at 436; and the instrument in Commissioner of State Revenue v Lam & Kym Pty Ltd (2004) 10 VR 420 at [8], both of which were declarations of trust in express terms. On the other hand, following the words of appointment in the first sentence of the resolution, the resolution continues:“Henceforth the corpus so appointed…shall be held on separate trust and for the absolute benefit of the named beneficiaries in their own individual capacities.Mr Pankaj Oswal – 574 shares in Burrup Holdings Pty LtdMr Radhika Oswal – 574 shares in Burrup Holdings Pty Ltd”and it is signed by Mr Oswal and dated.In other words, Mr Oswal is not only making the appointment but resolving (declaring) that he will henceforth hold that part of the corpus (shares in Burrup Holdings) on separate trust for the absolute benefit of himself (as to 574 shares) and of his wife (as to 574 shares). Does the fact that Mr Oswal is exercising a special power of appointment under cl 17.1 of the Burrup Trust Deed mean that the 13 March 2007 resolution cannot be a declaration of trust within ordinary concepts, as distinct from being liable to stamp duty under a particular statute, because the methods of creating a trust by declaration and creating a trust by exercise of a power of appointment are mutually exclusive acts? This was an argument that was put to the Victorian Court of Appeal in Lam & Kym and, correctly in my view, rejected (at [36]–[45]); it involved, according to Nettle JA (with whom Vincent JA and Hansen AJA agreed), a misconception of treating the exercise of a power of appointment as a method of creating an inter vivos trust, in addition to the two methods of transfer of property and declaration of trust, and as mutually exclusive of both of them. At [37] and [41], his Honour said:[37] Mr Merralls took us first to passages from Jacobs’ Law of Trusts in Australia [6th ed, pp 75–7]; Sir Frederick Jordan’s Selected Legal Papers (Chapters on Equity in New South Wales) [(1983), pp 23–4]; Ford and Lee, Principles of the Law of Trusts; Lewin on Trusts [at [2000]–[2015] and [5050]–[5110]]; Underhill and Hayton, Law Relating to Trusts and Trustees [15th ed, pp 20–3 and 124–6]; Parker and Mellows, The Modern Law of Trusts [7th ed, (1998), pp 128, 129 and 163–90]; Pettit, Equity and the Law of Trusts [9th ed, pp 83 and 84]; the American Law Institute, Restatement 3d., The Restatement of the Law Trusts [(2003), vol 1, Pt 2, Ch 3, § 10]; and Scott and Fratcher, The Law of Trusts [4th ed, vol 1, § 17.1-§ 17.3]...…[41] …Each of the texts records that a non-testamentary trust may be created by transferring property to the proposed trustee to hold upon trust for the proposed beneficiary or, without transfer of property, by declaration of trust. Those methods of creation are mutually exclusive in the sense that one cannot effectually transfer property to another to hold upon trust and at the same time declare that one holds it oneself on trust. They are also exhaustive because, as the texts make clear, they are the only methods for the inter vivos creation of trusts. [(Of course excluding resulting and constructive trusts and trusts otherwise arising by operation of law.)] Consequently, when then the texts later go on to discuss the creation of trusts in exercise of a power of appointment, they are not concerned with methods of creation — for, as has been stated, the only methods of creation are transfer and declaration — but rather with power to create a trust, and in particular with power to create a trust in respect of property of another in exercise of a power of appointment. The point which is made in those later sections of the texts is that a general power of appointment impliedly empowers the donee to appoint to a trustee to hold on trust for the object chosen in exercise of the power and that, according to the terms of a special power of appointment, a special power of appointment may also empower the donee of the power to appoint to a trustee for the benefit of the chosen object, as opposed to appointing directly to the chosen object.