Nicholson v Parole Board of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Nicholson v Parole Board of Queensland [2021] QSC 325

PARTIES:

CLIVE ANTHONY NICHOLSON

(applicant)

v
PAROLE BOARD OF QUEENSLAND

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 9070 of 2021

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

10 December 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 November 2021

JUDGE:

Davis J

ORDERS:

1.    The decision of the respondent made on 13 July 2021 to refuse the applicant’s application for parole is set aside.

2.    The determination of the applicant’s application for parole is referred to the respondent for further consideration.

3.    The respondent file and serve written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 15 December 2021.

4.    The applicant file and serve any written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 23 December 2021.

5.    Each party have liberty to apply, by filing an application by 4.00 pm on 4 February 2022, for leave to make oral submissions on the question of costs.

6.    In the absence of the filing of an application for leave to make oral submissions as to costs, the question of costs will be determined on the written submissions without oral argument.

CATCHWORDS:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS - UNREASONABLENESS - where the applicant was convicted of the murder of his wife - where the body of the applicant’s wife has never been found - where the applicant made application for parole under the provisions of the Corrective Services Act 2006 (the Act) - where the Act empowered the respondent to grant parole or refuse parole - where by s 193A the respondent must refuse parole unless “satisfied the prisoner has cooperated satisfactorily in the investigation of the offence to identify the victim’s location” - where the respondent purported to make a “decision” that the applicant had not “cooperated satisfactorily in the investigation of the offence to identify the victim’s location” (the finding) – where, contrary to the Act, the respondent failed to then decide whether to grant or refuse parole - where the parties proceeded on the basis that the finding was the decision - where the applicant identified five factors not taken into account by the respondent in making the finding - where the respondent accepted that the application ought to be allowed if any of the considerations were not taken into account and were material - whether the considerations were taken into account - whether the considerations were material

Judicial Review of Administrative Action and Government Liability 6th ed 2017

Corrective Services Act 2006, s 193, s 193A
Criminal Code, s 2, s 23, s 271, s 302, s 303, s 304, s 305
Judicial Review Act 1991, s 20
Migration Act
1958, s 501, s 501CA
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, r 681

Ali v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCAFC 109, cited
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321, followed
Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nicholson v Parole Board of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 325
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nicholson v Parole Board of Queensland concerned a judicial review of a decision by the respondent to refuse the applicant’s application for parole. The applicant, Mr Nicholson, had been convicted of the murder of his wife, Julie Rose Nicholson. The body of Mrs Nicholson had never been found. The respondent, the Parole Board of Queensland, was empowered under the Corrective Services Act 2006 to grant or refuse parole, subject to certain conditions. The applicant made his application for parole, and the respondent purported to make a finding that the applicant had not cooperated satisfactorily in the investigation of the offence to identify the victim’s location. The respondent failed to then decide whether to grant or refuse parole. The parties proceeded on the basis that the finding was the decision.

The legal issues before the court were whether the five considerations identified by the applicant were taken into account by the respondent in making the finding, and if not, whether those considerations were material. The applicant argued that the respondent failed to consider several relevant matters, which were material to the decision. The respondent accepted that the application ought to be allowed if any of the considerations were not taken into account and were material.

The court found that the respondent had failed to take into account the five considerations identified by the applicant. The court held that the considerations were material, as they related to the truthfulness, completeness, and reliability of the information provided by the applicant in relation to the victim’s location. Furthermore, the court found that the respondent’s decision was unreasonable as it was based on an incomplete and inaccurate understanding of the applicant’s cooperation in the investigation.

The decision of the respondent made on 13 July 2021 to refuse the applicant’s application for parole was set aside. The determination of the applicant’s application for parole was referred to the respondent for further consideration. Both parties were required to file and serve written submissions on costs by specified dates. Each party had liberty to apply for leave to make oral submissions on the question of costs, but if no such application was made, the question of costs would be determined on the written submissions without oral argument.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of the respondent made on 13 July 2021 to refuse the applicant’s application for parole is set aside.

2. The determination of the applicant’s application for parole is referred to the respondent for further consideration.

3. The respondent file and serve written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 15 December 2021.

4. The applicant file and serve any written submissions on costs by 4.00 pm on 23 December 2021.

5. Each party have liberty to apply, by filing an application by 4.00 pm on 4 February 2022, for leave to make oral submissions on the question of costs.

6. In the absence of the filing of an application for leave to make oral submissions as to costs, the question of costs will be determined on the written submissions without oral argument.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Nicholson seeks judicial review of the decision which, for the reasons I later explain, is taken to be a decision to refuse parole.Background Mr Nicholson was, in 2003, living with Mrs Nicholson and their young daughter in Southport. Mr Nicholson was charged that:“On or about the 15th of July 2003 at Gold Coast in the State of Queensland, you murdered Julie Rose Nicholson.” At his trial in February 2006, Mr Nicholson did not contest that he had killed Mrs Nicholson. He raised the following in his defence:1.At the time he did the act[4] which killed his wife, Mr Nicholson did not intend to kill or do grievous bodily harm to her.[5]2.He acted in self-defence.[6]3.He acted under provocation.[7]4.The act which killed was not a willed act.[8][4]Criminal Code, s 2.[5]Criminal Code, s 302(1)(a).[6]Criminal Code, s 271.[7]Criminal Code, s 304.[8]Criminal Code, s 23. The Crown case was that Mr Nicholson killed Mrs Nicholson by delivering a blow or blows with a hammer. That allegation was not in dispute at the trial. In defence, it was argued that the hammer impacted Mrs Nicholson during a struggle. Therefore, the striking of her was not a willed act by him. Alternatively, it was argued that the blow or blows were delivered in defending an assault by Mrs Nicholson. In either of those scenarios, Mr Nicholson would not be guilty of murder and would not be guilty of manslaughter as the killing was not unlawful.[9][9]Criminal Code, s 303. Alternatively, Mr Nicholson argued in defence to the charge of murder that the killing either occurred without intent by him to cause Mrs Nicholson’s death or grievous bodily harm or, if he had that intent, he acted under provocation.[10] In either of those cases, Mr Nicholson would be guilty of manslaughter, not murder.[10]Criminal Code, s 304. The jury convicted Mr Nicholson of murder and he was sentenced to life imprisonment.[11][11]Criminal Code, s 305. The Crown case was based substantially upon a series of letters which Mr Nicholson had written to various people, including police, before he was arrested and charged with Mrs Nicholson’s murder. These letters were prepared at a time when Mr Nicholson was apparently contemplating suicide. It is unnecessary to analyse the letters in any depth. However, in the letters:1.he admitted to killing Mrs Nicholson;2.he said that he disposed of her body in the ocean off the Southport Spit;3.he said he was going to kill himself. That contemplated him also entering the ocean;4.he spoke of concerns for his young daughter who was then about three years of age. In one of the letters, Mr Nicholson spoke of hitting his wife with a hammer and:“Then my stupidity really took hold. I wrapped Julie in the sheets and doona and [hid] her in the walk-in robe, made sure [Mr Nicholson’s daughter] had gone back to sleep and dragged Julie down to the garage … I put her into the back of my ute. At some point she was still breathing. But by the time I returned to tidy her up in the ute, she had stopped. …”Later:“I should have called an ambulance, the police or someone but all I could think was being away from [Mr Nicholson’s daughter]. Hence all the stories, lies, attempts to make it appear Julie had left . …”And later:“So I continued to lie and stupidly build a case that Julie had deserted the family home and I should try for sole custody.”And later:“On the night of the Tuesday when [Mr Nicholson’s daughter] was asleep, I had wrapped Julie’s body and took her to the Spit and wrapped in a plastic drop sheet and floated her into the water. … I then went home, cleaned up the mess and later disposed of bloodstained sheets, hammer, etc at the tip with other rubbish from home.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

By way of summary, DSS Knight said this in the second cooperation report:“Truthfulness, completeness and reliability of information or evidence provided by the prisoner in relation to the victim’s locationIn the absence of locating the deceased’s body at the location and place nominated by NICHOLSON, it is difficult to assess the truthfulness, completeness and reliability of the information he provided. From 2003 until November 2017, NICHOLSON maintained a version that the deceased’s body had been disposed of in the seaway at the Southport Spit. NICHOLSON conceded in the interview conducted on 10 January 2019 that the information he provided on 2 November 2017 about the location of the deceased’s remains was not truthful.NICHOLSON’s disclosures that he buried the deceased in the Cedar Grove area are a significant departure from his previous versions. No evidence exists that the Cedar Grove area had ever been raised by NICHOLSON as a burial site. There exists no reference to Cedar Grove within any of the trial transcripts.To assist in identifying the alleged burial site, NICHOLSON was provided with maps and physically driven to the area to allow him a reasonable opportunity to locate the area he had described. All reasonable efforts to validate the truthfulness of NICHOLSON’s claims have failed.All information provided by NICHOLSON since 2003 has failed to result in the recovery of the deceased’s body. It therefore cannot be considered complete or reliable.The significance and usefulness of the prisoner cooperationNone of the information provided by NICHOLSON between 2003 and 2019 is considered significant or useful.None of the information provided by NICHOLSON has resulted in any corroborative evidence to substantiate a site where the deceased’s body was disposed.Furthermore, on 10 January 2019 NICHOLSON stated that he had consciously provided false information by stating that he had disposed of the deceased at the Southport Spit. NICHOLSON proceeded to provide an alternative set of circumstances, claiming that he buried the deceased’s body in bushland at Cedar Grove. Inquiries were conducted to explore the further information provided by NICHOLSON, which again failed to result in locating any supportive evidence.” The Board heard the application over various meetings. A dispute arose as to whether DSS Knight could be compelled to give oral evidence at the hearing and be cross-examined. The Board held that it had that power and that determination was the subject of an unsuccessful challenge to this Court.[17] Various submissions were sought and received by the Board. Neither in their written submissions nor in oral argument on this application did either of the parties raise any issues about the hearings or the process by which the decision was made. As already observed, the Board seemingly dismissed the parole application on 13 July 2021 and reasons were delivered.[17]Commissioner of Police Service v Parole Board of Queensland & Anor (2019) 3 QR 251.The reasons for the decision

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Corrective Services Act gave the Board the power to grant parole by s 193. It provides, relevantly:“193 Decision of parole board(1)After receiving a prisoner’s application for a parole order, the parole board must decide—(a) to grant the application; or(b) to refuse to grant the application. …(5)If the parole board refuses to grant the application, the board must—(a) give the prisoner written reasons for the refusal; and(b) if the application is for a parole order other than an exceptional circumstances parole order—decide a period of time within which a further application for a parole order (other than an exceptional circumstances parole order) by the prisoner must not be made without the board’s consent. …(6)If the parole board refuses to grant the application because of section 193A, the written reasons given under subsection (5)(a) must include a statement that the parole board is not satisfied the prisoner has cooperated as mentioned in section 193A(2).” The function of the Board is to decide whether to grant or refuse parole. For reasons later explained,[18] it made a different “decision”.[18]Paragraphs [58]-[66]. Section 193A prohibits the grant of parole in circumstances where the victim’s body has not been located unless the Board is “satisfied the prisoner has cooperated satisfactorily in the investigation of the offence to identify the victim’s location”. That is the effect of s 193A(2). Section 193A, relevantly here, is:“193A Deciding particular applications where victim’s body or remains have not been located(1)This section applies to a prisoner’s application for a parole order if the prisoner is serving a period of imprisonment for a homicide offence and—(a)the body or remains of the victim of the offence have not been located; or(b)because of an act or omission of the prisoner or another person, part of the body or remains of the victim has not been located.(2)The parole board must refuse to grant the application under section 193 unless the board is satisfied the prisoner has cooperated satisfactorily in the investigation of the offence to identify the victim’s location.(3)For subsection (2), the cooperation may have happened before or after the prisoner was sentenced to imprisonment for the offence.(4)After receiving the application, the board must, by written notice, ask the commissioner for a report about the prisoner’s cooperation as mentioned in subsection (2). …(6)The commissioner must comply with the request by giving the parole board, at least 28 days before the proposed hearing day, a written report that states whether the prisoner has given any cooperation as mentioned in subsection (2) and, if so, an evaluation of—(a)the nature, extent and timeliness of the prisoner’s cooperation; and(b)the truthfulness, completeness and reliability of any information or evidence provided by the prisoner in relation to the victim’s location; and(c)the significance and usefulness of the prisoner’s cooperation.(7)In deciding whether the parole board is satisfied about the prisoner’s cooperation as mentioned in subsection (2), the board—(a)must have regard to—(i) the report given by the commissioner under subsection (6); and(ii) any information the board has about the prisoner’s capacity to give the cooperation; and(iii) any relevant remarks made by the sentencing court that sentenced the prisoner to the term of imprisonment the prisoner is serving for the offence; and(iv) if the prisoner requests the board to consider a transcript of a proceeding against the prisoner for the offence—the transcript; and(b)may have regard to any other information the board considers relevant. …”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By way of summary of the significance and usefulness of Mr Nicholson’s cooperation, DSS Knight observed:“The significance and usefulness of the prisoner cooperationNICHOLSON has provided details relating to the location of the deceased’s body on two occasions.17 August 2003The first evidence of the location of the deceased’s body was provided within a hand-written letter dated 17 August 2003, NICHOLSON stated he placed the deceased’s body into the water in the general area of ‘The Spit’ at Southport.The first version provided by NICHOLSON was very general, referring only to ‘The Spit’ which is a large body of water. Upon review of the original investigation and the evidence contained within the trial transcripts, there is no evidence of any water searches being undertaken by the original investigating police officers.2 November 2017NICHOLSON did not provide any further details until approached by police more than fourteen years later. NICHOLSON provided a sketch diagram to police, describing the location where he claimed to have placed the deceased’s body.The information provided by NICHOLSON in 2017 did not afford any realistic opportunity to recover the deceased’s body.” In January 2019, Mr Nicholson, through his lawyers, contacted DSS Knight wishing to provide further information as to the whereabouts of Mrs Nicholson’s body. On 10 January 2019, Mr Nicholson was interviewed by DSS Knight and Detective Senior Constable Pordage. He told police that he had more information to give about the locality of Mrs Nicholson’s body and that the information was different to what he had given in November 2017. As to why he was now giving a different version, he explained:“CN[14] Um on the aar November 17 you came out here my daughter was going through her last year of high school HSC and was doing brilliantly well at school and I wanted no publicity nothing so I just perpetuated the myths of what had happened in the past.CK[15] YepCNOn the basis of well there would be no publicity she can get on with her exams, she’s done brilliantly she got into the double university degree that she wants partial scholarship and everything so and that’s why this time round aar at the moment she is in Korea on a student exchange”[14]A reference to Mr Nicholson.[15]A reference to DSS Knight. Mr Nicholson explained to police that he had initially planned to place Mrs Nicholson’s body in the ocean, but in the end, buried her in a hole about two feet deep at Cedar Grove which is near Jimboomba. As to why he did not place the body in the water, Mr Nicholson said:“CNUm which I had it at that time driven to the to the Broadwater there was too many fishermen and stuff so I went home check my daughter make sure she was still asleep and then went out to um its out near Beaudesert where some years before I had been working on a builders property out the …CKOk ok and sorry what happened out there you said ok so you went out to Beaudesert what happened down thereCNThat’s where this would have been at night are from an area called I believe it’s um Cedar Grove then you follow it along over the railway track and down a dirt track um and then there’s a rubbish a lot of scrub area um obviously who would dump their rubbish and stuff cause it reflected in my headlightsCKHmhmCNand that’s where I then buried Julie’s body” (emphasis added)