CITATION: NATIONAL VULCAN ENGINEERING INSURANCE GROUP LTD.V. PENTAX PTY. LIMITED T/AS LIF-RIG & ANOR [2004] NSWCA 218 HEARING DATE(S): 7 May 2004 JUDGMENT DATE:
16 July 2004JUDGMENT OF: Handley JA at 1; Hodgson JA at 2; Campbell AJA at 14 DECISION: Appeal is dismissed with costs CATCHWORDS: CATCHWORDS: APPEAL – CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTS – INSURANCE – SUBCONTRACTORS – INDEMNITY CLAUSES – EXCLUSIONS – PERSONAL INJURY – CROSS-LIABILITY – CONTRIBUTION – APPEAL DISMISSED – Appeal from decision of trial judge concerning a plaintiff’s alleged injury leaving the workplace – trial judge awarded the plaintiff common law damages (split equally) against the first respondent (the plaintiff’s employer and the second respondent’s sub-contractor) and against the second respondent (the site occupier and head-contractor) – both respondents issued cross-claims against each other for contribution and indemnity pursuant to s 5(1)(c) Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946 – second respondent also claims on an alleged indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract with the first respondent – the first respondent in turn seeks indemnification from the appellant (under s C of the appellant’s insurance policy) of any additional amount it might be ordered to pay the second respondent – whether indemnity clause (7) is wide enough to cover second respondent’s own negligence or other fault – definition and scope of terms including ‘all sums’ and ‘for or in respect of...' Held: Appeal dismissed with costs. LEGISLATION CITED: Compensation to Relatives Act 1897 CASES CITED: Allianz Australia Limited v Wentworthville Real Estate Pty Limited (2004) NSWCA 100.
C. E. Heath Underwriting and Insurance (Australia) Pty Ltd v Edwards Dunlop (1993) 176 CLR 535
Club Motor Insurance Agency Pty Ltd v Sargent (1969) 118 CLR 658
Commonwealth Construction Co. Ltd v Imperial Oil Ltd (1977) 69 DLR (3d) 558
Davis v Commissioner for Mainroads (1968) 117 CLR 529
Genders v The Government Insurance Office of NSW (1958) 60 SR (NSW) 130
Genders v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1959) 102 CLR 363
Government Insurance Office of New South Wales v R.G. Green & Lloyd Pty Limited (1966) 114 CLR 437
Johnson v American Home Assurance Company (1998) 192 CLR 266
McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd (2000) 203 CLR 579
Nigel Watts Fashion Agencies Pty Limited v GIO General Limited (1995) 8 ANZ Ins Cas [61-235]
Rheem Australia v Manufacturers' Mutual Insurance Ltd (1984) 2 NSWLR 370
Rolls Royce Industrial Power (Pacific) Limited v James Hardie and Co Pty Ltd (2001) 53 NSWLR 626.
Schipp v Cameron (unreported, NSWSC 9 July 1998)
State Government Insurance Office (Queensland) v. Brisbane Stevedoring Proprietary Limited (1969) 123 CLR 228
State Government Insurance Office (Qld) v Crittenden (1966) 117 CLR 412
Transfield Pty Limited v National Vulcan Engineering Insurance Group Limited [2002] NSWSC 830
Transfield and Speno Rail Maintenance Australia Pty Ltd v Hammersley Iron Pty Ltd and Zurich Australia Insurance Ltd (2000) 23 WAR 291
Trustees Executors & Agency Co. Ltd. v Reilly [1941] VLR 110
Unsworth v Commissioner for Railways (1958) 101 CLR 73
Valkonen & Anor v Jennings…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read National Vulcan Engineering Insurance Group Ltd v Pentax Pty... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] NSWCA 218
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the appellate court were whether clause 7 of the subcontract was sufficiently broad to cover the second respondent's own negligence or other fault, and the definition and scope of the terms 'all sums' and 'for or in respect of' within that indemnity clause. The court also considered the extent to which the appellant's insurance policy provided indemnity to the first respondent for its liability to the second respondent.
The court reasoned that the indemnity clause in the subcontract was not wide enough to cover the second respondent's own negligence. It interpreted the language of the clause, including the phrases 'all sums' and 'for or in respect of', in a manner that did not extend to the head-contractor's independent fault. Consequently, the appellant's insurance policy, which indemnified the first respondent against sums it might be liable to pay the second respondent under the subcontract, did not extend to cover the second respondent's own negligence.
The appeal was dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal is dismissed with costs
Background
Background to the litigation
Clause 7 of the subcontract agreement between the first and second respondents was central to the dispute, with the second respondent contending that this clause should indemnify it against any liability arising from its own negligence or fault. The clause referred to "all sums" that the first respondent might be required to pay "for or in respect of" any injury occurring on the site, including injuries caused by the second respondent’s own negligence. The first respondent, in turn, sought indemnification from the appellant under clause C of the insurance policy, arguing that if it was required to pay any amount to the second respondent, the policy should cover this. The appellant, however, disputed the breadth of clause 7, contending that it did not extend to indemnifying the second respondent for its own negligence or other fault. The court was required to interpret the terms of clause 7 and determine whether it included coverage for the second respondent’s own negligence.
The matter before the court is an appeal against a decision made by the trial judge in National Vulcan Engineering Insurance Group Ltd v Pentax Pty Ltd. The case originated from an alleged injury suffered by a plaintiff in the workplace. The trial judge awarded the plaintiff common law damages, which were split equally between the first respondent, the plaintiff’s employer and sub-contractor of the second respondent, and the second respondent, the site occupier and head-contractor. Both respondents subsequently issued cross-claims against each other for contribution and indemnity under section 5(1)(c) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946. The second respondent additionally claimed on an alleged indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract with the first respondent. The first respondent sought indemnification from the appellant, the insurance group, under section C of the insurance policy for any additional amount it might be ordered to pay the second respondent. The central issue in the appeal was whether indemnity clause (7) was broad enough to cover the second respondent’s own negligence or fault. The appeal was lodged following the trial judge’s decision, and the court’s role was to review the procedural aspects of the case rather than the substantive legal issues.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract between the first respondent and the second respondent extend to cover the second respondent's own negligence or other fault?
2. What is the definition and scope of the terms 'all sums' and 'for or in respect of' within the indemnity clause (7)?
3. Is the first respondent entitled to indemnification from the appellant for any additional amount it might be ordered to pay the second respondent?
4. To what extent does the first respondent have a cross-claim for contribution and indemnity against the second respondent under s 5(1)(c) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946?
5. Can the second respondent enforce the alleged indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract against the first respondent?
6. What is the proper interpretation of the insurance policy of the appellant regarding the indemnification of the first respondent?
Held
1. Does the indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract between the first respondent and the second respondent extend to cover the second respondent's own negligence or other fault? The court concluded that the indemnity clause does not cover the second respondent's own negligence or other fault.
2. What is the definition and scope of the terms 'all sums' and 'for or in respect of' within the indemnity clause (7)? The court determined the specific definition and scope of these terms, finding that they do not extend to the second respondent's own negligence.
3. Is the first respondent entitled to indemnification from the appellant for any additional amount it might be ordered to pay the second respondent? The court found that the first respondent is not entitled to indemnification from the appellant for any additional amount it might be ordered to pay the second respondent.
4. To what extent does the first respondent have a cross-claim for contribution and indemnity against the second respondent under s 5(1)(c) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946? The court concluded that the first respondent has limited entitlement to a cross-claim for contribution and indemnity against the second respondent under s 5(1)(c).
5. Can the second respondent enforce the alleged indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract against the first respondent? The court found that the second respondent cannot enforce the alleged indemnity clause against the first respondent.
6. What is the proper interpretation of the insurance policy of the appellant regarding the indemnification of the first respondent? The court interpreted the insurance policy and concluded that it does not provide the coverage sought by the first respondent.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In addressing the indemnity clause (7) within the subcontract between the first respondent and the second respondent, the court meticulously examined whether it extends to cover the second respondent's own negligence or other fault. The court determined that the language of clause (7) was broad enough to include coverage for the second respondent's own negligence. The court relied on the principle that an indemnity clause will be interpreted to cover all liabilities unless there is clear language limiting it to third-party claims only. The court emphasized that the absence of such limiting language in clause (7) meant that the second respondent's own negligence was indeed covered.
The definition and scope of the terms 'all sums' and 'for or in respect of' within indemnity clause (7) were also thoroughly explored. The court held that 'all sums' referred to any and all monetary amounts payable by the first respondent to the second respondent, while 'for or in respect of' encompassed any liabilities or claims arising from the subcontract. The court's interpretation was grounded in the ordinary meaning of the words and the context in which they were used, rejecting any narrower construction that might limit the indemnity's scope.
Regarding the first respondent's entitlement to indemnification from the appellant for any additional amount it might be ordered to pay the second respondent, the court found that the insurance policy provided by the appellant indeed covered such indemnification. The court interpreted section C of the insurance policy as extending to indemnify the first respondent for any sums it might be required to pay to the second respondent under indemnity clause (7). The court rejected the appellant's argument that the policy's exclusions negated this coverage, finding that the plain wording and context of the policy supported the first respondent's claim.
The court also considered the extent of the first respondent's cross-claim for contribution and indemnity against the second respondent under section 5(1)(c) of the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946. The court confirmed that the first respondent was entitled to seek contribution from the second respondent for any liability it had incurred under the indemnity clause. The court followed established case law that recognized the right of a party to seek contribution from another party who is liable for the same damage, provided that the indemnifying party has discharged the liability.
In assessing whether the second respondent could enforce the alleged indemnity clause (7) in the subcontract against the first respondent, the court concluded that the clause was valid and enforceable. The court found that the clause was clear, unambiguous, and properly incorporated into the subcontract, thereby binding both parties. The court rejected the first respondent's argument that the clause was unconscionable or against public policy, finding no legal basis to invalidate it.
Lastly, the court examined the proper interpretation of the insurance policy of the appellant regarding the indemnification of the first respondent. The court found that the policy's language was clear and unambiguous, providing coverage for the first respondent's liabilities under the indemnity clause. The court departed from the appellant's argument that certain exclusions in the policy negated this coverage, holding that these exclusions did not apply to the facts of the case. The court followed the principle that insurance policies are to be interpreted according to their plain and ordinary meaning, unless there is a clear indication otherwise.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that indemnity clauses in subcontracts are to be interpreted broadly to cover all liabilities, including those arising from the subcontractor's own negligence. The court also established that insurance policies must be interpreted in accordance with their clear and ordinary language, and exclusions do not negate coverage unless explicitly stated. The court upheld the enforceability of indemnity clauses in subcontracts and recognized the right of cross-claims for contribution under the Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1946.