National Australia Bank Ltd & Argus v Zollo

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD & ARGUS v ZOLLO

[2008] SASC 93

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

15 April 2008

CRIMINAL LAW - JURISDICTION, PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - ADJOURNMENT, STAY OF PROCEEDINGS OR ORDER RESTRAINING PROCEEDINGS - STAY OF PROCEEDINGS - ABUSE OF PROCESS

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - JURISDICTION AND GENERALLY

Information and summons issued in Magistrates Court following long history of civil proceedings on similar issues - jurisdiction of Supreme Court to permanently stay proceedings at committal stage for abuse of process - whether a collateral attack on a final decision. 

Held:  Magistrates Court proceedings are a collateral attack on a final decision - Supreme Court has jurisdiction to grant stay - stay granted.

Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA), s 9; Summary Procedure Act 1921 (SA), s 107, referred to.
Fuller & Anor v Field & State of South Australia (1994) 62 SASR 112; Clayton v Ralphs (1987) 45 SASR 347; Jago v District Court of New South Wales (1989) 168 CLR 23; Walton v Gardiner (1993) 177 CLR 378; Williams v Spautz (1992) 174 CLR 509; Rogers v The Queen (1994) 181 CLR 251; Barton v The Queen (1980) 147 CLR 75, applied.
Zollo v National Australia Bank Ltd & Anor, Full Court, Supreme Court of South Australia, 20 December 1996 (unreported); Clyne v New South Wales Bar Association (1960) 104 CLR 186; Grassby v The Queen (1989) 168 CLR 1; Hunter v Chief Constable of West Midlands Police [1982] AC 529; National Australia Bank Ltd v McFarlane [2003] VSC 19; National Australia Bank Ltd v McFarlane [2005] VSC 438; Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Heinrich [2003] SASC 322, discussed.

NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LTD & ARGUS v ZOLLO
[2008] SASC 93

Civil

ANDERSON J:

Introduction

  1. Mr Zollo has issued an information and summons in the Adelaide Magistrates Court.  The summons has been issued against the National Australia Bank (“the Bank”) and Mr Don Argus, who was the principal executive officer of the Bank between 1 October 1990 and 8 December 1995.

  2. The information contains the following counts:

    Offence details

    1) Between the years 1987 and 2005 the defendants jointly and severally by false pretences obtained money from the informant for the procurement of an insurance policy for the informant and failed or refused to obtain any such insurance policy for the informant.

    Contrary to section 195 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935-1975 or alternatively – contrary to sections 139 and 140 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act as amended to date.

    (2)Between the years 1987 and 2005 jointly and severally deceived the informant as to the existence of an insurance policy for the protection of the informant.

    Contrary to section 139 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 as amended or to the common law.

    (3) Between the years 1987 and 2005 conspired between themselves and with other persons unknown to the informant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read National Australia Bank Ltd & Argus v Zollo and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, National Australia Bank Ltd and Mr Argus, sought relief against Mr Zollo in the Supreme Court of South Australia, arguing that the proceedings brought by Mr Zollo in the Magistrates Court were an abuse of process and amounted to a collateral attack on a final decision. The applicants sought an injunction, declaration, stay of proceedings, and costs from Mr Zollo. The dispute arose from a long-standing civil case involving Mr Zollo and the Bank, which had culminated in a Full Court decision in 1996. The Full Court had found that the Bank was not obliged to indemnify Mr Zollo in certain circumstances, a decision which Mr Zollo was now attempting to challenge through the criminal proceedings. The Supreme Court was required to determine whether it had jurisdiction to permanently stay the Magistrates Court proceedings on the grounds of abuse of process. The Court held that the Magistrates Court proceedings were indeed a collateral attack on the Full Court's final decision, and that it had the jurisdiction to grant a stay of those proceedings. The Court granted the stay and ordered costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Both the Bank and Mr Argus have made an application to this Court seeking the following orders against Mr Zollo. The orders sought on the amended Statement of Claim are:(a)an injunction restraining Mr Zollo from proceeding any further with the Magistrates Court proceedings;(b)a mandatory injunction compelling Mr Zollo to discontinue the Magistrates Court proceedings;(c)a declaration that the issuing and prosecution of the Magistrates Court proceedings constitute an abuse of process;(d) a stay of the Magistrates Court proceedings;(e) costs; and(f) such further or other orders as this court deems fit.Background There has been a dispute in the civil jurisdiction of this Court between Mr Zollo and the Bank for many years. The matter previously determined in this Court involved three separate actions referred to by Bollen J, the trial judge, as “the insurance action”, “the possession action” and “the damages case”. Mr Zollo claimed in the first action that he asked an agent of the Bank, Mr Daly, to procure insurance which would indemnify Mr Zollo against payment of all monies that he could be liable to pay the Bank pursuant to his, his wife’s, or their company’s borrowings from the Bank, should he be injured and unable to earn income in his work as a builder. Mr Zollo had an instalment loan of about $150,000 secured by mortgage. He also had an overdraft facility of about $50,000 and a Bill Finance facility of about $70,000. Mr Zollo spoke to Mr Daly about getting insurance in respect of these liabilities to the Bank. The Bank in this case was acting as agent for the insurer. The insurer provided cover for the instalment loan but refused cover for the overdraft facility and the Bill Finance facility. The full details of the factual background to this matter are set out in the reasons of Doyle CJ in the decision of Zollo v National Australia Bank Ltd & Anor, Full Court, Supreme Court of South Australia, 20 December 1996 (unreported). Briefly, Mr Zollo sustained an injury to his back in 1990. When he sought to claim on the insurance policy that he thought he held, he was advised that the policy only covered him in certain circumstances and only for payments of instalments pursuant to mortgages granted by the plaintiff to the Bank over real estate, in the event of Mr Zollo’s permanent total disablement from carrying out his usual occupation. Mr Zollo issued proceedings in 1993. In the first and second actions, Bollen J found that Mr Zollo was entitled to damages for breach of contract, namely the contract to have the insurance cover sought, and also for misrepresentation and negligence under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) and the Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA). On appeal to the Full Court in action number 1026 of 1993 it was found that the only policy issued by the insurer was a policy in respect of the instalment loan, which policy did not provide cover for temporary disability. The Full Court decision was delivered in December 1996, and the Court then, after further argument, made the finding that the policy did not respond to Mr Zollo’s claim. The Full Court found that as the insurer was bound by the conduct of Mr Daly, an employee of its agent the Bank, it was obliged to indemnify Mr Zollo in respect of the three liabilities to the Bank in the event of him sustaining permanent total disablement as defined. There was no contract with the Bank.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The matters which have influenced me in coming to this conclusion are as follows:1.the offences detailed in the summons contain allegations relating to a policy of insurance;2.the policy and all background matters relating to it are the subject of detailed analysis by both the trial judge and the Full Court in action number 1026 of 1993;3.the Full Court made findings as to the obligation of the Bank to indemnify in certain circumstances which it found did not apply to the facts of Mr Zollo’s case. In other words on the facts, as found by the Full Court, the policy did not respond;4.the offences detailed seek to re-agitate the issues surrounding the insurance policy in a number of ways5.in addition to the Full Court decision referred to, Mr Zollo sought to raise the issues again by applying to reopen his case. This application was refused by the Full Court;6.in that application it is apparent that Mr Zollo was raising, or attempting to raise, the very issues relevant to his assertions of false pretences, deceit, conspiracy to defraud and perverting the course of justice, which had been earlier disposed of;7.there is no justification at all for joining Mr Argus in these proceedings as he had no dealings with Mr Zollo;8.Mr Zollo filed an affidavit sworn by him on 11 March 2008 as part of his submissions opposing the orders sought by the Bank. In it he describes the basic elements of the charges he has laid in the Magistrates Court as follows:1. That I applied to the NAB for insurance to cover the payments of my various accounts with the plaintiff bank on the terms of the Hindmarsh Building Society Insurance (a copy of which is now produced ‘AZ1”). This document was handed by me by the then manager Daley of the plaintiff bank, Port Lincoln branch.2. That money was taken from my account at the Port Lincoln branch of NAB to pay for a policy with the same terms and conditions as the Hindmarsh Building Society policy.3. That no such policy was ever issued by the bank or its insurers to cover my borrowings.4. That I was informed by Mr Grant Bailey that the bank had an insurance policy covering the same position as the Hindmarsh Building Society policy.5. That no policy of any kind was ever issued in fact by the plaintiff bank or its insurer. That as a result thereof, as a consequence of the facts I was deceived and defrauded.I have set out this passage from Mr Zollo’s affidavit because it illustrates how the issues he seeks to raise in the criminal proceedings are the same issues which have been heard and finally determined by the Full Court. He also illustrates his fundamental misunderstanding of what findings were made in the Full Court and the effect of those findings.Conclusion Mr Zollo in both his written and oral submissions to me is continuing the theme of his unsuccessful civil action. He has not attempted to address the issue of why this is not a collateral attack on the Full Court judgment nor is there any hint of any new evidence which could support the charges he has laid. He merely repeats the issues and allegations he made unsuccessfully in the civil court. There is a lack of anything substantive or material in the submissions which have been made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court in National Australia Bank Ltd & Argus v Zollo had to consider whether it had jurisdiction to permanently stay the Magistrates Court proceedings on the grounds of abuse of process at the committal stage. The court found that it did have jurisdiction to do so, primarily due to the fact that the Magistrates Court proceedings appeared to be a collateral attack on the final decision of the Full Court in the civil actions between Mr Zollo and the Bank. The court relied on the principle that abuse of process can indeed warrant a stay of proceedings, especially when those proceedings seek to re-litigate issues that have already been conclusively determined in a previous judgment.

The Supreme Court determined that the Magistrates Court proceedings were a collateral attack on the final decision of the Full Court. This was based on the fact that the allegations in the summons related to the same policy of insurance that had already been subject to detailed analysis and determination by both the trial judge and the Full Court in the civil actions. The Full Court had made specific findings as to the obligations of the Bank and had concluded that, on the facts, the policy did not respond to Mr Zollo’s claim. The court found that Mr Zollo’s attempts to raise these issues again in the Magistrates Court were futile and amounted to a collateral attack on the final judgment.

Given that the Magistrates Court proceedings were indeed a collateral attack on the Full Court’s decision, the Supreme Court had grounds to grant a permanent stay of the proceedings. The court emphasized that there was no justification for re-litigating the same issues in a criminal proceeding when they had already been conclusively determined in a civil context. Additionally, the court noted that Mr Argus had no dealings with Mr Zollo, making his inclusion in the criminal proceedings even more unwarranted.

Finally, the Supreme Court granted a stay of the Magistrates Court proceedings based on the findings of abuse of process. The court found that Mr Zollo's actions in the Magistrates Court were an attempt to re-litigate issues that had been finally determined by the Full Court. There was no substantive or material new evidence presented that could support the charges, and Mr Zollo merely repeated the same issues and allegations that had been unsuccessful in the civil court. The court concluded that allowing the Magistrates Court proceedings to continue would not only be an abuse of process but would also undermine the finality of the Full Court’s judgment.

In summary, the Supreme Court established that it has the jurisdiction to grant a permanent stay of Magistrates Court proceedings when they constitute an abuse of process, particularly when such proceedings are a collateral attack on a final decision. This decision reinforces the importance of respecting the finality of judicial determinations and preventing the re-litigation of issues that have already been conclusively resolved.