Nash v Food and Beverage Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Civil)

NASH v FOOD AND BEVERAGE AUSTRALIA LTD

[2021] SASCA 59

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable Justice Lovell, the Honourable Justice Livesey and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

10 June 2021

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS - TRUST DEED OR CONSTITUTION

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS - WINDING UP

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS

CORPORATIONS - FINANCIAL SERVICES AND MARKETS - MARKET MISCONDUCT AND OTHER PROHIBITED CONDUCT - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT

Appeal against two judgments of the Supreme Court which determined a claim and counterclaim arising out of a dispute in respect of a managed investment scheme.

The respondent, Food and Beverage Australia Ltd (‘FBA’), sued the second appellant, Philip Nash as trustee of the Nash Family Trust, for fees payable in respect of a managed investment scheme called ‘The Tasmanian Premium Cherries Project’ (‘Cherries Project’). Philip Nash as trustee of the Nash Family Trust was a participant in the Cherries Project, participants being described in the relevant documents as ‘Growers’.

The appellants counterclaimed against FBA, claiming that FBA had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct in representing that Mr Nash would be able to obtain loans from an associated company, Total Beverage Australia Pty Ltd ('TBA').  The purpose of those loans, as claimed to have been represented, was to cover the first four years of the fees (‘Grower Fees’) that Mr Nash would need to pay to participate in the Cherries Project.

The trial judge, gave judgment in favour of FBA for the amount claimed in respect of invoices it had issued on account of the Cherries Project.  He dismissed the Counterclaim, finding that FBA had not engaged in the claimed misleading and deceptive conduct.

The substantive issues arising on appeal are whether parts of the amounts found to be owed under the invoices were recoverable by FBA or by a different entity, whether the eventual winding up and deregistration of the Cherries Project disentitled FBA from obtaining judgment, and whether the trial judge erred in finding that FBA had not engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct as to the availability of finance from TBA and the provision of rain covers and bird netting on the orchards.

Held (by the Court), dismissing the appeal:

1. Growers had a substantive obligation under the operative documents to pay Grower Fees to FBA. Once the invoices were issued to Mr Nash in accordance with the terms of the Constitution, Mr Nash was liable in debt to FBA.

2.  The trial judge was correct to conclude that the winding up and deregistration of the Cherries Project had no effect on FBA’s entitlement to judgment.

3.  The trial judge did not err in his conclusions with respect to the claim that FBA had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Chapter 5C; Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), referred to.

Food and Beverage Australia Ltd v Nash [2020] SASC 92

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nash v Food and Beverage Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASCA 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Food and Beverage Australia Ltd (FBA) and Mr Nash regarding payments owed under a managed investment scheme known as the Cherries Project. FBA, acting as the responsible entity for the scheme, had issued invoices to Mr Nash for "Grower Fees," which included licence fees and rental components. Mr Nash disputed his liability for these fees, arguing that they were recoverable by a different entity, Aussie Cherries Ltd, and that the winding up and deregistration of the Cherries Project affected FBA's entitlement to judgment. Additionally, Mr Nash alleged that FBA had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct concerning the availability of finance and the provision of orchard amenities. The matter was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The court was required to determine several legal issues. Firstly, it needed to ascertain whether FBA or another entity was entitled to recover the licence fees and rental components of the invoices issued to Mr Nash. Secondly, the court had to consider whether the winding up and subsequent deregistration of the Cherries Project precluded FBA from obtaining judgment for these amounts. Finally, the court was tasked with determining whether FBA had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to the availability of finance from TBA and the provision of rain covers and bird netting on the orchards.

The court reasoned that Mr Nash had a substantive obligation under the operative documents to pay the Grower Fees to FBA. Once the invoices were issued in accordance with the terms of the Constitution, Mr Nash became liable in debt to FBA, thus dismissing grounds 9 and 10 of the appeal. Regarding the winding up and deregistration, the court found that the Grower Fees were not considered "Scheme Property" as defined in the Constitution. The court interpreted the definition of Scheme Property in context, concluding that Grower Fees were payable to FBA in its own right for services rendered, rather than being contributions to the Project itself. Therefore, the winding up of the Cherries Project did not affect FBA's entitlement to judgment for these fees, dismissing ground 11. Lastly, the court found no error in the trial judge's conclusions regarding FBA's alleged misleading and deceptive conduct, dismissing ground 12.

The appeal was dismissed, with the court upholding the trial judge's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held (by the Court), dismissing the appeal:

1. Growers had a substantive obligation under the operative documents to pay Grower Fees to FBA. Once the invoices were issued to Mr Nash in accordance with the terms of the Constitution, Mr Nash was liable in debt to FBA.

2. The trial judge was correct to conclude that the winding up and deregistration of the Cherries Project had no effect on FBA’s entitlement to judgment.

3. The trial judge did not err in his conclusions with respect to the claim that FBA had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct.

Background

Background to the litigation

The substantive issues arising on the Notice of Appeal are contained in the grounds numbered 9 to 12 inclusive. They are as follows:·whether the licence fees and rental components of the invoices were recoverable by FBA or by a different entity, Aussie Cherries Ltd (‘ACL’) (Grounds 9 and 10);·whether the winding up and deregistration of the Cherries Project disentitled FBA from obtaining judgment for the amounts reflecting the licence fee and rental components (Ground 11); and·whether Blue J erred in finding that FBA had not engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct with respect to the availability of finance from TBA and with respect to the provision of rain covers and bird netting on the orchards (Ground 12).Background The factual matrix underlying the dispute is set out comprehensively in the decision of Food and Beverage Australia Limited v P J Nash Pty Ltd[3] and in the decision the subject of this appeal, Food and Beverage Australia Limited v Nash.[4] The following is a summary.[3] [2019] SASC 208 (Doyle J).[4] [2020] SASC 92 (Blue J).The appellants Mr Nash works as a fruit wholesaler in Melbourne. He is the sole director of P J Nash Pty Ltd (‘Nash Co’), which he incorporated in July 2005 as a vehicle to acquire the Westmores fruit wholesaling businesses, having worked for those businesses since about 1985. At some point, Mr Nash married the third appellant, Mrs Nash. In August 2005, Mr Nash established a discretionary family trust, the Nash Family Trust.The respondent The respondent, FBA, is based in Adelaide. It operates managed investment schemes as a ‘responsible entity’ under Chapter 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). It is a wholly owned subsidiary of The FABAL Group Pty Ltd (‘FBG’), which owns several other subsidiaries involved in, or providing services to, agricultural businesses and projects in Australia. Relevantly, FBG owns TBA, a small-scale lender to investors in agricultural projects conducted by FBG and its subsidiaries. It also owns FABAL Operations Pty Ltd (‘FABAL Operations’), which held a separate bank account for each managed investment scheme of which FBA was the responsible entity. We will refer to the group comprising FBG and its subsidiaries collectively as FABAL. Christopher Day was the chief executive officer of the FABAL companies. Christopher Dundon was the chief operations officer.The Cherries Project The Cherries Project was a managed investment scheme involving the acquisition, development and management of a 46.5-hectare cherry orchard in the Huon Valley region of Tasmania. Investors in the project were provided with a licence to grow cherries on parcels of land owned by ACL. They were required to enter into a Management Agreement by which they appointed FBA to manage their individual orchard allotments. The scheme was divided into 465 ‘Interests’, each representing 0.10 hectares of the orchard. Mr Nash conceived the project in 2006, after prior experience investing in managed investment schemes. His idea was to purchase land in the Huon Valley from members of the Driessen family, who grew apples and cherries on the land. This fruit had been wholesaled by Westmores for some years.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Justice Blue did not err in his conclusions with respect to the claim that FBA had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct as to the availability of finance from TBA and the provision of rain covers and bird netting on the orchards. We dismiss Ground 12.Conclusion The appeal is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The point is well made, but it does not matter. The substantive obligation under the operative documents was to pay the Grower Fees to FBA. Once the invoices were issued to Mr Nash in accordance with the terms of the Constitution, Mr Nash was liable in debt to FBA. Grounds 9 and 10 fail.Whether the winding up and deregistration of the Cherries Project disentitled FBA from obtaining judgment for the amounts reflecting the licence fee and rental components After Blue J had delivered his reasons for judgment,[10] Mr Nash drew to the Court’s attention the fact that the Cherries Project had been wound up in mid‑2018 and deregistered by ASIC in December 2018. The issue that he then agitated was whether the entitlement of FBA to payment by the Nash Family Trust of the Grower Fees in the amount of $220,954.80, the subject of the judgment, comprised ‘Scheme Property’ within the meaning of the Constitution. He argued that if it did, FBA could not recover those fees because it was no longer the Responsible Entity of the Cherries Project. [10] Food and Beverage Australia Ltd v Nash [2020] SASC 92. Schedule 1 of the Constitution defined ‘Scheme Property’ as follows:Any funds, investments, assets, contributions of money or monies worth to the Tasmanian Premium Cherries Project including money that forms part of Scheme Property under the provisions of the Commonwealth Corporations Act 2001 or the Commonwealth ASIC Act 2001 and monies held in the Proceeds Fund. Scheme Property also includes any other property including money raised or borrowed by the Responsible Entity for the purposes of the Tasmanian Premium Cherries Project and property acquired directly or indirectly or with the proceeds of contributions of money that forms part of Scheme Property or rights contributed by Growers, but excluding any assets or other property vested directly in the Growers, including:·the picked cherries pending their sale;·proceeds generated by Allotments, including the sale of cherries pending its distribution; and ·proceeds of insurance to which all Growers are entitled and which are deposited in the Proceeds Fund,but not including:·Grower Interests; or·any sale proceeds generated by a Grower on his or her own behalf. Justice Blue observed that the first part of the definition of ‘Scheme Property’ included a reference to contributions of money to the Cherries Project. He observed, however, that this reference was required to be construed in context:[11]The context includes that an individual grower pays grower fees to FBA in consideration of services rendered to the individual grower pursuant to the management and licence agreements. Grower fees are not contributed to the Cherries Project as such. Clause 7.1 of the Constitution required FBA to hold all Scheme Property on trust for growers for the entire term of the Cherries Project: this cannot apply to grower fees because they are payable to FBA in their own right. If grower fees formed part of Scheme Property, FBA wold be precluded from receiving them in its own right and would be required to provide the services pursuant to the management agreement without being paid for them. Accordingly, construed in context, the reference in the first section of the first part of the definition of Scheme Property to “contributions of money … to the … Project” does not encompass grower fees. Consequentially, the reference to “assets [of] … the … Project” does not encompass the right of FBA to recover unpaid grower fees from an individual grower.[11] Food and Beverage Australia Ltd v Nash (No 2) [2020] SASC 181 at [36].