Food and Beverage Australia Limited v Nash

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

FOOD AND BEVERAGE AUSTRALIA LIMITED v NASH

[2020] SASC 92

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

29 May 2020

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS

CORPORATIONS - MANAGED INVESTMENTS - TRUST DEED OR CONSTITUTION

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT

The plaintiff sues the defendants for fees allegedly payable in respect of an avocado managed investment scheme and the second defendant for fees allegedly payable in respect of a cherries managed investment scheme.

The second defendant counterclaims seeking remedies for misleading conduct and breach of contract in respect of the cherries scheme restoring the parties to the position before his investment in the scheme or damages to the same effect.

The issues in relation to the avocado claim are:

1. Did the parties enter into contracts for the payment of the fees the subject of the invoices?

2. Did the parties enter into an agreement that no amount would be payable until the scheme was cashflow positive or is the plaintiff precluded by estopped by representation from claiming payment?

3. Has the plaintiff proved the quantum of fees the subject of the May 2010 invoices?

The issues in relation to the cherries claim are:

1. Did the parties enter into contracts for the payment of the fees the subject of the invoices?

2. Are the licence and rental fee components of the invoices recoverable by the plaintiff or are they only recoverable by Aussie Cherries Limited?

3. Did the parties enter into an agreement that $435,000 that the plaintiff acknowledged was to be paid to a company owned by the first defendant was to be offset against the fee invoices?

The issues in relation to the cherries counterclaim are:

1. Did the plaintiff engage in misleading conduct by representing to the second defendant that he could obtain loans from an associated company to cover the first four years’ grower fees; did he rely on those representations in deciding to apply to become a grower; and if so what relief should be granted?

2. Did the plaintiff engage in misleading conduct by representing to the second defendant that rain covers and bird netting would be installed over the cherry orchards; did he rely on those representations in deciding to apply to become a grower; and if so what relief should be granted?

3. Did the plaintiff breach the Constitution by failing to make reasonable endeavours to sell the second defendant’s interest in the cherries scheme; if so, did it cause loss or damage; and if so what relief should be granted?

Held:

1. Although the documents were not tendered, it should be inferred based on the presumption of regularity that Timbercorp Securities Limited executed the requisite agreements in relation to the avocado scheme (at [163]). Alternatively, the parties by their conduct entered in contracts in terms of the agreements attached to the Constitution (at [171]).

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Food and Beverage Australia Limited v Nash and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Food and Beverage Australia Limited (FBA) and Mr Nash, as trustee for the Nash Family Trust, are the parties involved in this dispute. Mr Nash counterclaimed against FBA, seeking remedies for misleading conduct and breach of contract in relation to the Cherries Project. The claim was brought both in Mr Nash’s personal capacity and as trustee for the Nash Family Trust, though his investment in the Cherries Project was made exclusively in the latter capacity. The primary legal issues before the court were whether FBA had breached the Corporations Act by failing to exercise reasonable care and diligence or act in the best interests of the Nash Family Trust, and if FBA had breached the trust deed by not making reasonable endeavours to sell Mr Nash’s interest in the Cherries Project. Additionally, the court had to determine if FBA had misled Mr Nash about the quality of the cherries produced.

The court held that Mr Nash’s claims were not substantiated. The court found that Mr Nash did not prove that FBA failed to work with Aussie Cherries or did not make reasonable endeavours to produce cherries. The court also determined that Mr Nash did not establish a breach by FBA of section 601FC of the Corporations Act. Furthermore, Mr Nash’s allegation that FBA failed to make reasonable endeavours to sell his interest in the Cherries Project was dismissed, as there was no evidence to support this claim. The court concluded that FBA was entitled to judgment on the avocado and cherries claims against Mr Nash and the Nash Family Trust, with specified amounts plus interest.

The court's decision underscores the importance of proving contractual and statutory breaches in managed investment schemes. The judgment highlights that mere allegations without sufficient evidence are insufficient to establish misconduct or breaches of duty by the responsible entity. The court's ruling ensures that claims against investment entities must be substantiated with credible evidence to succeed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Nash as trustee of the Nash Family Trust[1] counterclaims against FBA seeking remedies for misleading conduct and breach of contract in respect of the Cherries Project restoring the parties to the position before his investment in the scheme or damages to the same effect.Background[1] The claim is expressed to be by both Mr Nash as the first defendant in his personal capacity and by Mr Nash as the second defendant as trustee for the Nash Family Trust. However, Mr Nash’s investment in the Cherries Project was exclusively as trustee for the Nash Family Trust. I therefore refer to the claim as being by Mr Nash as trustee of the Nash Family Trust. Mrs Nash is also named as a claimant on the counterclaim. This is because the counterclaim originally included a claim by all three defendants in respect of the Avocado Project. However, that claim was abandoned at trial.FABAL group FBA has carried on business as the operator, as responsible entity, of managed investment schemes under Chapter 5C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) (and its predecessor) since 1995. It is based in Adelaide. It holds an Australian Financial Services Licence authorising it to operate managed investment schemes. Until it became involved in the Cherries Project in 2007, its managed investment schemes were associated with vineyards. Investors in managed investment schemes operated by FBA are called growers. FBA is a wholly owned subsidiary of The FABAL Group Pty Ltd (FBG). FBG owns several other subsidiaries involved in, or providing services to, agricultural businesses and projects in Australia, including Total Beverage Australia Pty Ltd (TBA) and FABAL Operations Pty Ltd (FABAL Operations). TBA has carried on business as a small-scale lender to investors in agricultural projects conducted by the group comprising FBG and its subsidiaries (collectively FABAL) since about 2005. Apart from lending in relation to the Cherries Project, its total lending in relation to other schemes was limited to approximately $300,000 to $400,000, with maximum lending to any one grower limited to $50,000 or $100,000. FABAL Operations held a separate bank account for each managed investment scheme of which FBA was the responsible entity. Payments of grower fees were banked into a bank account of FBA and then transferred to a bank account of FABAL Operations. Expenses of a scheme were paid out of the relevant bank account of FABAL Operations. Christopher Day has been a director of the FABAL companies since at least 1995. He was the chief executive officer of the FABAL companies (apart from a brief interlude) at all material times. He has a Bachelor of Laws, Bachelor of Economics, Master of International Business, Graduate Diploma of Applied Finance and Diploma in Financial Services. John Lambert has been the chief financial officer of the FABAL companies since at least 1995. He is an accountant. Christopher Dundon was the chief operations officer of FBA since 2002. He is now, and has since some point after the events the subject of this action been, the chief horticultural officer. He has also been the chief governance officer since about 2010 or 2011. His background is in agriculture. Before joining FBA, he worked as a technical viticulturist and as a technical officer for an irrigation business.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Before and after closing addresses, both parties applied for permission to amend their pleadings (FBA’s Statement of Claim and Reply and Defence to Counterclaim and the Nash Parties’ Defence and Counterclaim). Ultimately there was no objection to these amendments and I granted permission to amend.Credit and reliability of Mr Day’s evidence The Nash parties challenge the credibility and reliability of Mr Day’s evidence. I reject their invitation to find that Mr Day was a dishonest witness. I have found below that Mr Day does not, in fact, have as clear a recollection of his discussions with Mr Nash in relation to a cherries set-off as his evidence would suggest and his evidence is to a significant extent the result of reconstruction rather than recollection. However, I find that this did not involve dishonesty on his part but rather he has come to believe that he recollects what, in reality, is reconstruction in this respect. Overall, I regard Mr Day as an honest witness and in relation to the issues in the case (leaving aside the cherries set-off issue) I consider that his evidence was reliable. The Nash parties contend that I should find that, contrary to Mr Day’s evidence summarised at [106] above, Mr Nash did not agree to the June 2008 $435,000 agreement and in particular did not agree to lend the amount of $435,000 back to TBA. The Nash parties contend that a rejection of Mr Day’s evidence on this question would reflect adversely on his credit. This issue is ultimately only relevant to credit because TBA is not a party to this action and I conclude below that the existence or non-existence of this agreement does not impact on the cherries set-off issue addressed at [239] and following below. I am satisfied that Mr Day believed in June 2008 (and still believes) that he entered into the June 2008 $435,000 agreement with Mr Nash. First, although not conclusive in itself, in the absence of such an agreement, the transfer of $435,000 by FPA to TBA on 27 June 2008 is inexplicable. Secondly, Mr Day’s explanation of the rationale for the agreement makes commercial sense. Thirdly, although Mr Nash denied that he specifically agreed to lend the monies to TBA, he did give evidence that more generally he agreed to leave the amount of $435,000 with FABAL for the purpose of enhancing financing Grower Fees. Fourthly, TBA maintained records showing a borrowing of $435,000 from Nash Co (and $865,000 from Holt Norman & Co) together with interest accruing on the borrowings. Fifthly, it would have been a brazen exercise for Mr Day to have invented the transaction. Sixthly, I have no reason to reject Mr Day’s evidence and no reason to prefer Mr Nash’s evidence over that of Mr Day. This does not entail that Mr Nash was dishonest in denying that he agreed to the transaction. It may well be that the parties were not ad idem in their discussion about Mr Nash leaving in the amount of $435,000. Mr Day may have believed that he adequately explained, and Mr Nash understood, not only that the monies would be left in with FABAL but also more specifically that they would now be owed by TBA rather than FBA but in fact Mr Nash only understood the former and not the latter. I do not treat Mr Nash’s denial that he agreed to the June 2008 $435,000 agreement as reflecting adversely on his credit.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Nash fails on this issue.Conclusion FBA is entitled to judgment on the avocado claims against Mr Nash for $12,714.90 plus interest; Mr Nash as trustee of the Nash Family Trust for $42,383.00 plus interest; and Mrs Nash for $12,714.90 plus interest. FBA is entitled to judgment on the cherries claim against Mr Nash as trustee of the Nash Family Trust for $220,954.80. I will hear the parties concerning the calculation of interest and costs and orders to finalise this proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Nash contends, based on that provision in the Cherries PDS, that FBA had a responsibility to Growers to work with Aussie Cherries and make all reasonable endeavours in relation to ensuring that cherries were of merchantable quality, fit for purpose and free of defects and would meet the specifications prescribed by Nash Co from time to time. Again, Mr Nash did not run a case at trial to this effect. In any event, he did not prove such a case. He did not establish that FBA failed to work with Aussie Cherries or that it did not make reasonable endeavours in relation to the production of cherries.Breach of section 601FC of the Corporations Act Mr Nash pleaded in his counterclaim that FBA failed to exercise reasonable diligence and care or to act in the best interests of Mr Nash as a member of the Cherries Project and thereby breached section 601FC of the Corporations Act and sought a declaration that FBA contravened that section. In his counterclaim at the commencement of trial, Mr Nash had pleaded at paragraph 13 that FBA breached section 601FC of the Corporations Act by failing to keep monies of the Project separate from other monies but that case was not pursued at trial and during closing address Mr Nash produced a proposed amended counterclaim in which paragraph 13 was deleted. It appears that Mr Nash omitted to delete other paragraphs in the counterclaim referring to section 601FC of the Corporations Act. In any event, Mr Nash does not plead any sections of the Corporations Act that create a cause of action or seek any substantive relief for a breach of section 601FC (other than a declaration). Nor did he run a case at trial based on a cause of action involving a breach of section 601FC of the Corporations Act. In his written closing address, apart from a bare assertion of breach of section 601FC, he does not advance any substantive submissions in support of such a case. In any event, he failed to establish a breach by FBA of section 601FC of the Corporations Act.Reasonable endeavours to sell Nash interest Mr Nash pleads that FBA breached the Constitution by failing to make any reasonable endeavour to sell his interest in the Cherries Project, causing loss and damage being the loss of a chance to offset the value of that interest against any entitlement that FBA may have to Grower Fees and to receive any surplus. Clause 23 of the Constitution includes the following provisions:23.1If a Defaulting Grower’s Interest is terminated by the Responsible Entity, the Responsible Entity must make all reasonable endeavours to sell the Defaulting Grower’s Interest as an attorney for the Defaulting Grower on the best Terms it can obtain.23.2The Responsible Entity is indemnified by the Defaulting Grower for or on account of any loss incurred by that Defaulting Grower in the sale of the Defaulting Grower’s Interest by the Responsible Entity, and the Responsible Entity is not liable in any way if it is not able to sell the Defaulting Grower’s Interest.