Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1352

Citation: Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1352
Appeal from: Application for leave to appeal: Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd v Narain [2010] FMCA 188
Parties: EDWINA KATE NARAIN v EUROASIA (PACIFIC) PTY LTD
File number: VID 631 of 2010
Judge: GRAY J
Date of judgment: 6 December 2010
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY – sequestration – whether order should have been made – judgment entered pursuant to terms of settlement – application to set aside unsuccessful – appeal from that judgment dismissed – applicant wishing to pursue application for special leave to appeal to High Court – whether federal magistrate bound to decline to make sequestration order until all avenues of appeal exhausted – whether exercise of discretion miscarried

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – application for leave to appeal out of time – whether special reasons – whether adequate explanation of delay – whether absence of prejudice from delay – whether sufficient prospect of success on appeal

EVIDENCE – affidavit – affidavits filed and relied on – claim to legal professional privilege as to exhibits – whether partial waiver of privilege possible – whether affidavits and their exhibits should be available for inspection

Legislation: Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 33(2A)
Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 52, 52(1), 52(2), 52(2)(a), 52(2)(b)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 119, 122, 122(1), 122(2), 122(3)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 50(1)
Federal Magistrates Act 1999 (Cth) ss 103(1), 104(2), 104(3)
Statute Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1987 (Cth) ss 2(1), 3
Federal Court Rules O 46 r 6(3), O 46 r 6(3)(a), O 52 r 15, O 52 r 15(1)(a)(i), O 52 r 15(2)
Federal Magistrates Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 Item 5 Sch 2
Cases cited: Adamopoulos v Olympic Airways SA (1990) 95 ALR 525 followed
Ahern v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (Qld) (1987) 76 ALR 137 followed
Cain v Whyte (1933) 48 CLR 639 cited
Re Dolman; Ex parte Elder Smith Goldsbrough Mort Ltd (1967) 10 FLR 384 followed
Elkofairi v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd [2002] NSWCA 413 cited
Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd v Narain [2008] VSC 153 cited
Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd v Narain [2008] VSC 524 cited
Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd v Narain [2010] FMCA 188 affirmed
Finance Facilities Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1971) 127 CLR 106 discussed
Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd (1998) 194 CLR 395 discussed
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 applied
Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd [2008] VSCA 195 discussed
Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd [2009] VSCA 290 discussed
Rigg v Baker (2006) FCAFC 179 (2006) 155 FCR 531 followed
Sarina v Council of the Shire of Wollondilly (1980) 48 FLR 372 followed
Re SVIR; Ex parte Commissioner of Taxation (1998) 83 FCR 314 followed
Ward v Williams (1955) 92 CLR 496 discussed
Wilson v Alexander [2003] FCAFC 272 (2003) 135 FCR 273 cited
Yerkey v Jones (1939) 63 CLR 649 discussed
Dates of hearing:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 1352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Narain v Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd involved the creditor, Euroasia (Pacific) Pty Ltd, seeking a sequestration order against the debtor, Mrs Narain. The dispute centred on whether Mrs Narain was able to pay her debts as alleged by Euroasia, and whether a sequestration order should be made for other sufficient cause. The matter was heard and determined in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The primary legal issue was whether the Federal Circuit Court should make a sequestration order against Mrs Narain despite her application for special leave to appeal to the High Court. Mrs Narain argued that her application for special leave was arguable and that it should be considered as sufficient cause to not make a sequestration order.

The court considered the arguments presented by Mrs Narain and the countervailing points made by Euroasia. The court found that while the application for special leave was arguable, it had been rejected by multiple judges and courts. The court also considered the likelihood of success of the application for special leave, which was uncertain. Furthermore, the court noted that the administration of the sequestration order had been ongoing since December 2009 and that the debts were conceded to be owing. Balancing these considerations, the court found that making a sequestration order was the appropriate exercise of discretion. The court affirmed the decision of Registrar Luxton to make a sequestration order and dismissed the application for review. This decision was based on the reasoning that the application for special leave had been rejected by several courts and judges, and that the arguments presented by Mrs Narain were not compelling enough to warrant withholding the sequestration order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At [28]-[29] of his reasons for judgment, the federal magistrate referred to the need to be satisfied of the matters stated in the creditor’s petition, of the service of that petition, and of the fact that the debt on which Euroasia relied was still owing and found there was no serious dispute. At [30], his Honour pointed out that Ms Narain had not sought at any stage to file material to the effect that she was able to pay the debts alleged against her. His Honour was therefore not able to be satisfied that she was able to pay her debts. At [31]-[36], his Honour said:The question then becomes whether for other sufficient cause, a Sequestration Order should not be made (section 52(2)(b)).Here, Mrs Narain points fairly and squarely to her application for special leave. It is not an assertion without force. Master Daly thought that, notwithstanding the difficulties that Mrs Narain might face, her case was arguable in the light of the consideration of Garcia.The various countervailing points to be made to that submission are, in my view, as follows:a. the view expressed by Master Daly was not accepted by Robson J;b. it was not accepted by Hollingworth J;c.it was not thought to be clearly wrong by Nettle JA and the other two members of the Court of Appeal in Victoria;d. it was thought to be correct by the Court of Appeal of New South Wales;e.even if the legal position for which Mrs Narain contends in her special leave application were to be correct, the Court of Appeal in Victoria, led by Nettle JA, found squarely against her.Nettle JA, in the reasons I have earlier described, found that she was not a volunteer to the Deed of Settlement and obtained benefit thereby;f.the administration has been underway since December 2009 (although this is a relatively minor point);g. the amounts allegedly owing are conceded to be owing;h.the application for special leave will clearly be strongly resisted, and while its chances of success cannot be said to be negligible, they are clearly uncertain, at least so far as this Court is concerned;On the other hand, however, it should be noted that the making of a Sequestration Order is highly likely to deprive Mrs Narain of the capacity to pursue her application for special leave and, if granted, her appeal to the High Court.Balancing all of the above considerations together, it seems to me that the proper exercise of my discretion is to make a Sequestration Order. In my view, it is not appropriate to ignore the fact that the arguments sought to be placed before the High Court have been rejected by two puisne Judges of the Supreme Court of Victoria and three Justices of Appeal in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Although the argument as to the application of Yerkey found favour with Nettle JA, he was not prepared to say that the decision of the Court of Appeal in New South Wales was plainly wrong, and the other two Justices of the Court of Appeal of Victoria did no more than to adopt his Honour’s reasons. They also adopted his Honour’s reasoning that Mrs Narain was not a volunteer.In all the circumstances, and based upon the remarks set out above, I think that the proper exercise of my discretion is to make a Sequestration Order. In the light of the observations of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Totev v Sfar, I will affirm the decision of Registrar Luxton to make a Sequestration Order and dismiss the application for review.The evidence in support of the application

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I have said, the judgment of the federal magistrate was given on 24 March 2010. The application that is before me, for leave to appeal out of time from that judgment, was filed on 29 July 2010. On 30 July 2010, Ms Narain’s application to the High Court for special leave to appeal was stood out of the list at the request of counsel appearing for her, on the basis that it should not proceed unless and until Ms Narain could succeed in having the sequestration order against her set aside.The federal magistrate’s reasons for judgment At [28]-[29] of his reasons for judgment, the federal magistrate referred to the need to be satisfied of the matters stated in the creditor’s petition, of the service of that petition, and of the fact that the debt on which Euroasia relied was still owing and found there was no serious dispute. At [30], his Honour pointed out that Ms Narain had not sought at any stage to file material to the effect that she was able to pay the debts alleged against her. His Honour was therefore not able to be satisfied that she was able to pay her debts. At [31]-[36], his Honour said:The question then becomes whether for other sufficient cause, a Sequestration Order should not be made (section 52(2)(b)).Here, Mrs Narain points fairly and squarely to her application for special leave. It is not an assertion without force. Master Daly thought that, notwithstanding the difficulties that Mrs Narain might face, her case was arguable in the light of the consideration of Garcia.The various countervailing points to be made to that submission are, in my view, as follows:a. the view expressed by Master Daly was not accepted by Robson J;b. it was not accepted by Hollingworth J;c.it was not thought to be clearly wrong by Nettle JA and the other two members of the Court of Appeal in Victoria;d. it was thought to be correct by the Court of Appeal of New South Wales;e.even if the legal position for which Mrs Narain contends in her special leave application were to be correct, the Court of Appeal in Victoria, led by Nettle JA, found squarely against her.Nettle JA, in the reasons I have earlier described, found that she was not a volunteer to the Deed of Settlement and obtained benefit thereby;f.the administration has been underway since December 2009 (although this is a relatively minor point);g. the amounts allegedly owing are conceded to be owing;h.the application for special leave will clearly be strongly resisted, and while its chances of success cannot be said to be negligible, they are clearly uncertain, at least so far as this Court is concerned;On the other hand, however, it should be noted that the making of a Sequestration Order is highly likely to deprive Mrs Narain of the capacity to pursue her application for special leave and, if granted, her appeal to the High Court.Balancing all of the above considerations together, it seems to me that the proper exercise of my discretion is to make a Sequestration Order. In my view, it is not appropriate to ignore the fact that the arguments sought to be placed before the High Court have been rejected by two puisne Judges of the Supreme Court of Victoria and three Justices of Appeal in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Although the argument as to the application of Yerkey found favour with Nettle JA, he was not prepared to say that the decision of the Court of Appeal in New South Wales was plainly wrong, and the other two Justices of the Court of Appeal of Victoria did no more than to adopt his Honour’s reasons. They also adopted his Honour’s reasoning that Mrs Narain was not a volunteer.In all the circumstances, and based upon the remarks set out above, I think that the proper exercise of my discretion is to make a Sequestration Order. In the light of the observations of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Totev v Sfar, I will affirm the decision of Registrar Luxton to make a Sequestration Order and dismiss the application for review.The evidence in support of the application

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.