MZYHT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MZYHT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 659

Citation: MZYHT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] FCA 659
Appeal from: MZYHT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2010] FMCA 581
Parties: MZYHT v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: VID 38 of 2011
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 10 June 2011
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Citizen of Bangladesh – Protection visa application – Visa refusal – Refugee Review Tribunal – Alleged fear of persecution due to political beliefs and political activism – Whether Tribunal erred in law by imposing an onus of proof – Whether Tribunal required applicant’s claims or evidence to be substantiated or corroborated by documentary or other third party evidence – Whether error inferred from selective evaluation of corroborating documentary evidence prior to assessment of applicant’s credibility
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 65(1)
Cases cited: Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 75 ALD 630 cited
Bushell v Repatriation Commission (1992) 175 CLR 408 cited
Eshetu v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1997) 46 ALD 203 cited
Machmud v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2001) 66 ALD 98 considered
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI & Anor (2009) 111 ALD 15 cited
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 cited
MZXLB v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 1588 cited
MZXSA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor (2010) 117 ALD 441 considered
MZYHT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2010] FMCA 581 affirmed
NAQR v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 1033 cited
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Applicant S20/2002 (2003) 73 ALD 1 cited
SZEEU v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 150 FCR 214 cited
Warnakulasuriya v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1998] FCA 336 considered
Date of hearing: 18 May 2011
Date of last submissions: 18 May 2011
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 76
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr J Gibson
Solicitor for the Appellant: Victoria Legal Aid
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr R Knowles
Solicitor for the Respondents: DLA Piper Australia

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 38 of 2011

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MZYHT
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 JUNE 2011

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal made by amended notice of appeal dated 2 May 2011 be dismissed with costs.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 38 of 2011

ON…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MZYHT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 659
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, a citizen of Bangladesh, appealed against the refusal of a protection visa by the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship. The appellant argued that he would be persecuted by the Awami League due to his political beliefs and activism as a member of the Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) and its student wing, the Jatiyatabadi Chhatra Dal (JCD). The Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal) dismissed the appeal, and the appellant sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision. The court had to determine whether the Tribunal erred in imposing an onus of proof on the appellant, requiring his claims to be substantiated or corroborated by documentary or third-party evidence, and whether the Tribunal's selective evaluation of corroborating documentary evidence prior to assessing the appellant's credibility constituted an error.

The court found that the Tribunal did not err in law. The court noted that the appellant's claims depended on inferring error from the combined alleged indicia in the absence of a clearly identifiable locus or statement of error. The court held that the Tribunal's assessment of documentary evidence was not selective. The court concluded that the Tribunal appropriately attributed weight to the evidence of Ms. KR, an officer of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT), who advised that the appellant was not recognised by her office, and found it "not particularly plausible" that if the appellant's claims were valid, he would not be recognised by the convenor of the other half of the BNP district to which his constituency belonged. The court also found that the Tribunal appropriately balanced the weight of the appellant's documentary evidence against the weight of the non-corroborative evidence from DFAT.

The appeal was dismissed with costs. The court found that the Tribunal had not erred in its assessment of the appellant's claims and evidence, and had appropriately balanced the weight of the documentary evidence against the non-corroborative evidence from DFAT. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was not flawed and did not constitute an error of law. The appellant's appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Tribunal was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal made by amended notice of appeal dated 2 May 2011 be dismissed with costs.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the absence of a clearly identifiable locus or statement of error, the appellant’s case depended on inferring error from the combined alleged indicia.Whether selective approach to documentary evidence The appellant, while acknowledging that the Tribunal’s fact-finding and weighing of evidence were not legitimately subject to judicial review, contended that in this case the selective treatment of documentary evidence was relevant on appeal as both an element and hallmark of the Tribunal’s fundamentally flawed approach. The appellant submitted that selectivity was revealed by the weight the Tribunal accorded to a single item of non‑corroborative evidence (the advice to DFAT of Ms KR that the appellant was not known to her office) at the expense of four items of corroborative evidence, although two of them were obtained from the same “relatively disinterested” source (DFAT) as the former. The supporting letter of Mr ERC, an ex-Member of Parliament and former State Minister and ex‑president of the M District of the BNP, stated that the appellant was a member of the JCD and was an active member and leader of the party at S University. Mr ERC subsequently confirmed to DFAT by telephone that he issued the letter of support to the appellant and was not a family member but a distant relative. Mr MR, president of the JCD from the M district and the Vice‑President of the National Executive Committee of the JCD, advised DFAT that he recognised the appellant as a member of the JCD and a student from S University. Mr SST, the President of the Central Committee of the JCD, initially advised DFAT that he was unable to recognise the appellant, but subsequently confirmed that the appellant was a member of the JCD at S University. The supporting letter of Mr MAH, ex‑president of the District BNP in S, Bangladesh stated, inter alia, that the appellant “has been participating in… BNP [and] become [sic] the prime target of the … Awwami [sic] League…” and stated that the student wing of the Awami League had destroyed his office and he had “actively… taken part in the last election”. In my opinion, the Tribunal’s assessment of the documentary evidence was not selective. Independent country information indicated that only a relatively high-profile activist member of the BNP would be liable to fear harm from political opponents in the Awami League. The fundamental basis of the appellant’s claim was not his membership of BNP per se, but his asserted status as an activist member of some prominence who had participated in electioneering and delivered over 100 speeches in his local constituency during the 2001 election campaign, thereby acquiring such a high profile that he remained a current and reasonably foreseeable future target for persecution by the Awami League due to his political opinions and role, although he had not participated in the 2008 election. It was in the context of those claims that the Tribunal, while accepting DFAT’s advice that two JCD officers had identified the appellant as a member, attributed weight to the evidence of Ms KR and found it “not particularly plausible” that if the appellant’s claims were valid, he would not be recognised by the convenor of the other half of the BNP district to which his constituency belonged, as Ms KR had advised DFAT (at [150]).

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his protection visa application received on 9 September 2009, the appellant stated he feared the Awami League as it was the current ruling party. He stated that he had been an active member of the BNP and, when a student, of the Jatiyatabadi Chhatra Dal (“JCD”), which is the student wing of the BNP. The appellant claimed that when the BNP lost power and the Awami League took over, he became a “prime target” due to his close involvement in the BNP’s activities. In March 2009, after the appellant’s home and office were destroyed by members of the ruling party, he left Bangladesh to study for a PhD in Fiji. When his PhD candidature and visa were terminated in Fiji, the appellant applied for a protection visa in Australia. The appellant stated that he feared persecution, including imprisonment, torture and death, by the Awami League “because of my political [beliefs]”.THE DELEGATE’S DECISION On 9 October 2009, the appellant was interviewed by the delegate of the first respondent. In the interview, the appellant reiterated he was a prominent activist in the BNP and a target for political violence perpetrated by the governing Awami League. He claimed that his house and office had been destroyed by supporters of the Awami League. The appellant stated that his PhD candidature in Fiji was terminated due to a disagreement with his supervisor, on which, according to the delegate, he focused excessively during the interview. The appellant informed the delegate that he had been extremely active in the 2001 elections, but had not been involved in the December 2008 elections after which the Awami League formed government. The appellant stated that he feared harm from the youth wing of the Awami League. By a decision made on 13 October 2009, the delegate refused the appellant’s protection visa application on the basis that there was no real chance of the appellant being persecuted by the Awami League were he to return to Bangladesh. The appellant had played no role in the 2008 election and the delegate was sceptical that he would have represented more than an “immediate target of convenience” in the election’s immediate aftermath. The delegate also considered independent country information which stated that following the 2008 election, the violence had subsided in early 2009. The delegate concluded that the appellant’s fears of harm and of persecution were not well-founded.THE TRIBUNAL HEARING On 21 October 2009 the appellant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision. The Tribunal subsequently invited the appellant to a hearing to take place on 9 December 2009. On 2 November 2009 the Tribunal sought information from the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (“DFAT”) about the appellant’s political membership and activities in the BNP. DFAT’s information confirmed that the appellant was a member of JCD as a student. On 9 December 2009, the appellant appeared before the Tribunal, assisted by an English/Bengali interpreter. The appellant also submitted various documents to the Tribunal, including submissions dated 7 December 2009, Odhikar reports for 1 January 2009 to 30 September 2009 and for 1 to 31 October 2009, the US Department of State County Report on Human Rights Practices Bangladesh 2008 containing country information, news reports, the appellant’s employment and business history, letters of support from an ex-Member of Parliament, Mr ERC, dated 5 September 2009 and Mr MAH dated 1 November 2009, and a medical report dated 20 June 2009 stating that the appellant had been treated from 12 to 18 June (year unspecified) because he had been wounded.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established