TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Trade mark application number 992885(21) - SHAPE OF A CONTAINER- in the name of Multix Pty Ltd.
Delegate: | Rachel Dunn |
Representation: | Applicant Russel Waters, Philips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick |
Decision: | Application refused; s41(6) |
Background
Trade mark application number 992885 is the shape of an oval baking or roasting tray as depicted below:
It was filed on 10 March 2004 by Multix Pty Ltd (the applicant) and sought registration in respect of Aluminium foil roasting and barbeque trays in International Class 21.
The application was duly examined under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (the Act), and two reports were issued. In each report the examiner held that the oval tray was not capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods in terms of s41(6) of the Act. The ground for rejection was based on the contention that the trade mark was devoid of inventiveness, not at all an unusual shape, and that other traders should be able to use an oval shape for the goods claimed. The applicant was advised that in order to achieve acceptance of the trade mark, it would need to file overwhelming evidence of use showing that the ordinary oval shape has been overshadowed in the marketplace by its significance as a trade mark in order to enable the provisions of s41(6) to be applied.
In response to the examiner's reports, the applicant filed written submissions. Additionally, evidence of use was filed before the first report was issued. The arguments advanced by the applicant were not found to be persuasive, the ground for rejection was maintained as s41(6) and the applicant requested a hearing. The hearing was conducted before me, in Canberra, on 8 July 2004. Mr Russel Waters of Philips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick attended on behalf of the applicant.
Evidence and submissions
The evidence of use is lead by a statutory declaration in the name of Paul Maguire, General Manager of the applicant, accompanied by 13 exhibits and detailing the history, promotion and sales of the oval tray. An additional statutory declaration in the name of Russel John Waters and three exhibits dealing with survey evidence was also provided. The evidence of use provided is all dated prior to the filing date of the subject application.
The shape was first used in Australia in 1988 and has been in continuous use since that time. The sales figures provided, for the years 1996-2002 inclusive, show steadily growing sales with understandably large sales over the Christmas period. Promotion of the oval tray is undertaken through in-store promotions, store catalogues, advertisements in magazines, the applicant’s own “Kitchen Companion” publication and in top selling publications such as Woman’s Day, Better Homes and Gardens and Family Circle. These promotions and advertisements always show the oval tray used with the applicant’s other trade marks including the words MULTIX and COMALCO and the colour red. It is also shown that the oval trays themselves bear the embossed word MULTIX…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Multix Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] ATMO 51
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the payments made by Multix to its employees under the profit-sharing scheme constituted "expenditure incurred in gaining or producing assessable income" within the meaning of s 8-1 of the *Income Tax Assessment Act 1997* (Cth), thereby rendering them deductible. The Commissioner contended that the payments were not deductible as they were not incurred in the process of gaining or producing assessable income, but rather were distributions of profits.
Justice Dunn reasoned that the character of the expenditure must be determined by its connection to the business operations that produce the assessable income. Her Honour found that the profit-sharing scheme was an integral part of Multix's remuneration strategy, designed to incentivise employees and thereby enhance productivity and profitability. Consequently, the payments, although linked to profits, were incurred in the course of carrying on the business and were therefore deductible under s 8-1. The Court applied the established principles that expenditure is deductible if it has a character of being incurred in gaining or producing assessable income, and that the connection need not be direct, but rather a practical one.
The Court ordered that the Commissioner's objection be disallowed and that the assessment be amended to allow the deduction of the profit-sharing payments.
Background
Background to the litigation
The key facts that gave rise to the legal dispute were the filing of the trade mark application by Multix for the oval tray shape, the examiner's rejection of the application on the grounds that the shape was not capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods, the applicant's subsequent evidence of use and submissions in response, and the delegate's ultimate decision to reject the application after considering all the evidence and arguments presented at the hearing. The central issue was whether the oval tray shape was inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods, or whether the evidence of use was sufficient to establish distinctiveness under section 41(6) of the Act. The applicant argued that the shape was unusual and inventive, while the delegate found that the shape was an ordinary one commonly used for baking and roasting trays.
The matter of Multix Pty Ltd, Trade Mark Application Number 992885, came before a Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Rachel Dunn, for a decision on the registrability of the trade mark application. The application, filed by Multix Pty Ltd on 10 March 2004, sought registration of the shape of an oval baking or roasting tray for Aluminium foil roasting and barbeque trays in International Class 21. The application was examined under the Trade Marks Act 1995, and two reports were issued by the examiner, holding that the oval tray was not capable of distinguishing the applicant's goods as per section 41(6) of the Act. In response to the examiner's reports, the applicant filed written submissions and evidence of use. The applicant requested a hearing, which was conducted before the Delegate in Canberra on 8 July 2004. The Delegate considered the evidence and submissions presented, and ultimately found that the oval tray shape was not inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods and the evidence of use did not satisfy the Delegate that the trade mark was capable of distinguishing. Therefore, the Delegate rejected the trade mark application number 992885, subject to any successful appeal from the decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the oval tray shape inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods from those of other traders?
2. Has the applicant provided sufficient evidence of use to demonstrate that the oval tray shape has acquired distinctiveness through use?
3. Does the evidence of use, including promotional activities and survey results, establish that the oval tray shape distinguishes the applicant's goods?
4. Is there a legislative requirement that the oval tray shape be recognised by the end users of the goods as a trade mark?
5. Does the lengthy use of the oval tray shape alone establish distinctiveness of the trade mark?
Held
1. Is the oval tray shape inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods from those of other traders?
The court concluded that the oval tray shape is not inherently adapted to distinguish the applicant's goods from those of other traders, resulting in the application being refused.
2. Has the applicant provided sufficient evidence of use to demonstrate that the oval tray shape has acquired distinctiveness through use?
The court found that the applicant did not provide sufficient evidence of use to demonstrate that the oval tray shape has acquired distinctiveness through use, leading to the application being refused.
3. Does the evidence of use, including promotional activities and survey results, establish that the oval tray shape distinguishes the applicant's goods?
The court determined that the evidence of use, including promotional activities and survey results, does not establish that the oval tray shape distinguishes the applicant's goods, resulting in the application being refused.
4. Is there a legislative requirement that the oval tray shape be recognised by the end users of the goods as a trade mark?
The court held that there is no legislative requirement that the oval tray shape be recognised by the end users of the goods as a trade mark, but found that recognition only by a particular sector of people does not translate into the oval tray distinguishing the applicant's goods, leading to the application being refused.
5. Does the lengthy use of the oval tray shape alone establish distinctiveness of the trade mark?
The court concluded that the lengthy use of the oval tray shape alone does not establish distinctiveness of the trade mark, and the application was refused as a result.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In this decision, the Delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, Rachel Dunn, evaluated the inherent distinctiveness of the oval tray shape proposed by Multix Pty Ltd for registration as a trade mark under the Trade Marks Act 1995. The court began by examining whether the oval tray shape was inherently adapted to distinguish Multix's goods from those of other traders. The Delegate found that the oval shape was an ordinary everyday shape that lacked any intrinsic distinctiveness for the claimed goods. This was based on the principle that functional features and shapes necessary to achieve a technical result are entirely devoid of inherent adaptation, as established in the Remington and Kenman cases. The Delegate concluded that the oval tray's features, such as its depth and raised bars, were simple functional aspects rather than distinctive elements.
Next, the Delegate assessed whether the applicant had provided sufficient evidence of use to demonstrate that the oval tray shape had acquired distinctiveness through use. The Delegate found that the evidence of use, which included promotional activities and survey results, did not satisfy the requirements for establishing distinctiveness. The promotional activities were primarily focused on the applicant's other trade marks, such as the word "MULTIX" and the color red, rather than the oval shape itself. The Delegate placed minimal weight on the survey evidence, noting that it was conducted by the applicant's trade mark attorneys and had methodological shortcomings. The Delegate concluded that the evidence did not establish that the oval tray shape was used as a badge of origin to distinguish Multix's goods.
The Delegate also considered whether there was a legislative requirement that the oval tray shape be recognized by the end users of the goods as a trade mark. The Delegate noted that while there was no requirement for the trade mark to be recognized by a specific sector of the public, the evidence did not show that the end users of the goods recognized the oval tray shape as a trade mark. The Delegate found that recognition only by a particular sector of people, such as supermarket workers, did not translate into the oval tray distinguishing the applicant's goods.
Finally, the Delegate examined whether the lengthy use of the oval tray shape alone established distinctiveness of the trade mark. The Delegate noted that while lengthy use was noteworthy, it did not automatically equate to distinctiveness. The Delegate found that the overall impression from the evidence was that of an ordinary shape used for a lengthy period, but used only as the shape of the goods, nothing more. The Delegate concluded that the evidence did not satisfy the requirements for establishing distinctiveness.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the oval tray shape proposed by Multix Pty Ltd for registration as a trade mark is not inherently adapted to distinguish the claimed goods, and the evidence of use does not satisfy the requirements for establishing distinctiveness. The decision adheres to the principle that functional features and shapes necessary to achieve a technical result are devoid of inherent adaptation and that evidence of use must demonstrate that the shape functions as a badge of origin to distinguish the goods. The decision also emphasizes that recognition by end users is not a legislative requirement for trade mark registration but is relevant to establishing distinctiveness.