FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Mulholland v Australian Electoral Commission [2014] FCA 916
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mulholland v Australian Electoral Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] FCA 916
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several legal issues, including the adequacy of Mr. Mulholland's explanation for the delay in filing the appeal, whether the AEC's decision was still operative, and if the appeal raised significant questions of fact or law. It found that while the AEC's decision to replace Mr. Mulholland as the registered officer was still in effect, Mr. Mulholland's appeal raised new factual and legal questions not considered in previous administrative reviews. The court concluded that an extension of time should be granted to Mr. Mulholland to allow him to present his case, but his application for leave to appeal should be refused. The court found that the appeal did not raise significant new questions of fact or law, and the previous decisions of the AEC and other forums were still valid.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Mulholland set out 15 grounds in both his application for extension of time and leave to appeal and in his proposed draft notice of appeal. They were as follows.1.His Honour proceeded with an preconceived view that the Appellant “was defeated by Mr Zegenhagen in a contested ballot for the position of Federal Secretary of the DLP” before the latter applied to replace the Appellant as Registered Officer of the DLP under s.134 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 , at[19].2.His Honour failed to give adequate weight to the concession made by the Respondent as to having suffered no prejudice as a result of the Appellant’s delay, at [22].3.His Honour erred in finding that the Appellant had failed to provide an adequate explanation for his delay, at [23-25].4.His Honour erred in finding, or was misled (by a mistaken submission of Senior Counsel) in his finding that the Respondent, between 10 April 2013 and 12 September 2013, “was entitled to consider that the matter was finalised”, at [26].5.His Honour’s relied on speculation or conjecture in place of evidence for his finding or conclusion as to prejudice to the DLP and other third parties if an extension of time were to be granted, at [27-29].6.His Honour failed to distinguish the case of Re Wakim (per Gummow and Hayne JJ at 592-593) from the Appellant’s new case with respect to potential prejudice to the DLP and other third parties, at [27-29].7.His Honour failed to apply the correct principle of law (per Brennan J in Re Brian Lawler Automotive Pty Ltd as cited in Shi v MARA [2008] 235 CLR 236 at [100] by Justices Hayne and Heydon), in relation to whether the AEC delegate’s decision (of 8 January 2010) remains “intact”, “operative” and “real” at [33-44].8.His Honour failed to take into account that the relief sought by the Appellant, under the ADJR Act (if his application for an extension of time was granted) and under the Judiciary Act, was based upon factual and legal questions different to those considered by the AEC delegate, by the Full AEC and by the AAT relating to the decision of the delegate on 8 January 2010 to change the Register was correct at [45-46].9.Further to Ground 8, his Honour could not have taken into account relevant new material from the judgment in Butler v Mulholland (No.2) [2013] VSC 662 (given after his Honour’s hearing of the Appellant’s applications), which material, in conjunction with Mulholland v VEC & Butler [2012] VSCA 104, demonstrably falsifies findings of the AEC delegate, the Full AEC and the AAT relating to the decision of the delegate on 8 January 2010 to change the Register at [45-46].10.His Honour failed to comprehend the substance of the Appellant’s argument as to the interpretation in Mulholland v VEC & Butler [2012] VSCA 104, of clause 4 of the DLP Constitution and Rules at [47].11.His Honour erred in finding that the Appellant did not establish from two DLP membership lists he relied upon, as new evidence, how certain people attending a said Federal Conference, were not members within the Constitution at [48].12.His Honour failed to comprehend the nature of the new circumstances relied upon by the Appellant, which led his Honour to conclude, in error, that the Appellant was seeking to undermine earlier factual findings, with evidence that was available at the earlier time [47-49].13.His Honour erred in relying upon the Appellant’s lack of success in earlier administrative review processes, in other forums, as the basis for refusing an extension of time for the hearing of a new and different application for judicial review that raised new questions of fact and law and mixed fact and law at [50-52].14.His Honour wrongly grounded his discretion to summarily dismiss the Appellant's application for relief under s.39B of the Judiciary Act upon an erroneous view that the application raised no significant question of fact or law or mixed fact and law, that it lacked merit and that the decision sought to be challenged was no longer operative [56-59].15.His Honour erred in the exercise of his discretion to dismiss the Appellant’s ADJR Act application by giving inadequate or secondary consideration to the substantive matters of the Appellant’s principal case relative to procedural technicalities [60-62].CONSIDERATIONDoes Mr Mulholland require leave to appeal?