John Mulholland v Australian Electoral Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

[2011] AATA 879 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2010/2416

Re

John Mulholland

APPLICANT

And

Australian Electoral Commission

RESPONDENT

And

Anthony Zegenhagen

JOINED PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal

Justice Downes, President
Deputy President J W Constance
Mr John Handley, Senior Member

Date 12 December 2011
Place Melbourne

Decision affirmed.

................[sgd].......................................................

Garry Downes, President

CATCHWORDS

ELECTIONS – political parties – Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) – registration – change to register – registered officer of Democratic Labor Party (DLP) – reconstitution of branches of DLP – federal conference requested by majority of state branches – properly constituted federal conference – valid appointment of registered officer – registration of officer by Australian Electoral Commission – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) s 134

REASONS FOR DECISION

Tribunal

Justice Downes, President
Deputy President J W Constance
Mr John Handley, Senior Member

Date 12 December 2011

SUMMARY

  1. On 20 July 1984, on the application of John Mulholland and others, the Democratic Labor Party (DLP) of Australia was registered with the Australian Electoral Commission as a political party.  At all times subsequently, until 8 January 2010, Mr Mulholland remained the registered officer of the DLP.

  2. The joined party, Anthony Zegenhagen, and three other members of the party made an application on 9 December 2009 to change the Register of Political Parties held by the Electoral Commission by substituting Mr Zegenhagen for Mr Mulholland as the registered officer.

  3. On 8 January 2010 a delegate of the Electoral Commission decided to change the Register by substituting the name of Mr Zegenhagen for that of Mr Mulholland as the registered officer of the DLP.  The delegate’s decision was affirmed by the Commission on 28 May 2010.  Mr Mulholland is seeking review of the Commission’s decision.

  4. For the reasons which follow we have decided that the decision under review is correct.  It will be affirmed.

    LEGISLATION

  5. Subsection 134(1) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) (the Act) provides in part:

    Where a political party is registered under this Part, an application may be made to the Electoral Commission, by:

    …

    (b)in the case of a political party other than a Parliamentary party – 3 members of the party;

    to change the Register by:

    …

    (g)substituting for the name of the registered officer entered in the Register the name of a person specified in the application.

  6. Subsection 134(3) of the Act provides:

    Upon receipt of an application under subsection (1) or (1A), the Electoral Commission shall deal with the application in accordance with this Part and determine whether the change requested in the application should be made.

    FACTS

    Constitution and rules of the DLP

  7. On the basis of the evidence of Mr Zegenhagen we are satisfied that the DLP is “an unincorporated association of volunteer members who share a common political purpose and a desire to work through the DLP to contribute to the democratic process in Australia and its constituent states.”[1] The party is governed by its Constitution and Rules.[2]

    [1] Affidavit of Anthony Zegenhagen…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read John Mulholland v Australian Electoral Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] AATA 879
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of John Mulholland v Australian Electoral Commission involved a dispute regarding the registration of a political party officer under the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth). The central issue was whether the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) correctly decided to change the registered officer of the Democratic Labor Party (DLP) from John Mulholland to Anthony Zegenhagen. The legal questions before the court were whether the Federal Conference of the DLP, which requested the change, was properly constituted and whether the appointment of Zegenhagen as the registered officer was valid.

The court examined the constitutional and procedural requirements for the DLP to convene a Federal Conference and make decisions regarding its registered officer. It was established that Clause 34 of the DLP Constitution mandated that the Federal Conference be convened either by the Federal Executive or by a majority of the state branches. The court considered evidence about the DLP's organisational structure and historical context, particularly its state prior to 2008. The evidence showed that prior to mid-1970s, the DLP had a significant presence in all states except Victoria, where the party continued to operate. The DLP was registered as a political party in 1984, with Mulholland serving as both Victorian and Federal secretary and registered officer.

The court concluded that the Federal Conference held on 28 November 2009 was properly constituted and that Zegenhagen was validly appointed as the registered officer of the DLP. The court found that the minutes of the meeting confirmed Zegenhagen's election as Federal secretary without any opposition. Additionally, the application made to the AEC on 3 December 2009 to change the registered officer was in accordance with the correct procedures. As a result, the court affirmed the AEC's decision to change the registered officer of the DLP from Mulholland to Zegenhagen.

The final orders of the court were that the decision of the Australian Electoral Commission made on 28 May 2010 would be affirmed, recognising Anthony Zegenhagen as the duly appointed registered officer of the Democratic Labor Party under the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Subsection 134(3) of the Act provides:Upon receipt of an application under subsection (1) or (1A), the Electoral Commission shall deal with the application in accordance with this Part and determine whether the change requested in the application should be made.FACTSConstitution and rules of the DLP On the basis of the evidence of Mr Zegenhagen we are satisfied that the DLP is “an unincorporated association of volunteer members who share a common political purpose and a desire to work through the DLP to contribute to the democratic process in Australia and its constituent states.”[1] The party is governed by its Constitution and Rules.[2][1] Affidavit of Anthony Zegenhagen 15 October 2011.[2] Section 37 Documents T3 and Exhibit ACZ-1 to the Affidavit of Mr Zegenhagen 15 October 2011. Clause 34 of the Constitution provides:Federal Conference: The supreme governing body of the Democratic Labor Party (DLP) of Australia shall be the Federal Conference, meeting at the earliest practicable opportunity in the period between each federal election or as otherwise required by the Federal Executive or requested by a majority of the State Branches. The Federal Executive may convene a Federal Conference by way of correspondence or by postal vote in the same manner applicable to a State Conference. Any questions resolved in this manner shall have the full effect of Federal Conference decisions. Clause 148 provides:Until the reconstitution of a Branch of the Democratic Labor Party (DLP) of Australia in a State other than Victoria, decisions of the State Conference and the State Executive of the Victorian Branch shall have respective standing as Federal Conference and Federal Executive decisions, to the extent of their relevance to the federal context. At any time, the effect of this rule shall apply, mutatis mutandis, to any single remaining State Branch.The state of the DLP prior to 2008 Prior to the mid-nineteen seventies the DLP was a party with up to five Senators in the Australian Parliament. In the mid-seventies the organisation of the party collapsed in all States except Victoria. The Victorian Branch continued to operate at both the State and Federal levels. The DLP was registered as a political party under the Act in 1984. At the time of the registration of the party, Mr Mulholland was the Victorian secretary and the Federal secretary of the party and on registration he became the registered officer.[3] [3] Statement of John Mulholland 30 September 2011. Mr Mulholland gave evidence that on 1 July 2007 a meeting of the Victorian State Conference was held.[4] Mr Mulholland claims that this meeting was also a meeting of the Federal Conference and that at the meeting he was elected as Victorian and Federal secretary of the DLP.[4] Statement of John Mulholland 30 September 2011. Mr Mulholland referred us to a document headed Resolutions of Victorian/Federal Conference of the DLP 2007.[5] This document is undated and unsigned and makes no reference to the election of Mr Mulholland to a position within the party. [5] Section 37 Documents T31.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The minutes record that Mr Zegenhagen was elected Federal secretary of the party unopposed. There was no motion moved in relation to Mr Zegenhagen’s position as registered officer of the party. On this basis we conclude that the Federal Conference accepted that Mr Zegenhagen continued in this role following his appointment at the meeting in Brisbane in November 2009.CONCLUSION We are satisfied that on 28 November 2009 a valid meeting of the Federal Conference of the Democratic Labor Party (DLP) of Australia appointed Mr Anthony Zegenhagen as the registered officer of the party for the purposes of the Act. We are satisfied also that on 3 December 2009 an application was properly made to the Commission to change the Register of Political Parties by substituting the name of Anthony Zegenhagen for that of John Mulholland as the registered officer of the party. It is to be noted that Mr Mulholland did not dispute that the application was made in accordance with correct procedures. For these reasons the decision of the Commission made on 28 May 2010 will be affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.