Mt Isa Mines Limited v CMA Assets Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mt Isa Mines Limited v CMA Assets Pty Ltd & Ors  [2016] QSC 260

PARTIES:

MOUNT ISA MINES LIMITED (ACN 009 661 447)

(plaintiff)

v
CMA ASSETS PTY LIMITED
(ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 112 821 735)

(first defendant)
LEE WHALE
(second defendant)
SHAUN WILLIAM McQUEEN
(third defendant)
IPA PERSONNEL PTY LTD (ACN 060 472 666)
(fourth defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 9066 of 2011

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

15 November 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

21 October 2016

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.  The first and second defendants’ application filed 9 September 2016 is dismissed.

2.  The third and fourth defendants’ application filed 9 September 2016 is dismissed.

3.  I will hear the parties as to any further orders and costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – STRIKING OUT – where claim and statement of claim filed and served by plaintiff on 25 September 2013 – where amended statement of claim was filed and served on 4 May 2016 – where the defendants allege that the amendments in the amended statement of claim add new causes of action to the claim – where the defendants allege that the new causes of action are required leave to be pleaded – whether the amendments add new causes of action – whether leave is necessary

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) r 171, r 376(4)

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175; [2009] HCA 27
Borsato v Campbell [2006] QSC 191, considered
Commonwealth of Australia v Cornwell (2007) 229 CLR 519; [2007] HCA 16, cited
Draney v Barry (2002) 1 Qd R 145, distinguished
Menegazzo v Price Waterhouse Coopers [2016] QSC 94, cited
Murdoch v Lake [2014] QCA 216, considered
Paul v Westpac Banking Corporation [2016] QCA 252, cited
Thomas v State of Queensland [2001] QCA 336, considered

COUNSEL:

TP Sullivan QC with S Armitage for the plaintiff
DA Savage QC with J Baartz for the first and second defendants

D Kelly QC with M Trim for the third and fourth defendants

SOLICITORS:

Carter Newell for the plaintiff

Moray & Agnew for the first and second defendants
Clyde & Co for the third and fourth defendants

  1. On 4 May 2016 Mt Isa Mines Limited (MIM) filed an Amended Statement of Claim (ASOC) without first seeking leave to do so. The four named defendants in the ASOC applied to have paragraphs 26 to 29 of the ASOC struck out pursuant to r171 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR) with no liberty to re‑plead.  Separate applications were filed by the first and second defendants and by the third and fourth defendants. 

  2. The basis of the applications is that paragraphs 26 to 29 of the ASOC add new causes of action out of time for which leave has not been granted pursuant to UCPR…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mt Isa Mines Limited v CMA Assets Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 260
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mt Isa Mines Limited v CMA Assets Pty Ltd, the Queensland Court of Appeal was called upon to decide whether the plaintiff's amended statement of claim introduced new causes of action that required leave under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR). The defendants argued that the amendments in the plaintiff's statement of claim introduced new causes of action, which required leave to be pleaded. The central issue before the court was whether the amendments introduced new causes of action that were not substantially the same as the original claims and, if so, whether leave should be granted for these new causes of action.

The court began its analysis by comparing the original statement of claim with the amended statement of claim to determine if the new causes of action arose from the same or substantially the same facts. The court found that any new causes of action that may have been introduced by the amendments did indeed arise from the same or substantially the same facts as the original claims. This finding aligned with the test established by Thomas JA in Draney v Barry and further interpreted by the Court of Appeal in Thomas v State of Queensland, which emphasised a broad comparison between the nature of the original claim and the amended claim.

Having determined that the new causes of action arose from the same or substantially the same facts, the court then turned to the question of whether it was appropriate to grant leave for the amendments. The court acknowledged its broad discretion in deciding whether an amendment is appropriate, taking into account principles of fairness and any prejudice to the defendants, as well as the overarching principles discussed in Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University. After considering these factors, the court found that the amendments were appropriate and dismissed the defendants' applications.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the defendants' applications to strike out the amendments to the plaintiff's statement of claim. The court determined that the new causes of action introduced by the amendments did not constitute new causes of action for the purposes of the UCPR and that leave was not necessary. The court further found that granting leave for the amendments was appropriate, considering the principles of fairness and the broad brush comparison of the claims. The court left the matter open for further orders and costs to be determined.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first and second defendants’ application filed 9 September 2016 is dismissed.

2. The third and fourth defendants’ application filed 9 September 2016 is dismissed.

3. I will hear the parties as to any further orders and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

I conclude therefore, that the amendments and new facts pleaded in paragraphs 26 to 29 of the ASOC do not constitute the addition of new causes of action.Rule 376(4)(b): The new cause of action arises out of the same facts or substantially the same facts If I am wrong in this conclusion I would otherwise find that any new causes of action arise out of the same facts or substantially the same facts as the causes of action pleaded in the original SOC. Thomas JA in Draney v Barry[58] held that a resolution of this issue may involve a consideration of whether the “necessary additional facts to support the new cause of action arise out of substantially the same story as that which would have to be told to support the original cause of action”. Thomas JA’s reference to the “story to be told” has been referred to as “a short-hand reference to the matters that the plaintiff has to prove”.[59] The Court of Appeal in Thomas v State of Queensland construed the test suggested by Thomas JA as encouraging “a fairly broad brush comparison between the nature of the original claim and that to which it is sought to be amended”.[60][58] (2002) 1 Qd R 145, at [57].[59] [2001] QCA 336 at [19].[60] [2001] QCA 336 at [19]. The most recent consideration by the Court of Appeal of rule 376(4) is the case of Paul v Westpac Banking Corporation.[61] Fraser JA (with whom Gotterson JA and Douglas J agreed) stated:“The question in each case is whether the facts out of which a new cause of action arises are substantially the same as facts relied upon in a cause of action for which relief has already been claimed in the proceeding. As has been mentioned in other cases, this may involve questions of degree and fine judgment, but the answer to that question should be informed by an appreciation that the policies underlying the applicable statute of limitation may be inappropriately undermined if the required analysis is conducted at too high a level of generality. If those underlying policies are not threatened by a proposed amendment, the test in UCPR r 376(4)(b) may be found to be satisfied even though the new claim involves some variation in the facts. This approach is consistent with the careful way in which the rule has generally been applied since it was enacted.” (citations omitted)[61] [2016] QCA 252. I have already carried out the comparison of the original SOC with the ASOC for the purposes of determining whether any new causes of action were added. Based upon that analysis and applying the broad brush comparison suggested in Thomas v State of Queensland, I am satisfied that if new causes of action had in fact been added, they arise out of the same or substantially the same facts.Rule 376(4)(a) – Does the Court consider it appropriate to grant leave? The Court has a broad discretion in determining whether an amendment is “appropriate”. The exercise of this discretion brings into account considerations of fairness and any prejudice caused to the defendants. The Court should also have regard to the principles discussed in Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University[62] and rule 5 of the UCPR. I have previously considered these principles in Monto Coal 2 Pty Ltd v Sanrus Pty Ltd.[63][62] (2009) 239 CLR 175.[63] [2014] QCA 267 at [73]-[74].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.