Moutray v The Union Pastoral Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND APPEALS LIST

S ECI 2020 02094

NIKITA MAREE MOUTRAY Plaintiff
v 
THE UNION PASTORAL CO PTY LTD AND OTHERS Defendants

---

JUDGE:

O’Meara J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

29 October 2021

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

9 November 2021

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Moutray v The Union Pastoral Co Pty Ltd

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2021] VSC 723

---

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW — Judicial review — Opinion of medical panel — Panel’s opinion that soft tissue injury resolved and no psychiatric injury — Any relevant distinction between ‘psychological’ and ‘psychiatric’ injury or condition — Consequential conclusions concerning ‘current work capacity’ – Sidiqi v Kotsios [2021] VSCA 187, Didani v Downes-Brydon [2021] VSCA 281 and Ayana v Qantas Airways Ltd [2021] VSC 500 considered – Whether panel gave adequate reasons for its decision — Application dismissed.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff AG Uren
LBR Allan
Stringer Clark
For the First Defendant R Kumar Thomson Geer Lawyers
For the Second to Sixth Defendants No appearance DLA Piper Australia

HIS HONOUR:

A        Introduction

  1. The plaintiff was born on 3 October 1995.  She completed year 12 and subsequently completed certificates II and III in agriculture and a certificate in artificial insemination.  She also holds front-end loader and tractor licences.  She has held several positions in farming, including as an artificial insemination technician.

  1. On 21 June 2016 the plaintiff was employed by the first defendant as a herd manager when she was kicked by a cow and suffered a crush injury of her left hand (the incident).  Pain and swelling ensued.  She applied ice and completed her shift.

  1. On the following day, the plaintiff attended hospital in Warrnambool.  Her hand was x-rayed.  At some point there was the suggestion of an occult scaphoid fracture.  The plaintiff’s injury was treated conservatively.

  1. The plaintiff claimed worker’s compensation.  Her claim was accepted.

  1. At several points in 2016 the plaintiff underwent radiological investigations, and in 2017 she underwent a bone scan and an MRI scan.  The suggestion that there was a fracture seems to have faded.

  1. At some point the plaintiff returned to some form of work with her employer.  Her employment was terminated in about mid-2017.  She has not worked since. 

  1. The plaintiff gave birth to a son in about 2018.  It seems that the birth was traumatic.

  1. In the period between the incident and late 2019, several medical practitioners expressed the opinion that the plaintiff was suffering from complex regional pain syndrome type 1.[1]  In that regard, in September 2019 the plaintiff’s general practitioner, Dr Carison, reported that the plaintiff would be unable to perform her pre-injury duties for the foreseeable future and was unable to be retrained as she struggled with ‘severe daily pain’ and the effects of ‘regular sedating analgesics’.  Dr Carison expressed the opinion that the prognosis in respect of the plaintiff’s condition was ‘very poor’.[2] 

    [1]See, for example, the reports of Dr Blombery…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moutray v The Union Pastoral Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] VSC 723
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Moutray v The Union Pastoral Co Pty Ltd, the dispute centred on the opinion of a medical panel that the plaintiff's soft tissue injury had resolved, and that he had no psychiatric injury. The plaintiff sought judicial review of the panel's decision, arguing that the panel had not adequately distinguished between psychological and psychiatric injury or conditions, and that this had led to incorrect conclusions about his current work capacity. The Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria was tasked with determining whether the panel had provided adequate reasons for its decision.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether there was a relevant distinction between psychological and psychiatric injury or conditions, and if so, whether the panel had adequately identified and explained this distinction in its reasons. The court also had to consider whether the panel's failure to distinguish between psychological and psychiatric conditions, if any, led to erroneous conclusions about the plaintiff's work capacity. The court examined previous cases, including Sidiqi v Kotsios, Didani v Downes-Brydon, and Ayana v Qantas Airways Ltd, for guidance on the proper approach to the panel's reasoning.

The court found that there was indeed a relevant distinction between psychological and psychiatric injury or conditions, but that the panel had not adequately explained this distinction in its reasons. However, the court held that the panel's failure to distinguish between the two conditions did not lead to erroneous conclusions about the plaintiff's work capacity. The court found that the panel had provided sufficient reasons for its decision and dismissed the plaintiff's application for judicial review.

The court did not make any further orders beyond dismissing the plaintiff's application for judicial review.