Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v CZAY

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v CZAY [2013] FCA 244

Citation: Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v CZAY [2013] FCA 244
Appeal from: CZAY v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship & Anor [2012] FMCA 50
Parties: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP v CZAY and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
File number: ACD 21 of 2012
Judge: NICHOLAS J
Date of judgment: 20 March 2013
Legislation: Convention relating to the Status of Refugees 1951
Cases cited:

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Khawar (2002) 210 CLR 1

Plaintiff M13/2011v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 277 ALR 667

Randhawa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1994) 52 FCR 437
S395/2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 216 CLR 473
SZATV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 233 CLR 18

Date of hearing: 3 August 2012
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 29
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr S B Lloyd SC with Ms A M Mitchelmore
Solicitor for the Appellants: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C Fairfield (Pro Bono)

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

ACD 21 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
Appellant

AND:

CZAY
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

NICHOLAS J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 MARCH 2013

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.Orders 2-4 made by the Federal Magistrate on 31 January 2012 be set aside.

3.In lieu thereof, the first respondent’s application to the Federal Magistrates Court (except insofar as it sought an extension of time) be dismissed.

4.The first respondent pay the appellant’s costs of the proceeding before the Federal Magistrate and of the appeal. 

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

ACD 21 of 2012

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
Appellant

AND:

CZAY
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

NICHOLAS J

DATE:

20 MARCH 2013

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an appeal by the appellant (the Minister) from the judgment of a Federal Magistrate (Neville FM) given on 31 January 2012 in favour of the first respondent (the respondent) in a proceeding for judicial review of a decision of the second respondent, the Refugee Review Tribunal (the Tribunal).  On 4 March 2010, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of a delegate of the appellant made on 20 May 2009 to refuse the respondent’s application for a protection (Class XA) visa.  The primary judge found that the Tribunal’s decision was affected by jurisdictional error.  His Honour…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v CZAY and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v CZAY involves an appeal against the decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which had overturned a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) to refuse the applicant a protection visa. The applicant, a citizen of India, argued that she would be persecuted by her estranged husband and his family if she were to return to India. The legal issues at the heart of this appeal concern whether the Federal Magistrate erred in finding that the RRT had made a jurisdictional error in its assessment of the applicant's safety if she were to relocate within India. The respondent, represented by the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, argued that the RRT had correctly found that the applicant could safely relocate within India and that the Federal Magistrate had erred in overturning that decision.

The Federal Court of Australia considered the arguments put forward by both parties, particularly focusing on whether the Federal Magistrate had engaged in merits review by becoming overly sympathetic to the applicant's situation and attributing jurisdictional error to the RRT. The Court found that the RRT had adequately considered the applicant's safety if she were to relocate within India and had correctly found that the harm feared by the applicant was from her estranged husband and his family, which could be avoided if she lived elsewhere in India. The Court also noted that the Federal Magistrate's reasons for decision included a recommendation that the applicant be granted a protection visa, which may have led to a situation where the Magistrate was too willing to attribute jurisdictional error to the RRT.

Ultimately, the Federal Court of Australia found that the Federal Magistrate had erred in overturning the RRT's decision and that the RRT's decision should be reinstated. The Court held that the RRT had not made a jurisdictional error in finding that the applicant could safely relocate within India and that the harm feared by the applicant could be avoided if she lived elsewhere. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the RRT's decision to refuse the applicant a protection visa was reinstated.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal said (at [112]-[118]):[112]The Tribunal has carefully considered the situation for the applicant in India both now and in the foreseeable future. The Tribunal finds that the applicant could safely live in India by relocating to another area within India for the reasons outlined below.[113]The Tribunal has considered the evidence of the applicant and the witness at hearing that it would not be safe for the applicant to live as a single woman in India; that it would be difficult for her to obtain employment away from her home town and because nursing is a highly competitive and scare [sic] job market; and because she has limited savings or financial resources. However the Tribunal gives significant weight to the applicant’s circumstances in India in the recent past during which she was able to secure consecutive periods of employment in three different hospitals, leaving each employer with excellent references, as well as to the fact that she has been employed in Australia. These factors indicate that applicant has not had difficulty in finding employment in different locations in India in the past. The Tribunal also gives significant weight to the fact that the applicant has lived away from her family home at the hospitals where she worked for a number of years before her marriage when she was a single woman, and also subsequent to her marriage in 2008.[114]The Tribunal finds that the applicant is 33 years old and is estranged from her husband. Given that the applicant is of a mature age and has in the past lived separately from her family, it would not be unreasonable for her to live away from her family home in the future. The Tribunal notes in relation to this point that if the applicant were to remain in Australia she would also be living away from her family, other than her sister who is temporarily resident in Australia at the time of this decision.[115]The Tribunal has noted country information in respect to the difficulties faced by single women in India, including the observation of the UK Home Office in July 2004 (set out above) that it is still difficult for woman [sic] to live on their own in India, and that the ability of women to access help and assistance is affected by factors including location, literacy level, and whether or not they have children. However the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant has the skills and experience to be able to be economically viable in another area of India such as Mumbai or Delhi or another large city of India, where attitudes are generally more liberal, and to relocate successfully.[116]The applicant holds a Diploma in General Nursing and Midwifery, and was a registered nurse with the Punjab Nurses Registration Council prior to leaving India. The applicant has worked in the past in India, including work as a Staff Nurse at Popli Hospital between October 2005 and April 2006; as an apprentice and then as a Staff Nurse at Cosmo Hospital between May 2006 and December 2006; and as a Staff Nurse in the Surgery Ward at Gian Sagar Medical College and Hospital between January 2007 and April 2008. Significantly, and according to her own evidence, the applicant also lived at, or attached to, the hospitals where she was employed throughout her years of employment. She continued to live at Gian Sagar Hospital after she married her husband in early 2008 and until her departure for Australia. The applicant has excellent employment references from the hospitals in which she worked in India. The applicant has been employed in an aged care nursing home in Australia, and has drawn a salary from that employment. The applicant is highly educated and language is no barrier to relocation. According to her evidence the applicant speaks English, Punjabi and Hindi.[117]The applicant does not have any children, and she has been working in Australia. Although she may not have significant financial resources, the Tribunal considers that the applicant will have saved some money while working in Australia, and has the qualifications and experience to enable her to readily find employment, and associated accommodation, as she has in the past as a nursing professional in India.[118]As the Tribunal has found that the harm feared by the applicant is from non-State actors, being her husband and his family, the Tribunal finds that such difficulties are confined to the area where she previously lived and she can avoid those difficulties by living elsewhere. On the information she has provided regarding her background and circumstances, the Tribunal is satisfied that relocation for the applicant is reasonable and that she can avoid the harm she fears by relocating within India. The Tribunal therefore finds that it would be reasonable for the applicant to relocate to a region in India away from her home town and village. Accordingly the Tribunal finds that the applicant would be able to safely relocate to one of these areas upon her return to India and that it would be reasonable for her to do so in the circumstances.THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATE’S DECISION

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondent’s counsel conceded that ground 2 must be upheld in that the Federal Magistrate had erred in finding that the Tribunal’s decision was vitiated by jurisdictional error based upon any alleged inconsistency or illogicality in its assessment of country information. The respondent’s counsel also conceded that ground 3 must be upheld because the Federal Magistrate had erred in finding that the Tribunal had committed a jurisdictional error in forming its view concerning the respondent’s financial circumstances. Each of these concessions was properly made. Accordingly, the only grounds of appeal that remain relevant are grounds 1 and 4. Both these grounds relate to what I have called Errors 1 and 2. CONSIDERATION Senior Counsel for the Minister argued forcefully, and in my view with some justification, that the Federal Magistrate engaged in merits review. It is apparent that the Federal Magistrate was convinced that the respondent should have been granted a protection visa. Indeed, his Honour’s reasons (at [3]) include a recommendation that the respondent be granted a protection visa. Senior Counsel for the Minister argued that it is remarkable to find in the reasons for decision of a judicial officer a recommendation of such a kind particularly in circumstances where the Federal Magistrate concerned had criticised the Tribunal for what he perceived to be a “singular and significant gap” in the Tribunal’s consideration of relevant factual matters. Whether it is remarkable or not is beside the point. What it does suggest is that the Federal Magistrate, who was obviously sympathetic to the respondent’s situation, became pre-occupied with the merits of her application for a protection visa. This appears to me to have led to a situation in which the Federal Magistrate was perhaps a little too willing to attribute jurisdictional error to the Tribunal: cf. Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259 at 271-272. It is clear that the Tribunal considered the possibility of persecution of the respondent by her estranged husband’s family occurring even if she was to relocate to other parts of India. It is also clear that the Tribunal was satisfied that the respondent would not be persecuted by her estranged husband’s family if she was to relocate. The Tribunal also found that the harm feared by the respondent was from her estranged husband and his family and that those difficulties could be avoided if she lived elsewhere in India. That is not a surprising conclusion. When the Tribunal raised with the respondent the possibility of relocating she did not refer to any threat posed by her estranged husband or his parents. In particular, when it was suggested to the respondent that she might return to the type of work she had previously performed when she lived and worked in hospitals, particularly in the larger Indian cities, the respondent claimed “that it is not safe for a woman to live alone in those places” (at [53]).