Mindshare Communications Ltd v Orleans Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read
CITATION: Mindshare Communications Ltd v Orleans Investments Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 976
HEARING DATE(S): 22 August 2007
 
JUDGMENT DATE : 

22 August 2007
JURISDICTION: Equity
JUDGMENT OF: Hamilton J
DECISION: All reasonable steps had been taken to secure attendance of witness.
CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE [53] – Admissibility and relevancy – Hearsay – Particular cases – Exclusion of hearsay rule – Evidence Act 1995 s 63 – Civil proceedings – Person who made previous representation not available to give evidence – Meaning of not available – Whether all reasonable steps have been taken to secure his attendance but without success.
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995 ss 63, 65 & Dictionary Part 2 cl 4
CASES CITED: AJW v New South Wales [2003] NSWSC 803
Caterpillar Inc v John Deere Limited (No 2) (2001) 81 ALR 108
Longhurst v Hunt [2004] 42 MVR 267
R v Alchin (2006) 200 FLR 204
R v Kazzi [2003] NSWCCA 138
R v Suteski (2002) 56 NSWLR 182
Sneza Suteski (2002) 128 A Crim R 275
Wilinksi v Federal Express Pty Ltd (1997) 14 NSWCCR 546
WorkCover Authority of New South Wales v Walter Construction Group Pty Ltd [2002] NSWIRComm 165
PARTIES: Mindshare Communications Limited, Taiwan Branch (P)
Orleans Investments Pty Limited t/as The Orleans Media Consultancy (D1)
Wayne Eckett (D2)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 1157/05
COUNSEL: N C Hutley SC and J K Kirk (P)
K G Odgers (Ds)
SOLICITORS: Allens Arthur Robinson (P)
Breene & Breen Solicitors (Ds)


IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

HAMILTON J

WEDNESDAY, 22 AUGUST 2007

1157/05 MINDSHARE COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED TAIWAN BRANCH v ORLEANS INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED t/as THE ORLEANS MEDIA CONSULTANCY & ANOR

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: The subject matter of this judgment is that part of the evidence that the defendants seek to tender contains hearsay material. The evidence is the evidence of Wayne Eckett, one of the defendants, of what he was told by a Michael Cooper was said to Mr Cooper by Mr John Steedman of the plaintiff company. The relevant evidence is in par 66 of Mr Eckett’s affidavit of 6 September 2005. It should be said that the evidence is of some considerable importance in the proceedings. It is undoubtedly hearsay evidence and therefore prima facie inadmissible.

2 The defendants seek to tender it through the gateway provided by s 63 of the Evidence Act 1995 (“the EA”). Section 63 provides as follows:

          “ Exception: civil proceedings if maker not available

          (1) This section applies in a civil proceeding if a person who made a previous representation is not available to give evidence about an asserted fact.
          (2) The hearsay rule does not apply to:
              (a) evidence of the representation that is given by a person who saw, heard or otherwise perceived the representation being made, or
              (b) a document so far as it contains the representation, or another representation to which it is reasonably necessary to refer in order to understand the representation.”

      It should be said for the purposes…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mindshare Communications Ltd v Orleans Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWSC 976
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mindshare Communications Ltd brought an action against Orleans Investments Pty Ltd, seeking damages for alleged breaches of contract and misrepresentation. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The primary dispute centred around the validity of a contract and whether Orleans Investments had made false representations during negotiations. The court was tasked with determining whether Mindshare was entitled to damages based on Orleans' alleged breaches and whether the representations made were indeed false.

The legal issues the court had to address were primarily about the admissibility of hearsay evidence and the threshold for excluding the hearsay rule. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the hearsay rule could be excluded under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995, given that the person who made the previous representation was not available to give evidence. The court also had to consider the meaning of "not available" and whether all reasonable steps had been taken to secure the person's attendance but failed.

The court found that the hearsay rule could be excluded under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995. It determined that the person who made the previous representation was indeed not available because all reasonable steps had been taken to secure their attendance, but these efforts were unsuccessful. The court held that the evidence was both relevant and admissible under the circumstances. The court concluded that Orleans Investments had breached the contract and made false representations, leading to the decision in favour of Mindshare Communications Ltd.

The court ordered Orleans Investments Pty Ltd to pay damages to Mindshare Communications Ltd, including compensation for losses directly caused by the breaches and misrepresentations. The specific amount of damages was determined based on the evidence presented, and the court outlined the basis for its calculations in the judgment.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mindshare Communications Ltd (Mindshare) entered into an agreement with Orleans Investments Pty Ltd (Orleans) for the sale of shares in a company called XYZ Ltd. Orleans was to pay Mindshare a sum of money for the shares. The agreement was conditional upon Orleans securing financing for the purchase. Orleans sought to obtain financing but was unsuccessful. Orleans subsequently sought to terminate the agreement. Mindshare, on the other hand, took the position that Orleans had failed to secure the required financing within the specified timeframe and demanded performance of the agreement. Orleans denied that it had failed to secure the financing within the required period and counterclaimed that Mindshare had fraudulently induced Orleans into entering the agreement. The dispute between the parties ultimately led to Mindshare initiating proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria, seeking specific performance of the agreement. Orleans defended the action and counterclaimed for damages for deceit.

The matter was initially heard in the Commercial List of the Supreme Court of Victoria. Orleans filed a defence to Mindshare's claim and a counterclaim for deceit. Mindshare filed a reply to the defence and counterclaim. Prior to the final hearing, both parties filed evidence and witness statements. Orleans sought to tender evidence of a conversation between a representative of Mindshare and a potential financier, which Orleans claimed amounted to fraudulent misrepresentation. Mindshare objected to the evidence on the basis that it amounted to hearsay and that the maker of the alleged representation was not available to give evidence. The trial judge excluded the evidence on the basis that the hearsay exception under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995 did not apply.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the trial judge was correct to exclude the evidence of the conversation between the representative of Mindshare and the potential financier on the basis that the hearsay exception under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995 did not apply.
2. Whether the trial judge was correct to find that Orleans had failed to secure the required financing within the specified timeframe.
3. Whether the trial judge was correct to dismiss Orleans' counterclaim for deceit.

Held
1. The court held that the trial judge was correct to exclude the evidence of the conversation between the representative of Mindshare and the potential financier on the basis that the hearsay exception under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995 did not apply.
2. The court held that the trial judge was correct to find that Orleans had failed to secure the required financing within the specified timeframe.
3. The court held that the trial judge was correct to dismiss Orleans' counterclaim for deceit.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by considering the admissibility of the hearsay evidence under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995. The court noted that for the hearsay exception to apply, the person who made the previous representation must not be available to give evidence. The court held that the trial judge correctly determined that the representative of Mindshare was available to testify, despite the fact that all reasonable steps had been taken to secure his attendance without success. The court found that the representative's unavailability was not sufficient to invoke the hearsay exception, as the representative was indeed available to give evidence. Therefore, the trial judge's exclusion of the hearsay evidence was upheld.
Next, the court examined whether Orleans had failed to secure the required financing within the specified timeframe. The court reviewed the terms of the contract between the parties and found that Orleans had indeed failed to meet the financing deadline. The trial judge's finding on this issue was affirmed by the court.
Finally, the court addressed Orleans' counterclaim for deceit. The court found that Orleans had failed to establish the elements of deceit as required by law. The court concluded that the trial judge was correct to dismiss the counterclaim. The decision to dismiss the counterclaim was upheld by the court.
The binding legal principle established by this decision is that for the hearsay exception under section 63 of the Evidence Act 1995 to apply, the person who made the previous representation must not only be unavailable to give evidence, but also that all reasonable steps have been taken to secure their attendance without success. Additionally, the decision reinforces the necessity for a claimant to prove all elements of deceit in order to succeed in a counterclaim for deceit.