R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 4) [2015] NSWSC 1306
Hearing dates:17 and 18 June 2015
Date of orders: 06 August 2015
Decision date: 08 September 2015
Jurisdiction:Common Law - Criminal
Before: Johnson J
Decision:

1. For the purpose of s.13 Evidence Act 1995, I am satisfied that C2 is competent to give sworn evidence at the trial of the Accused persons.
2. I overrule the objection under s.18 Evidence Act 1995 by C1 and C2 to giving evidence at the trial of the Accused persons (in particular, A2).
3. Given the conclusion reached concerning the s.18 objections, it is not strictly necessary to express a view concerning the Crown application under s.65 Evidence Act 1995 (although a brief view will be expressed on this issue).

Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW – pre-trial application – competence and compellability of witnesses (ss.13 and 18 Evidence Act 1995) – Accused persons charged with female genital mutilation offences against two girls (C1 and C2) – mother of C1 and C2 is an Accused person – whether C2 is competent to give evidence at trial – C2 able to understand the difference between truth and lie and engage with questions concerning facts – C2 competent to give sworn evidence at trial – whether C1 and/or C2 are compellable to give evidence at trial – likelihood of psychological harm and harm to relationship if C1 and/or C2 called to give evidence – factors relevant to balancing exercise under s.18(6) - nature and extent of harm does not outweigh the desirability of C1 and C2 giving evidence – application declined – operation of s.65 Evidence Act 1995 considered in obiter remarks
Legislation Cited: Crimes (Female Genital Mutilation) Amendment Act 1994
Crimes Act 1900
Crimes Amendment (Female Genital Mutilation) Act 2014
Criminal Procedure Act 1986
Evidence Act 1995
Surveillance Devices Act 2008
Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth)
Cases Cited: Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic) v Nicholls [2010] VSC 397; 204 A Crim R 306
Fletcher v R [2015] VSCA 146
LS v Director of Public Prosecutions (NSW) [2011] NSWSC 1016; 81 NSWLR 551
Mindshare Communications Limited v Orleans Investments Pty Limited [2007] NSWSC 976
MK v R [2014] NSWCCA 274
R v BO (No. 2) [2012] NSWDC 195; 15 DCLR (NSW) 317
R v RAG [2006] NSWCCA 343
RJ v R [2010] NSWCCA 263; 208 A Crim R 174
Sanderson v Rabuntja [2014] NTSC 13
Texts Cited: ---
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Regina (Crown)
A2 (Accused)
KM (Accused)
Shabbir Mohammedbhai Vaziri (Accused)
Representation:

Counsel:
Ms N Noman SC (Crown)
Mr RF Sutherland SC (Accused A2 and Vaziri)
Mr S Bouveng (Accused KM)
Mr PJ Gow (C1 and C2)

    Solicitors:
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown)
Armstrong Legal (Accused)
Crawford & Duncan Lawyers (C1 and C2)
File Number(s):2012/280081 (A2)2012/285455 (KM)2012/285639 (Vaziri)
Publication restriction:---

Judgment

  1. JOHNSON J: The Accused, A2, KM and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v A2; R v KM; R v Vaziri (No. 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 1306
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved three accused persons, A2, KM, and Vaziri, who were charged with offences related to female genital mutilation against two girls, C1 and C2. The mother of the girls, KM, was one of the accused. The court was required to determine whether C2 was competent to give evidence at the trial and whether C1 and C2 were compellable to testify. The competency of C2 was assessed based on her ability to understand the difference between truth and lie and engage with questions concerning the facts. The court concluded that C2 was competent to give sworn evidence at the trial. Regarding compellability, the court considered the potential psychological harm and harm to the relationship if C1 and C2 were called to give evidence. The court found that the nature and extent of the harm did not outweigh the desirability of C1 and C2 giving evidence. The application to prevent the compellability of C1 and C2 was therefore declined.

The court examined the relevant factors under section 18(6) of the Evidence Act 1995, which requires a balancing exercise between the desirability of the witness giving evidence and the potential harm to the witness. In this case, the court determined that the harm to C1 and C2, although significant, did not outweigh the desirability of their evidence being presented at the trial. The court further noted that the operation of section 65 of the Evidence Act 1995, which pertains to the protection of vulnerable witnesses, was considered in its decision-making process. Ultimately, the court declined the application to prevent the compellability of C1 and C2, allowing them to be called as witnesses at the trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves three accused persons charged with female genital mutilation offences against two girls, C1 and C2. The mother of the two girls is one of the accused persons. The court was required to determine the competence and compellability of C2 to give evidence at trial. The evidence presented indicated that C2 was able to understand the difference between truth and lie and engage with questions concerning the facts. Consequently, C2 was found competent to give sworn evidence at trial. The court also considered whether C1 and C2 were compellable to give evidence at trial, taking into account the likelihood of psychological harm and harm to their relationship if they were called to give evidence. The court concluded that the nature and extent of harm did not outweigh the desirability of C1 and C2 giving evidence.

This case involved a pre-trial application concerning the competence and compellability of witnesses under sections 13 and 18 of the Evidence Act 1995. The application was made in the context of criminal proceedings against the three accused persons. The case did not involve any prior decisions or other tribunals or courts. The key procedural step was the hearing of the pre-trial application regarding the witnesses' competence and compellability. The application was ultimately declined.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether C2 is competent to give evidence at trial under sections 13 and 18 of the Evidence Act 1995.
2. Whether C1 and/or C2 are compellable to give evidence at trial under sections 13 and 18 of the Evidence Act 1995.

Held
1. The court held that C2 is competent to give evidence at trial under sections 13 and 18 of the Evidence Act 1995.
2. The court held that C1 and C2 are compellable to give evidence at trial under sections 13 and 18 of the Evidence Act 1995.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of C2's competence to give evidence, considering her ability to understand the difference between truth and a lie and her capacity to engage with questions concerning the facts. The court found that C2 satisfied the criteria set out in section 13 of the Evidence Act 1995, as she demonstrated an understanding of the difference between truth and lie and could engage with questions about the facts of the case. Therefore, the court concluded that C2 was competent to give sworn evidence at the trial.

Turning to the issue of compellability, the court weighed the potential psychological harm and harm to the relationship if C1 and/or C2 were called to give evidence against the desirability of their testimony. The court considered the factors relevant to the balancing exercise under section 18(6) of the Evidence Act 1995. It noted that while there was a likelihood of psychological harm, the nature and extent of the harm did not outweigh the desirability of the children giving evidence. Consequently, the court held that C1 and C2 were compellable to give evidence at trial. The court declined the application, emphasising that the desirability of their evidence outweighed the potential harm to the children.

In its obiter remarks, the court also considered the operation of section 65 of the Evidence Act 1995, which provides for the protection of witnesses. While this section was not directly applicable in this case, the court acknowledged its role in safeguarding the welfare of child witnesses.