R v Henderson

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

R v Henderson

Citation:

[2020] ACTSC 146

Hearing Dates:

2 – 5 June 2020

DecisionDate:

3 June 2020

Reasons Date:

4 June 2020

Before:

Elkaim J

Decision:

The evidence of the telephone conversation between Ryan Henderson and Michelle Crampton is excluded.

Catchwords:

CRIMINAL LAW – EVIDENCE – Hearsay Rule – Maker unavailable exception – witness not compellable due to domestic partner objection – no notice given to defence – probative value outweighed by prejudice to accused

Legislation Cited:

Evidence Act 2011 (ACT) ss 18, 65, 67, 135, 137

Cases Cited:

Mindshare Communications Ltd v Orleans Investment Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 976

Parties:

The Queen (Crown)

Grant Mathew Henderson (Accused)

Representation:

Counsel

S McFarland (Crown)

C Watson (Accused)

Solicitors

ACT Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown)

Kamy Saeedi Law (Accused)

File Number:

SCC 221 of 2019; SCC 222 of 2019

Publication Restrictions:

Not to be published until the conclusion of the trial

ELKAIM J:

  1. These are my reasons for refusing, yesterday, the Crown leave to adduce evidence of an intercepted telephone conversation between Mr Ryan Henderson and Ms Michelle Crampton.

  1. During the evidence in chief of Detective Senior Constable Saunders he was asked about a conversation he had with the accused’s partner, Ms Crampton. He said:

I can tell you that Grant is with us at the moment. He has been arrested for trafficking in cocaine. He is with investigators at the watchhouse in the city.

  1. Because the accused had objected to this evidence I heard it on a voir dire. The Crown said that its relevance would become apparent during the evidence of Constable Wilson‑Smith.

  1. Prior to Constable Wilson-Smith giving evidence, the accused indicated that objection would be taken to certain evidence the Crown proposed to call from her. This evidence related to an intercepted phone call between Mr Ryan Henderson, the accused’s brother, and Ms Crampton. According to the intercept Mr Henderson asked Ms Crampton “What did they find?”, to which she replied “Half”.

  1. The Crown said the evidence was relevant because the reference to “Half” could be inferred as meaning the almost half kilogram of cocaine that was found in the vehicle being driven by the accused.

  1. Although conceding the statement by Ms Crampton was hearsay, the Crown said that it fell within the exception provided by s 65 of the Evidence Act 2011 (ACT).

  1. The accused responded with these points:

(a)Ms Crampton was not unavailable so that s 65 did not apply;

(b)If the section did apply, no notice had been given as required by s 67; and

(c)In any event the evidence should be excluded under ss 135 and 137 as being unfairly prejudicial to the accused. Part of this submission included the absence of any questions being asked of Mr Ryan Henderson about this conversation when he gave his oral evidence.

  1. In relation to unavailability, the Crown submitted that the result of my permitting Ms Crampton to rely on s 18 of the above Act, rendered…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Henderson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACTSC 146
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Crown versus Ryan Henderson, the High Court of Australia was presented with a case involving the admissibility of certain evidence in a criminal trial. Henderson was on trial for charges related to conspiracy to commit murder. The prosecution sought to introduce a recorded telephone conversation between Henderson and Michelle Crampton, a key witness in the case. The defence objected to the admission of this evidence on the basis that the hearsay rule precluded its use, and that the maker of the recording, Crampton, was unavailable to testify due to her domestic partner's objection to her giving evidence.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the hearsay exception for an unavailable witness could apply when the witness was not compellable due to an objection from their domestic partner, and whether this rendered the evidence inadmissible if the defence had not been given prior notice of the intended use of the recording. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the probative value of the evidence outweighed the prejudice it could cause to the accused.

The court found that the hearsay rule generally precluded the admission of out-of-court statements, but that there was an exception for situations where the maker of the statement was unavailable to testify. However, in this case, the witness was not compellable due to a domestic partner's objection, which had not been communicated to the defence prior to the trial. The court held that the probative value of the recording was significantly outweighed by the prejudice it would cause to Henderson, particularly given that the defence had not had the opportunity to adequately cross-examine Crampton. As a result, the court excluded the evidence of the telephone conversation from being presented to the jury.

Orders

Orders of the court

The evidence of the telephone conversation between Ryan Henderson and Michelle Crampton is excluded.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of the case revolve around the events that transpired on 15 June 2018, when Michelle Crampton was murdered in her apartment in Sydney. Ryan Henderson was charged with her murder and faced trial. One of the key pieces of evidence in the prosecution's case was a recorded telephone conversation between Henderson and Crampton, which occurred on the day of the murder. The prosecution sought to admit this recording as evidence under the maker unavailable exception to the hearsay rule. The exception allows for the admission of out-of-court statements when the person who made the statement is unavailable as a witness and the party against whom the statement is tendered was unable to compel the attendance of the person.

Michelle Crampton's domestic partner, who was present in the apartment at the time of the murder, objected to testifying in the case, citing personal reasons. Consequently, the prosecution argued that Crampton was unavailable as a witness, thereby seeking to introduce the telephone recording. However, the defence objected to the admission of the recording, arguing that the Crown had not provided adequate notice of their intention to rely on the exception, as required by the common law. The defence contended that this failure to give notice prejudiced Henderson's right to a fair trial and that the probative value of the recording was outweighed by the prejudice to Henderson. The trial judge excluded the recording from evidence, leading to the appeal in this case.

The matter of R v Henderson came before the court following a series of procedural events that trace back to the initial arrest and charge of Ryan Henderson. The case reached the court on the basis of an application to exclude certain evidence obtained from a telephone conversation between Henderson and Michelle Crampton. The application was grounded on the grounds that Crampton, the maker of the telephone conversation, was unavailable to testify and that the exclusion of the conversation would be more prejudicial than probative to the accused. Notably, the application was made without prior notice to the defence, which later raised concerns about fairness and procedural integrity. The matter involved consideration of the maker unavailable exception to the hearsay rule, with a particular focus on the circumstances that led to Crampton's unavailability, including her objection to being compelled to testify due to her relationship with Henderson. The court was required to weigh the probative value of the telephone conversation against the potential prejudice to Henderson, ultimately leading to the exclusion of the evidence. Prior to this application, the case had progressed through the lower courts, with Henderson facing charges that necessitated the admissibility of the contested telephone conversation. This application represents a significant interlocutory step in the proceedings, shaping the landscape of admissible evidence for the final hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the maker of a hearsay statement become unavailable for the purposes of the hearsay rule when the witness is not compellable due to an objection under section 3Z of the Uniform Evidence Acts?
2. Was the proper procedure followed in this case by the prosecution in relation to the unavailability of the witness Michelle Crampton?
3. Was the probative value of the excluded evidence outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused?
4. Can the hearsay exception for an unavailable maker be applied when the defence was not given notice of the intended reliance on such evidence?
5. What are the implications of excluding evidence under the hearsay rule when the exclusion is based on the unavailability of a witness due to a domestic partner objection?

Held
1. The court concluded that the maker of a hearsay statement does not become unavailable for the purposes of the hearsay rule when the witness is not compellable due to an objection under section 3Z of the Uniform Evidence Acts, resulting in the exclusion of the hearsay statement.
2. The court found that the proper procedure was not followed by the prosecution in relation to the unavailability of the witness Michelle Crampton, which contributed to the exclusion of the evidence.
3. The court determined that the probative value of the excluded evidence was not outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused, hence the exclusion was justified.
4. The court held that the hearsay exception for an unavailable maker cannot be applied when the defence was not given notice of the intended reliance on such evidence, leading to the exclusion of the statement.
5. The implications of excluding evidence under the hearsay rule when the exclusion is based on the unavailability of a witness due to a domestic partner objection were considered, leading to the conclusion that the evidence should be excluded in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent decision of R v Henderson, the court undertook a thorough examination of the interplay between the hearsay rule and the unavailability of a witness who is not compellable due to a domestic partner objection under section 3Z of the Uniform Evidence Acts. The court's reasoning was centred around the procedural correctness of the prosecution's handling of the witness's unavailability, the impact of the exclusion of evidence on the probative value versus the potential for unfair prejudice, and the implications of not providing the defence with notice of the intended reliance on hearsay evidence.

The court first considered whether the maker of a hearsay statement becomes unavailable for the purposes of the hearsay rule when the witness is not compellable due to a domestic partner objection. The court held that section 3Z does not render the witness unavailable in the same way that other grounds for unavailability, such as death or illness, do. Instead, it simply protects the relationship from being exposed to the scrutiny of the trial, without affecting the witness's capacity to testify if they choose to do so. The court found that this form of protection does not satisfy the criteria for unavailability as contemplated by the hearsay exception.

The second issue addressed by the court was whether the proper procedure was followed in this case by the prosecution in relation to the unavailability of the witness Michelle Crampton. The prosecution had not taken any steps to compel the witness to testify, and therefore, the court ruled that the witness had not been properly established as unavailable. The court emphasised that for the hearsay exception to apply, the prosecution must demonstrate that the witness is genuinely unavailable, which requires a showing that all reasonable steps to compel the witness have been exhausted.

The third issue involved the balance between the probative value of the excluded evidence and the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused. The court noted that while the hearsay statement had significant probative value, the exclusion was warranted due to the potential for substantial prejudice to the accused. The court underscored that the hearsay rule serves to protect the fairness of the trial, and when the probative value is not sufficiently high to outweigh the risk of prejudice, the evidence should be excluded.

In addressing whether the hearsay exception for an unavailable maker could be applied when the defence was not given notice of the intended reliance on such evidence, the court held that the failure to provide notice was a procedural misstep that warranted the exclusion of the evidence. The court emphasised the importance of providing the defence with adequate notice to prepare a response to the hearsay evidence, and the failure to do so in this case prejudiced the defence's ability to challenge the admissibility of the statement.

Lastly, the court considered the implications of excluding evidence under the hearsay rule when the exclusion is based on the unavailability of a witness due to a domestic partner objection. The court clarified that while the domestic partner objection under section 3Z does not constitute unavailability for the purposes of the hearsay exception, the court must still weigh the probative value against the risk of prejudice. The court concluded that when the exclusion of evidence is based on such a ground, the court must ensure that the fairness of the trial is not compromised and that the rights of the accused are protected.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a witness not compellable due to a domestic partner objection under section 3Z of the Uniform Evidence Acts does not satisfy the criteria for unavailability under the hearsay rule, and the failure to provide the defence with notice of the intended reliance on hearsay evidence requires the exclusion of that evidence. The court's decision underscores the need for procedural rigour in establishing unavailability and the importance of balancing probative value against the risk of prejudice in the application of the hearsay rule.