Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 460

Citation: Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 460
Appeal from: BP Australia Pty Ltd v Ian David Menzies & Anor [2010] FMCA 375
Parties: IAN DAVID MENZIES and COLLEEN ANNE MENZIES v PACCAR FINANCIAL PTY  LTD (ACN 005 592 049)
File number: VID 495 of 2010
Judge: BROMBERG J
Date of judgment: 10 May 2011
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY – s 49 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) – whether primary judge’s discretion miscarried in granting an application for substitution of a creditor to a creditor’s petition – principles relevant to the exercise of the discretion discussed – standard of satisfaction required where the debt relied upon by the applicant for substitution is disputed – genuine or arguable dispute sufficient – primary judge’s discretion miscarried by determining the merits of and resolving dispute – appeal allowed.
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 49, 52(1), 52(4)
Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 459H, 465B
Fair Trading Act 1982 (NSW) s 42
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24(1)(d),
s 25(1A)(a)
Trade Practices Act 1975 (Cth) s 52
Cases cited:

Adamopoulous v Olympic Airways (1990) 95 ALR 525 Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd v Prestia [2001] FCA 792
Ahern v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (Qld) (1987) 76 ALR 137
BP Australia Pty Ltd v Ian David Menzies & Anor [2010] FMCA 375
Chadwick Industries (South Coast) Pty Ltd v Condensing Vaporisers Pty Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 37
Dean v QUF Industries Ltd (1981) 51 FLR 317

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Clyne (1984) 4 FCR 156

Eyota Pty Ltd v Hanave Pty Ltd (1994) 12 ACSR 785
Farrington v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2002] 50 ATR 429
Gajic & Anor v Poyser [2007] VSCA 175
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499
Jarpab v Winter (1994) 14 ACSR 255
Johnstone v Guss [1998] FCA 1658
Mibor Investments Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1993) 11 ACSR 362
ReCalsil Ltd (1982) 6 ACLR 515
Re Juanita Lee Faint Ex Parte: the Shell Company of Australia Ltd, Westpac Banking Corporation and Australian Guarantee Corporation Limited [1994]  FCA 1363
Rhagodia Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd (2008) 67 ACSR 367
Roadships Logistics Ltd v Tree (2007) 64 ACSR 671
South-East Water Ltd v Kitoria Pty Ltd (1996) 21 ACSR 465
TR Administration Pty Ltd v Frank Marchetti & Sons Pty Ltd (2008) 66 ACSR 67

Date of hearing: 10 December 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr M McInnis
Solicitor for the Appellants: Hall Partners
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr P Fary
Solicitor for the Respondent: Hopkins Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 495 of 2010

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

IAN DAVID MENZIES
First Appellant

COLLEEN ANNE MENZIES
Second Appellant

AND:

PACCAR FINANCIAL PTY  LTD (ACN 005 592…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 460
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the Menzies and Paccar Financial regarding the validity of a guarantee and associated loan agreements. The Menzies, who operated a trucking business through Menzies Haulage Pty Ltd, had executed a guarantee in May 2006 to secure loans for two long haul trucks and trailers. Paccar alleges that the Menzies guaranteed Menzies Haulage's liability to Paccar for these loans. In 2009, BP obtained a judgment against the Menzies, and subsequently, Paccar applied to be substituted as the petitioning creditor in bankruptcy proceedings initiated by BP. The Menzies challenged Paccar's application, raising several defences including that the contracts and guarantee were not executed and were therefore void. The Menzies also claimed that Paccar breached variations in the loan agreements and engaged in misleading conduct. The case proceeded to the Federal Magistrates Court, where the primary judge granted Paccar's application for substitution.

The legal issues before the court included whether the primary judge's discretion in granting Paccar's application for substitution was properly exercised and what standard of satisfaction was required to determine the validity of the disputed debt. Specifically, the court needed to ascertain whether the primary judge erred in deciding the merits of the dispute between Paccar and the Menzies and in substituting Paccar as the petitioning creditor. The Menzies argued that the primary judge's discretion miscarried by resolving the merits of the dispute rather than merely determining if there was a genuine or arguable dispute.

The court found that the primary judge's discretion miscarried because the judge determined the merits of the dispute instead of focusing on whether there was a genuine or arguable dispute. The court held that the primary judge should not have resolved the dispute but should have focused on whether the Menzies' defences were sufficient to constitute a genuine or arguable dispute. As the Menzies had raised credible defences, the court concluded that the primary judge's decision should be set aside. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the orders substituting Paccar as the petitioning creditor, sequestrating the Menzies' estates, and ordering them to pay Paccar's costs were set aside. The creditor's petition was remitted to the Federal Magistrates Court, and Paccar was ordered to pay the Menzies' costs for the application for substitution, the hearing of the creditor's petition, and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made by the Federal Magistrate on 11 June 2010:

(a) substituting the respondent as the petitioning creditor;

(b) sequestrating the estates of the appellants; and

(c) ordering the appellants to pay the respondent’s costs

be set aside.

3. The creditor’s petition be remitted to the Federal Magistrates Court.

4. The appellants’ costs of and incidental to the respondent’s application for substitution and the hearing of the creditor’s petition in the Federal Magistrates Court, together with the costs of this appeal, be paid by the respondent.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that the judgment of the Federal Magistrate is affected by discretionary error and as a consequence the appeal should be allowed. BACKGROUND Mr and Mrs Menzies were involved in a trucking business. The business was conducted through their company, Menzies Haulage Pty Ltd (“Menzies Haulage”). In May 2006, Paccar financed the purchase by Menzies Haulage of two long haul trucks and trailers (“the trucks and trailers”). Paccar alleges that the Menzies guaranteed the liability of Menzies Haulage to Paccar in respect of those loans (“the Guarantee”). In March 2009, BP Australia Pty Ltd (“BP”) obtained a judgment from the Magistrates Court of Victoria against the Menzies in the sum of $32,125.45. In late May 2009, Paccar commenced Supreme Court proceedings in the Victorian Supreme Court against Mr and Mrs Menzies (“the Victorian Supreme Court proceeding”). That proceeding was based on the Guarantee said to have been executed by the Menzies in May 2006 in New South Wales. On 13 August 2009, BP served a bankruptcy notice on the Menzies. On 18 September 2009, BP presented a creditor’s petition against the Menzies and commenced the Federal Magistrates Court proceedings the subject of this appeal, on the basis that the Menzies had committed an act of bankruptcy on 4 September 2009. In October 2009, BP and the Menzies settled their differences on the basis that BP’s creditor’s petition would be dismissed. On 19 November 2009, Paccar applied, pursuant to s 49 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Bankruptcy Act”), to be substituted as the petitioning creditor (“the application for substitution”). On 11 December 2009 the Victorian Supreme Court proceeding was transferred to the New South Wales Supreme Court (“the first New South Wales proceeding”). On 18 December 2009 the Menzies commenced proceedings in the New South Wales Supreme Court against Paccar (“the second New South Wales proceeding”). In the first New South Wales proceeding, Paccar claims that Menzies Haulage made with Paccar four Deed of Loan and Charge Agreements (“the Contracts”). Paccar claims that Menzies Haulage failed to meet its payment obligations under the Contracts and was in default. Paccar alleges that it terminated the Contracts, sought repossession of the trucks and trailers for which it had loaned monies and a termination amount of $375,098. By reason of the alleged Guarantee provided by the Menzies, Paccar sought the payment of the termination amount from the Menzies and claimed $390,455 from the Menzies (being the termination amount plus costs and legal costs). By their Defence to the first New South Wales proceedings and by the second New South Wales proceedings in which the Menzies were plaintiffs, the Menzies deny their indebtedness to Paccar and claim damages and other relief. This is put on a number of grounds which I summarise as follows:(i)the Contracts and Guarantee were never executed by Menzies Haulage or the Menzies and were of no legal consequence or effect (“the non est factum defence”);(ii)that any loan agreements made between Paccar and Menzies Haulage were the subject of variations by two agreements made in August 2008 (“the Variation Agreements”). Those variations were to the effect that Paccar agreed to receive certain payments from Menzies Haulage and agreed that if Menzies Haulage made further payments as agreed, Paccar would not seek to repossess the trucks and trailers and would not seek to make a claim as against the Menzies under the Guarantee or the Contracts. The Menzies claim that the Variation Agreements were breached by Paccar including because: Paccar sought to repossess the trucks and trailers; Paccar petitioned for and wound up Menzies Haulage; and, Paccar reported the Menzies as credit defaulters with the effect of limiting their capacity to refinance and pay out any monies owed to Paccar;(iii)the Menzies also claim that representations and warranties were made by Paccar in May 2006 to the effect that if Menzies Haulage entered into loan agreements, Paccar would provide Menzies Haulage with flexible repayment terms in order to accommodate any material change in circumstances. The Menzies claim that the representations made were misleading and deceptive conduct within the meaning of s 52 of the Trade Practices Act 1975 (Cth) (“the Trade Practices Act”) and s 42 of the Fair Trading Act 1982 (NSW). They claim that despite the representations made, Paccar refused to extend to Menzies Haulage flexible payment terms in circumstances where material change had occurred; and (iv)the Menzies also claim that the Guarantee was an unjust contract within the meaning of the Contracts Review Act 1980 (NSW) and seek that the Guarantee be set aside or alternatively be varied.PROCEEDINGS IN THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.