Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1161

Citation: Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1161
Parties:

IAN DAVID MENZIES and COLLEEN ANNE MENZIES v PACCAR FINANCIAL PTY LTD (ACN 005 592 049)

IAN DAVID MENZIES and COLLEEN ANNE MENZIES v PACCAR FINANCIAL PTY LTD (ACN 005 592 049) & ORS

File numbers: VID 495 of 2010
VID 660 of 2010
Judge: TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 21 October 2011
Catchwords: COSTS – indemnity costs orders sought – arising out of bankruptcy proceedings – stay of sequestration order – appeal from sequestration order allowed – contempt charges – motions for removal of trustees - brought for ulterior purpose
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 54, 179
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 24, 37M, 37N, 43
Federal Court Rules 2010 (repealed) O 62 r 9, Div 1, pt 52
Revised Professional Practice and Conduct Rules 1995 (NSW) R 23A, pts 22, 23, 35, 36, 37
Cases cited: Advan Investments Pty Ltd v Dean Gleeson Motor Sales Pty Ltd [2003] VSC 201 cited, applied
Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225 cited
Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Incorporated (1991) 33 FCR 397 cited
De Sousa v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1993) 41 FCR 544 cited
Doolan v Dare [2004] FCA 682 compared
Dowling v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCAFC 28 cited
Fountain Selected Meats (Sales) Pty Ltd v International Produce Merchants Pty Ltd (1988) 81 ALR 397 considered, compared
J-Corp Pty Ltd v The Australian Builders Labourers Federation Union of Workers (No 2) (1993) 46 IR 301 cited
Lemoto v Able Technical Pty Ltd (2005) 63 NSWLR 300 cited, applied
Levick v Commissioner of Taxation (2003) 102 FCR 155 cited, applied
Menzies v Paccar Financial Ltd [2010] FCA 748 considered
Menzies v Paccar Financial Ltd [2010] FCA 931 considered
Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 460 referred to
Re Alafaci; Registrar in Bankruptcy v Hardwick (1976) 9 ALR 262 cited
Ridehalgh v Horsefield [1994] Ch 205
Ruddock v Vadarlis (No 2) (2001) 115 FCR 229
Date of hearing: 15-16 November 2010
Date of last submissions: 19 November 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 135
Counsel for the First and Second Appellants: The Appellants appeared in person
Counsel for the First Respondent: T Davies
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Hopkins Lawyers
Counsel for the Second and Third Respondents: S Maiden
Solicitor for the Second and Third Respondents: Charles Fice Lawyers
Counsel for T Hall G Craddock SC
Solicitor for T Hall HWL Ebsworth


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 495 of 2010

BETWEEN:

IAN DAVID MENZIES
First Appellant

COLLEEN ANNE MENZIES
Second Appellant

AND:

PACCAR FINANCIAL PTY LTD (ACN 005 592 049)
Respondent

JUDGE:

TRACEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 OCTOBER 2011

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appellants pay the costs of Paul Andrew…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd involved a dispute arising from bankruptcy proceedings. The Menzies were declared bankrupts by the Federal Magistrates Court, but an appeal against this decision was later allowed by Bromberg J. Various motions related to the bankruptcy were subsequently filed, including motions by the Menzies seeking contempt charges against the trustees and orders for the removal of the trustees. The trustees, in turn, filed motions seeking clarification of the effect of certain orders made by Ryan J. The court was required to determine the costs associated with these motions.

The legal issues centred on whether indemnity costs should be awarded in the circumstances of the case. The principles for such an award were established in Fountain Selected Meats, where it was held that indemnity costs may be awarded if an action was commenced or continued despite a lack of reasonable prospects of success. The court needed to determine if the Menzies' motions were brought for an ulterior purpose or with wilful disregard of known facts or law.

Sundberg J found that the Menzies' motions were indeed brought for an ulterior purpose. The court determined that the Menzies had no reasonable prospects of success in their motions and that they were aware of this at the time of filing. Consequently, the Menzies were ordered to pay the costs of the trustees on an indemnity basis for certain motions. Additionally, the Menzies were required to indemnify Trevor Hall against these costs. The motions by the trustees seeking clarification were dismissed, and the other motions brought by the Menzies and the trustees were refused.

The final orders included that the Menzies pay the costs of the trustees for specific motions, that certain motions by the trustees and the Menzies be dismissed or refused, and that no order be made regarding the costs incurred in the applications for the payment of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appellants pay the costs of Paul Andrew Burness and Morgan Gerard James Lane of and incidental to the appellants’ motions, numbered 4 to 7 inclusive, notice of which was given on 13 July 2010.

2. The appellants pay Paul Andrew Burness’ and Morgan Gerard James Lane’s costs of and incidental to the appellants’ motions, numbered 2 and 3, notice of which was given on 13 July 2010 on an indemnity basis.

3. There be no order for costs of and incidental to Paul Andrew Burness’ and Morgan Gerard James Lane’s motion, notice of which was given on 8 July 2010.

4. Mr Trevor Hall indemnify the appellants against the costs order made in paragraph 2 above.

5. The respondent’s motions, notice of which was given on 9 August 2010, otherwise be refused.

6. Paul Andrew Burness’ and Morgan Gerard James Lane’s motions, notice of which was given on 9 August 2010, otherwise be refused.

7. No order be made in relation to the costs incurred by the parties in relation to the present applications for the payment of costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

1. The appellants pay the second and third respondents’ costs of the application.

2. The first respondent’s motions, notice of which was given on 8 September 2010, each be dismissed.

3. The second and third respondents’ motions, notice of which was given on 18 August 2010, each be refused.

4. The first respondent’s motions, notice of which was given on 4 October 2010, each be refused.

5. No order be made in relation to the costs incurred by the parties in relation to the present applications for the payment of costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

The evidence relied on by the Respondents in support of each of their motions is substantially the same. It will, therefore, be convenient to deal with the general costs issues and the particular issues raised by each of the motions together.THE BACKGROUND FACTS The events which bear on the costs issues which I am required to determine commenced on 4 September 2009 when Mr and Mrs Menzies committed acts of bankruptcy. A creditor’s petition was filed by BP Australia Pty Ltd on 18 September 2009. On 19 November 2009 Paccar filed an application seeking to be substituted as the petitioning creditor. Paccar also sought sequestration orders against Mr and Mrs Menzies. On 19 and 20 May 2010 a Federal Magistrate heard Paccar’s applications. Mr and Mrs Menzies resisted these applications. In doing so they gave evidence relating to their assets and liabilities. On 11 June 2010 the Federal Magistrate made sequestration orders against the estates of Mr and Mrs Menzies. She noted that the relevant date of the acts of bankruptcy was 4 September 2009. On 24 June 2010 Mr and Mrs Menzies filed a notice of appeal against the Federal Magistrate’s decision. This appeal became proceeding VID 495 of 2010. The appeal was ultimately allowed by Bromberg J: see Menzies v Paccar Financial Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 460. As already noted an application was made by Mr and Mrs Menzies for a stay of operation of the sequestration order pending the hearing and determination of the appeal. Ryan J dealt with that application on 1 July 2010. On 2 July 2010 the solicitors for the trustees wrote to Mr Hall a letter which was to commence an acrimonious exchange of correspondence. The letter asserted that:“The condition of the stay [made by Ryan J] has not been satisfied because statements of affairs have not been lodged. The condition can never be satisfied because statements of affairs cannot now be lodged within 14 days of notification of the bankruptcy, as mandated by section 54 [of the Bankruptcy Act] and accordingly there can never be statements lodged in conformity with section 54.” The letter accused Mr Hall of failing to inform Ryan J that Mr and Mrs Menzies had already “committed a strict liability offence by contravening section 54” and suggested that Ryan J would not have granted the stay had he been so informed. The letter continued:“As there is no stay (and can never be a stay under present orders) and as statements of affairs have not been furnished, the trustees have no option but to continue to carry out their statutory duties, including to ascertain the assets and liabilities of the bankrupts (section 19(1)) and to forthwith take possession of all the property of the bankrupts capable of manual delivery (section 129(1))”. The solicitors sought confirmation that, by the close of business on 2 July 2010, the bankrupts would give the trustees free access to their farm and books and would “permit them to seize and remove property of the bankrupts that is stored on the farm.” The letter was sent by facsimile transmission at 12:03 pm.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The principles which are to be applied when the Court is asked to award costs on an indemnity basis were expounded by Woodward J in Fountain Selected Meats at 400-1. His Honour there said:“As I said in Australian Transport Insurance Pty Ltd v Graeme Phillips Road Transport Insurance Pty Ltd (1986) 71 ALR 287 at 288, concerning this court's discretion in the award of costs:‘That discretion is ‘absolute and unfettered’, but must be exercised judicially (Trade Practices Commission v Nicholas Enterprises (1979) 28 ALR 201 at 207). Courts in both the United Kingdom and Australia have long accepted that solicitor and client costs can properly be awarded in appropriate cases where ‘there is some special or unusual feature in the case to justify the court exercising its discretion in that way’ (Preston v Preston [1982] 1 All ER 41 at 58). It is sometimes said that such costs can be awarded where charges of fraud have been made and not sustained; but in all the cases I have considered, there has been some further factor which has influenced the exercise of the court's discretion - for example, the allegations of fraud have been made knowing them to be false, or they have been irrelevant to the issues between the parties: see Andrews v Bames (1888) 39 Ch D 133; Forester v Read (1870) 6 LR Ch App 40; Christie v Christie (1873) 8 LR Ch App 499; Degmam Pty Ltd (In liq) v Wright (No 2) [1983] 2 NSWLR 354.’ ‘Another case cited in argument was Australian Guarantee Corp Ltd v De Jager [1984] VR 483 where (at 502) Tadgell J allowed solicitor and client costs because he found the pursuit of the action to have been ‘a high-handed presumption’.’No doubt the expression ‘high-handed presumption’ was appropriate in the case Tadgell J had to decide, and he needed to go no further; but in order to establish a convenient principle in such cases it is necessary to be a little more prosaic. I believe that it is appropriate to consider awarding ‘solicitor and client’ or ‘indemnity’ costs, whenever it appears that an action has been commenced or continued in circumstances where the applicant, properly advised, should have known that he had no chance of success. In such cases the action must be presumed to have been commenced or continued for some ulterior motive, or because of some wilful disregard of the known facts or the clearly established law. Such cases are, fortunately, rare. But when they occur, the court will need to consider how it should exercise its unfettered discretion.See also Colgate-Palmolive Company v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225 at 230-4 (per Sheppard J); J-Corp Pty Ltd v The Australian Builders Labourers Federation Union of Workers (No 2) (1993) 46 IR 301 at 303 (per French J); Dowling v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCAFC 28 at [42]-[45] (per Graham J), [139]‑[140] (per Logan and Flick JJ).COSTS IN VID 495 OF 2010 - CONSIDERATION Three separate, but related, groups of motions were before Sundberg J. They were Mr and Mrs Menzies’ motions seeking orders that the trustees be punished for contempt and that they be removed and replaced. The third was the trustees’ motion which sought orders to clarify the effect of Ryan J’s orders. Distinct costs issues arise in respect of each of these motions. I will, therefore, deal with them separately.