Medical Board of Australia v RTF

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Medical Board of Australia v RTF [2018] QCAT 323

PARTIES:

MEDICAL BOARD OF AUSTRALIA
(applicant)

v

DR RTF

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR240-16

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

3 October 2018

HEARING DATE:

13 March 2018, 18 September 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judge Sheridan, Deputy President

Assisted by:
Dr J Black
Dr H Moudgil
Mr M Halliday

ORDERS:

1.  Pursuant to s 196(1)(b)(iii) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the respondent has behaved in a way that constitutes professional misconduct.

2. Pursuant to s 196(2)(a) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the respondent is reprimanded.

3. Pursuant to s 196(2)(b) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the following conditions be imposed:

(a)   The practitioner must be mentored by another registered health practitioner in relation to maintaining professional boundaries and identifying conflicts for a minimum period of 12 months.

(b)   The mentoring must comprise a minimum of 12 sessions with each session being of one hour duration occurring over a 12 month period.

(c)   Within 21 days of the notice of the imposition of these conditions, the practitioner must, on the approved form, nominate a person(s) to be approved by the Board to act as mentor.  The practitioner must ensure that the nomination is accompanied by acknowledgment, on the approved form, from the nominated person.

(d)   Within 21 days of the notice of imposition of these conditions, the practitioner must provide to AHPRA, on the approved form, acknowledgment that AHPRA may seek reports from the approved mentor on any or all of the following occasions:

(i)     every three months;

(ii)   at the conclusion of the mentoring relationship in order to confirm the outcomes of the mentoring;

(iii)     whenever the mentor has a concern or becomes aware of a concern regarding the practitioner’s conduct or professional performance; and

(iv)   when otherwise requested by AHPRA or the Board.

(e)   Within 28 days of receipt of the nomination, or any renomination if one becomes necessary, the Board must notify the practitioner of its decision in relation to the nominated mentor.

(f)    In the event an approved mentor is no longer willing or able to provide the mentoring required the practitioner is to provide a new nomination in the same terms as previous nominations.  Such nomination must be made by the practitioner within 14 days of becoming aware of the termination of the mentoring relationship.

(g)   Within 28 days of the conclusion of the mentoring the practitioner must provide a report demonstrating, to the satisfaction of the Board, that the practitioner has reflected on the issues that gave rise to the condition requiring they attend for mentoring and outlining how the practitioner has incorporated the lessons learnt in the mentoring into their practise.

(h)   The costs of compliance with the conditions are to be borne by the practitioner.

4. Pursuant to s 196(3) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the review period for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Medical Board of Australia v RTF and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Medical Board of Australia brought disciplinary proceedings against RTF, a registered medical practitioner and specialist in psychiatry. The case centred on the respondent's inappropriate personal relationship with a patient, which began during the period in which the respondent was providing psychiatric treatment to the patient. The respondent's conduct was compounded by initial dishonesty during the investigation, but the respondent later admitted to the misconduct and fully cooperated with the investigation and proceedings.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the sanction proposed by the parties was appropriate, considering the exceptional mitigating circumstances, and the unique and complicated nature of the respondent's circumstances. The court considered the respondent's significant personal difficulties, the absence of any evidence of the impact of the relationship on the patient, and the respondent's full cooperation and rehabilitation efforts. The court also weighed the need for personal deterrence and deterrence of others in the medical profession.

The court found that the respondent's misconduct was at the lower end of the scale, and the relationship was one in which both parties supported each other in their mutual struggle with their medical conditions and a shared feeling of isolation within their community. The court accepted that the risk of future similar misconduct was extremely low, given the respondent's insight and rehabilitation efforts. The court found the proposed sanction to be appropriate, considering the unique circumstances of the case and the exceptional mitigating factors.

ORDERS:
1. The respondent is reprimanded for professional misconduct.
2. The respondent must be mentored by another registered health practitioner in relation to maintaining professional boundaries and identifying conflicts for a minimum period of 12 months.
3. The costs of compliance with the conditions are to be borne by the practitioner.
4. The review period for the conditions is 12 months from the date hereof.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 196(1)(b)(iii) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the respondent has behaved in a way that constitutes professional misconduct.

2. Pursuant to s 196(2)(a) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the respondent is reprimanded.

3. Pursuant to s 196(2)(b) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the following conditions be imposed:

(a) The practitioner must be mentored by another registered health practitioner in relation to maintaining professional boundaries and identifying conflicts for a minimum period of 12 months.

(b) The mentoring must comprise a minimum of 12 sessions with each session being of one hour duration occurring over a 12 month period.

(c) Within 21 days of the notice of the imposition of these conditions, the practitioner must, on the approved form, nominate a person(s) to be approved by the Board to act as mentor. The practitioner must ensure that the nomination is accompanied by acknowledgment, on the approved form, from the nominated person.

(d) Within 21 days of the notice of imposition of these conditions, the practitioner must provide to AHPRA, on the approved form, acknowledgment that AHPRA may seek reports from the approved mentor on any or all of the following occasions:

(i) every three months;

(ii) at the conclusion of the mentoring relationship in order to confirm the outcomes of the mentoring;

(iii) whenever the mentor has a concern or becomes aware of a concern regarding the practitioner’s conduct or professional performance; and

(iv) when otherwise requested by AHPRA or the Board.

(e) Within 28 days of receipt of the nomination, or any renomination if one becomes necessary, the Board must notify the practitioner of its decision in relation to the nominated mentor.

(f) In the event an approved mentor is no longer willing or able to provide the mentoring required the practitioner is to provide a new nomination in the same terms as previous nominations. Such nomination must be made by the practitioner within 14 days of becoming aware of the termination of the mentoring relationship.

(g) Within 28 days of the conclusion of the mentoring the practitioner must provide a report demonstrating, to the satisfaction of the Board, that the practitioner has reflected on the issues that gave rise to the condition requiring they attend for mentoring and outlining how the practitioner has incorporated the lessons learnt in the mentoring into their practise.

(h) The costs of compliance with the conditions are to be borne by the practitioner.

4. Pursuant to s 196(3) of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland), the review period for the conditions is 12 months from the date hereof.

5. Part 7, Division 11, subdivision 2 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland) applies to the conditions.

6. No order as to costs.

7. The tribunal notes that orders were made by the tribunal on 25 January 2017 and 18 September 2018 prohibiting the publication of material that could identify or lead to the identification of the patient and/or the respondent, except as required by s 222 and s 225 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (Queensland). These reasons have been de-identified in compliance with those non-publication orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

In reconvening the Tribunal, it was necessary for the tribunal to be reconstituted, as the terms of two assessors had since expired.[4][4]At the hearing held on the papers on 13 March 2018, the Tribunal was assisted by Dr J Black, Dr G Powell and Mr W Sanderson. The terms of Dr Powell and Mr Sanderson subsequently expired.Background The respondent holds general registration as a medical practitioner and specialist registration in psychiatry, having completed psychiatry training in 2011.[5] Prior to moving to a regional town, the respondent had worked for two years as a senior registrar at a private hospital providing mental health services in a capital city. The respondent commenced employment as a clinical psychiatrist in an inpatient setting at a clinic in a regional town (the Clinic) in August 2011, and later in an outpatient setting at a different clinic in the same town in August 2012. [5]Statement of agreed facts dated 27 October 2017, [1]; Report of Dr Sue Splatt dated 5 February 2013. On 19 July 2012, the respondent’s clinical supervisor at the Clinic referred the patient to the respondent.[6] Between 19 July 2012 and 25 October 2012, the respondent provided psychiatric treatment to the patient. [6]Statement of agreed facts dated 27 October 2017, [10]. The patient had a history of psychiatric illness. The patient had been diagnosed with illnesses including bipolar affective disorder, depression, post-traumatic stress disorder, as well as alcohol and cannabis abuse.[7] [7]Statement of agreed facts dated 27 October 2017, [6]. The respondent assessed the patient as, at that time, suffering from severe depression, prominent neuro-vegetative features, auditory hallucinations and paranoia.[8] [8]Statement of agreed facts dated 27 October 2017, [11]. On 25 October 2012, the respondent referred the patient back to the referring doctor for ongoing psychiatric care, stating that it had come to the respondent’s attention “that socially [the patient] and a very close friend of mine … had engaged in a relationship”. The respondent stated: “Whilst I do not recall [the patient], we both remain in contact with this friend. In order to maintain professional boundaries, I feel I cannot continue in the role of treating psychiatrist.” [9][9]Board’s submissions on sanction dated 19 January 2018, [9]; Letter from Dr RTF to the clinical supervisor dated 25 October 2012, hearing brief p 48.Impairment and suspension The respondent’s personal circumstances are relevant to the context within which the conduct the subject of the Referral occurred. On 7 November 2012, two weeks after ceasing the therapeutic relationship with the patient, the respondent was admitted to a clinic under the care of a treating psychiatrist. The respondent was diagnosed with mixed affective state following a hypomanic episode and was commenced on mood stabilisers.[10] [10]Statement of agreed facts dated 27 October 2017, [23(b)]. On 8 November 2012, the respondent’s accreditation at both the Clinic and the private hospital in the regional town were suspended.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent’s legal representatives acknowledged that the conduct of each practitioner in the above three cases is proportionately more reprehensible than the respondent’s. There is no evidence from the patient the subject of these proceedings outlining the effect that the relationship had upon the patient, nor was any complaint made by the patient. The Tribunal does not accept the submission of the Board that the patient was negatively impacted because of any expressed feelings of guilt or remorse because of the position the respondent was in. Nor can it be said that there was ever an element of physical or emotional intimacy involved in the relationship. The presence of such elements would have elevated the relationship to one which could be classified as being at the higher end of such cases involving professional misconduct.Conclusion on sanction Whilst it is accepted that the respondent’s relationship was improper in the ways agreed by the parties, the misconduct is at the lower end of the scale. The Tribunal accepts that the relationship was one in which both parties supported each other in their mutual struggle with their medical conditions, and a shared feeling of isolation within their community. Arguably the most serious element of the respondent’s misconduct was the initial dishonesty with the regulator; however, the Tribunal believes that conduct must be put in the context of the Board pressing much more serious allegations against the respondent. The respondent subsequently cooperated fully with the Board, and the parties were able to arrive at an agreed position such as to obviate the need for a contested hearing of the facts. In assessing the appropriateness of the sanction proposed, the tribunal must also have regard to the exceptional mitigating circumstances. During the time it has taken for this matter to come before the Tribunal, the respondent has completely changed the method by which the respondent’s practice is conducted; taking into account the recommendations flowing from the independent health assessment report and ensuring the work environment is a collegiate one where the respondent is properly supported to avoid professional isolation and any likelihood of the behaviour the subject of the current proceedings ever happening again. The Tribunal finds that the measures adopted by the respondent to rehabilitate show a very high level of insight and that the risk of future similar misconduct is extremely low. The removal of any ongoing monitoring conditions by the Board and the submissions of the Board in these proceedings support those findings. In these circumstances, personal deterrence is not a factor which would support the sanction proposed. In terms of the need to deter others, the respondent’s circumstances are so unique and complicated by the interplay of the respondent’s impairment and misconduct. Issues between the respondent and the Board around the respondent’s impairment resulted in a period of some nine months of the respondent not being allowed to practice and then a further three months before the respondent commenced working. The respondent’s impairment resulted in the respondent being closely monitored by the Board for a period of almost three years. Whilst the Tribunal accepts that time cannot be treated in these proceedings as the respondent having been penalised, it is part of the overall factual matrix.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established