Medical Board of Australia v Dolar

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
CITATION: Medical Board of Australia v Dolar [2012] QCAT 271
PARTIES: Medical Board of Australia
(Applicant)
v
Dr Maria Angeles Dolar
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER:   OCR166-10
MATTER TYPE: Occupational regulation matters
DECISION OF: Judge Fleur Kingham, Deputy President
Assisted by:
Dr Kong Goh
Dr Dana Wainwright
Mr Michael Yau
DELIVERED ON: 16 May 2012
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane

ORDERS MADE:    

1.   Dr Dolar is reprimanded in respect of the conduct.

2.   The following conditions are imposed on Dr Dolar’s registration:

2.1     Dr Dolar is subject to professional supervision by a general medical practitioner approved by the Board in writing with the supervision to focus on ethical prescribing practices.

2.2     The supervision must be carried out on the following basis:

2.2.1     The supervisor must have full knowledge of these conditions;

2.2.2     In carrying out the supervision, the supervisor must report any concerns about Dr Dolar’s prescribing practices to the Board within 24 hours;

2.2.3     The supervisor and Dr Dolar must meet each week at Dr Dolar’s place of practice to enable review of Dr Dolar’s prescribing practices for patients, at which meetings Dr Dolar must make available to the supervisor her patient records;

2.2.4     If it is not possible in any given week for the supervisor and Dr Dolar to meet in person:

a.    The meeting must occur by telephone, with Dr Dolar to have provided to the supervisor prior to the meeting her patient list for the week and any records for those patients that the supervisor may request; and

b.    Dr Dolar must notify the Board if the weekly meeting with the supervisor takes place by telephone;

2.2.5     The supervisor must be reasonably available by telephone or in person or by email as is appropriate to discuss any issues raised by Dr Dolar regarding her practice of medicine;

2.2.6     Dr Dolar must provide at the end of each day to the supervisor the clinical record for any patient for whom she has that day prescribed any medication and make herself reasonably available to discuss such patients with the supervisor by telephone or in person or by email as is appropriate.

2.3     Dr Dolar agrees to allow a Board representative at her expense to attend any medical practice at which she is associated or employed to inspect her patient records for the duration of the conditions of supervision.

3.   Dr Dolar may not apply to the Tribunal to review these conditions for 1 year from the date of these orders.

4.   Dr Dolar must pay the Board’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings including investigation costs to be assessed.

CATCHWORDS: 

OCCUPATIONAL REGULATION – HEALTH PRACTITIONER – DISCIPLINARY – where the doctor prescribed steroids and other medications without properly investigating whether they were necessary – where the doctor admits unsatisfactory professional conduct – where doctor an older practitioner – where the parties are in agreement on sanction – where terms of endorsement will severely curtail the doctor’s scope of practice – where doctor’s practising will be closely supervised – whether proposed sanction…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Medical Board of Australia v Dolar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QCAT 271
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Medical Board of Australia sought disciplinary action against Dr Dolar for her professional conduct, specifically for prescribing steroids and other medications without adequately investigating whether they were necessary. Dr Dolar admitted to unsatisfactory professional conduct, and both parties agreed on the sanction. The primary issue for the court was whether the proposed sanction, which included stringent conditions on Dr Dolar’s registration, was appropriate given the circumstances. Dr Dolar, an older practitioner, would have her practice closely supervised, and the terms of endorsement would severely curtail her scope of practice.

The court considered the nature of Dr Dolar’s conduct, her admission of unsatisfactory professional conduct, and the agreement between the parties on the sanction. The court also weighed the impact of the proposed conditions on Dr Dolar’s ability to practise medicine. It determined that the conditions, which included professional supervision focusing on ethical prescribing practices and regular reporting and review, were necessary to protect public safety and maintain professional standards. The supervision would ensure Dr Dolar's practices were closely monitored, reducing the risk of similar conduct in the future.

In reaching its decision, the court emphasised the importance of maintaining high standards of professional conduct among medical practitioners. It acknowledged the severity of the conditions but found them necessary given the nature of Dr Dolar’s conduct and the need to protect public safety. The court also considered Dr Dolar's age and experience, which it found relevant in assessing the appropriate sanction.

The court ordered that Dr Dolar be reprimanded and imposed specific conditions on her registration, including professional supervision, regular reporting, and inspection of her patient records. Dr Dolar was also prohibited from applying to the Tribunal to review these conditions for one year and was required to pay the Board's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Dr Dolar is reprimanded in respect of the conduct.

2. The following conditions are imposed on Dr Dolar’s registration:

2.1 Dr Dolar is subject to professional supervision by a general medical practitioner approved by the Board in writing with the supervision to focus on ethical prescribing practices.

2.2 The supervision must be carried out on the following basis:

2.2.1 The supervisor must have full knowledge of these conditions;

2.2.2 In carrying out the supervision, the supervisor must report any concerns about Dr Dolar’s prescribing practices to the Board within 24 hours;

2.2.3 The supervisor and Dr Dolar must meet each week at Dr Dolar’s place of practice to enable review of Dr Dolar’s prescribing practices for patients, at which meetings Dr Dolar must make available to the supervisor her patient records;

2.2.4 If it is not possible in any given week for the supervisor and Dr Dolar to meet in person:

a. The meeting must occur by telephone, with Dr Dolar to have provided to the supervisor prior to the meeting her patient list for the week and any records for those patients that the supervisor may request; and

b. Dr Dolar must notify the Board if the weekly meeting with the supervisor takes place by telephone;

2.2.5 The supervisor must be reasonably available by telephone or in person or by email as is appropriate to discuss any issues raised by Dr Dolar regarding her practice of medicine;

2.2.6 Dr Dolar must provide at the end of each day to the supervisor the clinical record for any patient for whom she has that day prescribed any medication and make herself reasonably available to discuss such patients with the supervisor by telephone or in person or by email as is appropriate.

2.3 Dr Dolar agrees to allow a Board representative at her expense to attend any medical practice at which she is associated or employed to inspect her patient records for the duration of the conditions of supervision.

3. Dr Dolar may not apply to the Tribunal to review these conditions for 1 year from the date of these orders.

4. Dr Dolar must pay the Board’s costs of and incidental to the proceedings including investigation costs to be assessed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established