Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 4) [2012] FCA 1469

Citation: Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 4) [2012] FCA 1469
Parties: JILLIAN ANNETTA MEADEN, DAVID DARVILL, ELRYG NOMINEES PTY LTD (ATF THE ELRYG NOMINEES SUPERANNUATION FUND) YAEL SUPER, SHULVO INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION), ROOSEYCORP PTY LTD ACN 125 400 080 (ATF NORLEX SUPER FUND), TECHNICAL INVESTING PTY LTD ACN 111 646 032 (ATF TECHNICAL INVESTING ABSOLUTE RETURN FUND), KAS DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD ACN 065 305 204, NEIL MOUNT AND GEOFFREY JONES (ATF NEIL MOUNT SUPERANNUATION FUND ACCOUNT), MDS TILING PTY LTD ACN 096 842 152, PETER GEOFFREY TURNER AND ZENA TURNER (ATF THE P&Z SUPER FUND), CHRISTINE HILDEBRAND, CHRISTOPHER HO, IATRIX ENTERPRISES PTY LTD ACN 113 233 159, TPC PTY LTD ACN 000 823 414 (ATF THE ADAM FREIER FAMILY TRUST), PETER COPE PTY LTD ACN 123 888 586 (ATF COPE FAMILY SUPERANNUATION FUND), HAMMOND ROYCE CORPORATION PTY LTD ACN 005 562 050 (ATF LEN DAVID SUPER FUND), HAYSON BLOODSTOCK PTY LTD ACN 108 655 367, HAYSON SUPER INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 108 655 376, 242 CAPITAL PTY LTD ACN 123 073 754 (ATF 288 SUPERANNUATION FUND), QUATRO FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD ACN 108 057 870 (IN LIQUIDATION), JADWIGA MAJ, ROLAND HELBY, CHRISTOPHER PERDIS, PETER HALL (ATF SANDRA & PETER HALL TRUST), CLARE PLUMBING SERVICES SUPER FUND ACCOUNT PTY LTD ACN 003 814 257, VICPAR HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 113 077 419 (ATF VICPAR TRUST) (IN LIQUIDATION), ANDREW GEORGE, C A ARCHER HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 131 711 898 (ATF THE CA MELBOURNE SUPER FUND ACCOUNT), CYNTHIA ARCHER, ROSS GEORGE, DAVID AZAR, BRETT JOHNSON, WOODVEST PTY LTD ACN 001 659 892 (ATF WOODVEST PTY SUPERANNUATION FUND ACCOUNT), TIM STAR, ANNE AZAR, RICHARD AZAR, CRANPORT PTY LTD ACN 003 854 000, SOLOMONS & SHAW PTY LTD ACN 089 034 060, CHAGALL INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 084 160 583, MARIANNE DOWNS, STEVEN AND GLENDA SKEELS, ANDREW RANDALL, RYAN CROSS, SIMON MCLACHLAN, JOYBECK PTY LTD ACN 050 236 863 (ATF BLACK FAMILY TRUST), BRETT TYACK, JTW TRADING PTY LTD ACN 105 305 333, DRCW TRADING PTY LTD ACN 105 303 777, LAURAINE WORTHINGTON, APPLIKOTE PTY LIMITED ACN 010 446 269, PETER GIBSON AND KYLIE RUSSELL, ANDREW HARE (ATF HALES DOUGLAS HARE SUPERANNUATION FUND), BRETT MATTHEW LOUDEN & MELANIE JOY LOUDEN, ROGAN YATES, HOMEBOY PTY LTD ACN 123 378 512, KENOATH PTY LTD ACN 074 397 667, CHARMAINE PAYTEN, HELEN AND RICHARD PERESE, SHARPAZZ PTY LTD ACN 958 037 665, JUSTINE ASHTON, TRANSWORLD CHEMICAL (AUST) PTY LTD ACN 005 625 981, CHRISTOPHER SPURRIER, MISTYGLARE PTY LTD ACN 089 670 888, DOUG AND LYNETTE ELLEN PADDON (ATF PADDON FAMILY SUPER FUND), SIEGFRIED LINK, IAN MILLER, LEE MILLER and VERONIQUE GUICHON v BELL POTTER SECURITIES LIMITED ACN 006 390 772
File number: NSD 1310 of 2010
Judge: EDMONDS J
Date of judgment: 21 December 2012
Catchwords:

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – whether the material sought to be produced under the terms of a proposed subpoena, including material already provided,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1469
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Meaden v Bell Potter Securities Limited (No 4), the Federal Court addressed a dispute between the applicants and Bell Potter Securities Limited regarding the production of documents held by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) for use in an upcoming class action. The applicants sought to subpoena ASIC to produce documents obtained during its investigation into Bell Potter's conduct, specifically related to the recommendation of Progen Pharmaceuticals Limited shares. The legal issues centred on whether the documents sought under the subpoena satisfied the relevance test for disclosure and whether the subpoena was an abuse of process.

The court found that the scope of the subpoena was overly broad and not strictly relevant to the specific allegations in the class action. The documents sought by the subpoena related to an investigation into insider trading that occurred prior to the period relevant to the class action. The court held that the subpoena was not narrowly tailored to the issues in the class action and included documents that were not relevant to the proceedings. Furthermore, the court noted that the subpoena sought documents beyond those already provided to Bell Potter by ASIC, which had already undergone a review process for relevance. The court concluded that the subpoena was an abuse of process given the circumstances and the lack of need for further material not already considered by ASIC.

The court denied the applicants leave to issue the subpoena, ruling that the subpoena was not appropriately tailored to the issues in the class action and was an unnecessary duplication of efforts already undertaken by ASIC. The court's decision underscored the importance of ensuring that discovery processes are relevant, proportionate, and not abusive, particularly when documents are already available through other investigative processes.

Background

Background to the litigation

These principles are uncontroversial and are not in dispute. What is disputed is whether the documents sought to be produced by ASIC under the terms of the Schedule to the proposed subpoena satisfy the descriptive or adjectival relevance test referred to by Beaumont J in Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Limited (No 2) (1989) 21 FCR 306.BACKGROUND By letter dated 25 February 2009, the applicants’ solicitors requested ASIC to exercise its general discretion under s 25 of the ASIC Act and the ASIC Regulatory Guide 103 (as updated 26 February 2006 [sic]) to release the documents and information described in the letter to them subject to the undertakings and conditions set out on page 2 of the letter. The letter relevantly read:Contemplated Legal ProceedingSlater & Gordon expects to shortly commence a class action under Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) against Bell Potter Securities Limited (“Bell Potter”) in relation to investment advice given by Bell Potter about Progen Pharmaceuticals Limited (ASX Code: PGL) (“PGL”) (“the Proceeding”).The class will comprise those current and former retail clients of Bell Potter who have suffered financial loss in their dealings with certain investment advisers/brokers employed by Bell Potter, including Ms Linda Ong and two former EG Capital employees, Mr Greg Ward and Mr Nick Atkinson.We understand ASIC has conducted investigations that would have focused on issues, and gathered documents and information, relevant to the issues in the Proceeding.More specifically, we expect that the documents and information will be particularly relevant to the allegations in the Proceeding relating to:(i)conduct that breaches the prohibition against a corporation engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct or conduct likely to mislead or deceive in relation to financial advice pursuant to the Corporations Act and the ASIC Act;(ii)whether Bell Potter brokers were actively involved in a marketing push for investments in PGL using overvaluations of PGL stock; and(iii)misconduct in the circumstances surrounding a capital raising by PGL in June 2008 which was co-underwritten by Bell Potter(“the Confidential Documents and Information”).Bell Potter will be obliged in the upcoming class action to make available in discovery much the same documents and information that came to light during the ASIC investigation. In the normal course, no additional forensic disadvantage would be visited upon the affected persons. The allegation in (iii) is no longer pressed. By letter dated 1 March 2012, ASIC relevantly wrote, in the following terms:2.You have requested copies of the transcripts and related books in respect of any section 19 ASIC Act examination arising out of any investigation relating to Bell Potter Securities Limited, its directors, officers or agents recommending to its clients that they acquire Progen Pharmaceuticals Limited shares during the period 13 December 2006 to 5 December 2007. This request has been duly considered and ASIC has decided to release the documents listed in the attached Schedule and enclosed in the accompanying folder (the Information), subject to the following conditions: …

Decision

Reasons for decision

The respondent’s counsel referred to the following matters in developing these four broad propositions:(1)It is clear from the documents produced by the first applicant in response to the notice to produce dated 23 February 2012 (part of Ex C), that back in July 2011 the applicant’s solicitors were informed that ASIC’s investigation into dealings in Progen Pharmaceuticals Limited (“PGL”) shares was concerned with allegations of insider trading in those shares in the period before December 2006.(2)This is confirmed, at least as far as the time period is concerned, by the ASIC s 19(2) notices issued to Ms Ong dated 10 July and 10 October 2007 (also part of Ex C). There is about a week overlap, at the most, between the period with which this proceeding is concerned (13 December 2006 to 5 December 2007) and the period the subject of the ASIC investigation (before 13 December 2006 and, at most, not beyond 19 December 2006).(3)The conclusion is open, from the particularisation in the schedule (p 39 of Ex 2) of the extracts from the transcripts of the examination of Ms Ong, Mr Ward and Mr Atkinson and the redaction of those extracts, that particular pages only have been selected for release and particular parts of those pages have been selected for redaction and that the probable reason for this selection and redaction is because the subject matter of the investigation was something quite different to the subject of this proceeding. In addition to selection and redaction of specific pages of transcripts of examinations, specific documents have been selected as well. When considered in the context that ASIC requested and were provided with the draft application and statement of claim, as originally filed on behalf of the first applicant, such a conclusion is more readily open as a deliberate process undertaken by ASIC.(4)Reference was made to Mr Giles’ affidavit (Ex A), in particular to paras 4, 5 and 6 which read:4.Annexed and marked “A” is a letter from the applicants’ solicitors dated 9 November 2012. The letter sets out the reasons why the applicants should be granted leave to issue the subpoena to ASIC. The letter refers to a request having been made to ASIC for provision of documents in ASIC’s possession, and to ASIC having provided to the applicants “selected and redacted” copies of transcripts of ASIC examinations of three persons (Linda Ong, Greg Ward and Nicholas Atkinson), and documents referred to in such examinations. The letter then states:“Our clients’ proposed Subpoena seeks, in complete and unredacted form, documents and/or information of the same nature as those sought in our request to ASIC. Such (complete and unredacted) documents and/or information would have already been available by ASIC to your client and the intervieweesOur clients are therefore prejudiced so long as they do not have access to the same documents and/or information that your client has already been given access to.”5.I am informed by Carol Simpson, Head of Compliance at Bell, and verily believe as follows:(a)in or about May 2012 ASIC provided Bell with copies of ‘selected and redacted’ transcripts of examinations of the three persons referred to above; and(b)Bell does not possess, and has not ever possessed, complete and unredacted copies of those ASIC examination transcripts, or any more complete versions of the transcripts than the ones provided to it by ASIC.6.I am informed by Murray Deakin of Middletons Lawyers, who acted on behalf of Bell in relation to the dealings with ASIC referred to in paragraph 5 above, and verily believe as follows:(a)that the documents released to Bell as referred to in paragraph 5(a) above are the same as the documents that had already been provided to the applicants’ solicitors; and(b)that he was informed by ASIC that in relation to the application made by the applicants’ lawyers pursuant to section 25(1) of the [ASIC Act], in determining which documents should be provided to the applicants’ lawyers ASIC conducted a review of the material and made a determination as to the relevance of that material pursuant to section 25(1).(5)Particular emphasis was placed on what Mr Giles deposes to at para 6(b) as being the only direct evidence in relation to what ASIC has done. It was submitted that in the circumstances the only inference is that ASIC’s investigation related to something different and the best evidence of that is the examination notices – an investigation of share trading prior to the relevant period; to the extent that it threw up material that was relevant, that is a process ASIC has already been through and has delivered up the relevant documentation.(6)The terms of the Schedule to the proposed subpoena do not simply seek full and complete production of the transcripts; it is much wider than that and it is wider than is permissible given the issues in this proceeding. This proceeding essentially concerns 10 written reports issued by the respondent to various people including the applicants. It is those 10 reports that found the alleged representations; it is those 10 reports that found the allegation of market manipulation. Paragraph 1 of the Schedule is much wider than that; it calls for all documents, including correspondence, transcripts, related books and documents in respect of any investigation or examination conducted by ASIC, and it is any investigation relating to not only the respondent, but, for instance, (ii), its directors.(7)There is no pleading in this proceeding against any directors; there is no pleading about anything directors have done. The only issues in this case relate to recommendations in the 10 reports. So to the extent it seeks evidence about other recommendations, they are not relevant to this proceeding. (8)Then there are structural problems with para 2 of the Schedule to the proposed subpoena. Paragraph 2 is said to be for the avoidance of doubt and the documents sought in para 1 are “in particular, but not limited to” and so one would infer that subparas (a) to (m) – it then reverts to Roman numerals – (i) to (viii) – are presumably all intended to be either a subset of or instances of documents that would fall within para 1. But relevant documents are not easy to identify; there are a number of preconditions to fall within para 1. One has to have a document, it has to be a document in some sense in respect of an investigation conducted by ASIC, and that investigation has to relate to either the respondent, its directors, its officers or its agents, recommending the acquisition of PGL shares during that period.One then comes, for instance, to para 2(k); it is very difficult to see how that can be a subset of a recommendation to acquire PGL shares. Similarly, (l); similarly, (m); we then get into the Roman numerals, (i) cannot be a subset of documents about recommendations to buy PGL shares. In any event, that paragraph is plainly irrelevant. What relevance is there in hiring of employees? Which pleaded issue does that go to? Similarly, (iv): How is that a subset of documents relating to recommendations? Or (v)?So, according to the respondent, this subpoena has structural problems in the sense that it is very hard to see how para 2 can appropriately be read as a subset of para 1, but, in any event, it goes way too far; it seeks documents which are not relevant, but in any event it is an abuse in the circumstances where there is no reason for the Court to think – and the question has not been asked of ASIC – that there is any material beyond that already produced and in the circumstances the Court should simply not grant leave to allow the subpoena to be issued.CONCLUSION AND REASONS

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the proposed subpoena in light of the principles established in Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Limited (No 2) and focused on whether the documents sought satisfied the descriptive or adjectival relevance test. The court found that the subpoena was overly broad, seeking documents and information that went beyond what was necessary for the class action proceeding against Bell Potter. The court emphasised that the proceeding essentially concerned 10 written reports issued by Bell Potter, and the subpoena sought documents relating to a broader range of issues, including recommendations made by directors, officers, and agents of Bell Potter. The court highlighted structural problems with the subpoena, such as the difficulty in identifying relevant documents within the specified categories, and concluded that the subpoena was not appropriately tailored to the specific issues in the proceeding.

The court further examined the relevance of the documents sought by the subpoena to the class action proceeding. It was determined that the documents were not pertinent to the proceeding as they related to issues that were not pleaded or relevant to the proceeding. The court found that the subpoena sought evidence about other recommendations that were not relevant to the proceeding, and there were structural problems with the subpoena that made it difficult to identify relevant documents.

Regarding the redaction of certain documents and the selective release of information, the court found that ASIC had not adequately justified the actions taken. The court noted that there was no sufficient reason provided by ASIC to justify the selective redaction and release of information, and the court was not convinced that there was any material beyond that already produced. The court concluded that the subpoena should not be granted as it sought information that was not pertinent to the proceeding and was overly broad.

In summary, the court held that the proposed subpoena did not satisfy the descriptive or adjectival relevance test, the documents sought were not relevant to the class action proceeding, the subpoena was overly broad, and ASIC had not adequately justified the redaction of certain documents and the selective release of information. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a subpoena must be tailored to the specific issues in the proceeding and not seek documents that are beyond what is necessary or relevant to the proceeding.