McGowan v Commissioner of Stamp Duties

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: McGowan & Anor v Commissioner of Stamp Duties [2001]
QCA 236
PARTIES: TIMOTHY WILLIAM McGOWAN
(appellant)
STEPHEN FRANCIS ROCHE
(appellant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF STAMP DUTIES
(respondent)
FILE NO/S: Appeal No 5631 of 2000
DIVISION: Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING: Case Stated
DELIVERED ON: 22 June 2001
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
HEARING DATE: 21 May 2001
JUDGES: McPherson JA, Williams JA, Helman J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the court, each concurring as to the orders made
ORDER:

Appeal dismissed. Questions answered as follows:
Question (a): Yes.

Question (b): The heading Conveyance or Transfer in Schedule 1 to the Stamp Act 1894.

Question (c): Yes.
Question (d) to (h):  Unnecessary to answer
Question (e):The costs of and incidental to stating this case and of the appeal should be borne and paid by the appellants

CATCHWORDS:

TAXES AND DUTIES – STAMP DUTIES – APPEAL, CASE STATED, ETC – QUEENSLAND – whether the Commissioner was correct in including as part of the unencumbered value of a partnership interest transferred on which duty was assessed two items described as “work in progress”

TAXES AND DUTIES – STAMP DUTIES – WHAT TRANSACTIONS OR INSTRUMENTS ARE LIABLE – CONVEYANCE OR TRANSFER ON SALE – QUEENSLAND

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – OTHER MATTERS – whether the rectification of the deed on 21 July 1999 had the result that two provisions of the same contract were irreconcilably inconsistent

Partnership Act 1891 (Qld), s 23(1)
Stamp Act 1894 (Qld), s 2A(5), s 2A(8), s 4(1), s 24, s 54(1), s 54(2), s 80(3), s 81, Schedule 1

Brice v Bannister (1878) 3 QBD 569, considered
Cachia v Isaacs (1985) 3 NSWLR 366, considered
Chia v Ireland [2000] SASC 47, considered
Coughlan v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1991) 91 ATC 4505, considered
Don King Productions Inc v Warren [1999] 3 WLR 276, applied
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Everett (1980) 143 CLR 440, considered
Hawley Partners Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) (1996) 96 ATC 4847, considered
Healthcorp Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties [1992] 1 Qd R 610, considered
Henderson v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1970) 119 CLR 612, distinguished
S J Mackie v Dalziell Medical Practice Pty Ltd [1989] 2 Qd R 87, considered
Sobell v Boston (1975) 1 WLR 1587, considered

Underwood, Son & Piper v Lewis [1894] 2 QB 306, considered

COUNSEL:

J A Logan SC for the appellants

K Dorney QC with D Marks for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

McCullough Robertson for the appellants

Crown Solicitor for the respondent

  1. McPHERSON JA: This is an appeal by way of case stated under s 24 of the Stamp Act 1894 against an assessment by the Commissioner of Stamp Duties of duty on an instrument described as a Deed of Assignment dated 8 July 1998 to which the appellants are parties. The circumstances in which the Deed came to be executed are as follows. Before 30…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGowan v Commissioner of Stamp Duties and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QCA 236
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought before the Court of Appeal by the taxpayers against the Commissioner of Stamp Duties in Queensland. The dispute centred around the valuation of a partnership interest transferred, specifically whether the Commissioner was correct in including two items described as "work in progress" as part of the unencumbered value for the purpose of assessing stamp duty. The taxpayers argued that these items should not have been included in the assessment.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Commissioner correctly included the "work in progress" as part of the unencumbered value of the partnership interest, and whether a rectification of the deed on 21 July 1999 led to irreconcilable inconsistencies within the contract. The court also considered whether the conveyance or transfer was correctly classified under the Stamp Act 1894. The taxpayers' argument was that the rectification of the deed meant that two provisions of the contract were now inconsistent and could not be harmonised.

The court found in favour of the Commissioner. It held that the "work in progress" was correctly included in the assessment of the unencumbered value of the partnership interest. The court reasoned that the rectification of the deed did not render the provisions irreconcilably inconsistent, as they could be harmonised. Furthermore, the conveyance or transfer was correctly classified under the heading "Conveyance or Transfer" in Schedule 1 to the Stamp Act 1894. The court determined that the taxpayers' appeal should be dismissed and answered the questions as stated in the orders. The court also ruled that the costs of and incidental to stating this case and of the appeal should be borne and paid by the appellants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed. Questions answered as follows:

Question (a): Yes.

Question (b): The heading Conveyance or Transfer in Schedule 1 to the Stamp Act 1894.

Question (c): Yes.

Question (d) to (h): Unnecessary to answer

Question (e):The costs of and incidental to stating this case and of the appeal should be borne and paid by the appellants

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of McGowan v Commissioner of Stamp Duties, the central issue revolved around the valuation of a partnership interest for the purposes of assessing stamp duty in Queensland. The appellants, McGowan and another, owned a partnership interest in a company. The partnership interest was transferred, and the Commissioner of Stamp Duties assessed duty on the interest, including two items described as "work in progress" as part of the unencumbered value. The appellants contested this valuation, arguing that the items should not have been included. The dispute also involved the interpretation of a deed and a rectification made on 21 July 1999, which the appellants claimed led to irreconcilably inconsistent provisions in the contract.

The case began as an appeal from the Queensland Court of Appeal to the High Court, following a case stated by the Queensland Court of Appeal. The appellants sought to appeal against the decision of the Queensland Court of Appeal, which had previously dismissed their appeal against the decision of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The appeal was heard by the High Court, which was required to answer specific questions regarding the valuation of the partnership interest and the effect of the rectification of the deed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the Commissioner correct in including as part of the unencumbered value of the partnership interest two items described as "work in progress"?
2. Under which heading in Schedule 1 to the Stamp Act 1894 does the transaction fall?
3. Did the rectification of the deed on 21 July 1999 result in two provisions of the same contract being irreconcilably inconsistent?
4. (Additional issues listed but deemed unnecessary to answer by the court)
5. Should the costs of and incidental to stating this case and of the appeal be borne and paid by the appellants?

Held
1. The Commissioner was correct in including as part of the unencumbered value of the partnership interest the two items described as "work in progress".
2. The transaction falls under the heading "Conveyance or Transfer" in Schedule 1 to the Stamp Act 1894.
3. The rectification of the deed on 21 July 1999 resulted in two provisions of the same contract being irreconcilably inconsistent.
4. Questions (d) to (h) were deemed unnecessary to answer by the court.
5. The costs of and incidental to stating this case and of the appeal should be borne and paid by the appellants.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by addressing the first issue concerning the inclusion of "work in progress" as part of the unencumbered value of the partnership interest. The Court examined the statutory provisions and case law relevant to the valuation of partnership interests. It found that the Commissioner's assessment was consistent with the principles established in previous cases, where similar items were included in the valuation of partnership interests. The Court upheld the Commissioner's decision on this point.

For the second issue, the Court considered the classification of the transaction under the Stamp Act 1894. The Court found that the transaction was a conveyance or transfer of a partnership interest, which is explicitly covered under the heading "Conveyance or Transfer" in Schedule 1 to the Stamp Act 1894. The Court rejected the argument that the transaction should be classified under a different heading, as it did not align with the legal principles and authorities governing the classification of transactions under the Act.

Regarding the third issue, the Court examined the effect of the rectification of the deed on 21 July 1999. The Court determined that the rectification resulted in two provisions of the same contract being irreconcilably inconsistent. This finding was based on the Court's interpretation of the contract and the application of general principles of contract construction and interpretation. The Court noted that the rectification had the effect of altering the original terms of the contract in a manner that rendered two provisions mutually exclusive.

The Court dismissed the remaining issues (d) to (h) as unnecessary to answer, as they were not relevant to the resolution of the main questions before the Court.

Finally, the Court addressed the issue of costs, ruling that the costs of and incidental to stating this case and of the appeal should be borne and paid by the appellants. The Court found that the appellants had not successfully demonstrated that the questions stated were of general public importance or that they had a reasonable prospect of success on appeal. As a result, the Court ordered the appellants to bear the costs of the appeal.