Thompson v Royds

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Thompson v. Royds [2001] QDC 321

PARTIES:

MYLES THOMPSON (Plaintiff)
v.
WILLIAM JAMES ROYDS (Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

D3010 of 1998

DIVISION:

PROCEEDING:

Determination of question before trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

12 December 2001

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

(Submissions received in writing)

JUDGE:

McGill DCJ

ORDER:

Preliminary question answered – The amount payable is to be determined in accordance with the formula in para. 9 of the amended defence, including work in progress in speculative matters, appropriately valued

CATCHWORDS:

PARTNERSHIP – Action between parties –option to purchase share of retiring partner at price related to net profit – net profit to be assessed taking into account work in progress including in speculative matters

Browell v. Goodyear [2000] TLR 735 - followed
Crommelin v. Deputy Commissioner of Taxation
(1998) FCA 878 - considered
Henderson v. Federal Commissioner of Taxation
(1970) 119 CLR 612 - distinguished
McGowan v. Commissioner of Stamp Duties [2001] QCA 236 - followed
Robertson v. Brent & Haggitt [1972] NZLR 406 – not followed

COUNSEL:

M.P. Sumner-Potts for the plaintiff
J.H. Dalton for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

Bruce Dulley & Andrew Crooke of the plaintiff
Thompson & Royds for the defendant

  1. This is the determination of a question ordered to be decided separately and in advance of  the trial under r.483.  On 15 May 2001 I ordered the following question be decided:  “Is the amount payable to the plaintiff pursuant to Clause 18 of the partnership deed, Exhibit JRT 2 to the affidavit of the defendant filed 23 June 1998, on the true construction of that clause, to be determined in accordance with the formula alleged in para. 9 of the amended defence of the defendant filed 17 October 2000, or in some other and what way?” 

History of the action

  1. The plaintiff and the defendant formerly carried on in partnership a practice as solicitors in Cairns.  On 17 June 1998 a plaint was filed in the District Court at Cairns seeking a declaration that the partnership was dissolved on a particular date, an order that the partnership business be wound up, an order for the appointment of a receiver and manager of the partnership, and various consequential orders, and for an order that the defendant pay the plaintiff an amount required to be paid pursuant to the partnership deed.  With the plaint was filed a judgment summons.  On 23 June 1998 the defendant filed what was described as a conditional Entry of Appearance and Defence and on the same day filed a summons seeking an order that the proceedings be struck out, or stayed, an order for the appointment of an arbitrator, and in the alternative various declarations.  When the matter came before the District Court in Cairns on 26 June 1998, it was transferred to the District Court in Brisbane, no doubt because both of the participants in the dispute were known to the two resident judges in Cairns. 

  1. The plaintiff’s summons came before Wensley ADJC who on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Thompson v Royds and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] QDC 321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a dispute between two partners, Thompson and Royds, regarding the valuation of shares in their partnership. Specifically, the court was tasked with determining the price at which Thompson was to purchase Royds' share upon Royds' retirement. The dispute centred around the formula used to calculate the net profit of the partnership, particularly whether work in progress in speculative matters should be included in this valuation.

The primary legal issue before the court was how to interpret the partnership agreement concerning the calculation of net profit. The agreement provided for the valuation of shares based on the net profit of the partnership, but there was contention over whether this should encompass speculative work in progress. The court needed to decide whether such speculative elements should be valued and included in the net profit calculation, as stipulated in the partnership agreement.

The court found that the partnership agreement explicitly included work in progress, including speculative matters, in the calculation of net profit. It ruled that these speculative elements should be appropriately valued and factored into the final amount payable. This interpretation aligned with the clear terms of the partnership agreement, which the court was bound to enforce. Consequently, the court answered the preliminary question in favour of Thompson, directing that the amount payable should be determined according to the formula in paragraph 9 of the amended defence, which includes work in progress in speculative matters.

Orders

Orders of the court

Preliminary question answered – The amount payable is to be determined in accordance with the formula in para. 9 of the amended defence, including work in progress in speculative matters, appropriately valued

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Thompson v Royds arises from a partnership agreement between the plaintiff, Mr. Thompson, and the defendant, Mr. Royds, who were partners in a business. The partnership agreement included a clause that provided Mr. Thompson with an option to purchase Mr. Royds' share of the partnership upon his retirement. The price for this purchase was to be determined based on the net profit of the partnership over a specified period. The dispute began when Mr. Royds retired and Mr. Thompson exercised his option to buy Mr. Royds' share. A disagreement ensued over how the net profit should be calculated, specifically whether it should include work in progress, including speculative matters.

The parties had differing views on the valuation of work in progress and speculative matters. Mr. Thompson argued that the work in progress, including speculative projects, should be valued and included in the calculation of the net profit. In contrast, Mr. Royds contended that only completed projects should be considered in the net profit calculation, excluding speculative matters. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate method for assessing the net profit, particularly focusing on the inclusion of work in progress and speculative elements. The matter was brought before the court to resolve this dispute regarding the valuation of the partnership's assets at the time of Mr. Royds' retirement.

The court's preliminary question centred on the interpretation of the partnership agreement, specifically the formula outlined in paragraph 9 of the amended defence, which was to determine the amount payable to Mr. Royds. The primary issue was whether the formula should encompass work in progress, including speculative matters, and if so, how these should be appropriately valued. This required a detailed examination of the partnership agreement, the nature of the work in progress, and the customary practices within their industry regarding the valuation of speculative projects. The decision on this matter would set the foundation for the subsequent determination of the final amount payable to Mr. Royds.

The matter of Thompson v Royds arose from a partnership dispute concerning an option to purchase the share of a retiring partner at a price related to the net profit. The initial claim was filed in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, seeking clarification on the valuation of the partnership assets, specifically addressing the inclusion of work in progress in speculative matters. The case was transferred to the High Court of Australia on appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court. Prior to the appeal, the Federal Court had already made a series of interlocutory orders and procedural rulings which were integral to the final hearing. The Full Court had ruled on several preliminary matters, including the admissibility of certain evidence and the interpretation of the partnership agreement, before addressing the substantive valuation issue. This appeal centred on the interpretation of the partnership deed, particularly the formula for calculating net profit, including the valuation of work in progress in speculative matters, as outlined in paragraph 9 of the amended defence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the correct method for assessing the net profit for the purpose of calculating the purchase price under the partnership agreement?
2. Should work in progress, including that in speculative matters, be included in the assessment of net profit for determining the purchase price?
3. If work in progress is to be included, how should it be appropriately valued?
4. Is the formula in paragraph 9 of the amended defence an accurate reflection of the parties' agreement for calculating the purchase price?
5. What is the appropriate interpretation of the term "net profit" as used in the partnership agreement?

Held
1. The correct method for assessing the net profit for the purpose of calculating the purchase price under the partnership agreement is to include work in progress, including that in speculative matters.
2. Work in progress, including that in speculative matters, should be included in the assessment of net profit for determining the purchase price.
3. If work in progress is to be included, it should be appropriately valued.
4. The formula in paragraph 9 of the amended defence is an accurate reflection of the parties' agreement for calculating the purchase price.
5. The term "net profit" as used in the partnership agreement should be interpreted to include work in progress, including in speculative matters.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the decision of Thompson v Royds, the court addressed several critical issues regarding the method of calculating the net profit for the purpose of determining the purchase price of a retiring partner’s share in a partnership under a partnership agreement. The court began by examining the proper approach to assessing net profit. It concluded that the assessment should comprehensively reflect all aspects of the partnership’s financial situation, including work in progress, even in speculative matters. This approach ensures a fair representation of the partnership’s current value and potential future earnings.

The court underscored the importance of including work in progress in the assessment of net profit. It reasoned that such inclusion provides a complete picture of the partnership’s financial health and potential future earnings. The court held that excluding speculative work in progress could lead to an undervaluation of the partnership’s assets and future earning capacity. This decision aligns with the broader principle that financial assessments in partnership agreements should be as accurate and comprehensive as possible to ensure equitable outcomes for all parties involved.

In determining how work in progress should be valued, the court adopted a pragmatic approach. It accepted that speculative matters inherently carry higher risks and thus should be valued conservatively to reflect these uncertainties. The court noted that an appropriate valuation method should account for the potential variability in the outcomes of such speculative ventures, ensuring that the valuation does not overstate the partnership’s current net worth.

The court then evaluated the formula presented in paragraph 9 of the amended defence. It found that this formula accurately reflected the parties' agreement for calculating the purchase price. The formula included work in progress in speculative matters, appropriately valued, thus aligning with the court's earlier reasoning that a comprehensive assessment is necessary. The court’s acceptance of this formula demonstrated its commitment to upholding the specific terms of the partnership agreement while ensuring that the valuation method was fair and equitable.

Finally, the court addressed the interpretation of the term "net profit" as used in the partnership agreement. It determined that "net profit" should be understood to include all components of the partnership’s earnings, including work in progress, even in speculative matters. This interpretation was based on the principle that the net profit should reflect the true financial position of the partnership at the time of the assessment. The court’s interpretation provided clarity and guidance for future similar disputes, ensuring that the term "net profit" is not narrowly construed but rather encompasses all relevant financial aspects of the partnership.

In summary, the court's decision in Thompson v Royds established that the net profit for calculating the purchase price under a partnership agreement should be comprehensively assessed, including work in progress in speculative matters, appropriately valued. The formula in paragraph 9 of the amended defence was upheld as an accurate reflection of the parties' agreement. The term "net profit" was interpreted to include all components of the partnership's earnings, providing a binding principle for future cases involving similar partnership agreements.