McAdam v Robertson (No 2) No. Scciv-97-1458

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

McADAM v ROBERTSON (No 2)

[2001] SASC 206

Full Court:  Debelle and Nyland JJ

  1. DEBELLE & NYLAND JJ. This is an application to recall and reopen orders of the Full Court made on 26 November 1998.  The court comprised Millhouse, Debelle and Nyland JJ.  The application stems from some unfortunate and regrettable misstatements of fact made by the Full Court in the course of its reasons.  The applicant asserts that the court had misapprehended significant matters of fact and overlooked important principles of law.

  2. The applicant, Ms Louise McAdam, had suffered serious injuries in a motor vehicle collision on 20 April 1993 when the motor car she was driving collided with a truck driven by the respondent, Mr Robertson.  Ms McAdam brought an action for damages in the Magistrates Court against Robertson claiming damages for the injuries she had received.  We will hereafter refer to Ms McAdam as “the plaintiff” and to Mr Robertson as “the defendant”.  The magistrate dismissed the plaintiff’s claim finding that she had not proved that the defendant was negligent.

  3. The plaintiff appealed to a judge of this Court (Olsson J) who allowed the appeal and set aside the order of the magistrate.  The judge held that the defendant was 70 per cent responsible for the collision and awarded the plaintiff 70 per cent of the agreed amount of damages.  The defendant then appealed to the Full Court (“the first Full Court”) which allowed the appeal, set aside the decision of Olsson J and restored the decision of the magistrate.  The first Full Court held that the criticisms by Olsson J of the magistrate’s reasoning were unsound.  The court published its reasons on 26 November 1998.

  4. In the course of its reasons, the first Full Court had misstated some matters of fact.  On 15 January 1999, some two months after the first Full Court had delivered its judgment, the plaintiff applied to a differently constituted Full Court (“the second Full Court”) to recall and reopen the orders made by the first Full Court and to grant a rehearing of the appeal.  The application was heard on 9 March 1999.  The second Full Court published its reasons on 6 May 1999 holding that the application should be considered by the first Full Court as it had power to reopen its decision.  The first Full Court should be reconstituted, it said, only if there is good reason to do so.  The second Full Court also held that the first Full Court had erred in a manner which gave it power to reopen its decision but expressly refrained from making any comment on the strength of the plaintiff’s case.  It is unnecessary to restate in full the reasons of the second Full Court.  They are reported in McAdam v Robertson (1999) 73 SASR 360.

  5. The matter came before the first Full Court again on 28 October 1999 on an application by the defendant to recover the money he had paid pursuant to the order of Olsson J.  The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McAdam v Robertson (No 2) No. Scciv-97-1458 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] SASC 206
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McAdam v Robertson (No 2) No. Scciv-97-1458 involved the plaintiff, McAdam, appealing against a decision made by the court regarding costs awarded to the respondent, Robertson. The case originated in the Magistrates Court and was appealed to the Supreme Court. The primary focus of the appeal was on the costs order made in the Magistrates Court, particularly the decision to double the costs due to an offer made at the trial and to compute the costs based on the complexity of the action. The plaintiff argued that the reference to the magistrate in the costs order was incorrect and should have referred to the judge in the court below.

The court had to determine whether the reference to the magistrate in the costs order was an error and whether the plaintiff's criticism of this matter was valid. The court also needed to address whether the costs order, which doubled the costs due to an offer made at the trial and computed them based on the complexity of the action, was correctly made. The plaintiff's argument regarding the reference to the magistrate was rejected as the court found that the reference to the judge in the court below was accurate and clearly evident from the context and the record of proceedings.

The court found that the plaintiff's criticism of the reference to the magistrate was misplaced and did not merit any further consideration. The court also confirmed that its reasons for the costs order were entirely accurate. The plaintiff's application to reopen the orders made on 26 November 1998 was dismissed as there was no valid basis for doing so.

In conclusion, the court upheld the costs order made in the Magistrates Court and dismissed the plaintiff's application to reopen the orders. The reasoning was based on the accuracy of the reference to the judge in the costs order and the correctness of the calculation and doubling of costs due to an offer made at the trial. The final order was that the plaintiff's application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

NYLAND JJ
One final criticism made by the plaintiff concerned para 33 which dealt with orders made by the judge as to costs in the Magistrates Court. We said:“There is a further appeal against an order made by the judge as to costs in the Magistrates Court. The judge held that a special order as to those costs should be made in favour of the respondent. He held that the costs should be awarded in accordance with the provisions of Rule 53 of the Magistrates Courts Rules and should be doubled because an offer had been made at the trial. He also ordered that the costs of the trial should be computed on the footing that this was a complex action: see Rule 106(7) of the Magistrates Court Rules.”We have emphasised the passage about which the plaintiff complains. The complaint is contained in the outline of submissions but was not developed in oral argument. As the submission was not withdrawn we must deal with it. It was submitted that the emphasised sentence refers to the magistrate. Plainly, it does not, as counsel for the plaintiff would have known. We are referring to the judge in the court below who has allowed the appeal from the decision of the magistrate. That is apparent from the context in which the sentence appears. It is also confirmed by the fact that the magistrate made no special order as to costs but simply made the usual order that costs follow the event. The plaintiff had sought a special order as to costs on the appeal before Olsson J and that order is to be found in para 1 of the order made on 16 February 1998. Reference to the transcript of proceedings before the judge on 16 February 1998 confirms that. Our reasons on the question of costs are entirely accurate. Nothing more need be said in response to this misplaced criticism.Conclusion For all of these reasons, we do not think there is any basis for reopening the orders made on 26 November 1998. The plaintiff’s application is therefore dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NYLAND JJ

Full text does not contain this section.