Masson v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Masson v State of Queensland [2018] QSC 162

PARTIES:

THE ESTATE OF THE LATE JENNIFER LEANNE MASSON 

(Plaintiff)

v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

306 of 2005

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Claim

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Cairns

DELIVERED ON:

23 July 2018

DELIVERED AT:

Cairns

HEARING DATES:

12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 19, 20, 21 February 2018, 8 March 2018

JUDGE:

Henry J

ORDERS:

1.       Claim dismissed.

2.       I will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am 8 August 2018 (out of town parties having leave to appear by telephone) if costs are not agreed in the meantime.

CATCHWORDS:

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE– ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – STANDARD OF CARE – GENERALLY – whether the ambulance officers exercised the standard of care expected of an ambulance officer operating in the field in an emergency – whether reasonable care and skill was exercised – whether adrenaline should have been administered in preference to salbutamol – whether the response to the risk was reasonable – whether the timely administration of adrenaline would have avoided the injury.

TORTS – NEGLIGENCE – ESSENTIALS OF ACTION FOR NEGLIGENCE – DUTY OF CARE – GOVERNMENT AND PUBLIC AUTHORITIES – whether the State owed the plaintiff a duty of care to ensure that Queensland Ambulance Service officers acted in accordance with their obligations under the Queensland Ambulance Service guidelines and duty of patient care – where the guideline invited consideration of the administration of adrenaline – whether the guideline mandated the administration of adrenaline.

Ambulance Service of NSW v Worley [2006] NSWCA 102, cited
CGU Insurance Ltd v Porterhouse (2008) 235 CLR 103, cited
Roads & Traffic Authority (NSW) v Dederer (2007) 234 CLR 330, cited
Robinson Helicopter Co Inc v McDermott (2016) 90 ALJR 679, cited
Rogers v Whitaker (1992) 175 CLR 479, cited
Vairy v Wyong Shire Council (2005) 223 CLR 422

Crown Proceedings Act 1980 (Qld), s 8.
Succession Act 1981 (Qld), s 66.

COUNSEL:

D Campbell SC with S Longhurst for plaintiff

D H Tait QC with C Fitzpatrick for defendant

SOLICITORS:

RMB Lawyers for plaintiff

Crown Law for defendant

  1. Jennifer Masson suffered hypoxic brain damage as a result of a severe asthma attack.  It is alleged she would have avoided the injury if ambulance officers who attended upon her had administered adrenaline promptly to her.   Their decision not to do so is said to have been contrary to Queensland Ambulance Service (“QAS”) guidelines and a breach of the QAS’s duty of patient care. 

  2. The injury occurred in 2002. Ms Masson lingered, catastrophically brain damaged in around the clock care, for many years before her death in 2016. Her personal injuries claim against the State of Queensland, per s 8 Crown Proceedings Act 1980 (Qld), had not been resolved by then.

  3. The action survived in the hands of her estate, pursuant to s 66 Succession Act 1981 (Qld). Quantum was agreed in the amount of $3,000,000 prior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Masson v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QSC 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Masson v State of Queensland, the plaintiff, Ms Masson, a chronic asthmatic, brought an action against the State of Queensland, specifically the Queensland Ambulance Service (QAS), alleging negligence in the treatment of her asthma attack. The case proceeded to a nine-day trial focused on the State's liability for negligence, with quantum already agreed at $3,000,000. The primary legal issues before the court were whether the ambulance officers exercised the standard of care expected in an emergency and if they should have administered adrenaline instead of salbutamol. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the State owed a duty of care to ensure that the QAS officers adhered to the Queensland Ambulance Service guidelines and the duty of patient care, particularly regarding the administration of adrenaline.

The court examined the QAS guidelines, which included a note encouraging officers to consider the best possible care for the patient, deviating from guidelines only when necessary and justifiable. The guidelines indicated that adrenaline was an appropriate treatment for bronchospasm unresponsive to salbutamol. Despite this, the ambulance officers administered salbutamol instead of adrenaline. The court considered the past episodes where adrenaline successfully treated Ms Masson's severe asthma attacks, suggesting that timely administration of adrenaline would likely have been successful in the present case as well.

Ultimately, the court found that the ambulance officers did not breach their duty of care by not administering adrenaline. The court concluded that the officers' decision to administer salbutamol was reasonable under the circumstances and within the standard of care expected. Consequently, the claim was dismissed. The court will hear the parties regarding costs on 8 August 2018, if not agreed beforehand.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Claim dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs at 9.15 am 8 August 2018 (out of town parties having leave to appear by telephone) if costs are not agreed in the meantime.

Background

Background to the litigation

The action survived in the hands of her estate, pursuant to s 66 Succession Act 1981 (Qld). Quantum was agreed in the amount of $3,000,000 prior to the nine-day trial of her action on the issue of the State’s liability in negligence.Facts Ms Masson was a 25-year-old chronic asthmatic. Asthma is an episodic respiratory disease characterised by acute exacerbations of airflow obstruction due to airway inflammation and airway hypo responsiveness to a wide range of stimuli.[1] It is not known what stimuli prompted the asthma attack with which this case is concerned.[1] Ex 4 p 8. Ms Masson had previously suffered severe asthma attacks which, unbeknown to the ambulance officers in this case, had been successfully treated by the administration of adrenaline. She carried a Ventolin puffer and had been prescribed an EpiPen (a patient administered adrenaline auto injector[2]) but there is no evidence she possessed or attempted to use an EpiPen during the events in question.[3] [2] Adrenaline is also known as “epinephrine”.[3] Notes made by a treating doctor on Ms Masson’s eventual arrival at Cairns Base Hospital recorded Ms Masson’s presenting history as: “asthma with two life-threatening episodes in past carries adrenaline” (Ex 22 p 517). The source of that information is unclear. If it was conveyed by the ambulance officers, it was likely conveyed to them by one of Ms Masson’s friends at the scene but telling against that is the absence of such a record in the Ambulance Report Form. In any event, the plaintiff did not allege the ambulance officers knew Ms Masson carried an EpiPen or knew that her asthma was specifically known to respond to adrenaline. Turning to those events, on the night of 21 July 2002 Ms Masson drove to the home of her friend Jonathon Turner in Brinsmead, Cairns. On walking into the house, she was wheezing badly and announced she was returning to her car, apparently to look for her Ventolin puffer. When she returned to the house she asked Mr Turner to take her to the hospital. As they walked outside she collapsed on the front lawn. Another friend who was present, David Denman, telephoned for ambulance assistance and Mr Turner tended to Ms Masson, performing mouth to mouth resuscitation. According to the QAS trip history record[4] and the QAS ambulance report form (“ARF”)[5], Mr Denman’s call was received at 22.52 and ambulance officers were at the scene at 22.58, six minutes later.[4] Ex 23 p 1324.[5] Ex 5. Two ambulance crews attended: intensive care paramedic Clinton Peters with third year paramedic Tania Stirling, and advance care paramedic Glen Timmins with first year paramedic Neville Weazel. Of them, Mr Peters and Ms Stirling gave evidence. Mr Peters’ witness statements of 2 February 2006 and 5 July 2009 were also exhibited.[6] Mr Peters was the senior officer and the determinative decision maker amongst the officers.[6] Ex 6. On arrival, Mr Peters noticed Ms Masson lying supine on the grass while a male performed external compressions on her.[7] The ambulance officers were given a history of Ms Masson having had a history of severe asthma,[8] suffering an asthma attack, having used her puffer to no effect, asking to be taken to hospital and collapsing into respiratory arrest, after which a friend performed “EAR/CPR” (expired air resuscitation/cardiopulmonary resuscitation).[9] Mr Turner and Mr Denman did not give evidence, but their unsigned statements became exhibits by consent. Those statements only spoke of Mr Turner performing “mouth to mouth”. Whether it was Mr Turner or another bystander who was the male Mr Peters saw performing CPR is unclear.[7] T2-56 L12.[8] T2-64 L27.[9] Ex 5.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Significantly, in the context of the present case, the section of patient care principles in respect of clinical judgment/problem solving, includes this note:“Officers must consider the best possible care for the patient. The QAS Clinical Practice Manual is designed to assist clinical judgment, using the problem solving approach, to achieve best practice. It is acknowledged that every situation is different. Deviations from the guidelines will occur but must be documented and audited, and officers must be able to justify that their treatment was in the patient’s best interest.”[119] (emphasis added)[119] Ex 2 p 887.QAS asthma guideline Section A of the manual contains the case management guidelines. Its table of contents contains major headings followed by relevant sub-headings. Under the major heading “Dyspnoea” (laboured breathing), one of the sub-headings is “Asthma”. The two pages of the manual’s case management guidelines dealing with asthma (“the QAS asthma guideline”) contain at the first page, information including: “Diagnostic pattern:- Past history of asthma- Wheeze; Initially apparent on expiration but as the disease progresses there may be both inspiratory and expiratory wheeze evolving into only inspiratory wheeze and then no wheeze.- Leaning forward braced posture- Prolonged expiratory phase of ventilation- Pursing of lips- Hyper inflated thorax- Cyanosis (late sign)Guiding principles:- “All that wheezes is not asthma.” Consider other causes of wheeze, eg. bronchiolitis, acute pulmonary oedema, c.o.a.d., chest infection (particularly if there is no history of asthma).A patient with apnoea or near arrest requires ventilation assisted with slow gentle, shallow breaths of 100% oxygen at a rate of 4-8 per minute – very slow to allow passive exhalation. IPPV carries the risk of creating a pneumothorax (pulmonary barotrauma from high inflation pressure from air trapping) and then converting this into a tension pneumothorax.”[120] (emphasis added)[120] Ex 2 p 911. The second page of the QAS asthma guideline is the following flow chart (“the flowchart”):Asthma data sheet The manual’s chapter on clinical pharmacology also contains information about adrenaline, in the form of a two-page drug data sheet.[121] Its first page includes a section headed “Indications”, against which there is a large tick (as distinct from cross) symbol, indicating the situations listed are apt for the administration of adrenaline, as follows:“INDICATIONS- Cardiac arrest.- Bradycardia and/or poor perfusion unresponsive to other measures.- Anaphylactic reactions.- Bronchospasm unresponsive to Salbutamol.- Croup with life-threatening airway compromise (nebulised)”[121] Ex 2 pp 1007, 1008. The first page contains a variety of other information on the topics of presentation, pharmacology, action, metabolism, precautions, routes for administration, side effects, drug effect and contra-indications. The second page of the drug data sheet contains usual dosages for adults and children. It begins with the following caution:“Caution:The use of adrenaline may lead to hypertension, stroke, MI or a life-threatening arrhythmias.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Lest I be wrong in that conclusion I should for completeness address causation, on the premise, contrary to my view, that the non-administration of adrenaline did result from a breach.Causation issue 1: Would timely administration of adrenaline have avoided the injury? Ms Masson was admitted to Shoalhaven District Hospital on 4 May 1995[149] against a background where she had woken up with an exacerbation of asthma and her father had administered adrenaline. The hospital records noted inter alia:“Woke up with exacerbation of asthma. Father administered 1 ampule 1:1000 adrenaline due to patient being cyanosed. …”[150][149] Ex 21 p 415.[150] Ex 21 p 417. This suggests as early as 1995 her family had been equipped by medical practitioners to administer adrenaline to her in the event of an asthma attack. On 10 July 1997 Ms Masson had an acute asthma attack and was attended upon by New South Wales ambulance. They found her in severe respiratory distress, cyanosed and apnoeic, and administered two lots of adrenaline,[151] the result of which was recorded as being an improved response. The ambulance record form also records her father had given her an adrenaline injection.[152] On admission at Shoalhaven District Memorial Hospital, her condition on arrival was noted as:“History of asthma past respiratory arrests requiring home adrenaline. Tonight sudden onset asthma – found apnoeic by ambo’s, given adrenaline by father and ambo’s. On arrival inspiratory and expiratory wheeze, cyanosed, restless.”[153][151] Ex 21 p 333.[152] Ex 21 p 333.[153] Ex 21 p 317. Ms Masson was admitted again to Shoalhaven District Memorial Hospital on 12 February 2000. The notes of that admission record that she had presented for the second time in the last few hours. She had inspiratory and expiratory wheeze and had used her nebuliser 10 times at home without any improvement. The record notes that following her presentation she became unable to breathe and unresponsive.[154] Oxygen ventilation was commenced and 0.5 ml of 1 mg in 1000 adrenaline was given and recorded as having a “good response”.[155][154] Ex 21 p 233.[155] Ex 21 p 234. The evidence of the successful use of adrenaline to treat Ms Masson’s apparently severe asthma attacks in 1997 and 2000 is relied upon as supporting the inference the timely administration of adrenaline in the present instance would again have been successful. No evidence other than records was led in respect of these past episodes. Each obviously involved life threatening attacks of asthma, although it is not apparent there had been respiratory arrest or that either episode involved the prolonged period in extremis awaiting intervention which this case involves. That said, the evidence of Ms Masson’s past positive responses, of which the ambulance officers were unaware, trends against the conclusion that the risk of her condition worsening in consequence of the administration of adrenaline was likely to manifest and in favour of the conclusion adrenaline would have had a positive effect.