Marijancevic v Mann

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Marijancevic v Mann [2008] FCAFC 161

INCOME TAX – garnishee notice issued before notices of default assessments – Commissioner conceded invalidity of garnishee notice – Commissioner claimed letter advising of garnishee notice sent to former address of taxpayer by mistake – taxpayer claimed default assessments issued solely to justify garnishee notice – no testimony from relevant officers at Tax Office  –  whether conscious or deliberate maladministration of the assessment process by Commissioner – no inference of deliberate maladministration open –  appeals dismissed

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) ss 6(1), 166, 167, 177, 204(1)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) ss 255-45, 260-5 of Schedule 1

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Richard Walter Pty Ltd (1995) 183 CLR 168 referred to
R v Hickman; ex parte Fox and Clinton (1945) 70 CLR 598 referred to
Commissioner of Taxation v Futuris Corporation Ltd [2008] HCA 32 applied
Weissensteiner v R (1993) 178 CLR 217 referred to
Martin v Wagga Wagga City Council [2004] NSWCA 289 cited
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 referred to
Bonnell v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] FCAFC 146 referred to
R v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (WA); ex parte Briggs (1987) 14 FCR 249 referred to
Trautwein v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1936) 56 CLR 63 referred to
Madden v Madden (1996) 65 FCR 354 referred to
Kordan Pty Limited v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2000) 46 ATR 191 referred to

WILLIAM MARIJANCEVIC v NEIL MANN, A DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

VID 1085 OF 2007
VID 1087 OF 2007

RYAN, KENNY & STONE JJ
8 SEPTEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1085 OF 2007 VID 1087 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

WILLIAM MARIJANCEVIC
Appellant

AND:

NEIL MANN, A DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGES:

RYAN, KENNY & STONE JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

8 SEPTEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

A.       In proceeding VID 1085 of 2007:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

B.       In proceeding VID 1087 of 2007:

1.        The appeal be dismissed.

2.          The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 1085 OF 2007
VID 1087 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM A SINGLE JUDGE OF THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

WILLIAM MARIJANCEVIC
Appellant

AND:

NEIL MANN
A DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
Respondent

JUDGES:

RYAN, KENNY & STONE JJ

DATE:

8 SEPTEMBER 2008

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

INTRODUCTION

  1. The appellant, William Marijancevic, appeals against orders made by a judge of the Court on 2 November 2007 in each of two proceedings heard by the primary judge together. The appeals have become VID 1085 of 2007 (“the assessment proceeding”)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marijancevic v Mann and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Marijancevic v Mann, the primary dispute between the parties revolved around whether the Commissioner of Taxation had engaged in deliberate or conscious maladministration of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (ITAA36) or had acted in excess of his powers when making default assessments against Mr Marijancevic. The core of the dispute was whether the Commissioner's actions, particularly in issuing garnishee notices and default assessments, were intended to prevent the return of seized funds to Mr Marijancevic rather than to assess his taxable income accurately. Mr Marijancevic argued that the default assessments were invalid and amounted to deliberate maladministration by the Commissioner.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Commissioner's issuance of the garnishee notices and default assessments constituted deliberate or conscious maladministration of the ITAA36, and if the Commissioner had acted beyond his statutory powers in making these assessments. This included whether the Commissioner's actions were taken in bad faith, and if there was evidence to support the notion that the assessments were designed to ensure that the funds seized by the Queensland Police were available to satisfy Mr Marijancevic's taxation obligations.

The court examined the Commissioner's actions in the context of statutory provisions, specifically sections 167 and 177 of the ITAA36, which provide for the making of default assessments and the conclusive evidence of assessments respectively. The court also considered the nature of the garnishee notices and their validity. The primary judge found that the Commissioner's actions were part of an audit process aimed at determining Mr Marijancevic's taxable income. Despite errors in the assessments, the court found no evidence of deliberate or conscious maladministration. The Commissioner's issuance of garnishee notices, although procedurally flawed, did not impact the validity of the default assessments. The court concluded that the Commissioner's actions were within his statutory powers and not in bad faith.

The appeals were dismissed, and Mr Marijancevic was ordered to pay the Commissioner's costs of the appeal. The court found no basis to support the claim of deliberate maladministration or excess of powers by the Commissioner.

Orders

Orders of the court

A. In proceeding VID 1085 of 2007:

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

B. In proceeding VID 1087 of 2007:

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties were in agreement that the outcome of these appeals turns largely on the question whether the Commissioner engaged in deliberate or conscious maladministration of the ITAA36, or deliberately or consciously acted in excess of his powers in making the default assessments to Mr Marijancevic. For the reasons that follow, the appeals should be dismissed.BACKGROUND From the summary made by the primary judge (see Marijancevic v Mann [2007] FCA 1648 (“Marijancevic v Mann”) at [6] and [7] of his reasons) of the evidence adduced at trial by Mr Marijancevic (also known as John William Henderson) and the Commissioner, and the material to which our attention was drawn, it can be said that there was before his Honour uncontested evidence to the following effect:·On 20 April 2002, Mr Marijancevic was arrested in Queensland in possession of approximately $620,000 in cash and was charged with possession of property reasonably suspected of being tainted and drug related offences. ·On about 21 April 2002, without Mr Marijancevic’s permission, the Queensland Police placed the money into a bank account nominated by the Police. ·On 27 November 2002, the Queensland Police faxed to the Serious Non-Compliance Team of the Australian Tax Office profile information on Mr Marijancevic (referred to in the faxed document as “John William Henderson”). ·On 30 November 2002, the Magistrates Court at Cairns dismissed the charges against Mr Marijancevic. ·An appeal against the dismissal of the charges was brought in the Cairns District Court.·A file note dated 21 January 2003 over the name of Alan Saunders, a Tax Office employee, noted that, in June/July 2000, Mr Marijancevic’s address was changed on bank statements from 84 Hamilton Street Yarraville (“the Yarraville address”) to 7 Burton Crescent Maribyrnong (“the Maribyrnong address”). This file note also recorded that the points noted “would suggest the purchase of a house (7 Burton Cres, Maribyong [sic]). Source of funds not known.” ·Mr Saunders’ subsequent file note of 24 January 2003 recorded that he had been advised by his team-leader to “ensure that garnishee action will be taken in respect of the money held by QPol[ice]”, and that “[j]udge is to hand down a decision about the money being returned to Henderson on 12 February 2003”.·Mr Saunders emailed Ronda Lynch (a Tax Office Accounts Receivable Officer) on 3 February 2003 saying “[a]ssuming all goes well with the keying/processing the debt will be on the system by this Friday” (7 February 2003) and that “[a]ny queries concerning this case should be referred to Gary Wicks … as I will be on leave for a minimum of two weeks and possibly 3 weeks”.·On 3 February 2003, the Commissioner requested a property search.·On 5 February 2003, the Commissioner issued a garnishee notice to “The Property Officer Cairns Police Station” requiring the officer, as a person who owes or may owe money to Mr Marijancevic, to pay the sum of $919,051.50 to the Commissioner, or if the money in his hands was less than that, then the whole of the available money. The garnishee notice named Ronda Lynch as contact officer.·On 5 February 2003, the Commissioner sent a letter (“the garnishee notice letter”) addressed to “Mr John William Henderson” (that is, Mr Marijancevic) at the Yarraville address informing him that the Commissioner’s records “show that an amount of $919,051.50 … remains unpaid on your account with this office” and that, as a consequence, a “notice under section 260-5 of Schedule 1 of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 has been issued”. This was, of course, a reference to the garnishee notice that had been issued to the Property Officer at the Cairns Police Station. This letter was signed by an officer in the Tax Office’s “SASP Debt Collection” for “Erin Holland Deputy Commissioner of Taxation” and named “Debt & Lodgement” as the contact officer.·On 5 February 2003, the Commissioner sent a letter (“the default assessments letter”) to Mr Marijancevic at the Maribyrnong address notifying him of the preparation of assessments under s 167 of the ITAA36 for years ended 1998, 2000, 2001 and 2002. This letter was headed “RE AUDIT: Years ended 30 June 1998 to 2002” and attached the calculation statements for each year. The letter was sent over the name “N Mann Deputy Commissioner of Taxation Small Business”, naming as contact officer the “Special Audit Manager”. The letter did not mention any garnishee notice.·On 6 February 2003, the result of the property search showed that Mr Marijancevic had transferred his interest in the property at the Yarraville address to his wife in August 1999, the consideration for the sale being “natural love and affection”.·On 10 February 2003, the Queensland Director of Public Prosecutions made a successful ex parte application to restrain any dealings with the $620,000.·On 11 February 2003, at 10:30 am, Mr Marijancevic spoke to Gary Wicks (a Tax Office employee filling in for Mr Saunders who was on leave). Mr Wicks said that he would chase up the file and ring back. According to a file note also dated 11 February 2003, Mr Wicks telephoned Mr Marijancevic at 3:20 pm that day, but Mr Marijancevic was unavailable and Mr Wicks left a message.·Also on 11 February 2003, the Commissioner issued notices of assessment of income tax to Mr Marijancevic in respect of each of the years of income ended 30 June 1998, 2000, 2001 and 2002. A certified extract of each notice of assessment was in evidence before the primary judge. The assessments in question were the default assessments, for an amount totalling $919,051.50. This was comprised of: (1) year ended 30 June 1998 – $173,373.73; (2) year ended 30 June 2000 – $272,722.06; (3) year ended 30 June 2001 – $441,059.70; and (4) year ended 30 June 2002 – $959,287.00. ·On 12 February 2003, the District Court allowed the appeal against the judgment of the Cairns Magistrates Court dismissing the charges against Mr Marijancevic.·On 3 March 2003, Mr Saunders signed a document headed “Serious Non-Compliance Team Audit Case Plan Update – Review Points” (“the audit report”). The audit report is discussed below.·On 6 March 2003, Mr Marijancevic objected to the assessments.·On 25 July 2003, the Commissioner issued a writ in the Supreme Court of Victoria claiming recovery of $1,008,564.95 with respect to the default assessments. This began the recovery proceeding. In his defence, Mr Marijancevic claimed that the Commissioner had not made a bona fide assessment of his taxable income. The action was transferred (on 7 June 2006) by consent to this Court.·On 4 March 2004, Mr Marijancevic’s objections were allowed in part (“the objection decisions”) and, on 14 April 2004, notices of amended assessments were issued to Mr Marijancevic for each of the relevant income years. ·On 29 April 2004, Mr Marijancevic applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) for review of the objection decisions under Part IVC of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) (“ the TAA”).·By an application and statement of claim filed in this Court on 9 June 2004, Mr Marijancevic applied under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) (“the Judiciary Act”), seeking, amongst other things, a declaration that the default assessments were void. This began the assessment proceeding.·On 27 June 2005, the Tribunal varied the objection decisions by allowing them to the following extent: (1) year ended 30 June 1998 – taxable income reduced to nil; (2) year ended 30 June 2000 – taxable income reduced to $52,780; (3) year ended 30 June 2001 – taxable income reduced to $34,731; and (4) year ended 30 June 2002 – taxable income reduced to $100,578.·On 25 August 2005, further notices of amended assessments were issued to Mr Marijancevic, to give effect to the decision of the Tribunal. A certified extract of each notice of amended assessment was in evidence before the primary judge.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the recovery proceeding, the Commissioner sought judgment in the amount of $121,068.01, being the amount certified under s 255-45 of Schedule 1 of the TAA as a debt due and payable by Mr Marijancevic as at 28 August 2007. This was the amount of the further amended assessments. It was common ground between the parties that, if Mr Marijancevic failed in the assessment proceeding, then the Commissioner was entitled to judgment in the recovery proceeding. In conformity with this understanding, the primary judge delivered judgments for Mr Marijancevic to pay the Commissioner the sum of $121,068.01 and dismissing the assessment proceeding. THE DECISION OF THE PRIMARY JUDGE The primary judge recorded that “[t]he essence of [Mr Marijancevic’s] case is that the assessment was not an attempt to assess income but an attempt to ‘justify’ a garnishee notice designed to prevent the return of the money to him”; i.e, to ensure “that the total of the assessments would at least equal the amount in the garnishee notice”. See Marijancevic v Mann at [14]. His Honour noted (at [14]) that:The Commissioner conceded that in computing the amount assessed for 2002 he had included two sums $31,141.62 and $255,571.52, totalling $286,713.14. The first was the amount of a cash deposit in [Mr Marijancevic’s] bank made on 21 February 2002. The second was the amount of a deposit on the same date made up in part by cash and the balance by cheque. [Mr Marijancevic] relies on a ‘Notice of acquisition of an interest in land’ relating to the sale by [him] of land at Sunshine for $285,000 payable by a deposit of $28,500. The notice does not disclose the date of the payment of the balance, but the date of possession/transfer is given as 20 February 2002. That was one day before the two bank deposits referred to above. Those bank deposits were doubtless the consideration received from the purchaser. Indeed, when [Mr Marijancevic] objected to the 2002 assessment, the Commissioner allowed the objection so far as it related to the $255,571.52 and part of the $31,141.62. [Mr Marijancevic] contends that the Commissioner’s inclusion of the two amounts in his computation for 2002 is ‘indicative of bad faith when you take into account the need … to boost the assessable income in order to justify the garnishee’. Referring to the audit report and the Commissioner’s 5 February 2003 letter informing Mr Marijancevic of the making of the assessments under s 167 of the ITAA36, the primary judge found that the Commissioner’s “assessments and garnishee actions were the result of an audit of [Mr Marijancevic’s] affairs in respect of the years ended 30 June 1998 to 2002”: Marijancevic v Mann at [15]. In relation to bank account credits, his Honour found (at [21]-[23]):The list of credits to [Mr Marijancevic’s] bank accounts used by the Commissioner to increase [his] taxable income for the year ended 30 June 2001 was in evidence. Credits relating to one savings account total $206,538, all but one item relating to interest. The other item was a cheque deposit of $200,000, which a note describes as an ‘unexplained deposit’. Credits relating to another savings account total $69,847, made up of cash deposits of $13,900, a cheque deposit of $55,616.83 and interest. These credits were all ‘treated as unidentified resulting in the Income Adjustment Increase of $69,847 being $331 for interest and $69,515 as unexplained deposits’.The Commissioner’s list of credits to [Mr Marijancevic’s] bank accounts for the year ending 30 June 2002 total $363,463. Apart from interest of $61, the other credits were included in the taxable income as ‘unexplained’. The total amount includes the two credits derived from the sale of the Sunshine property.Other documents show cash withdrawals of $76,900 between March 2001 and February 2002.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On appeal, as before the primary judge, the Commissioner accepted that the garnishee notice was invalid since it had preceded the making of the default assessments and there was no debt to support it. The Commissioner argued, however, that the invalidity of the garnishee notice had no bearing on whether there had been deliberate or conscious maladministration of the ITAA36 or the assessment process. The Commissioner submitted that there was no evidence to justify an inference of deliberate maladministration and that, on the contrary, the evidence as to the circumstances in which the assessments had been made supported the primary judge’s finding that the Commissioner had proceeded carefully to gather information to determine what, if any, amounts should be included in his taxable income. The Commissioner argued that the fact that the default assessments were shown to be incorrect to some extent on objection and review by the Tribunal did not establish the deliberate or conscious maladministration alleged by Mr Marijancevic. The Commissioner further argued that there had been no misuse of the power conferred by s 260-5 of Schedule 1 to the TAA to issue a garnishee notice, since this was a power that the Parliament had conferred to facilitate the Commissioner’s statutory duty to recover revenue for the Commonwealth and, in this case, the Commissioner’s officers had sought to exercise the power in order “to ensure that the funds seized by the Queensland Police were available to satisfy [Mr Marijancevic’s] taxation obligations”. The Commissioner submitted that the evidence adduced by Mr Marijancevic did not give rise to any circumstance that attracted the rule in Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298 (“Jones v Dunkel”) and Weissensteiner had no application. CONSIDERATION Section 167 of the ITAA36 relevantly provides that, if any person makes default in furnishing a return, the Commissioner may make an assessment of the amount upon which, in his judgment, income tax ought to be levied, and that amount shall be the taxable income of that person for the purposes of s 166. Section 175 of the ITAA36 provides that “[t]he validity of any assessment shall not be affected by reason that any of the provisions of the [ITAA36] have not been complied with”. Section 177 states in part that:(1)The production of a notice of assessment, or of a document under the hand of the Commissioner, a Second Commissioner, or a Deputy Commissioner, purporting to be a copy of a notice of assessment, shall be conclusive evidence of the due making of the assessment and, except in proceedings under Part IVC of the [TAA] on a review or appeal relating to the assessment, that the amount and all the particulars of the assessment are correct. …(4) The production of a document under the hand of the Commissioner, a Second Commissioner, or a Deputy Commissioner, purporting to be a copy of or extract from any return or notice of assessment shall be evidence of the matter therein set forth to the same extent as the original would be if it were produced. Section 177 of the ITAA36 is an evidentiary provision, designed to facilitate proof by the Commissioner of the making of an assessment: see Futuris at [64]-[67]. As noted already, certified extracts of the relevant notices of assessment were in evidence before the primary judge. Any income tax assessed is due and payable by the person liable to pay the tax at the time for which s 204(1) of the ITAA36 provides.