Lunney v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read
100 CLR 478

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA HAYLEY

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA Income Tax (Cth.)-Allowable deductions Losses and outgoings 1957-1958.

gaining or producing assessable income or

necessarily incurred in carrying on a business for the purpose of gaining or producing such income -Employee 1957,

in receipt of wages-Professional man carrying on practice-Claim by each SYDNEY,

deduct fares paid in journeys to and from place of work from and to place of Nov. 26-28;

residence-Whether deductible-Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1956 (No. 27 of 1936-No. 101 of 1956), 8. 51 (1). 1958, MELBOURNE,

Fares paid by taxpayers, whether employed or carrying on business on their own account, in travelling day by day from their homes to their places of employment or business and back again are not deductible expenses pur- suant to S. 51 (1) of the Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assess- ment Act 1936-1956 allowable against the assessable income earned in the employment or business.

So held by Dixon C.J., Williams, Kitto and Taylor JJ., McTiernan J. dis- senting.

CASES STATED.

Lunney v. Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of In an appeal to the High Court of Australia by Kenneth Edmond Lunney against an assessment to income tax made by the Com- missioner of Taxation in respect of the year ended 30th June 1957,

100 CLR 479

Kitto J. on 21st October 1957 stated a case for the opinion of the Full Court of the High Court substantially as follows:-1. The appellant is a ship's joiner by occupation and was employed in that capacity by the Union Steamship Company of New Zealand (herein- after called the company") for the whole of the period 1st July 1956 to 30th June 1957. 2. The appellant's hours of employment were from 7.45 a.m. to 4.30 p.m. daily Mondays to Fridays. He was required to report at the office of the company at no. 11 Darling Harbour, both at the commencement and at the completion of each day's work. From the said office he travelled at the expense of the company to various parts of the Port of Sydney to carry out his work. 3. At all material times the appellant resided at 64 Parr Parade, Narraweena, near Dee Why, an almost entirely residential suburb of Sydney, a large proportion of the working population of which travels to and from the city daily for the purpose of getting from their respective residences to their places of employment and returning therefrom to their respective residences. The approximate distance between Narraweena and no. 11 Darling Harbour is fourteen miles. 4. Throughout the period from 1st July 1956 to 30th June 1957 on days on which the appellant worked at his employment as aforesaid, he travelled from his said residence at Narraweena to the office of the company at Darling Harbour before 7.45 a.m. and travelled from the said office to his said residence after 4.30 p.m. During the said period he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lunney v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1958] HCA 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered appeals by Kenneth Edmond Lunney and Nigel Ralfe Hayley concerning the deductibility of daily travel expenses from their residences to their places of employment or business. Mr. Lunney, a ship's joiner, claimed a deduction for £62 in bus fares incurred travelling between his home in Narraweena and his work at Darling Harbour. Dr. Hayley, a dentist practising in Sydney, claimed a deduction for £28 in train fares incurred travelling between his home in Strathfield and his professional rooms. The Commissioner of Taxation disallowed these claims in both instances.

The central legal issue before the Full Court of the High Court was whether the fares paid by the taxpayers for their daily journeys to and from their places of work or business constituted losses or outgoings that were deductible under section 51(1) of the *Income Tax and Social Services Contribution Assessment Act 1936-1956*. Specifically, the Court had to determine if these expenses were incurred in gaining or producing assessable income, or necessarily incurred in carrying on a business for that purpose, and whether they were of a capital, private, or domestic nature, which would render them non-deductible.

The majority of the Court, comprising Dixon C.J., Williams, Kitto, and Taylor JJ., held that the fares paid for daily travel between home and work were not deductible. The Court reasoned that these expenses were not incurred in gaining or producing assessable income, nor were they necessarily incurred in carrying on a business for that purpose. Instead, such travel was considered to arise from the taxpayer's choice of residence and was therefore of a private or domestic nature, falling within the exclusionary part of section 51(1). While acknowledging that times had changed and the financial significance of such deductions was considerable, the Court affirmed that the established legal principle, supported by long-standing Australian and English authorities, was that these daily commuting expenses were not deductible.

McTiernan J. dissented, finding that the fares were incurred in gaining or producing assessable income. He argued that the phrase "incurred in gaining or producing" should be interpreted broadly to include expenses necessarily incurred to enable the taxpayer to perform their duties, even if incurred outside the strict temporal or physical limits of work. He distinguished the present cases from those where business was conducted at home, suggesting that the distinction between private and non-private outgoings should not solely depend on whether the taxpayer resided at their place of business. Despite his dissenting view, the majority decision prevailed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established