Jonathan Ting and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

[2015] AATA 166 

Division TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION

File Number

2014/5244

Re

Jonathan Ting

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President F J Alpins

Date of oral decision

23 February 2015
Date of written reasons 20 March 2015
Place Melbourne

For the reasons given orally at the conclusion of the hearing of this matter, the Tribunal varies the decision under review so that the objection is allowed in part on the further basis that the applicant is allowed a deduction in the amount of $11,844.15 for the year of income ending 30 June 2013.

.......[sgd.................................................................

Deputy President F J Alpins

TAXATION – income tax – allowable deductions – whether expenses incurred in undertaking post-graduate studies in management were incurred “in gaining or producing” applicant’s assessable income as school teacher – Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) s 8-1

TAXATION - administrative penalty – false or misleading statement – whether shortfall amount resulted from a failure to take reasonable care – whether remission of penalty warranted

Legislation

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth), s 8-1
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 82A

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), ss 14ZZK; ss 284-75, 284-85, 284-90, 298-20 Sch 1

Cases

Aurora Developments Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (No 2) (2011) 196 FCR 457

Baini v R (2012) 246 CLR 469

Commissioner of Taxation v Anstis (2010) 241 CLR 443

Commissioner of Taxation v Day (2008) 236 CLR 163

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Finn (1961) 106 CLR 60

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Hatchett (1971) 125 CLR 494

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Klan (1985) 16 ATR 176

Federal Commissioner of Taxation vMaddalena (1971) 2 ATR 541

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Payne (2001) 202 CLR 93

Federal Commissioner of Taxation  v Cooper (1991) 29 FCR 177

Ronpibon Tin NL v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1949) 78 CLR 47

Sanctuary Lakes Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2013) 212 FCR 483

Sent v Commissioner of Taxation (2012) 128 ALD 34

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President F J Alpins

20 March 2015

Written statement of oral reasons

  1. On 23 February 2015, the Tribunal heard this application for review.  After a brief adjournment, the Tribunal gave reasons orally for its decision.  The parties have requested a written statement of those reasons.  That statement, set out below, is an edited version of the transcript of the Tribunal’s oral reasons, with headings added for convenience.

    Introduction

  2. This application for review primarily concerns the issue of whether certain expenses incurred by the applicant, Mr Ting, in undertaking post-graduate studies were deductible under s 8-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (the “ITAA 1997”) from his assessable income earned as a school teacher during the year of income ending 30 June 2013.

  3. During that year of income, the applicant was employed on a full-time basis as a teacher at Greensborough Secondary College.  He was also enrolled as a part-time student in what was then known as the “Postgraduate Diploma in Management”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jonathan Ting and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Jonathan Ting against the Commissioner of Taxation involved a dispute over the deductibility of expenses incurred by the applicant for post-graduate studies in management during the 2013 year of income. The Commissioner argued that the expenses were not deductible as they did not have a necessary connection to the applicant’s income as a school teacher, as required by section 8-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth). The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the expenses for the course were wholly deductible and, if not, to what extent they were deductible.

The primary legal issue was whether the expenses for the post-graduate course in management were deductible under section 8-1 of the ITAA 1997, which pertains to deductions for expenses incurred in gaining or producing assessable income. The Court considered the nature of the applicant's employment as a classroom teacher and the content of the course. The applicant argued that the course was beneficial to his teaching duties, while the Commissioner contended that the course expenses were not connected to the applicant's income-earning activities as a teacher.

The Tribunal concluded that the expenses for the course were not deductible because they did not have a necessary connection to the applicant's income as a classroom teacher. The Tribunal noted that the applicant's duties as a teacher were pedagogical in nature and that the course did not improve or maintain his skills and knowledge as a teacher. The Tribunal found that the applicant's motivation for undertaking the course was not sufficient to establish a necessary connection to his income-earning activities. The Tribunal also considered the administrative penalty imposed on the applicant for making a false or misleading statement and decided that there were no additional circumstances warranting further remission of the penalty beyond that already granted by the Commissioner.

The Tribunal varied the objection decision to allow the applicant a partial deduction of $11,844.15 for the year of income ending 30 June 2013, corresponding to the respondent's concession regarding four of the six subjects originally in issue. The Tribunal held that the applicant's motivation and the nature of the course did not establish a necessary connection to his income-earning activities, and therefore, the expenses were not deductible.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent contended that the applicant’s expenses for the course were not wholly deductible and that, although the applicant’s expenses with respect to the conceded subjects were deductible, the applicant’s expenses with respect to the disputed subjects were not. The respondent maintained that, when regard is had to the applicant's duties as a teacher and the nature of the course he undertook and the subjects still in dispute, neither the expenses for the course considered as a whole, nor those relating to those particular subjects, have the requisite nexus with the gaining or producing of the applicant's income for the purposes of s 8(1) of the ITAA 1997. Facts During the 2013 year of income, the applicant was employed as a “Classroom Teacher Range 2”, being one of two job classifications (range 1 and range 2), according to salary range, for classroom teachers set out in a document published by the Victorian education department which concerns teachers’ roles and responsibilities. It is stated in that document that “[t]he primary focus of the classroom teacher is on the planning, preparation and teaching of programs to achieve specific student outcomes”. The document distinguishes classroom teachers from “leading teachers”. It says with respect to the latter:“Leading teachers will be highly skilled classroom practitioners and undertake leadership and management roles commensurate with their salary range. The role of leading teachers is to improve the skill, knowledge and performance of the teaching workforce in a school or group of schools and to improve the curriculum program of a school. Typically, leading teachers are responsible for coordinating a number of staff ….. Leading teachers are expected to lead and manage a significant area or function within the school …” The applicant teaches science and maths at a senior school level. During the relevant year of income, the applicant taught the following subjects – psychology, chemistry, mathematics and science. The applicant’s duties also included organising a school activity, being the school’s participation in the “State Schools Spectacular”, which involved budgeting for that activity, selection of participants and arranging costumes and bus travel. He also coached school sporting teams, such as soccer and softball. Those duties are contemplated in the document to which I have referred as duties which a classroom teacher of his classification may be required to undertake “in addition to their rostered teaching duties”. The course in which the applicant was enrolled during the relevant year of income is described on the Melbourne Business School’s website as “the entry path-way into” the part-time MBA program. It is said to provide “a comprehensive introduction to the major areas of business management”. Furthermore, it is described as:“encompass[ing] an academically rigorous, current and practical curriculum aimed at developing managerial awareness, skills and judgement. It introduces students to the disciplines and concepts used in the management of business, government and non-profit organizations”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 298-20(1) in Sch 1 to the TAA provides that the Commissioner may remit all or a part of the penalty. I am not satisfied, having regard to the applicant’s particular circumstances, that it is appropriate to remit all or any further part (beyond that already remitted by the respondent) under s 298-20 (see Sanctuary Lakes Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (2013) 212 FCR 483 at [249] per Griffiths J (Edmonds J agreeing). Given my finding with respect to the applicant’s primary motivation in incurring the course expenses, which affected the basis upon which the deduction was in fact claimed by the applicant, I do not consider that the fact that the respondent has conceded some of the claimed deduction warrants further remission of the remaining penalty. There are no other circumstances arising from the evidence warranting remission beyond that which has already been granted. Conclusion Given my conclusion that neither the course expenses as a whole, nor those relating to the disputed subjects in particular, were deductible during the relevant year of income and given my conclusions about the penalty assessment, it follows that the objection decision is to be varied solely to give effect to the respondent’s concession with respect to four of the six subjects originally in issue. Accordingly, the objection decision is varied so that the objection is allowed in part on the further basis that the applicant is allowed a deduction in the amount of $11,844.15 for the year of income ending 30 June 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, in my view the applicant’s motivation is significant to the issue of the applicant’s liability to an administrative penalty and its remission, as I explain later in these reasons. Consideration As I have indicated, the first issue to be addressed is whether the applicant’s expenses in undertaking the course considered in its entirety are deductible under s 8-1. I have concluded that they are not. The occasion of those outgoings is not found in that which was productive of the applicant’s assessable income. The evidence before the Tribunal establishes that what was productive of the applicant’s assessable income was his employment as a classroom teacher, his tasks and duties in that respect being essentially pedagogical in nature. His involvement in organising a school activity and coaching school sports were ancillary to his classroom teaching. His responsibilities accorded in fact with those of a Classroom Teacher Range 2 described in the departmental document to which I have referred. I accept the respondent’s submission that the applicant’s income-earning activities as a classroom teacher stand in contradistinction to those of a leading teacher, which is a management role. The evidence, including both the applicant’s oral evidence and the departmental document to which I have referred, establishes that employment as a classroom teacher is materially different from employment as a leading teacher. Promotion to the position of a leading teacher does not merely constitute increased income for the same income-earning activities; rather, it involves engagement in relevantly new income-earning activities for the purposes of s 8-1. Put simply, it means more pay for doing a different job. The course was not required as a condition of the applicant's employment, nor was it required in order to fulfil his tasks and duties (cf Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Finn (1961) 106 CLR 60 at 67, cited in Day at [33]). Furthermore, the evidence establishes that it would not bring about an increase in his income from his current employment (cf Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Hatchett (1971) 125 CLR 494 at 498). That required employment as a leading teacher. Given its nature, the course did not improve or maintain the applicant's skills and knowledge as a teacher (cf. Finn); rather, it had the more general effect of increasing the likelihood of him being a better teacher, but that connection is too tenuous to make the course expenses deductible (Hatchett at 499). While the applicant feels that the course made and makes him a better teacher, more responsive to the needs of students and parents and while it is admirable that he sees himself as a representative of the school at all times, those matters are not to the point. The fact that the applicant perceives there to be a connection between his course expenses and his current employment as a classroom teacher does not, in itself, justify deductibility – in that sense, as the High Court warned in Day (at [29]), the expression “perceived connection” used in Hatchett (at 499) can be misunderstood as giving the taxpayer’s subjective opinion a part to play in determining whether his or her expenditure is deductible (Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Klan (1985) 16 ATR 176 at 182-183 per Ormiston J).