David Ford and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2014] AATA  361

Division SMALL TAXATION CLAIMS TRIBUNAL

File Number

2013/2680

Re

David Ford

APPLICANT

And

Commissioner of Taxation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S E Frost

Date   27 May 2014
Date of written reasons 6 June 2014
Place Sydney

The objection decision is affirmed.

......................[SGD]..................................................

Deputy President S E Frost

CATCHWORDS

TAXATION – Income tax – allowable deductions – travel expenses – train guard – transport of materials between home and work – whether materials bulky and essential to income generating activity- whether secure environment provided – whether personal choice involved – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997; s 8-1

CASES

Lunney v Commissioner of Taxation (1958) 100 CLR 478

Commissioner of Taxation v Vogt [1975] 1 NSWLR 194; 75 ATC 4073

Re Crestani and Commissioner of Taxation [1998] AATA 612; (1998) 40 ATR 1037; 98 ATC 2219

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S E Frost

6 June 2014

  1. On 27 May 2014, at the conclusion of the hearing, I delivered an oral decision in this matter, affirming the decision under review.  The respondent Commissioner of Taxation has asked for a statement in writing of the reasons for my decision.  Those reasons follow.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The application relates to a claim for a tax deduction in relation to work-related car expenses for the 2010 income year.

  3. The basis of the claim is that, during the relevant income year, Mr Ford was required by his work circumstances to carry bulky equipment between his workplace and home.  He says that the bulky equipment was unable to be stored securely at his workplace.  In those circumstances he was forced to carry the equipment every day to and from home.   The only way he could do that is by car.

  4. The simple question before the Tribunal is whether Mr Ford is entitled, under s 8-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, to the deduction claimed.

    BACKGROUND

  5. Mr Ford has worked as a City Rail Intercity Train Guard for Rail Corporation New South Wales for about 28 years.  I will refer to his employer as “RailCorp” although its name now appears to have been changed to Transport NSW Sydney Trains.

  6. When he lodged his 2010 income tax return, Mr Ford did not claim a deduction for work-related car expenses.  In fact, it seems that he had never claimed this type of deduction over the many years he had worked as a train guard. 

  7. However, he gathered from discussions that he had with his workmates in late 2012 or early 2013 that some of them were claiming deductions of this kind.  Mr Ford asked his tax agent if it was possible to claim a deduction for 2010, but when the agent asked for Mr Ford’s return to be amended, the Commissioner said the amendment period had already expired.  So the tax agent, on Mr Ford’s behalf, lodged an objection against Mr Ford’s assessment for the 2010 year.  The objection was also out of time, but the Commissioner granted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read David Ford and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 361
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

David Ford sought a tax deduction for travel expenses between his home and workplace, arguing that he needed to transport essential materials and equipment for his role as a train guard. The Commissioner of Taxation disallowed the deduction, leading to a review by the Tribunal. The central legal issue was whether Mr Ford's travel expenses were deductible under section 8-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the transport of bulky and essential materials between home and work constituted an allowable deduction or remained a personal choice, which would render it non-deductible.

The Tribunal considered whether the materials Mr Ford transported were both bulky and essential to his work, and if taking them home constituted more than just travel between home and work. The Tribunal acknowledged that Mr Ford had essential equipment that did not fit in his locker at Moss Vale station, but it also noted that he had a choice in what he transported home. The Tribunal concluded that this choice meant the transport did not qualify as a deduction under the exceptions to the general rule that home-work travel expenses are not deductible. The Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's decision, holding that Mr Ford's transport expenses were not deductible as they did not meet the stringent criteria established by previous cases, particularly Lunney v Commissioner of Taxation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The simple question before the Tribunal is whether Mr Ford is entitled, under s 8-1 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, to the deduction claimed.BACKGROUND Mr Ford has worked as a City Rail Intercity Train Guard for Rail Corporation New South Wales for about 28 years. I will refer to his employer as “RailCorp” although its name now appears to have been changed to Transport NSW Sydney Trains. When he lodged his 2010 income tax return, Mr Ford did not claim a deduction for work-related car expenses. In fact, it seems that he had never claimed this type of deduction over the many years he had worked as a train guard. However, he gathered from discussions that he had with his workmates in late 2012 or early 2013 that some of them were claiming deductions of this kind. Mr Ford asked his tax agent if it was possible to claim a deduction for 2010, but when the agent asked for Mr Ford’s return to be amended, the Commissioner said the amendment period had already expired. So the tax agent, on Mr Ford’s behalf, lodged an objection against Mr Ford’s assessment for the 2010 year. The objection was also out of time, but the Commissioner granted an extension of time, effectively accepting the objection as if it had been lodged within time. The objection sought a deduction of $3,700, calculated on the “cents per kilometre” basis, at $0.74 per kilometre for the maximum 5,000 km allowed. No basis other than the cents per kilometre basis was available to Mr Ford, since he had not kept a log book during the relevant income year. The objection was disallowed, which is why the matter is now before the Tribunal.THE DEDUCTION CLAIM Mr Ford’s case is this:·His base of operation is Moss Vale railway station – this is where he starts and finishes all his shifts;·He lives in the Camden area, about 85 kilometres away from Moss Vale station;·RailCorp has issued him with a lot of materials and equipment that are essential to the carrying out of his functions as a train guard;·He has a locker available to him at Moss Vale station;·Not all of the materials and equipment issued to him by RailCorp fit into the locker;·He is liable to RailCorp for the loss of any of the equipment issued to him;·Anything that does not fit into the locker cannot be stored securely at Moss Vale station;·He has to take any excess materials and equipment home with him every day;·The materials he has to transport are bulky;·The only reasonable way he can transport the materials is by car;·The cost of travelling by car between his workplace and home should be deductible as a loss or outgoing incurred “in gaining or producing [his] assessable income”, in the words of s 8-1.DEDUCTIBILITY The starting point in a case such as this is the well-established principle that travel between home and a place of employment is not deductible: Lunney v Commissioner of Taxation (1958) 100 CLR 478. But there are exceptions to that general principle. One category of exception, which is relevant in Mr Ford’s case, is the circumstance in which a worker carries, between work and home, equipment which is both bulky and essential to the income-generating activity. In some circumstances that transport can be characterised as something other than simply “travel between work and home”.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Even if it were the case that his locker did not accommodate all the equipment issued to him by RailCorp, and he chose to store the non-essential equipment (such as his wet weather gear) in the locker and transport his essential equipment, his claim would similarly fail. That would also be a matter of personal choice, and personal choice of that kind is not enough to displace the principle established in Lunney’s case that transport between work and home is not deductible.CONCLUSION For these reasons the objection decision is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established