Lonsdale Investments v OM (Manganese) Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   LONDSDALE INVESTMENTS PTY LTD -v- OM (MANGANESE) LTD  [2009] WASC 188

CORAM:   BEECH J

HEARD:   ON THE PAPERS

DELIVERED          :   2 JULY 2009

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1830 of 2006

BETWEEN:   LONDSDALE INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 091 245 144)

First Plaintiff

PROMET ENGINEERS PTY LTD (ACN 115 687 057)
Second Plaintiff

AND

OM (MANGANESE) LTD  (ABN 60 097 091 506)
Defendant

FILE NO/S              :CIV 2283 of 2006

BETWEEN             :OM (MANGANESE) LTD (ABN 60 097 091 506)

Plaintiff (by Counterclaim)

AND

LONDSDALE INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 091 245 144)
First Defendant (by Counterclaim)

PROMET ENGINEERS PTY LTD (ACN 115 687 057)
Second Defendant (by Counterclaim)

JAMES DINSDALE CRIBBES
Third Defendant (by Counterclaim)

DEREK MACAULEY
Fourth Defendant (by Counterclaim)
 

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Pleadings - Strike-out application - Application for further particulars - Whether pleadings and particulars too general - Whether pleadings to be read with expert evidence - Whether pleadings or particulars should refer to expert evidence

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Further particulars ordered

Category:    B

Representation:

CIV 1830 of 2006

Counsel:

First Plaintiff                  :     No appearance

Second Plaintiff             :     No appearance

Defendant:     No appearance

Solicitors:

First Plaintiff                  :     Sparke Helmore

Second Plaintiff             :     Sparke Helmore

Defendant:     Middletons

CIV 2283 of 2006

Counterclaim

Counsel:

Plaintiff (by Counterclaim)    :       No appearance

First Defendant (by Counterclaim)   :                 No appearance

Second Defendant (by Counterclaim)       :        No appearance

Third Defendant (by Counterclaim) :                 No appearance

Fourth Defendant (by Counterclaim)        :        No appearance

Solicitors:

Plaintiff (by Counterclaim)    :       Middletons

First Defendant (by Counterclaim)   :                 Sparke Helmore

Second Defendant (by Counterclaim)       :        Sparke Helmore

Third Defendant (by Counterclaim) :                 Sparke Helmore

Fourth Defendant (by Counterclaim)        :        Sparke Helmore

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281; (2006) 33 WAR 82

Bond Corporation Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd (1987) 14 FCR 215

Charlie Carter Pty Ltd v The Shop, Distributive & Allied Employees' Association of Western Australia (1987) 13 FCR 413

MacMahon Contractors Pty Ltd v Woodside Energy Ltd [2008] WASC 271

Murchison Zinc Company Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 167

  1. BEECH J:  The defendants by counterclaim (the Promet parties) apply to strike out paragraphs of OM  (Manganese) Ltd's (OMM) amended defence and counterclaim dated 13 March 2009.  Alternatively, the Promet parties apply for further particulars of those paragraphs.  In partial response to the application OMM has filed an amended defence and counterclaim dated 28 May 2009.  The application has proceeded by reference to the latter pleading.

Strikeout application - principles

  1. In Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority [2006] WASC 281; (2006) 33 WAR 82 Martin CJ said as follows:

    It is, I think, important when approaching an issue of that kind to bring to mind the contemporary purposes of pleadings. The purposes of pleadings are, I think, well known and include the definition of the issues to be determined in the case and enabling assessment of whether…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lonsdale Investments v OM (Manganese) Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] WASC 188
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lonsdale Investments Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, brought an action against OM (Manganese) Ltd, the defendant, and others concerning alleged defects in the design and construction of a manganese processing plant. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the primary legal issue was whether the defendant's pleadings and particulars were sufficiently detailed to avoid a strike-out application. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the pleadings were too general and whether they should refer to or be read in conjunction with expert evidence provided by the parties.

In addressing the issue, the court examined the allegations made by the defendant in its pleadings. The defendant had alleged that the plant's inability to produce ore at the specified rates was due to defective work, but had not provided sufficient details to support this claim. The court held that while it is permissible to plead that one thing caused another, the defendant needed to provide more facts to establish the causal link. The court further noted that the defendant's reliance on expert evidence should not substitute for specific allegations in the pleadings and particulars. The court concluded that the defendant needed to provide particulars identifying what it alleged the capability of the plant was and any facts relied on to support the allegation that the defective design work caused the plant's incapacity.

Based on its reasoning, the court ordered the defendant to provide further particulars to clarify the allegations in its pleadings. The order required the defendant to specify the alleged capability of the plant and the facts supporting the claim that the alleged incapacity was caused by the defective design work. This ruling ensured that the defendant's case would be sufficiently delineated for trial, thereby preventing any potential strike-out of the pleadings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Further particulars ordered

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This paragraph pleads that the plant's incapacity to produce ore at the specified rates was a consequence of the defective work pleaded in par 28(b). Whether it is sufficient to plead simply that one thing caused another, or whether further facts must be pleaded to establish the causal link, will depend upon the pleaded facts and circumstances: see, for example, Bond Corporation v Thiess (221 ‑ 222). OMM says in its letter of 12 June 2009 that in relation to par 28(c)(ii) it relies on pars 307 ‑ 313 of the report of Mr Hearse. In that report, Mr Hearse compares the reclaim rate specified in the design criteria with the actual reclaim rate of the plant. OMM also point to parts of the report of Mr Ooms served by the Promet parties. Paragraphs 777 ‑ 780 of Mr Ooms' report relate to other factors that may have contributed to the process plant not operating according to the design criteria. On the face of it, the fact that other factors may have caused or contributed to any failure or apparent incapacity of the plant to operate in accordance with the design criteria might be thought to underline the need for OMM to delimit its case. In particular it supports the need for OMM to identify:(a)what it says the capability of the plant was (if it says the actual throughput reflected the limits of the capability of the plant it should say so); and(b)any facts on which it relies in alleging that the pleaded defective work caused the plant's pleaded incapacity. The Promet parties' submissions emphasise that the relevant parts of Mr Hearse's report do not refer to the capacity of the plant, but to its actual throughput. As I have said, I accept that that is so. That it is so would not, in my view, preclude OMM from relying on the stated parts of Mr Hearse's report to delimit its case. It will be a matter for resolution at trial whether the actual throughput of the plant reflected its inherent incapacity (as distinct from being caused by other matters) and, if so, whether that incapacity was caused by the relevant design work. In my view, OMM should give particulars of the allegations in par 28(c)(ii):(a)identifying what it alleges the capability of the plant was in the relevant period; and(b)setting out any facts relied on in support of the allegation that the alleged incapability was caused by the defective design work pleaded in par 28(b). Whether OMM gives those particulars by reference to identified paragraphs of Mr Hearse's report or otherwise is a matter for OMM. Paragraph 28(d) and its particulars are in these terms:(d)Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2, caused the completion and commissioning of the Plant to be delayed by approximately 5 months 2 weeks. Particulars(i)practical completion and commissioning of the Plant took place on 26 May 2006;(ii)the following items of design work or information caused delays to the fabricated steel work:a.Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2, delays in providing issued for construction drawings;b.Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2, revisions to issued for construction drawings after fabrication commenced;(iii)Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2, failed to take any proper account of or undertake an assessment of the steel fabricators proposed steel substitutions for the fabrication of steel in China prior to authorising that fabrication could commence as follows:a.The proposed steel substitutions were provided on 22 and 25 July 2005;b.Authorisation to fabricate was given in Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2 on 25 July 2005;c.All steelwork substitutions were subsequently rejected by Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2 on 25 October 2005, after assessment by Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2, the consequences of which was delay in completion of steel fabrication caused by the need to refabricate or rectify rejected steelwork;(iv)Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2, failed to provide start up assistance and engineering support for shop detailing in China prior to authorising fabrication commencement as follows:a.Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2 was, pursuant to clause 3.1.1(d) of E1184 Rev P7, responsible for engineering support for shop detailing in China;b.Engineering support for shop detailing in China included responsibility for ensuring that the shop detailing and fabrication proceeded with current design drawings and that any new or revised design drawings were brought to the attention of the shop detailers and fabricators (drawing reconciliation):c.Authorisation to fabricate was given on 25 July 2005;d.Promet 1, further or alternatively Promet 2 allowed steelwork fabrication to proceed in the absence of any start up assistance and engineering support the consequence of which was delay in completion of steel fabrication caused by the need to refabricate or rectify rejected steelwork based upon unreconciled design drawings.