JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: HEALTHSAFE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD -v- PATTERSON [2022] WASC 194
CORAM: REGISTRAR WHITBREAD
HEARD: 11 NOVEMBER 2021
DELIVERED : 3 JUNE 2022
FILE NO/S: CIV 1621 of 2017
BETWEEN: HEALTHSAFE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
MARCELLE ANN PATTERSON
JOHN LESLIE PATTERSON
Defendants
Catchwords:
Practice & procedure - Application to strike out parts of defence to the re-amended statement of claim and further amended counterclaim - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Rules of Supreme Court 1971 (WA)
Result:
Application granted
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | Mr A Metaxas |
| Defendants | : | Mr N Andreou |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Metaxas Legal |
| Defendants | : | Monaco Lawyers |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Breen v Williams [1996] HCA 57
Clay v Clay (1999) 20 WAR 427; [1999] WASCA 8
English v Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd [2021] WASCA 47
Hospital Products Ltd v United States Surgical Corporation [1984] HCA 64; (1984) 156 CLR 41
In re Blundell; Blundell v. Blundell (1888) 40 Ch D 370
Pitt v Holt [2013] 2 AC 108; [2013] 3 All ER 429
Vantage Holdings Group Pty Ltd v Donnelly [No 4] [2019] WASC 398
REGISTRAR WHITBREAD:
The Application
The plaintiff (Healthsafe) filed an application on 21 July 2021 to strike out pars 41, 43, 44, 45, 46, 51, 52, and 53 of the defence to the re-amended statement of claim and the amended counterclaim (Defence and Counterclaim) filed on 8 July 2021 (Application) together with an application for an extension of time to file the Application. The paragraphs in issue all fall within that part of the Defence and Counterclaim that pleads the counterclaim. There was also an application for further and better discovery which has fallen away (save as to costs of the application).
The parties have filed written submissions and affidavits respectively in support of, and in opposition to, the Application as set out in more detail below. The Application was heard on 11 November 2021.
The parties pleaded cases
It is usual to set out the parties' pleaded cases before dealing with the issues raised on a strike out application. Neither of the parties set out the facts and background of the dispute or summarised their respective pleadings. I have summarised the facts and background and the parties' respective positions below in order to put the Application into its proper context. Where the parties are individual persons it is convenient to refer to them by their first names. No disrespect is intended by that approach.
Facts and Background
From 15 July 2002 to a date in October 2018, Healthsafe was the registered proprietor of leased office premises (Property) in its capacity as trustee of the Winton Road Property Trust (Trust).
There are 100 issued units in the Trust. Healthsafe claims that the defendants, Marcelle Ann Patterson (Marcelle) and John Leslie Patterson (John) own 51 units and Rachael Eilene Clohessy (Rachael) owns 49 units. Marcelle and John assert that they own 56…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Healthsafe Australia Pty Ltd v Patterson and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] WASC 194
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the Trust, as alleged by the plaintiffs, was validly created and if the transfers and resolutions were indeed void due to breaches of fiduciary duty by Healthsafe. Key issues included the proper identification of the beneficiaries of the Trust, the validity of the transfers of trust units, and the extent of any breaches of fiduciary duty by Healthsafe in its role as trustee. Additionally, the court had to assess the pleadings to determine if they sufficiently established the claims and counterclaims, considering the extensive history of amendments and re-amendments to the pleadings. The court's analysis focused on the adequacy of the pleadings to support the claims, the legal principles governing fiduciary duties and trust administration, and the consequences of any breaches on the validity of the Trust and its transactions.
The court concluded that the pleadings were inadequate in several respects, failing to sufficiently establish the material facts necessary to support the claims. The court held that the plaintiffs' pleadings did not adequately address the underlying causes of action, particularly in relation to the alleged breaches of fiduciary duty and the validity of the Trust. The court also found that the counterclaims were not sufficiently pleaded to allow for a fair determination of the issues. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' claims, finding that the pleadings did not meet the required standard for proceeding to trial. The court ordered that the plaintiffs' claims be struck out due to their insufficiency.
The court made no orders as to costs, leaving the parties to bear their own costs of the proceedings. This decision underscores the importance of precise and detailed pleadings in complex litigation, particularly in cases involving trusts and fiduciary duties.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In broad terms, Healthsafe seeks declarations going to breach of duties, under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by Marcelle; rectification of the ASIC register as to directors' appointments; damages for trespass; an account from Marcelle and John for monies received as agents for Healthsafe; and an indemnity for liability under the IPT Contract from Marcelle. Marcelle and John, respectively the first and second plaintiff by counterclaim, claim that the Trust was created by deed dated 7 January 2002 (Trust Deed) and the unit holders were the Deceased and Rachael (10 units), Marcelle and John (56 units) and Meegan (34 units). On Marcelle and John's case, Meegan's units were wrongfully, or invalidly and ineffectively, transferred from Meegan to the Deceased and Rachael in breach of the Trust Deed (Transfer). Healthsafe, the first defendant by counterclaim, is the trustee of the Trust; from 21 December 2015 Rachael, the second defendant by counterclaim, was the sole director of Healthsafe and from 2004, the sole shareholder. Marcelle and John claim that Healthsafe, as trustee, has breached fiduciary duties to the beneficiaries of the Trust and failed to comply with specified terms of the Trust Deed. Healthsafe, as trustee, has failed to avoid a conflict of interest; has made payments to, or for the benefit of Rachael, where payments were not made to Marcelle or John; has failed to take all relevant matters into account; and has breached the Trust Deed. It is the form of pleading of those alleged breaches of fiduciary duty which are the subject of the Application. As a consequence of the alleged breaches, Marcelle and John claim that the Transfer and resolutions passed on 8 January 2002 and 15 December 2009 to the benefit of the Deceased and Rachael (Resolutions) are void and of no effect. As a consequence of the alleged breaches Marcelle and John also claim that Rachael has wrongfully received monies directly or the benefit of monies. Marcelle and John claim that they have made loans to Healthsafe which have not been repaid. In broad terms, Marcelle and John seek, as against Healthsafe, declarations in respect of the Transfer and the Resolutions, compensation and/or damages, an account in respect of the Trust and an order that the Trust be wound up. As against Rachael they seek a declaration that monies wrongfully received by her are held on trust for them or compensation and/or damages. Both sides of this case have had multiple attempts at pleading their respective claims. Regrettably, the pleadings remain far from satisfactory. Some brief examples will suffice to illustrate this. First, at pars 12 to 18 of the re-amended statement of claim, Healthsafe pleads an exchange of correspondence between the parties' respective solicitors between September 2016 and March 2017. Each paragraph takes the form that by a letter of a certain date, one party in effect informed the other of certain matters, and made demands, or responded to demands made, under the threat of commencing legal proceedings. The matters asserted in that correspondence are not separately pleaded as material facts. The fact of demands having been made and not met might explain why this proceeding was commenced, but it is difficult to see how the making of demands in correspondence between solicitors is material to the underlying causes of action now asserted.