Murchison Zinc Co Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE FULL COURT (WA)

CITATION:   MURCHISON ZINC COMPANY PTY LTD -v- THIESS CONTRACTORS PTY LTD [2000] WASCA 167

CORAM:   STEYTLER J

WHEELER J

HEARD:   8 JUNE 2000

DELIVERED          :   20 JUNE 2000

FILE NO/S:   FUL 52 of 2000

BETWEEN:   MURCHISON ZINC COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 008 950 178)

Appellant (Defendant)

AND

THIESS CONTRACTORS PTY LTD (ACN 010 221 486)
Respondent (Plaintiff)

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Supreme Court procedure - Pleadings - Engineering contract - Application to strike out part of statement of claim - Whether statement of claim adequately particularised - Application to strike out refused even though pleading defective since issues to be defined otherwise than by pleading

Legislation:

Rules of the Supreme Court, O 20 r 8, r 13, r 19

Supreme Court Act 1935, s 60(1)(f)

Trade Practices Act 1974, s 51A, s 52

Result:

Application for leave to appeal refused

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant (Defendant)    :     Mr D J Martino

Respondent (Plaintiff)    :     Mr P G Clifford

Solicitors:

Appellant (Defendant)    :     Pullinger Readhead Stewart

Respondent (Plaintiff)    :     Fiocco Hopkins Nash

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Banque Commerciale SA (In Liq) v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279

Gould v Mount Oxide Mines Ltd (In Liq) (1916) 22 CLR 490

Jingellic Minerals NL v Abigroup Ltd (1992) 7 WAR 566

John Holland Construction & Engineering Pty Ltd v Kvaerner R J Brown Pty Ltd (1997) 13 BCL 262

SCM Chemicals Ltd v Saipem Australia Pty Ltd (1991) 4 WAR 569

Western Australia v Bond Corporation Holdings Ltd (1991) 5 WAR 40

Wilson v Metaxas [1989] WAR 285

Case(s) also cited:

Aintree Holdings Pty Ltd v Corderoy (1996) 16 WAR 416

Bailey v Commissioner of Taxation (1977) 136 CLR 214

Bomanite v Slatex Corporation Australia Pty Ltd (1991) 32 FCR 379

Jingellic Minerals NL v Abigroup Ltd (1992) 7 WAR 566

Lenijamar v AGC (Advances) Ltd (1990) 27 FCR 388

Neptune Oil Co Pty Ltd v Fowler (1963) 63 SR (NSW) 530

Rubenstein v Truth & Sportsman Ltd [1960] VR 473

Tony Sadler Pty Ltd v McLeod Nominees Pty Ltd (1994) 13 WAR 323

Trade Practices Commission v David Jones (Aust) Pty Ltd (1985) 7 FCR 109

Wharf Properties Ltd v Eric Cumine Associates [No 2] (1991) 52 BLR 8

Wilson v Metaxas [1989] WAR 285

WMC Resources Limited v Leighton Contractors Pty Ltd [1999] WASCA 10; (1999) 20 WAR 489

  1. JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is a renewed application for leave to appeal against a decision of a Judge of this Court in interlocutory proceedings (as to which see s 60(1)(f) of the Supreme Court Act 1935 and SCM Chemicals Ltd v Saipem Australia Pty Ltd (1991) 4 WAR 569 at 573, 583). The applicant is, in such a case, generally required to demonstrate both that the decision of the court below is wrong, or at least attended with sufficient doubt to justify the grant of leave, and that substantial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Murchison Zinc Co Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] WASCA 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Murchison Zinc Co Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd, the dispute pertains to an engineering contract involving the excavation and construction of a decline. The plaintiff, Murchison Zinc Co Pty Ltd, an underground and civil works contractor, filed a reamended substituted statement of claim against the defendant, Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd, a mining company acting as manager and agent for the Golden Grove Joint Venture. The plaintiff sought to enforce two contracts: the September 1994 Contract and the November 1995 Contract, both for the construction of the decline. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had agreed to pay for the work and variations, as well as extensions of time and related costs. The defendant applied to strike out substantial portions of the plaintiff's statement of claim, arguing that it was not adequately particularised. The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff's statement of claim was sufficiently detailed to withstand a strike-out application and whether the pleading defects could be rectified without substantial injustice.

The court considered whether the plaintiff's statement of claim sufficiently particularised the claims and whether any defects in the pleading could be rectified. The court held that the application to strike out was premature as the issues were yet to be defined. The court noted that the plaintiff's pleadings, although not distinguishing between the two contracts, were sufficient to allow the case to proceed to discovery. The court emphasised that the pleadings should not be struck out unless it was clear that the plaintiff could not succeed on any possible construction of the pleadings. The court also observed that the plaintiff's claim was broad and complex, involving multiple contracts and variations, which might justify a less rigid interpretation of the pleading requirements.

The court refused the application to strike out the plaintiff's statement of claim, noting that the plaintiff's pleadings were sufficient to allow the case to proceed. The court held that the pleadings, although defective, could be rectified without substantial injustice. The court also noted that the application for leave to appeal was unlikely to succeed, as the decision to refuse the strike-out application was not clearly wrong and the plaintiff would suffer substantial injustice if the decision was left unreversed. The court held that the plaintiff's claim was broad and complex, and the pleadings, while not perfect, provided a sufficient basis for the case to proceed. The court concluded that the application for leave to appeal should be dismissed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: This is a renewed application for leave to appeal against a decision of a Judge of this Court in interlocutory proceedings (as to which see s 60(1)(f) of the Supreme Court Act 1935 and SCM Chemicals Ltd v Saipem Australia Pty Ltd (1991) 4 WAR 569 at 573, 583). The applicant is, in such a case, generally required to demonstrate both that the decision of the court below is wrong, or at least attended with sufficient doubt to justify the grant of leave, and that substantial injustice would be done by leaving the decision unreversed (Wilson v Metaxas [1989] WAR 285 at 294). The discretion to grant or withhold leave is broad and these criteria are neither exhaustive nor rigid (see Jingellic Minerals NL v Abigroup Ltd (1992) 7 WAR 566 at 571). Moreover, what is a substantial injustice must depend upon all of the circumstances of the case (Jingellic, above, at 571 and Western Australia v Bond Corporation Holdings Ltd (1991) 5 WAR 40 at 55). The decision in respect of which leave to appeal is sought is one dismissing an application to strike out substantial portions of the plaintiff's statement of claim. On 24 January 2000 the plaintiff, an underground and civil works contractor, filed (in proceedings which have been on foot since 1996) a reamended substituted statement of claim against the defendant, a mining company which acts as manager and agent for a number of companies which have combined to form what has been described as the "Golden Grove Joint Venture". It was this statement of claim which was under attack in the proceedings giving rise to the application for leave to appeal. The plaintiff's claim, as pleaded, arises out of two contracts. The first of these was made on about 19 September 1994 and is described in the statement of claim as the "September 94 Contract". The second, which is pleaded to have replaced the first, is a contract in writing executed by the parties in late November 1995 and is described in the statement of claim as the "November 95 Contract". Each of these contracts (and they are pleaded to have contained many common terms) was for the excavation and construction, by the plaintiff on behalf of the defendant, of a decline. The plaintiff pleads (par 3 of the statement of claim) that the defendant agreed to pay to it rates and prices for that work in accordance with a contractual schedule and also such other amounts as might become due to it by reason of any variations by the defendant to the work under "the Contract" (presumably a reference to each contract). It pleads also (par 3) that the defendant would "reasonably consider requests for, and grant to the Plaintiff, extensions of time for the completion of the work under the Contract and pay consequent delay and disruption costs in accordance with the terms of the Contract". It says (par 19) that on about 3 and 4 December 1994 the defendant directed it to excavate the decline at a level some 12 metres higher and 2.21 metres to the right of the location shown in the original contractual drawings. This, it says (par 20(a)), was a variation of the contract works (presumably under the "September 94 Contract", the "November 95 Contract" not yet having been made, although the pleading, which generally does not distinguish between the two contracts, refers to changes to the "levels, lines, positions or dimensions of all or part of the Works within the meaning of General Conditions clause 40.1(c) of the Common Terms", this last phrase being a reference to terms common to both contracts.)