Evans v Pallas Bride and Fashion Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

JURISDICTION     :   DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

LOCATION:   PERTH

CITATION:   EVANS -v- PALLAS BRIDE AND FASHION PTY LTD [2016] WADC 85

CORAM:   BOWDEN DCJ

HEARD:   26 APRIL 2016

DELIVERED          :   3 JUNE 2016

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1211 of 2015

BETWEEN:   JAMES LEONARD EVANS

BARBARA NICOLA WOLFF
Plaintiffs

AND

PALLAS BRIDE AND FASHION PTY LTD
First defendant

TREVOR GRESHOM MORRIS
Second defendant

Catchwords:

Construction of contract - Rectification - Oral contract - Misleading/deceptive conduct

Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Statute of Frauds 1677

Result:

Judgment for the plaintiffs in the sum of $72,070

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiffs:     Mr H Robinson

First defendant              :     Mr C Graham

Second defendant          :     Mr C Graham

Solicitors:

Plaintiffs:     Haydn Robinson

First defendant              :     Graham & Associates

Second defendant          :     Graham & Associates

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Barclay Mowlen Construction Ltd v Dampier Port Authority & Anor (2006) 33 WAR 82

Boreland v Docker [2007] NSWCA 94

Bowtell v Goldsbrough, Mort & Co Ltd (1905) 3 CLR 444

BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Limited v President, Councillors and Ratepayers of the Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266 at 283; [1997] HCA 40

Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council (2001) 55 NSWLR 153; [2001] NSWCA 61

Civic Video Pty Ltd v Paterson [No 3] [2014] WASC 321(S)

Clambake Pty Ltd v Tipperary Projects Pty Ltd [No 5] [2009] WASC 141

Elders Trustee and Executor Co Ltd v E G Reeves Pty Ltd [1987] FCA 332; (1987) 78 ALR 193

Godecke v Kirwin [1973] HCA 38; (1973) 129 CLR 629

Hancock Prospecting v Wright Prospecting Pty Ltd [2012] WASCA 216; (2012) 45 WAR 29

Hitchcock v Goldspan Investment Pty Ltd [2015] WASC 277

Lighting by Design (Aust) Pty Ltd v Cannington Nominees Pty Ltd [2008] WASCA 23 (2008) 35 WAR 520

Marcus Clarke (Vic) Ltd v Brown [1928] HCA 12; (1928) 40 CLR 540

Masters v Cameron [1954] HCA 72; (1954) 91 CLR 353

Michael Kellaway International Pty Ltd v Shark Bay Airport Pty Ltd (Unreported, WASCA, Library No 980302, 25 March 1998)

Miller & Associates Insurance Broking Pty Ltd v BMW Australia Finance Ltd [2010] HCA 31

Mount Bruce Mining Pty Ltd v Wright Prospecting Ltd [2015] HCA 37

Murchison Zinc Company Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 167

NSIF Medical Defence Union Ltd v Transport Industries Insurance Co Ltd (1986) 6 NSWLR 740

Nyoni v Patterson [2012] WASCA 171

Owston Nominees No 2 Pty Ltd v Clambake Pty Ltd (2011) 248 FLR 193; [2011] WASCA 76

RCR Tomlinson Ltd V Russell [2015] WASCA 154

Ryledar Pty Ltd v Euphoric Pty Ltd (2007) 69 NSWLR 603

Taylor v Johnson (1983) 151 CLR 422

Technomin Australia Pty Ltd v Xstrata Nickel Australasia Operations Pty Ltd [2014] WASCA 164

Terravision Pty Ltd v Black Box Control Pty Ltd [No 3] [2016] WASC 95

Thermoplastic Foam Industry Pty Ltd v Imthouse Pty Ltd (1990) 5 BPR 11

Vantage Systems Pty Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evans v Pallas Bride and Fashion Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] WADC 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Evans v Pallas Bride and Fashion Pty Ltd was a case in which the parties disputed the terms of an oral agreement relating to the holding over of a lease. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute involved whether the oral agreement was ambiguous and, if so, whether the court should rectify the written agreement to reflect the parties' true intentions. The plaintiffs argued that the oral agreement was not ambiguous and sought rectification on the basis that the written agreement did not accurately reflect their understanding of the agreement. The defendants denied that the agreement was ambiguous and opposed the plaintiffs' application for rectification.

The court considered whether the language of the contract was ambiguous and whether the parties' competing constructions of the contract were reasonably arguable. The plaintiffs argued that the term "hold over" did not refer to the holding over clause in the lease agreement and that the third sentence of the agreement referred to a period beyond 2 January 2016. The defendants argued that the term "hold over" did refer to the holding over clause in the lease agreement and that the third sentence qualified the offer made in the second sentence of the agreement. The court found that the language of the contract was ambiguous and that the parties' competing constructions were reasonably arguable.

The court considered whether the plaintiffs' application for rectification should be granted. The court found that the plaintiffs had established the requirements for rectification, including that the written agreement did not accurately reflect the parties' true intentions and that there was no satisfactory explanation for the discrepancy between the written and oral agreements. The court also found that the defendants had not established any of the defences to rectification. The court granted the plaintiffs' application for rectification and ordered that the written agreement be rectified to reflect the parties' true intentions as set out in the oral agreement.

The court's orders included that the written agreement be rectified to reflect the parties' true intentions and that the defendants pay the plaintiffs' costs of the application for rectification. The court's decision highlights the importance of ensuring that written agreements accurately reflect the parties' true intentions and the potential consequences of discrepancies between written and oral agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The fact that adversaries can formulate and advance materially different constructions of the language of a contract does not itself satisfy the gateway requirement. Having regard to the language of the contract as a whole and what can be gleaned from that source as to the contractual purpose, competing constructions must be reasonably arguable. Technomin Australia Pty Ltd v Xstrata Nickel Australasia Operations Pty Ltd [2014] WASCA 164 [74] (McLure P); Terravision Pty Ltd v Black Box Control Pty Ltd [No 3] [2016] WASC 95 [38] (Le Miere J). The plaintiffs contend that there is no ambiguity in the November agreement when read with the lease agreement. They say:•The use of the word 'hold over' in the November agreement is not a reference to the holding over clause (cl 9.2) in the lease. They argue that the words 'hold over' should be given their normal natural meaning which according to Black's Legal Dictionary is 'to continue in possession of property for some period'. They say this construction is aided by the parties defining 'hold over' as continue.•The sentence 'The assignees reserves the right to increase the rent on or before 2 January 2016 for rent applicable to any further period of a lease offered by the assignees beyond 2 January 2016' (third sentence in par 2, hereinafter referred to as the third sentence) expressly contemplates a 'further period of the lease'; that further period being beyond 2 January 2016.•The words' any further period' implies the existence of a current period being from the date of the expiration of the lease, 2 January 2015, to the date of the commencement of any further period, being 2 January 2016.•The November agreement extends the term of the lease for 12 months so cl 9.2 is not engaged or alternatively the meaning of the words used varied both cl 9.2.1 of the lease by fixing the rent as specified in the agreement whereas it would otherwise increase by a minimum of 10%, and cl 9.2.2 in that the lease continued for a fixed term of 12 months from 2 January 2015 to 2 January 2016 whereas it would otherwise continue on a monthly basis (ts 201). The defendants contend that there is no ambiguity either, however they argue:•The November agreement is titled 'Agreement to hold over' and then incorporates the lease into the agreement itself and it is therefore an inescapable conclusion that the holding over provisions of the lease operate.•The operative provision of the November agreement is the second sentence in the second paragraph whereby there is an offer to hold over the lease on the same terms and conditions as in the lease document with the exception of the rent increase. Absent that provision, pursuant to cl 9.2.1 of the lease, there would be an automatic 10% rent increase whereas the November agreement fixes the rent at the current rent.•The third sentence simply qualifies the offer made in the second sentence and does not have an independent operation. That is, having exempted cl 9.2.1 of the lease, which would otherwise result in a 10% rent, the third sentence preserves the right of the plaintiffs to increase the rent for any period beyond 2 January 2016.•The November agreement affects cl 9.2.1 (rent increase), however the right to terminate the lease by one month's written notice pursuant to cl 9.2.2 continues unaffected.•The November agreement identifies itself as a holding over agreement, incorporates the terms and conditions of the lease with the exception of the rent increase which is fixed by the agreement and qualifies the duration of the period of the fixed rent.