LNMT and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

LNMT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 431 (6 March 2018)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:           2017/2769

Re:"LNMT"

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President K Bean

Date:  6 March 2018

Place:Adelaide

The decision under review is varied so as to provide that the applicant’s plan of 12 May 2017 (the existing plan) is itself varied so as to include the following additional supports, calculated on the basis explained in the Tribunal’s Reasons for Decision:

·Support coordination - $12,228.32;

·Increased social and community participation - $ 2,200;

·Core supports - $8,779.96;

·Cognitive assessment - $ 1,020.00;

·Assistive  technology - $10,080, in substitution for the amount of $980.00 allowed in the existing plan;

·Improved daily living - $11,375.70 plus the cost of an orientation assessment, in substitution for the amount of $11, 065.00 allowed in the existing plan; and

·Improved relationships - $5,847.45, in substitution for the amount of $5,614.70 allowed in the existing plan.

....................[Sgd]..........................................
Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Applicant a child with blindness, epilepsy and cognitive impairments – Reasonable and necessary supports – Support coordination – Support workers, pool program and aquatic therapy – Respite care – Whether participant plan should be extended - Decision under review varied.

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, ss 33, 34 and 209

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

CASES

McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean

6 March 2018

  1. The applicant in this matter is an 11 year old girl who suffers from blindness, epilepsy and cognitive impairments. She currently resides in Tennant Creek in the Northern Territory. She is subject to a care order made by Territory Families in January 2016 and has been in the care of her foster mother since July 2016.

  2. The applicant has had plans under the NDIS since at least September 2014, with the original plan the subject of the request for internal review in this matter covering the period 27 March 2017 to 27 March 2018.

  3. Following the request for internal review of that plan, on 9 May 2017 that plan was varied and the varied plan provided for supports in the amount of $62,172.91. The dates of the plan were also changed so that the plan started on 12 May 2017 and was to be reviewed by 14 May 2018.

  4. On 15 May 2017, a request was made on behalf of the applicant for review of the varied plan by the Tribunal, giving rise to this application.

  5. In making her application to the Tribunal, the applicant is seeking additional supports in areas including the following:

    (a)Speech pathology, occupational therapy and physiotherapy;

    (b)Positive behaviour therapy;

    (c)Assistive technology;

    (d)Increased funding for support workers;

    (e)Plan support coordination;

    (f)Respite – short‑term accommodation; and

    (g)A cognitive assessment.

  6. The issue for me, accordingly, is whether additional supports are required in any or all of these areas.

    THE LEGAL SETTING

  7. Section…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LNMT and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 431
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by LNMT, a child with blindness, epilepsy, and cognitive impairments, seeking a review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The dispute centred on the NDIA's refusal to fund certain supports deemed reasonable and necessary for the applicant, including increased support coordination, enhanced social and community participation, additional respite care, and a cognitive assessment. The case was heard by Deputy K Bean P.

The legal issues before the court were whether the NDIA's decision to exclude or limit funding for specific supports was correct, and consequently, whether the applicant's NDIS plan should be varied to include additional funding for support coordination, increased social and community participation, core supports (specifically respite care), and a cognitive assessment. The court was required to determine if these requested supports met the criteria of being reasonable and necessary within the framework of the National Disability Insurance Scheme.

The court reasoned that the NDIA's initial removal of support coordination from the applicant's plan was not adequately defended, particularly given that it had been included in a prior plan. While the NDIA later conceded that support coordination was appropriately funded by the NDIS, it contested the amount sought by the applicant. Considering the applicant's complex and evolving needs, the court found that a high level of support coordination was necessary and that the applicant's requested amount of $12,228.32 for 104 hours over six months was reasonable and necessary. The court also addressed other areas of disagreement, ultimately varying the decision under review to include additional funding for increased social and community participation, core supports, and a cognitive assessment, among other items. The court declined to extend the review date of the current plan, deeming it appropriate for a comprehensive review to occur as scheduled due to the applicant's deteriorating condition.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The areas of disagreement are as follows:·Support coordination – the applicant seeks $12,228.32 on the basis of 104 hours over 6 months calculated at $117.58 per hour;·Increased social and community participation – the applicant seeks additional funding for two support workers to take the applicant to the pool 5 hours per week for 24 weeks and 5 days (1 November to 1 May) calculated at $66.25 per hour on a weekday evening;·Core supports – the applicant seeks additional funding for respite care in disability supported accommodation for 7 days every 6 weeks calculated at $627.14 per day, to be substituted for the existing 14 days per year of respite allowed in the plan under review; and·Cognitive assessment – the applicant seeks the cost of this in the sum of $1,020.00.THE EVIDENCEThe applicant’s foster mother In her written statement provided to the Tribunal, the applicant’s foster mother provided detailed information in relation to the applicant’s behaviours and care needs:11. Some examples of [the applicant’s] concerning behaviours include:-i. Anti-social behaviours;ii. Incontinence;iii. Propensity for violence and acting / reacting violently;iv. Deficits in rational behaviour;v.Lack of understanding/coping with change causing trauma and behaviour issues;vi. Inability to navigate and regulate emotions;vii. Deficits in expression of emotions;viii. Inability to verbalise issues/challenges/feelings;ix.Deficits inability [sic] to share space, place, objects, songs and reacting violently to those who attempt to share with or in those things;x. Falling over/stammer in her feet;xi. Swearing and using words to threaten others;xii. Challenges with regulating sexualised behaviour;xiii. Masturbating in public, masturbating in shared spaces at home;xiv. Progressive increase in seizure activity’;xv. Echolalia speechxvi. Incessant talkingxvii. Challenges with learning new things;xviii. Challenges with her behaviour when expectations are not met;xix.Demonstrating a complete lack of understanding leading to reacting negatively when others values, beliefs, attitudes and emotions differ to her own;xx. Deficits in fine motor skills; andxxi. Fixation and obsession on objects, food and relationships.12. [The applicant] has high care needs.13. Some examples of [the applicant’s] care requirements include:-i. Advocacy and education for those working with [the applicant], e.g. school;ii. Scheduling and attending appointments;iii. Scheduling and attending care conferencing;iv. Consulting / working with relevant specialists;v. Transporting to and from appointments;vi. Developing strategies to address and provide behaviour support;vii. Washing clothes and bedding;viii. Medication administration;ix. Delivering therapeutic interventions;x. Recording behaviours;xi. Meal preparation;xii. Attending to personal care needs;xiii. Teaching body awareness, personal care and hygiene habits; andxiv. Supporting toileting including menstruation14. [The applicant’s] disability requirements are escalating.15.Since February 2017, [the applicant] has experienced an increase in falls. This has been caused from an escalation to her stammer in her footing and increased gait.16.There has also been an increase in her frequency of epileptic seizures.17.Prior to May 2017, [the applicant] would experience an epileptic seizure once every three weeks. Since May 2017, [the applicant] experiences three seizures a week; equating to approximately 12 seizures a month.[3][3] Statement of lived experience of the applicant’s foster mother dated 15 August 2017, [11]-[17].

Decision

Reasons for decision

As sought by the applicant, I have also considered whether it may be appropriate to extend the review date of the current plan. However the applicant’s needs are complex and changing. As I understand it both her blindness and epilepsy were deteriorating as at the time of the hearing. In these circumstances, and noting the constraints which operate on the Tribunal given its function, I consider it would be appropriate for a comprehensive review of the applicant’s needs to be undertaken in May this year, as currently scheduled. For the reasons I have given, I am not satisfied that I am in a positon to determine the appropriate supports for the applicant for a longer period.DECISION The decision under review is varied so as to provide that the applicant’s plan of 12 May 2017 is itself varied so as to include the following additional supports, calculated on the basis explained above:·Support coordination - $12,228.32;·Increased social and community participation - $ 2,200;·Core supports - $8,779.96;·Cognitive assessment - $ 1,020.00;·Assistive technology - $10,080, in substitution for the amount of $980.00 allowed in the existing plan;·Improved daily living - $11,375.70 plus the cost of an orientation assessment, in substitution for the amount of $11, 065.00 allowed in the existing plan; and·Improved relationships - $5,847.45, in substitution for the amount of $5,614.70 allowed in the existing plan.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Two members of the assessment team, Ms Murray and Ms Miller also gave oral evidence at the hearing, which was consistent with the report.CONSIDERATION Support coordination There is very little information before me which assists in determining with any precision how much support coordination the applicant requires. The applicant essentially relies upon the fact that in the applicant’s original plan of 27 March 2017, an amount of $23,605.92 was allowed, representing 208 hours over the course of the year,[7] at a rate of $113.49 per hour, being the amount then specified in the applicable Price Guide.[8] Somewhat surprisingly, there was no allowance for this at all in the revised plan of 12 May 2017. The only explanation given for eliminating this support in the very brief reviewable decision of 9 May 2017 was that “Support Coordination is not most appropriately funded by the NDIS”. In other words, no issue was apparently taken with the amount previously allowed. Rather the delegate apparently eliminated the support on the basis that it was more appropriately funded as part of a universal service obligation.[7] T-documents, T13/88.[8] NDIS Price Guide – Very Remote, version release date 24 June 2016, p 46. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the respondent has not sought to defend that positon in the context of this matter. However, for reasons which have not been explained, the respondent takes issue with the amount of support coordination allowed for by the NDIA itself in the original plan. The respondent now maintains that 80 hours of support coordination over six months should be sufficient, but has not put forward any evidence in support of that contention, or explained how that amount has been arrived at. The amount sought by the applicant over a six month period works out to $12,228.32, whereas the amount contended for by the respondent is $9,040.00. One of the complicating factors for me, of course, is that there are now less than 3 months remaining before the plan is due to be reviewed, and I have no information as to the extent of expenses which have been incurred for support coordination during the currency of the current plan. Noting the respondent’s revised position with respect to this support, it is of course possible that such expenses have been incurred in the expectation of a variation to the applicant’s plan, at least to the extent acknowledged by the respondent as appropriate. Having regard to the complexity and changing nature of the applicant’s needs, and the level and variety of supports she requires, it is clear that a high level of support coordination is required, including a high level of liaison with her school. I am also conscious of the risk that inadequate support coordination will add to the already enormous workload of the applicant’s foster mother. Noting that 208 hours per year were initially allowed for coordination of supports, the respondent now accepts that coordination of supports is appropriately funded by the NDIS and no reason has been given as to why a lesser amount should be allowed for this than the amount included in the applicant’s original plan, I have decided that the current plan should be varied so as to restore the level of support coordination contained in the applicant’s original plan, but for a six month period only as sought by the applicant. I have therefore decided to allow an amount of $12,228.32 calculated on the basis of 104 hours over 6 months at $117.58 per hour, as I am satisfied that this level of support coordination is reasonable and necessary for the applicant. I note that funds allocated must be spent in accordance with a participant’s plan, and to the extent these funds are not required during the currency of the applicant’s current plan, they will remain unspent.Increased social and community participation