Inquest into the death of Kumanjayi Holmes

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

CITATION:Inquest into the death of Kumanjayi Holmes [2023] NTLC 7

TITLE OF COURT:  Coroner’s Court

JURISDICTION:  Alice Springs

FILE NO(s):A0056/2021

DELIVERED ON:  31 March 2023

DELIVERED AT:  Alice Springs Local Court

HEARING DATE(s):  30 and 31 March 2023

FINDING OF:  Judge Elisabeth Armitage

CATCHWORDS:  Child death in care, inherited genetic disorder, removed from family due to disability

REPRESENTATION:  

Counsel Assisting:  Jodi Truman

Counsel for Department of

Territory Families:  Michael McCarthy

Judgment category classification:    A

Judgement ID number:  [2023] NTLC 7

Number of paragraphs:                   66

Number of pages:  18

IN THE CORONER’S COURT
AT ALICE SPRINGS IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. A0056/2021

In the matter of an Inquest into the death of

KUMANJAYI HOLMES
  ON: 31 OCTOBER 2021

AT: ALICE SPRINGS HOSPITAL

FINDINGS

Judge Elisabeth Armitage

Introduction

  1. The deceased was born on 24 May 2006 to Roxanne Morton and Damsien Kelly-Holmes. Her mother asked that she be referred to as Kumanjayi. Kumanjayi was born in the Alice Springs Hospital at full term via normal delivery, she weighed 2,980 grams and there were no antenatal or postnatal complications.  She had an elder brother and two younger siblings.  She was Aboriginal with family connections to Tennant Creek, Utopia and Murray Downs communities.

  2. Kumanjayi passed away on 31 October 2021 at the Palliative Care Ward of the Alice Springs Hospital.  She was fifteen years and five months old. She was loved by her family and foster mother and they miss her and grieve her passing. Her death was “reportable” as immediately prior to her death she was a “person held in care” being a “child who is in the CEO’s care as defined in the Care and Protection of Children Act 2007”.[1] This inquest is mandatory.

Her life before coming into the care of the Department of Territory Families, Housing and Communities

  1. In her early years, Kumanjayi and her family predominantly lived at Murray Downs Station, however they also moved between Harts Range, Ampilatwatja, Arlparra and Tennant Creek. 

  2. On 20 November 2012, when Kumanjayi was just six years of age, a notification was received by the Department of Territory Families, Housing and Communities (“TFHC”) from the mobile “Family as First Teachers” (“FAFT”) unit.  It was reported that Kumanjayi’s eyesight was deteriorating and her mother needed assistance to get her to specialist appointments. 

  3. In 2013 Kumanjayi was diagnosed with severe rod-cone dystrophy and epilepsy. Rod-cone dystrophy (aka cone-rod dystrophy) is an eye disorder that causes progressive vision loss.  Kumanjayi was treated with medication.

  4. Following a second notification in September 2014, her teacher advised TFHC that Kumanjayi was “blind” and had epilepsy, and the school and her mother were teaching her Braille. 

  5. On 2 December 2015 a nurse attached to the Royal Flying Doctor Service submitted a third notification reporting that:

    7.1Her eyesight was deteriorating and her seizure disorder was requiring medication twice per day;

    7.2She was refusing to go to school or take her medication and her mother was struggling with these challenging behaviours;

    7.3She required a comprehensive assessment which was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inquest into the death of Kumanjayi Holmes and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NTLC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kumanjayi Holmes, a 15-year-old Aboriginal girl, passed away on 31 October 2021 at Alice Springs Hospital due to complications of Batten disease (CLN3). This inquest, presided over by Judge Elisabeth Armitage, aimed to examine the circumstances surrounding her death while she was in the care of the Department of Territory Families, Housing and Communities (TFHC). Kumanjayi had a complex medical history, including severe rod-cone dystrophy, epilepsy, Batten disease, Autism Spectrum Disorder, Intellectual Disability-Severe Impairment Secondaries, Cone Rod Dystrophy, Epilepsy, and Incontinence. The court was required to determine whether there were any deficiencies in the care provided to Kumanjayi that contributed to her death.

The court found that Kumanjayi received love, care, and support from her foster mother, Ms. Angela Teasdale, and the TFHC, despite the significant challenges posed by her medical conditions. The court commended Ms. Teasdale for her exceptional advocacy and commitment to Kumanjayi. However, the inquest also highlighted difficulties in securing adequate and timely funding for Kumanjayi's care needs through the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The court acknowledged the complexity of the division of responsibilities between TFHC and the NDIS, which caused difficulties at times. However, the court found that the involvement of TFHC and its Disability and Development Team contributed positively to the provision of services to Kumanjayi.

The court made no recommendations in relation to this death, but it was noted that efforts are being made to streamline communications between the NDIA and child protection agencies to improve the provision of services to children like Kumanjayi. The court concluded that Kumanjayi's death was not unexpected or unexplained, and there was no suggestion of neglect or lack of care.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established