PNFK and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

PNFK and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 692 (28 March 2018)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2017/4514

Re:PNFK  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Professor R McCallum AO, Member

Date:28 March 2018

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision dated 27 June 2017 is varied as follows:

1.PNFK be given 100 hours of support coordination;

2.On standard work weeks from Monday to Friday, PNFK be given 9 hours of care from 8:30 am to 5:30 pm, and 3 hours of care to be used flexibly either before 8:30 am or after 5:30 pm;

3.On standard weekends, 4 hours of care for PNFK on both days, to be used flexibly;

4.On two weekends, PNFK be given 24 hours care, totalling 48 hours;

5.On two long weekends, 24 hours of paid care for PNFK totalling 72 hours;

6.On two weeks of the four weeks of the annual leave of PNFK’s Father and Mother, 24 hours of care for PNFK per day being 168 hours per week, totalling 336 hours for the two weeks;

7.For the remaining two weeks of annual leave, 9 hours care of PNFK on week days, that is from Mondays to Fridays, and four hours of care on each Saturday and Sunday;

8.For the remaining public holidays, 9 hours of care for PNFK at the public holiday rate; and

9.For the two public holidays which fall on weekends, 4 hours of care for PNFK at the public holiday rate. 

......................[sgd].................................................

Professor R McCallum AO, Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – applicant a child with multiple impairments – severe hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy – profound global developmental delay with cerebral palsy – seizures - cerebral irritability – bulbar palsy – feed intolerance and poor weight gain – mild to moderate hearing impairment - cortical visual impairment – support coordination – core supports – whether supports reasonable and necessary – hours of care for applicant  – respite – decision under review varied

LEGISLATION

National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013, ss 3, 4, 33, 34, 100, 103

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013, r 3.5, sch 1

CASES

LNMT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2018] AATA 431

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Convention on the Rights of the Child, Art 3, 23

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Art 7

REASONS FOR DECISION

Professor R McCallum AO, Member

28 March 2018

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant is a two and a half year old girl. To protect her privacy, I shall refer to her as PNFK.

  2. At birth, PNFK suffered severe hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy, and she was immediately admitted to the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit at the hospital.

  3. While her parents were advised that her chances of survival were not good, PNFK is a real fighter and has pulled through every setback.

  4. PNFK suffers from a number of impairments including profound global developmental delay with cerebral palsy; seizures; cerebral irritability; bulbar palsy; feed intolerance and poor weight gain; mild to moderate hearing impairment; and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read PNFK and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 692
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by PNFK, a child with multiple impairments including severe hypoxic ischaemic encephalopathy, profound global developmental delay, cerebral palsy, seizures, and feed intolerance, against the National Disability Insurance Agency. The dispute centred on the provision of reasonable and necessary supports under the National Disability Insurance Scheme, specifically regarding the hours of care and support coordination required for PNFK. The case was heard by Professor R McCallum AO, Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the appropriate quantum of reasonable and necessary supports for PNFK, as defined by section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act. This involved assessing the evidence regarding PNFK's profound care needs, including one-on-one supervision, assistance with all daily living activities, and the necessity of respite for her family. The Tribunal was required to consider whether the existing funding and hours allocated in PNFK's participation plan adequately met these needs, particularly in light of her severe medical conditions and dependence.

The Tribunal's reasoning was informed by the detailed evidence presented by PNFK's father, which described the child's extensive medical conditions and her critical need for constant, one-on-one care to prevent distress and life-threatening situations. The parties ultimately reached an agreement on a varied decision, which was made pursuant to section 26(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. This agreement did not represent a final determination on the substantive issues but ensured the continued availability of funding for reasonable and necessary supports until the proceeding was finalised.

The agreed orders varied the Respondent's decision dated 17 June 2017. Key variations included an increase in funding for support coordination to 100 hours, and significant increases in funding for improved daily living and core supports. The Tribunal also detailed specific hours of care to be provided on standard weekdays, weekends, long weekends, during family annual leave, and for public holidays, reflecting an enhanced provision to meet PNFK's complex needs and provide respite for her family.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the summary of evidence which follows, I shall do away with repetitions.The Evidence of PNFK’s Father PNFK’s Father was the first witness to give evidence. He affirmed his written statement dated 23 January 2018, portion of which is as follows:[PNFK) suffers from numerous ailments; spastic quadriplegia, no co-ordinated swallow, cannot roll over, can’t sit up, can’t walk or talk, can't feed by mouth, can’t coordinate her eye movement, can’t hold up her head with her neck, no trunk strength, high-tone limbs, little communication beyond crying and groaning.Despite this, she is a survivor and although constantly knocked down, she fights on. She is constantly afflicted by ailments, colds, flus, high temperatures and other worse things. She consistently vomits, cries in pain, has massive oral and nasal secretions, chokes on her own saliva. And yet she persists. She is quite amazing really.She suffers enormously if she does not have one-on-one care and support, and interaction. She has massive separation anxiety. Because her eyesight and hearing are extremely poor, physical separation can mean less than one metre and she gets very upset. She needs massaging, exercising, moving, rolling. Feeding is via a naso­gastric tube by a machine. [PNFK] will never taste or enjoy food, or water. [PNFK] requires constant one-on-one care. This includes physical interaction, talking to, singing to, cleaning, feeding, moving, rolling, massaging, bathing, dressing, nappy-changing, transporting, medicating, lifting. She can't be left alone. Being alone leads to distress, crying, excessive secretions, vomiting and choking. Being left alone for tens of minutes, or even just a few minutes, quickly becomes life-threatening for [PNFK]. [Footnotes omitted]. In his evidence, PNFK’s Father explained that PNFK suffered a severe asphyxiation in the birth canal. She has severe brain damage. She has severe cerebral palsy. She has profound global development delay, seizures and cerebral irritability. She is unable to suck. She has feed intolerance and is now fed via a naso­gastric tube by a machine. She has severe vomiting. She also has moderate hearing impairments, but there has been a slight improvement over time. She has visual impairments which have improved over time, but less than her hearing. She possibly recognises faces. In a practical sense, she has very poor tone in her trunk. She cannot hold her head upright. She has high tone in her arms and her legs. She cannot grip or hold at all. Her fists are permanently clenched. He explained that PNFK’s needs are profound and obviously greatly differ from the needs of the older children when they were toddlers. PNFK came home to her parents at about two weeks of age. He said that he was told that her likely survival was about one per cent. She is now about two and a half years old. He said that they are being told that her survivability is rather good. She fights off every ailment that comes her way. He said that there have been developments over time, hearing and eye sight, but are slight. He says that the prognosis of movement, swallowing, talking is extremely poor.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The extra hours are as follows:First, on two weekends, 24 hours care for PNFK for 48 hours to enable the other family members to have break time.Second, on two long weekends, 24 hours of paid care for PNFK totalling 72 hours, to enable the other family members to have break time.Third, on two weeks of the four weeks of the annual leave of PNFK’s Father and Mother, 24 hours of care for PNFK per day being 168 hours per week, totalling 336 hours for the two weeks, to enable her family to have some respite time. Fourth, for the remaining two weeks of annual leave, 9 hours care of PNFK on week days, that is from Mondays to Fridays, and four hours of care on each Saturday and Sunday. Fifth, for ten public holidays a year, 9 hours of care for PNFK at the public holiday rate. For two public holidays which fall on weekends, 4 hours of care at the public holiday rate.DECISION For the reasons given above, the reviewable decision dated 27 June 2017 is varied as follows:1.PNFK be given 100 hours of support coordination;2.On standard work weeks from Monday to Friday, PNFK be given 9 hours of care from 8:30 am to 5:30 pm, and 3 hours of care to be used flexibly either before 8:30 am or after 5:30 pm; 3.On standard weekends, 4 hours of care for PNFK on both days, to be used flexibly;4.On two weekends, PNFK be given 24 hours care, totalling 48 hours;5.On two long weekends, 24 hours of paid care for PNFK totalling 72 hours;6.On two weeks of the four weeks of the annual leave of PNFK’s Father and Mother, 24 hours of care for PNFK per day being 168 hours per week, totalling 336 hours for the two weeks;7.For the remaining two weeks of annual leave, 9 hours care of PNFK on week days, that is from Mondays to Fridays, and four hours of care on each Saturday and Sunday; 8.For the remaining public holidays, 9 hours of care for PNFK at the public holiday rate; and9.For the two public holidays which fall on weekends, 4 hours of care for PNFK at the public holiday rate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The parties agreed upon an order, which I made pursuant to section 26(1)(b) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) on 5 March 2018. Omitting formal parts, the order reads as follows:To allow the Applicant continued access to reasonable and necessary supports until such time as this proceeding is finalised, the parties agree in accordance with section 26 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act) that the decision of the Respondent dated 17 June 2017 will be varied as follows:(i)the date by which the Respondent must review the plan under Division 4 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act (NDIS Act) is to be 9 September 2018; and(j)the funding for supports identified as reasonable and necessary under section 34 of the NDIS Act is increased as follows:(i) the funding for support coordination is increased from $4,613.50 to $9,227; and(ii) the funding for improved daily living is increased from $16,328.01 to $24,492.02; and(iii) the funding for core supports is increased from $69,986 to $104,979.The Tribunal Notes: 1This agreement is reached under section 26 of the AAT Act to ensure the continued availability to the Applicant of funding for reasonable and necessary supports until such time as the Tribunal proceeding is finalised.2This agreement does not represent an agreement on the substantive issues before the Tribunal in this proceeding.3The parties agree that within 14 days after the AAT determination of this proceeding, a new plan will be made.CONSIDERATION At the outset of the hearing, the parties explained that they had agreed for 50 hours of support coordination in the second participation plan to be increased to 100 hours of support coordination. Accordingly, having regard to this agreement and to the evidence before me, I will vary the review decision of 27 June 2017 to include 100 hours of support coordination. During the hearing, it became clear that the parties were of the view that the reasonable and necessary core supports of approximately 1,515 hours of care for PNFK as set forth in the second participation plan should be increased to meet the care needs of PNFK. The applicant is of course PNFK. Through her counsel and parents she requests the following hours of care. First, on standard working weeks, from Monday to Friday, 14 hours of paid care for PNFK commencing at 7:00 am and concluding at 9:00 pm. The cost of the care between 8:30 am and 5:30 pm would be at the standard week day rate as set forth in the NDIA price guide. The hours between 7:00 am and 8:30 am, and between 5:30 am and 9:00 pm would be at higher rates. Where a long week end or public holiday cut into the standard work week, for example, a public holiday on a Monday, the remainder of the working week from Tuesday to Friday would warrant 14 hours of care per day. Second, on standard weekends, 4 hours of care for PNFK from 11:00 am to 3:00 pm on both days, that is on Saturdays and Sundays. Third, on four long weekends, 24 hour care of PNFK for three days to enable PNFK’s family to have respite.