LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte [2019] QSC 233

PARTIES:

JOHN RICHARD PARK AND GINETTE DAWN MULLER AS LIQUIDATORS OF LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288

(First Applicant)


AND

LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288
(Second Applicant)

v


DAVID WHYTE AS THE PERSON APPOINTED TO SUPERVISE THE WINDING UP OF THE LM FIRST MORTGAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288 PURSUANT TO SECTION 601NF OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT 2001

(First Respondent)

AND

SAID JAHANI IN HIS CAPACITY AS RECEIVER AND MANAGER OF THE ASSETS, UNDERTAKINGS, RIGHTS AND INTERESTS OF LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIEDATION) (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 AS THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM CURRENCY PROTECTED AUSTRLAIAN INCOME FUND ARSN 110 247 875 AND THE LM INSTITUTIONAL CURRENCY PROTECTED AUSTRALIAN INCOME FUND ARSN 122 052 868

(Second Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 3508 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application filed 10 October 2018 and an application filed 1 February 2019

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

2 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

For the application filed 10 October 2018 – 10 December 2018

For the application filed 1 February 2019 – 13 March 2019

JUDGE:

Jackson J

ORDER:

On the application filed 10 October 2018 the order of the court is that:

1.   The application is dismissed.

2.   The parties exchange and file written submissions as to costs by 8 October 2019.

On the application filed 1 February 2019 the order of the court is that:

1.   The first respondent is authorised and empowered to make an interim distribution from the property of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund (“FMIF”) among the members of the FMIF of up to $40 million.

2.   It is declared that each member holding “Class C” Units in the FMIF is entitled to be paid in the winding up of the FMIF amounts calculated by reference to the calculation of that member’s units in the foreign currency of investment as adjusted for the foreign exchange spot rate between the currency of investment and the Australian dollar prevailing at the date of the commencement of the winding up of the FMIF.

3.   The first respondent’s costs of the application be costs in the winding up of the FMIF to be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid to the first respondent from the property of the FMIF.

4.   Trilogy exchange and file with any opposite party submissions as to costs by 8 October 2019.

CATCHWORDS:

CORPORATIONS – MANAGED INVESTMENTS – WINDING UP – Where the second applicant is the responsible entity of a registered managed investment scheme – Where the first applicant is the liquidator of the second applicant – Where the first respondent was appointed to take…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 233
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte, the dispute involved the winding up of a registered managed investment scheme. The first applicant was the liquidator of the second applicant, who was the responsible entity of the scheme. The first respondent had been appointed to oversee the winding up of the scheme in accordance with its constitution. The first applicant sought directions to take over responsibility for the winding up process, while the first respondent applied for orders to authorise an interim distribution to the scheme members and a declaration regarding the entitlement of Class C unit holders to payments in the winding up. The court had to decide whether to transfer the responsibility for winding up the scheme from the first respondent to the first applicant, whether to authorise an interim distribution, and how to ascertain the entitlements of Class C unit holders in the winding up.

The court found that transferring the winding up responsibility from the first respondent to the first applicant was not appropriate at that stage. The court held that the continued appointment of the first respondent was necessary to ensure the scheme was wound up in accordance with its constitution and to address the remaining litigation matters. The court also authorised the first respondent to make an interim distribution of up to $40 million to the scheme members and declared that Class C unit holders were entitled to be paid amounts calculated by reference to the appropriate calculation of units in AUD as at the date of the commencement of the winding up.

The court's decision was based on the need to ensure the winding up process was managed effectively and efficiently, taking into account the remaining litigation matters and the interests of the scheme members. The court found that the first respondent was best placed to continue overseeing the winding up process, while also addressing the remaining litigation matters. The court also considered the need to provide some relief to the scheme members through an interim distribution and to ensure that Class C unit holders were paid amounts calculated correctly.

The final orders of the court dismissed the first applicant's application to take over responsibility for the winding up process. The court authorised the first respondent to make an interim distribution of up to $40 million to the scheme members and declared that Class C unit holders were entitled to be paid amounts calculated by reference to the appropriate calculation of units in AUD as at the date of the commencement of the winding up. The court also ordered the parties to exchange and file written submissions as to costs by specified dates.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the application filed 10 October 2018 the order of the court is that:

1. The application is dismissed.

2. The parties exchange and file written submissions as to costs by 8 October 2019.

On the application filed 1 February 2019 the order of the court is that:

1. The first respondent is authorised and empowered to make an interim distribution from the property of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund (“FMIF”) among the members of the FMIF of up to $40 million.

2. It is declared that each member holding “Class C” Units in the FMIF is entitled to be paid in the winding up of the FMIF amounts calculated by reference to the calculation of that member’s units in the foreign currency of investment as adjusted for the foreign exchange spot rate between the currency of investment and the Australian dollar prevailing at the date of the commencement of the winding up of the FMIF.

3. The first respondent’s costs of the application be costs in the winding up of the FMIF to be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid to the first respondent from the property of the FMIF.

4. Trilogy exchange and file with any opposite party submissions as to costs by 8 October 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In my view, no appointment of the liquidator as a contradictor for the Clear Accounts Proceeding should be made. Liquidator’s proposed remuneration and expenses regimes The liquidator submits that the winding up of the FMIF has been a lengthy and expensive task. In particular, the remuneration of Mr Whyte up to the time of making the first application has exceeded $14 million, to which must be added the remuneration of the liquidator (including whilst appointed voluntary administrator) and the external receivers. The liquidator submits that since all the assets of the FMIF have been realised, apart from any that may be collected in the remaining litigation, any course which lessens the cost burden on the members of the FMIF is desirable and necessary. Remuneration To that end, the liquidator proposes[21] that if he were appointed to continue the winding up of the FMIF, he would cap his remuneration for the work necessary to wind it up at $180,000 per annum plus $200,000 for identified one-off tasks that would need to be completed (both exclusive of GST). [21] By an affidavit of Kelly-Anne Trenfield. The liquidator submits that the continued appointment of Mr Whyte apart from continuing the Feeder Funds Proceeding, the Clear Accounts Proceeding and the EY Proceeding (and I infer the Bellpac Proceeding) is unnecessary. As previously mentioned, there is a substantial issue between Mr Whyte as receiver of the FMIF and LMIM in its own right, by the liquidator, as to whether LMIM in its own right is entitled to recover costs or expenses by an indemnity of exoneration from the scheme property of the FMIF, which is the subject of the Clear Accounts Proceeding. Notwithstanding this difficulty, the liquidator made submissions as to the differences between his proposals in relation to a number of different subject matters that would remain in the winding up of the FMIF, as matters that will attract remuneration for the insolvency practitioner carrying them out, on the basis that the comparison demonstrates that the liquidator would be more cost effective than Mr Whyte. Perhaps he would be on those matters, but it does not seem to me that is a strong factor in the circumstances viewed overall, because they are relatively minor matters of remuneration and expense in comparison to resolving the remaining litigation. Another point that assumed some significance in oral argument was Mr Whyte’s concern that if responsibility for the winding up of the FMIF were transferred to the liquidator, except for Mr Whyte’s conduct of the remaining litigation matters, the cash funds that are presently under Mr Whyte’s control would pass to the liquidator. Mr Whyte’s submissions expressed concern about both the practical need he would then have to involve the liquidator in seeking payment of sums on account of the remaining litigation and also that the liquidator has conflicts between LMIM’s own interests and LMIM’s duties as responsible entity of the other registered schemes on the one hand and the interests of the members of the FMIF. However, before reaching those matters there are a number of other points.