SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte [2019] QSC 245
PARTIES:
JOHN RICHARD PARK AND GINETTE DAWN MULLER AS LIQUIDATORS OF LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288
(First Applicant)
ANDLM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288
(Second Applicant)
v
DAVID WHYTE AS THE PERSON APPOINTED TO SUPERVISE THE WINDING UP OF THE LM FIRST MORTGAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288 PURSUANT TO SECTION 601NF OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT 2001(First Respondent)
FILE NO/S:
BS No 3508 of 2015
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application filed 17 July 2018
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:
2 October 2019
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
6 September 2018, 3 October 2018
JUDGE:
Jackson J
ORDER:
The order of the Court is that:
1. The first applicant’s Corporate Remuneration as liquidators for the period 2 August 2013 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $736,550.65 (including GST);
2. The first applicant’s Category 1 Remuneration as liquidators for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $1,089,078.65 (including GST);
3. The first applicant’s Category 2 Remuneration as liquidators for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $306, 792.75 (including GST);
4. The first applicant be paid the sum of $615,711.64 (including GST) from the scheme property of the AIF for remuneration as liquidators of the second applicant, such sum to include:
(a) $539,013.75 (including GST) for Category 1 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018; and
(b) $76,698.19 (including GST) for Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018.
5. The first applicant be paid the sum of $393,043.89 (including GST) from the scheme property of the FMIF for remuneration as liquidators of the second applicant, such sum to include:
(a) $316,345.70 (including GST) for Category 1 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018; and
(b) $76,698.19 (including GST) for Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018.
6. The first applicant be paid the sum of $310,417.39 (including GST) from the scheme property of the ASPF for remuneration as liquidators of the Second Applicant, such sum to include:
(a) $233,719.20 (including GST) for Category 1 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018; and
(b) $76, 698.19 (including GST) for Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018.
7. The parties exchange and file written submissions as to costs by 8 October 2019.
CATCHWORDS:
CORPORATIONS – WINDING UP – LIQUIDATORS – REMUNERATION – IN VOLUNTARY WINDING UP – Whether liquidator entitled to be paid remuneration from trust property for Corporate Remuneration, Category…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] QSC 245
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court held that the liquidators were entitled to be paid remuneration from the trust property for Corporate Remuneration, Category 1 Remuneration and Category 2 Remuneration. The Court found that there was no error in the liquidators’ approach to the determination of the Corporate Remuneration, Category 1 Remuneration and Category 2 Remuneration. The Court found that the liquidators were entitled to be paid remuneration for Category 1 and Category 2 Remuneration from the property of the schemes, and that the liquidators were entitled to receive GST in respect of any remuneration recoverable against the FMIF.
The Court made an order that the first applicant’s Corporate Remuneration as liquidators for the period 2 August 2013 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $736,550.65 (including GST), and that the first applicant’s Category 1 Remuneration and Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sums of $1,089,078.65 (including GST) and $306,792.75 (including GST) respectively. The Court also made an order that the first applicant be paid remuneration from the scheme property of the AIF, FMIF and ASPF in the sums of $615,711.64, $393,043.89 and $310,417.39 respectively (all including GST).
Orders
Orders of the court
The order of the Court is that:
1. The first applicant’s Corporate Remuneration as liquidators for the period 2 August 2013 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $736,550.65 (including GST);
2. The first applicant’s Category 1 Remuneration as liquidators for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $1,089,078.65 (including GST);
3. The first applicant’s Category 2 Remuneration as liquidators for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018 be determined in the sum of $306, 792.75 (including GST);
4. The first applicant be paid the sum of $615,711.64 (including GST) from the scheme property of the AIF for remuneration as liquidators of the second applicant, such sum to include:
(a) $539,013.75 (including GST) for Category 1 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018; and
(b) $76,698.19 (including GST) for Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018.
5. The first applicant be paid the sum of $393,043.89 (including GST) from the scheme property of the FMIF for remuneration as liquidators of the second applicant, such sum to include:
(a) $316,345.70 (including GST) for Category 1 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018; and
(b) $76,698.19 (including GST) for Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018.
6. The first applicant be paid the sum of $310,417.39 (including GST) from the scheme property of the ASPF for remuneration as liquidators of the Second Applicant, such sum to include:
(a) $233,719.20 (including GST) for Category 1 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018; and
(b) $76, 698.19 (including GST) for Category 2 Remuneration for the period 1 October 2015 to 30 June 2018.
7. The parties exchange and file written submissions as to costs by 8 October 2019.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The liquidator submits that while there may have been some residual doubt previously as to whether a liquidator may claim his or her general liquidation expenses out of trust assets, both the First Remuneration Decision and the later decisions on which he relies make it clear that such a claim may be made. In my view, there is nothing in the later decisions that changes the relevant questions or answers as to the recoverability of the liquidator’s remuneration in the present case. It is unnecessary to discuss those cases in detail.Corporate Remuneration As appears from the table set out above, the largest overall amount for which the liquidator seeks an order that the remuneration be paid from the property of the schemes, generally speaking, comprises the claimed Corporate Remuneration for the period of the voluntary administration ($658,220.84) and the period of the liquidation ($736,550.65). John Park describes Corporate Remuneration work as work which related only to LMIM in its corporate capacity or work which had to be done in the voluntary administration or the winding up of any company, but that was not referrable either to an individual scheme or to the schemes generally. He says further that Corporate Remuneration work in respect of both the voluntary administration and liquidation of LMIM was work that was not clearly referable to a particular scheme, or in respect of the funds’ management business of LMIM, or work which related to all of the schemes generally, or in respect of the FMIF controllerships (described as “Category 3 Remuneration” work in the First Remuneration Decision). Kellie-Ann Trenfield describes the separate recording of Corporate Remuneration in the time recording system of FTI Consulting. That time recording system was designed to comply with the ARITA Code of Professional Practice (“the ARITA Code”) in force from time to time. Using the ARITA Code categories, the liquidators, Ms Trenfield and other staff at FTI Consulting recorded time on a daily basis in 6 minute units for the duration of the time spent on a task, as well as a description of the task. A separate cost code number and category was created for work for LMIM as responsible entity of all of the schemes generally and LMIM in its own right. The work in that cost code was further sub-categorised using an activity code as between work for LMIM in its own right, referred to in this application as the work for Corporate Remuneration and work for LMIM as responsible entity of the schemes generally, although not for a particular scheme, sub-categorised as work for LMIM as RE/trustee, referred to in this application and the First Remuneration Decision as Category 2 Remuneration work. Ms Trenfield says that detailed instructions were given to FTI Consulting staff members as to how to distinguish the relevant work among the categories and sub-categories now reflected in the liquidator’s claims for Category 1 Remuneration, Category 2 Remuneration and Corporate Remuneration. Ms Trenfield is satisfied that those instructions were followed. As well, from time to time, Mr Park and Ms Trenfield have manually reviewed all of the time recorded in respect of all the categories and sub-categories of work.