LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte [2019] QSC 257

PARTIES:

JOHN RICHARD PARK AND GINETTE DAWN MULLER AS LIQUIDATORS OF LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288

(First Applicant)


AND

LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) (RECEIVERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM FIRST MORTAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288
(Second Applicant)

v


DAVID WHYTE AS THE PERSON APPOINTED TO SUPERVISE THE WINDING UP OF THE LM FIRST MORTGAGE INCOME FUND ARSN 089 343 288 PURSUANT TO SECTION 601NF OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT 2001

(First Respondent)

AND

SAID JAHANI IN HIS CAPACITY AS RECEIVER AND MANAGER OF THE ASSETS, UNDERTAKINGS, RIGHTS AND INTERESTS OF LM INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LIMITED (IN LIQUIEDATION) (RECEIVERS AND MANAGERS APPOINTED) ACN 077 208 461 AS THE RESPONSIBLE ENTITY OF THE LM CURRENCY PROTECTED AUSTRLAIAN INCOME FUND ARSN 110 247 875 AND THE LM INSTITUTIONAL CURRENCY PROTECTED AUSTRALIAN INCOME FUND ARSN 122 052 868

(Second Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 3508 of 2015

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Applications for costs

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

17 October 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Written submissions

JUDGE:

Jackson J

ORDERS:

On the application filed 17 July 2018 the order of the Court is that:

1.   In the event that GST is not assessed on some or all of the amounts ordered to be paid to the first applicant from the FMIF by the orders made on 2 October 2019, or, having been assessed, in the event that the first applicant later receives a decreasing adjustment, a refund or other credit on the basis that he was not in fact liable to be assessed on that amount (in whole or in part), the first applicant is to account to the FMIF for the GST included in the amounts ordered to be paid by these orders to that extent.

2.   The costs of the application be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the property of the AIF, FMIF and ASPF in equal (one third) shares.

On the application filed 10 October 2018 the order of the Court is that:

3.   The first respondent’s costs of the application be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the scheme property of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – COSTS – INDEMNITY COSTS – RELEVANT CONSIDERATIONS GENERALLY – Whether it was appropriate to reduce the liquidator’s costs by reference to a percentage of the liquidator’s assessed costs of the application attributable to Corporate Remuneration – Whether costs are to be assessed on the indemnity basis

Aion Corporation Pty Ltd v Yolla Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor [2013] QSC 216, cited

LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte [2019] QSC 233, cited

LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte [2019] QSC 245

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of LM Investment Management Limited v Whyte involved a dispute between the liquidator of a fund and a respondent regarding the assessment of costs associated with a legal application. The Queensland Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether the liquidator's costs should be reduced based on a percentage of the costs attributable to a claim for Corporate Remuneration and whether the costs should be assessed on an indemnity basis.

The court had to decide two key issues: whether it was appropriate to reduce the liquidator’s costs by reference to a percentage of the liquidator’s assessed costs attributable to the claim for Corporate Remuneration, and whether the costs should be assessed on the indemnity basis. The liquidator sought full indemnity costs from the scheme property of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund, LM Australian Income Fund, and LM Australian Structured Products Fund. The respondent argued that the liquidator should only recover 50% of the costs due to his failure to obtain an order for payment of Corporate Remuneration from the LM First Mortgage Income Fund.

The court rejected the respondent’s argument that the costs should be apportioned based on the percentage of the liquidator’s total claim for remuneration represented by Corporate Remuneration. The court found that the amount of the claim was not a reliable measure for apportioning costs. The court also dismissed the respondent’s contention that a significant proportion of the liquidator's supplementary material and the court's time was spent on issues related to Corporate Remuneration. The court concluded that the opposition to Corporate Remuneration was based on multiple grounds and that a great deal of the added time and expense related to grounds that were not decided.

The court ultimately ruled that the costs of the application be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the property of the LM Australian Income Fund, LM First Mortgage Income Fund, and LM Australian Structured Products Fund in equal shares. Additionally, the court made specific orders regarding the accounting for GST in the event that the liquidator was not liable for it.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the application filed 17 July 2018 the order of the Court is that:

1. In the event that GST is not assessed on some or all of the amounts ordered to be paid to the first applicant from the FMIF by the orders made on 2 October 2019, or, having been assessed, in the event that the first applicant later receives a decreasing adjustment, a refund or other credit on the basis that he was not in fact liable to be assessed on that amount (in whole or in part), the first applicant is to account to the FMIF for the GST included in the amounts ordered to be paid by these orders to that extent.

2. The costs of the application be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the property of the AIF, FMIF and ASPF in equal (one third) shares.

On the application filed 10 October 2018 the order of the Court is that:

3. The first respondent’s costs of the application be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the scheme property of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Following delivery of the decisions and orders made in LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte[1] (“Second Directions application and Interim Distribution application”) and LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte[2] (“Second Remuneration application”) the parties made written submissions as to costs. [1] [2019] QSC 233.[2] [2019] QSC 245.Second remuneration application The liquidator applies for an order that his costs of the Second Remuneration application be assessed on the indemnity basis and paid from the scheme property of the LM First Mortgage Income Fund (“FMIF”), LM Australian Income Fund (“AIF”) and LM Australian Structured Products Fund (“ASPF”), each as to one third of the total assessed amount. The first respondent, Mr Whyte, submits that the liquidator should only be permitted to recover 50 percent of the costs that might otherwise be payable from the scheme property of the FMIF because of the liquidator’s failure to obtain an order for payment of Corporate Remuneration[3] from that property. [3] As that term is used in LM Investment Management Limited & Anor v Whyte [2019] QSC 245. In substance, Mr Whyte’s position is at least analogous to treating the question of the recoverability of Corporate Remuneration from the scheme property of the FMIF as an “event” for the purposes of Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 681(1) or a question in the proceeding to which a percentage of the costs of the proceeding are attributable on a percentage basis for the purposes of r 684(1), so that an order specifying a percentage of assessed costs may be made under r 687(2). Mr Whyte submits that regard may be had to the proportion of the liquidator’s total claim for remuneration represented by Corporate Remuneration, i.e. 47 percent. I do not agree. The amount of the claim is not a reliable measure, even for “a rough apportionment of costs ‘intelligently made’”[4], of the costs occasioned by it. Next, Mr Whyte submits that his substantive objections in relation to Corporate Remuneration caused a significant proportion of the supplementary material filed by the liquidator and of the time of the court in the hearing to be taken up by issues related to Corporate Remuneration. In the circumstances, Mr Whyte submits that a 50 percent apportionment of costs to Corporate Remuneration is appropriate so as to reduce the percentage of the assessed costs of the liquidator that might be ordered to be paid from the scheme property of the FMIF.[4] Aion Corporation Pty Ltd v Yolla Holdings Pty Ltd & Anor [2013] QSC 216, [5] and [15]. That approach glosses over Mr Whyte’s opposition to Corporate Remuneration that was based on four separate grounds that I described as “cascading” in the reasons for decision.[5] In the result, I found it unnecessary to determine the other three grounds.[6] However, the very real possibility existed that a great deal of the added time and expense related to the three grounds not decided and that Mr Whyte would not have succeeded on those grounds. [5] [2019] QSC 245, [27].[6] [2019] QSC 245, [37].