Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Mercorella (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Mercorella (No 2)
[2006] FCA 763

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 601EE(2)

Re Stacks Managed Investments Ltd (2005) 54 ACSR 466
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v ABC Fund Managers Ltd (No 3) [2001] VSC 397
Mier v FN Management Pty Ltd (2005) 56 ACSR 93

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v GUISEPPE ANTONIO MERCORELLA & SEABAY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD

SAD 160 of 2005

MANSFIELD J
21 JUNE 2006
ADELAIDE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

SAD 160 OF 2005

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
PLAINTIFF

AND:

GUISEPPE ANTONIO MERCORELLA
FIRST DEFENDANT

SEABAY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 097 021 773
SECOND DEFENDANT

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE:

21 JUNE 2006

PLACE:

ADELAIDE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 20 April 2006, I varied an order of 8 November 2005 under Part 5.9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) for the examination of Domenico Zappia and for him to produce documents. The variation order extended the scope of the proposed examination and the range of the documents he was required to produce. These are my reasons for the variation order.

  2. The original order and the variation order were made on the application of Mr Nicol in the following context.

    BACKGROUND

  3. At material times, Mr Mercorella operated an unregistered managed investment scheme (the Scheme) in contravention of s 601ED(5) of the Act.  It was wound up by order of Lander J made on 8 August 2005 on the application of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) pursuant to s 601EE of the Act.  By the same order, Mr Nicol was appointed receiver and manager of all the property of Mr Mercorella (with one exception) and all property of the Scheme, and as liquidator of the Scheme.

  4. His Honour further ordered that:

    ‘Pursuant to s 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, the winding up of the Scheme shall be conducted as if the Scheme were for the purposes of the Corporations Act a “company” and in acting as liquidator and administering the affairs of the Scheme the liquidator shall have all the powers and responsibilities that a liquidator would have pursuant to the Corporations Act as if the Scheme were a company, with such modifications as are necessary.’

  5. The Scheme was defined in the order as:

    …the managed investment scheme operated by the first defendant whereby the first defendant:

    (a)      obtained moneys from investors;

    (b)pooled those moneys in a National Australia Bank Business Cheque Account, number 53-600-1597 held in the name of the first defendant and/or National Australia Bank, account number 5796-36963 and/or Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited, account number 5796-36963 and/or in any other account;

    (c)represented and/or agreed with investors that the moneys were to be invested for various periods;

    (d)represented and/or agreed with investors that in return for advancing funds, investors would receive a right to interest payments as agreed with the first defendant;

    (e)was to use the funds to fund…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Mercorella... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 763
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Mercorella (No 2) involved Mr Zappia challenging the extent of the liquidator's powers under the Corporations Act, specifically in the context of an unregistered managed investment scheme operated by Mr Mercorella. The dispute arose during Mr Zappia's examination regarding his dealings with Mr Mercorella, as distinct from transactions with the Scheme companies. Mr Zappia argued that his dealings with Mr Mercorella were beyond the scope of the liquidator's powers under section 601EE(2) of the Act, which provides for the winding up of unregistered managed investment schemes.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the liquidator's powers under section 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act extended to examining dealings between the liquidator and the operator of the unregistered managed investment scheme, or were limited to transactions between the liquidator and the Scheme companies. The court needed to determine the appropriate scope of the liquidator's powers under the Act and whether these powers could be varied to allow for broader examination of the operator's dealings.

The court considered the extensive discretion granted to it under section 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act to make orders it considered appropriate for the winding up of unregistered managed investment schemes. The court noted that liquidators appointed under this section have been granted powers similar to those of company liquidators, including powers binding on third parties. The Court of Appeal in Mier v FN Management Pty Ltd clarified that the court's power under section 601EE(2) allows for orders necessary for the due conduct and completion of the winding up. The court concluded that the liquidator's powers could be varied to include examining dealings between the liquidator and the operator of the unregistered managed investment scheme as these dealings were relevant to the winding up of the Scheme.

The court allowed the application, affirming the liquidator's power to examine dealings between the liquidator and the operator of the unregistered managed investment scheme. The court's decision was based on the broad discretion granted to it under section 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, ensuring that the liquidator had the necessary powers to effectively wind up the unregistered managed investment scheme. The court ordered that Mr Zappia and his associated entities were required to provide information about their dealings with Mr Mercorella as part of the liquidator's examination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The original order and the variation order were made on the application of Mr Nicol in the following context.BACKGROUND At material times, Mr Mercorella operated an unregistered managed investment scheme (the Scheme) in contravention of s 601ED(5) of the Act. It was wound up by order of Lander J made on 8 August 2005 on the application of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) pursuant to s 601EE of the Act. By the same order, Mr Nicol was appointed receiver and manager of all the property of Mr Mercorella (with one exception) and all property of the Scheme, and as liquidator of the Scheme. His Honour further ordered that:‘Pursuant to s 601EE(2) of the Corporations Act, the winding up of the Scheme shall be conducted as if the Scheme were for the purposes of the Corporations Act a “company” and in acting as liquidator and administering the affairs of the Scheme the liquidator shall have all the powers and responsibilities that a liquidator would have pursuant to the Corporations Act as if the Scheme were a company, with such modifications as are necessary.’ The Scheme was defined in the order as:…the managed investment scheme operated by the first defendant whereby the first defendant:(a) obtained moneys from investors;(b)pooled those moneys in a National Australia Bank Business Cheque Account, number 53-600-1597 held in the name of the first defendant and/or National Australia Bank, account number 5796-36963 and/or Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited, account number 5796-36963 and/or in any other account;(c)represented and/or agreed with investors that the moneys were to be invested for various periods;(d)represented and/or agreed with investors that in return for advancing funds, investors would receive a right to interest payments as agreed with the first defendant;(e)was to use the funds to fund investments with a view to generating a profit out of which interest payments were to be paid to investors; and(f) had day to day control over the moneys obtained from investors. Each of the Scheme companies was wound up, and Mr Nicol was appointed as liquidator of each of the Scheme companies, by order of this Court made on 29 September 2005. By Order of the Court made on 8 November 2005, Mr Zappia (among others) was ordered to attend for oral examination about the examinable affairs of the ten Scheme companies. Mr Zappia and, through him, three companies of which he is a director, were also ordered to produce books and documents in their possession relating to the examinable affairs of the ten Scheme companies. During the course of Mr Zappia’s subsequent examination, an issue arose as to its permissible extent. Mr Zappia objected to questions relating to dealings between Mr Zappia or his associated entities and Mr Mercorella as operator of the Scheme, as distinct from transactions between the Zappia interests and the ten Scheme companies themselves. The former category of dealings, it was said, were not encompassed within the examinable affairs any of the ten Scheme companies listed in the order and summons, and thus beyond the legitimate scope of the examination.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

Mr Zappia contended that:(1)s 601EE(2) of the Act did not authorise the Court to vary the summons and order in the terms proposed, and alternatively(2)it was not appropriate in the circumstances to exercise that power.CONSIDERATION(a) The power under s 601EE(2) Section 601EE of the Act provides: ‘(1)If a person operates a managed investment scheme in contravention of subsection 601ED(5), the following may apply to the Court to have the scheme wound up:(a)ASIC;(b)the person operating the scheme;(c)a member of the scheme.(3)The Court may make any orders it considers appropriate for the winding up of the scheme.’ Section 601EE(2) has been used by the courts to appoint liquidators, receivers and managers to unregistered managed investment schemes. Liquidators appointed under s 601EE(2) have been granted powers similar to those conferred upon company liquidators, including powers which are binding on third parties: see the review of authorities in Re Stacks Managed Investments Ltd (2005) 54 ACSR 466 at [27]-[37], per White J (Re Stacks). In Australian Securities and Investments Commission v ABC Fund Managers Ltd (No 3) [2001] VSC 397, Warren J specifically conferred upon the liquidator of a series of unregistered managed investment schemes the powers under Pt 5.9 Div 1 of the Corporations Act. Her Honour observed that s 601EE(2) ‘vests a wide and unqualified discretion in the court’ and that ‘the liquidator of the schemes should have every power as if the schemes were corporations ordered to be wound up’: at [5]-[6]. Some doubt was expressed as to the extent of the court’s power and the consequences of its exercise by White J in Re Stacks at [35]. However, as that case concerned the power to give directions as to the winding up of a registered scheme under s 601NF(2), White J found it unnecessary to express a conclusion regarding the reach of s 601EE(2). The scope of the court’s power under s 601EE(2) was put beyond doubt, for present purposes, by the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Queensland in Mier v FN Management Pty Ltd (2005) 56 ACSR 93. Keane JA, with whom McMurdo P and Douglas JA concurred, canvassed the ‘essential characteristics’ of the winding-up process and said, at [16]:‘[Section] 601EE(2) must be read as empowering a court to make such orders as it considers appropriate in order to apply such a procedure to an unregistered managed investment scheme. It may also be accepted that the terms of the section allow for further orders to be made as needed so long as they are required for the “due conduct and completion of the winding up” [Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Takaran Pty Ltd (No 2) (2002) 194 ALR 743 at [12]]. The necessary corollary is that an order that could not reasonably be seen as advancing this procedure would not be authorised by s 601EE(2). The comprehensive survey of authority undertaken by White J in Re Stacks Managed Investments Ltd shows that courts have used the power granted by s 601EE to appoint persons to act as receivers, managers or liquidators with powers commensurate with those that would be possessed by persons fulfilling similar roles in the winding up of a company.’ [footnotes omitted]