SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court)
LIQUORLAND (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD v WOOLWORTHS LIMITED AND ORS
[2018] SASCFC 31
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Peek and The Honourable Justice Parker)
8 May 2018
GAMING AND LIQUOR - ADMINISTRATION - LIQUOR LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR A LICENCE - APPLICATION HEARING - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION - WHETHER REQUIRED FOR NEEDS OF PUBLIC - SOUTH AUSTRALIA
The appellant applied for a retail liquor merchant’s licence for proposed premises at the Park Holme Shopping Centre.
A Judge of the Licensing Court refused the application because the appellant had not satisfied the prerequisites for the grant of a retail liquor merchant’s licence under s 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) (‘Act’). The Judge further held that even if the prerequisites in s 58(2) were met he would nevertheless exercise the discretion to refuse the application under s 53 of the Act.
On appeal, the appellant contends that the Judge erred by failing to identify the relevant locality, incorrectly applying the statutory test in s 58(2) and concluding that he would nevertheless refuse the application under s 53.
Held, by Parker J (Peek J agreeing), dismissing the appeal:
1. While it would have been highly preferable for the Judge to make a specific finding about the locality, the failure to do so did not affect the outcome (at [93]).
2. The words “adequately cater” in s 58(2) require the Licencing Court to make a normative judgment about contemporary expectations of accessibility to retail liquor services (at [97]).
3. The preferences and aspirations of significant sections of the community, the degree of difficulty and inconvenience in accessing retail liquor services if the application is refused and contemporary patterns of family, work and social life that rely on the convenience of one stop shopping are all relevant considerations when fixing the normative standard required by s 58(2) (at [100]).
4. This Court has previously observed that the community may have to tolerate some inconvenience in obtaining liquor. In that light, the question is whether the absence of a retail liquor merchant causes an unacceptable level of inconvenience by community standards (at [117]).
5. The Judge did not err in finding that the existing retail liquor outlets adequately met the public demand for liquor supplies. The evidence supported the Judge’s finding that the lack of a retail liquor merchant at the Park Holme Shopping Centre would not give rise to an unacceptable level of inconvenience by community standards (at [110] and [119]).
Held by Parker J (Kourakis CJ and Peek J agreeing):
1. The object of furthering the interests of the liquor and associated industries in s 3(1)(b) does not prevail over the specific statutory prohibition on taking into account the economic effect of a decision upon local licensees in s 53(1) (at [131]).
2. Whilst the grant of the licence may have the consequence of reducing competition or otherwise impairing the statutory objects, in order to reach that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Woolworths Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] SASCFC 31
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Full Court was whether the Licensing Court Judge had correctly applied section 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA). This section requires an applicant for a retail liquor merchant’s licence to demonstrate that existing licensed premises in the locality do not adequately cater for public demand for liquor for off-premises consumption, and that the licence is necessary to satisfy that demand. A related issue concerned the Judge’s failure to specifically define the "locality" for the purposes of this assessment.
The Full Court considered the evidence presented regarding the existing retail landscape and public demand. While acknowledging the Judge’s omission in failing to define the locality, the Court found this did not affect the outcome, as the boundaries proposed by the parties' planning experts were largely consistent. The Court reasoned that refusing an application based on a trend towards larger discount liquor stores would unfairly skew the competitive market. It held that if a retailer seeks to compete by meeting a specific demand, such as "one-stop shopping" for convenience, this should not be denied simply because larger stores exist.
By majority, the Full Court allowed the appeal. Kourakis CJ and Parker J concluded that the evidence clearly established the necessity of the proposed licence to satisfy public demand for off-premises liquor consumption in the locality. Peek J, however, would have dismissed the appeal, agreeing with the reasoning of Parker J.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The third to seventh respondents further submit that the appellant has not discharged the onus of demonstrating that the existing facilities do not adequately cater for public demand for consumption of packaged liquor in the locality. There is also no basis for the appellant’s contention that but for the alleged errors in his Honour’s approach he would have granted the application.Consideration The first eight grounds of appeal focus on the approach adopted by the Judge to the requirements of s 58(2) of the Act. Several of those grounds significantly overlap. The ninth ground of appeal advanced by the appellant is directed at the observations made by the Judge as to how he would have exercised his discretion under s 53 if he had concluded that the requirements of s 58(2) were satisfied. Failure to identify the locality The appellant’s first ground of appeal is that the Judge failed to identify the locality. I noted in Woolworths v Fassina Investments (with Kourakis CJ and Vanstone J agreeing) that s 58(2) gives rise to two questions:[19] 1Do the licenced premises already existing in the locality adequately cater for the public demand for liquor consumption off licensed premises?2Is the licence necessary to satisfy that demand?[19] (2015) 122 SASR 535. Those questions relate to the supply and demand for liquor in the locality. While it would have been highly preferable for the Judge to make a specific finding about the locality, for the reasons that follow, I do not consider that his Honour’s failure to do so affected the outcome. The only difference between the localities identified by the two planning experts was that Mr Burns placed the western boundary somewhat further west than Mr Smith. The boundaries identified by Mr Smith and Mr Burns were otherwise identical. They both fixed the eastern boundary at South Road, the southern boundary at Sturt Road and the northern boundary at Bray Street and Raglan Avenue. The economist, Mr Stephens, fixed part of the western boundary of the primary trade area at an intermediate position between the limits preferred by Mr Smith and Mr Burns. However, the secondary trade area described by Mr Stephens extended to Brighton Road, which is well beyond the western boundary identified by both Mr Smith and Mr Burns. The only significance of the difference in expert opinion concerning the extent of the locality is that the Fassina store on Oaklands Road at Somerton Park assumes greater importance as the boundary moves further west. The Fassina store is larger and provides a significantly greater range of products in comparison to the proposed premises and the other liquor outlets in or near the locality, with the exception of the Dan Murphy’s store at Westfield Marion. Even if the more confined western boundary preferred by Mr Smith is adopted, the fact that consumers living to the west of the Centre are likely to make at least some use of the Fassina store remains relevant. That is because when public demand for liquor is assessed it is permissible to have regard to premises outside the locality.[20] [20] Woolies Liquor Store Pty Ltd v Seaford Rise Tavern (2000) 76 SASR 290 at [29]-[36], Doyle CJ.