Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Woolworths Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LIQUORLAND (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD v WOOLWORTHS LIMITED AND ORS

[2018] SASCFC 31

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Peek and The Honourable Justice Parker)

8 May 2018

GAMING AND LIQUOR - ADMINISTRATION - LIQUOR LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR A LICENCE - APPLICATION HEARING - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION - WHETHER REQUIRED FOR NEEDS OF PUBLIC - SOUTH AUSTRALIA

The appellant applied for a retail liquor merchant’s licence for proposed premises at the Park Holme Shopping Centre.

A Judge of the Licensing Court refused the application because the appellant had not satisfied the prerequisites for the grant of a retail liquor merchant’s licence under s 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) (‘Act’). The Judge further held that even if the prerequisites in s 58(2) were met he would nevertheless exercise the discretion to refuse the application under s 53 of the Act.

On appeal, the appellant contends that the Judge erred by failing to identify the relevant locality, incorrectly applying the statutory test in s 58(2) and concluding that he would nevertheless refuse the application under s 53.

Held, by Parker J (Peek J agreeing), dismissing the appeal:

1.  While it would have been highly preferable for the Judge to make a specific finding about the locality, the failure to do so did not affect the outcome (at [93]).

2. The words “adequately cater” in s 58(2) require the Licencing Court to make a normative judgment about contemporary expectations of accessibility to retail liquor services (at [97]).

3. The preferences and aspirations of significant sections of the community, the degree of difficulty and inconvenience in accessing retail liquor services if the application is refused and contemporary patterns of family, work and social life that rely on the convenience of one stop shopping are all relevant considerations when fixing the normative standard required by s 58(2) (at [100]).

4.  This Court has previously observed that the community may have to tolerate some inconvenience in obtaining liquor. In that light, the question is whether the absence of a retail liquor merchant causes an unacceptable level of inconvenience by community standards (at [117]).

5.  The Judge did not err in finding that the existing retail liquor outlets adequately met the public demand for liquor supplies. The evidence supported the Judge’s finding that the lack of a retail liquor merchant at the Park Holme Shopping Centre would not give rise to an unacceptable level of inconvenience by community standards (at [110] and [119]).

Held by Parker J (Kourakis CJ and Peek J agreeing):

1. The object of furthering the interests of the liquor and associated industries in s 3(1)(b) does not prevail over the specific statutory prohibition on taking into account the economic effect of a decision upon local licensees in s 53(1) (at [131]).

2. Whilst the grant of the licence may have the consequence of reducing competition or otherwise impairing the statutory objects, in order to reach that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Woolworths Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASCFC 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd appealed to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia against a decision of the Licensing Court to refuse its application for a retail liquor merchant’s licence. The proposed licence was for a Liquorland store to be located within the Park Holme Shopping Centre, which already housed a Coles supermarket and various other retail outlets. The respondents included existing liquor retailers and hoteliers in the vicinity.

The primary legal issue before the Full Court was whether the Licensing Court Judge had correctly applied section 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA). This section requires an applicant for a retail liquor merchant’s licence to demonstrate that existing licensed premises in the locality do not adequately cater for public demand for liquor for off-premises consumption, and that the licence is necessary to satisfy that demand. A related issue concerned the Judge’s failure to specifically define the "locality" for the purposes of this assessment.

The Full Court considered the evidence presented regarding the existing retail landscape and public demand. While acknowledging the Judge’s omission in failing to define the locality, the Court found this did not affect the outcome, as the boundaries proposed by the parties' planning experts were largely consistent. The Court reasoned that refusing an application based on a trend towards larger discount liquor stores would unfairly skew the competitive market. It held that if a retailer seeks to compete by meeting a specific demand, such as "one-stop shopping" for convenience, this should not be denied simply because larger stores exist.

By majority, the Full Court allowed the appeal. Kourakis CJ and Parker J concluded that the evidence clearly established the necessity of the proposed licence to satisfy public demand for off-premises liquor consumption in the locality. Peek J, however, would have dismissed the appeal, agreeing with the reasoning of Parker J.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Permission to appeal under s 27 of the Act was granted by the Full Court on 22 May 2017.Background The Centre is a neighbourhood shopping centre situated at Park Holme on the south western corner of the junction of Marion Road and Oaklands Road. It includes a Coles supermarket together with a number of other shops and businesses. The other shops comprise two bakeries, a hairdresser, a butcher, a pharmacist, a newsagent, two takeaway food shops, a sushi shop, a cheesecake shop, a bank and an electric appliance shop. The Centre lacks a greengrocer, a barber, a dry cleaner, a petrol station and a café (as distinct from fast food outlets). The Judge listed most of the retail premises in his reasons but failed to mention the electric appliance and cheesecake shops and one of the fast food premises. The appellant proposes that its liquor store would be located in a new building to be erected in the northern side of the enclosed foyer leading into the Coles supermarket. Customers would enter the liquor store through automatic sliding doors near the entrance to the Coles supermarket. The new building would have a total floor area of 157 square metres, of which 121.5 square metres would be devoted to sales. The balance would comprise a cool room and a small stock area. Most stock would be held in a bond room some 100 metres away on the opposite side of the Centre.The locality The Licensing Court conducted a view at the Centre and also at several licensed premises in the general area. However, the Judge did not make any decision defining the locality for the purposes of s 58(2) of the Act. That is an unfortunate omission and forms the basis for the first ground of appeal. I will further consider the question of locality after I have referred to the evidence and the parties’ submissions. The evidence The appellant called Ms Sophie Wong, the operations manager for Coles Supermarkets in South Australia, the Northern Territory and Tasmania. Expert evidence was called by the appellant from Mr Jeffery Smith, a planning consultant, and Mr Sean Stephens, an economist. The appellant also called five local residents as witnesses. The first and second respondents called expert evidence from Mr Graham Burns, a town planner. The third to seventh respondents called evidence from Mr Shaun Dwyer, the manager of the BWS liquor store at Ascot Park, Mr Samuel McInnes, the general manager of the Hurley Hotel Group, and Mr Nicholas Limberis, the bottle shop manager at the Marion Hotel. Sophie Wong In her former role as Manager of Coles Liquor, Ms Wong was responsible for 35 Coles liquor stores in South Australia. She stated that, as far as possible, the aim of the Coles Group is to co-locate liquor stores with supermarkets. Ms Wong suggested that people are generally “time poor” and the current trend is for people to shop on multiple occasions each week rather than to have one big weekly shopping excursion. The proposed store would offer “one stop shopping” for customers and remove the need to make another trip for liquor purchases. The store would provide easy access for customers with trollies.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Licensing Court conducted a view at the Centre and also at several licensed premises in the general area. However, the Judge did not make any decision defining the locality for the purposes of s 58(2) of the Act. That is an unfortunate omission and forms the basis for the first ground of appeal. I will further consider the question of locality after I have referred to the evidence and the parties’ submissions. The evidence The appellant called Ms Sophie Wong, the operations manager for Coles Supermarkets in South Australia, the Northern Territory and Tasmania. Expert evidence was called by the appellant from Mr Jeffery Smith, a planning consultant, and Mr Sean Stephens, an economist. The appellant also called five local residents as witnesses. The first and second respondents called expert evidence from Mr Graham Burns, a town planner. The third to seventh respondents called evidence from Mr Shaun Dwyer, the manager of the BWS liquor store at Ascot Park, Mr Samuel McInnes, the general manager of the Hurley Hotel Group, and Mr Nicholas Limberis, the bottle shop manager at the Marion Hotel. Sophie Wong In her former role as Manager of Coles Liquor, Ms Wong was responsible for 35 Coles liquor stores in South Australia. She stated that, as far as possible, the aim of the Coles Group is to co-locate liquor stores with supermarkets. Ms Wong suggested that people are generally “time poor” and the current trend is for people to shop on multiple occasions each week rather than to have one big weekly shopping excursion. The proposed store would offer “one stop shopping” for customers and remove the need to make another trip for liquor purchases. The store would provide easy access for customers with trollies. Ms Wong stated that some 28,000 to 30,000 people visit the Coles supermarket at Park Holme each week. The supermarket was the fourteenth busiest of the 56 Coles stores in South Australia. The Park Holme Coles is a “full line” supermarket and comprises 3,500 square metres. The site was re-developed in 2012 at a cost of $5.5 million. Ms Wong acknowledged that the proposed Liquorland store would be one of the smaller stores operating under that name in South Australia. Based upon her knowledge of drive through bottle departments at hotels operated by the Coles Group, Ms Wong stated that persons attending bottle departments are predominantly male whereas Liquorland customers are predominantly female. She also stated that at drive through bottle departments a high proportion of the sales are beer and pre-mixed drinks, whereas in a liquor store the product mix is more evenly weighted. Specifically, in Liquorland stores there is a “higher skew” towards wine, with up to 50% of sales attributable to wine. Jeffery Smith Mr Smith prepared a detailed report and gave oral evidence. He described the Centre as a “landmark” shopping centre that has operated for more than 50 years. Due to its longevity and mix of tenants, it has sustained its position as an important retail centre for the local community. In the view of Mr Smith, the proposed Liquorland store will add to the range of facilities available in this well recognised and substantial neighbourhood shopping centre.

Decision

Reasons for decision

More importantly, if that trend is used to justify the refusal of applications, such as the one proposed by the appellant, the superstore trend will inexorably march on. If one of the larger, or smaller, retailers, wishes to compete by meeting the sectional demand for one stop shopping, it is wrong in law to deny its application, even in part, because there is a stronger demand for large discount liquor stores. To refuse an application, even in part, on that ground, would skew the competitive market place which might otherwise adequately meet the demands of all significant sections of the public.Conclusion The evidence clearly establishes that the proposed licence is necessary to satisfy public demand in the locality for the off-premises consumption of liquor. I would allow the appeal. I would grant the licence. PEEK J: I would dismiss the appeal. I agree with the reasons of Parker J. PARKER J: This is an appeal from the decision of the Licensing Court of South Australia to refuse the grant of a retail liquor merchant’s licence for premises that the appellant, Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd, proposes to build at the Park Holme Shopping Centre (‘the Centre’). The appellant contends that the Licensing Court Judge incorrectly applied s 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) (‘the Act’). The first and second respondents, Woolworths Limited and Woolies Liquor Stores Pty Ltd, operate a Dan Murphy’s liquor store at the Westfield Marion Shopping Centre and a BWS liquor store on Marion Road at Ascot Park. The first and second respondents are represented by the same counsel. The third and fourth respondents, P & J Hurley & Hurley/Symons Pty Ltd and Hurley Hotels Pty Ltd, operate the Marion Hotel on Marion Road, Mitchell Park and the Tonsley Hotel on South Road, Clovelly Park. The names of the fifth and sixth respondents identify their respective businesses, the Warradale Hotel Pty Ltd and the Morphett Arms Hotel Pty Ltd. Those hotels are respectively located on Diagonal Road, Warradale and Morphett Road, Glengowrie. The seventh respondent, Fassina Holdings Pty Ltd, operates a retail liquor store on Oaklands Road, Somerton Park. The third to seventh respondents are represented by the same counsel.The Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) The relevant provisions of the Act are: 3—Objects(1)The object of this Act is to regulate and control the sale, supply and consumption of liquor for the benefit of the community as a whole and, in particular—(a) to encourage responsible attitudes towards the promotion, sale, supply, consumption and use of liquor, to develop and implement principles directed towards that end (the responsible service and consumption principles) and minimise the harm associated with the consumption of liquor; and(b) to further the interests of the liquor industry and industries with which it is closely associated—such as the live music industry, tourism and the hospitality industry—within the context of appropriate regulation and controls; and(c) to ensure that the liquor industry develops in a way that is consistent with the needs and aspirations of the community; and(d) to ensure as far as practicable that the sale and supply of liquor contributes to, and does not detract from, the amenity of community life; and(e) to encourage a competitive market for the supply of liquor; and(f) …(2)In deciding any matter before it under this Act, the licensing authority must have regard to the objects set out in subsection (1).…53—Discretionary powers of licensing authority(1)Subject to this Act, the licensing authority has an unqualified discretion to grant or refuse an application under this Act on any ground, or for any reason, the licensing authority considers sufficient (but is not to take into account an economic effect on other licensees in the locality affected by the application).…58—Grant of hotel licence or retail liquor merchant's licence(1)…(2)An applicant for a retail liquor merchant's licence must satisfy the licensing authority that the licensed premises already existing in the locality in which the premises or proposed premises to which the application relates are, or are proposed to be, situated, do not adequately cater for the public demand for liquor for consumption off licensed premises and the licence is necessary to satisfy that demand.(3)…Grounds of appeal

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The third to seventh respondents further submit that the appellant has not discharged the onus of demonstrating that the existing facilities do not adequately cater for public demand for consumption of packaged liquor in the locality. There is also no basis for the appellant’s contention that but for the alleged errors in his Honour’s approach he would have granted the application.Consideration The first eight grounds of appeal focus on the approach adopted by the Judge to the requirements of s 58(2) of the Act. Several of those grounds significantly overlap. The ninth ground of appeal advanced by the appellant is directed at the observations made by the Judge as to how he would have exercised his discretion under s 53 if he had concluded that the requirements of s 58(2) were satisfied. Failure to identify the locality The appellant’s first ground of appeal is that the Judge failed to identify the locality. I noted in Woolworths v Fassina Investments (with Kourakis CJ and Vanstone J agreeing) that s 58(2) gives rise to two questions:[19] 1Do the licenced premises already existing in the locality adequately cater for the public demand for liquor consumption off licensed premises?2Is the licence necessary to satisfy that demand?[19] (2015) 122 SASR 535. Those questions relate to the supply and demand for liquor in the locality. While it would have been highly preferable for the Judge to make a specific finding about the locality, for the reasons that follow, I do not consider that his Honour’s failure to do so affected the outcome. The only difference between the localities identified by the two planning experts was that Mr Burns placed the western boundary somewhat further west than Mr Smith. The boundaries identified by Mr Smith and Mr Burns were otherwise identical. They both fixed the eastern boundary at South Road, the southern boundary at Sturt Road and the northern boundary at Bray Street and Raglan Avenue. The economist, Mr Stephens, fixed part of the western boundary of the primary trade area at an intermediate position between the limits preferred by Mr Smith and Mr Burns. However, the secondary trade area described by Mr Stephens extended to Brighton Road, which is well beyond the western boundary identified by both Mr Smith and Mr Burns. The only significance of the difference in expert opinion concerning the extent of the locality is that the Fassina store on Oaklands Road at Somerton Park assumes greater importance as the boundary moves further west. The Fassina store is larger and provides a significantly greater range of products in comparison to the proposed premises and the other liquor outlets in or near the locality, with the exception of the Dan Murphy’s store at Westfield Marion. Even if the more confined western boundary preferred by Mr Smith is adopted, the fact that consumers living to the west of the Centre are likely to make at least some use of the Fassina store remains relevant. That is because when public demand for liquor is assessed it is permissible to have regard to premises outside the locality.[20] [20] Woolies Liquor Store Pty Ltd v Seaford Rise Tavern (2000) 76 SASR 290 at [29]-[36], Doyle CJ.