Costco Wholesale Australia Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

COSTCO WHOLESALE AUSTRALIA PTY LTD v WOOLWORTHS LTD AND ORS

[2016] SASCFC 75

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Bampton and The Honourable Justice Parker)

21 July 2016

GAMING AND LIQUOR - ADMINISTRATION - LIQUOR LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR A LICENCE - APPLICATION HEARING - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION - GENERALLY

GAMING AND LIQUOR - ADMINISTRATION - LIQUOR LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR A LICENCE - APPLICATION HEARING - POWERS OF LICENSING AUTHORITY - DISCRETION TO GRANT OR REFUSE LICENCE

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - WHOLE ACT TO BE CONSIDERED

Appeal from a decision of the Licensing Court refusing an application by Costco Wholesale Australia Pty Ltd (Costco) for the grant of a special circumstances licence with an extended trading authorisation in respect of premises at Churchill Road, Kilburn. The sales model proposed by Costco was to sell a limited range of liquor to Costco members and employees. The liquor was to be offered for sale in an area not physically separate from the rest of the store. The Licensing Court judge found that the preconditions were satisfied for the grant of a special circumstances licence under s 40 but refused the application by exercising against Costco the discretion to grant the licence under s 53 of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997. The issues on appeal were; first, whether the judge erred in finding that a retail liquor merchant’s licence could not adequately cover Costco’s business; secondly, whether Costco satisfied the two preconditions for a special circumstances license; and thirdly, whether the judge erred by exercising the discretion to refuse the application.

Held per Kourakis CJ, dismissing the appeal:

(1)  Strong reasons would have to be shown to grant a special circumstances licence to authorise the sale of liquor for off-premises consumption without a need to meet the public demand test and free of the physical separation requirement.

Held per Parker J (Kourakis CJ and Bampton J agreeing), dismissing the appeal:

(1)  The judge erred in finding that Costco would not qualify for a retail liquor merchant’s licence because the membership requirement was inconsistent with the implied requirement to sell to the public. Costco members are merely a class of the general public and thus Costco is selling to the public.

(2) The judge correctly concluded that a licensing authority would not exercise the s 37(2) discretion to exclude Costco from the physical separation requirement under a retail liquor merchant’s licence. A mere preference for full integration of liquor and general sales would not provide a proper reason to warrant exercise of the discretion.

(3) Costco does not qualify for a special circumstances licence because it does not satisfy the preconditions under s 40 that:

(a)  no licence of any other category would adequately cover the kind of business proposed. The essential element of a retail liquor merchant’s licence is that it authorises the sale of liquor for consumption off…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Costco Wholesale Australia Pty Ltd v Woolworths Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASCFC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Costco Wholesale Australia Pty Ltd appealed a decision of the Licensing Court of South Australia concerning its application for a liquor licence for its Kilburn store. The proposed licence would permit the sale of liquor within a designated area of the general store, with sales restricted to Costco members and employees. Purchases would be made at existing checkouts, and the store would stock a limited range of high-quality liquor. Woolworths Ltd was the respondent in the appeal.

The primary legal issues before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia were whether the judge erred in finding that Costco's proposed business model could not operate under a retail liquor merchant's licence, whether Costco could properly be granted a special circumstances licence, and whether the judge erred in exercising his discretion to refuse the application. A key aspect of the dispute revolved around section 37(2) of the relevant Act, which generally requires licensed premises to be devoted entirely to the sale of liquor and to be physically separate from premises used for other commercial purposes, subject to exceptions.

The Court reasoned that Costco's proposed business model could not be accommodated by a standard retail liquor merchant's licence due to the requirement for physical separation of the liquor sales area from other commercial activities, a requirement Costco was unwilling to meet. The Court also considered whether Costco's membership-based sales model satisfied an implied requirement that a retail liquor merchant's licence holder must sell to the public generally. Ultimately, the Court concluded that Costco had not established that its business would be substantially prejudiced if its trading rights were limited to those possible under a retail liquor merchant's licence, and therefore, it was not entitled to a special circumstances licence.

The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow I would dismiss the appeal.Background The proposed licensed premises would form part of a Costco store located at the Churchill Centre. This is a major retail development on the site of the former Islington railway yards. Costco commenced business in Canada and now has more than 600 stores in eight countries. The Kilburn store is Costco’s first site in South Australia. At the time of the application it had six other stores in Australia located in Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland and the Australian Capital Territory. The Costco business model is different to that customarily found in the liquor industry. The liquor licence proposal includes the following features:·Liquor will be offered for sale in a defined area that will not be physically separate from the rest of the store. Purchases will be made at the same checkouts used for all goods purchased in the store;·The trading hours will not be greater than 9.00 am to 9.00 pm on Monday to Friday and 9.00 am to 7.00 pm on Saturday, Sunday and public holidays. An extended trading authorisation was sought to allow sales between 9.00 am and 11.00 am on Sundays;·Liquor will only be sold and supplied to persons whom are either members of Costco (the annual membership fee is $60) or employed by Costco; ·No more than 300 lines of liquor product will be stocked at any one time; and·The liquor will be of high quality with an emphasis on imported products. It will not be refrigerated and beer will only be sold by the carton. Costco stores have the internal appearance of a warehouse. Costco’s sales model has a dual focus. It operates as a wholesale supplier for small to medium businesses and also sells on a retail basis to individuals. Sales are only made to members. In addition to payment of the $60 annual fee, applicants for membership must be aged over 18 years, provide photographic identification and an address. Business applicants must also supply a tax file number or alternative proof that they operate a business. The Kilburn store offers a wide range of goods. The range includes food, clothing, outdoor furniture, sporting goods, watches and jewellery, hearing aids, electrical appliances and car tyres. Fuel is also sold on a completely self service basis with customers inserting their credit card and membership card to make a purchase. The evidence given in support of Costco was that it only intends to stock a limited range of liquor because dealing in pallet quantities minimises labour costs. Placement of the liquor section within the general store area (without separate checkout facilities) is, in part, intended to reduce shoplifting. The legislative scheme The grant of a retail liquor merchant’s licence is governed by s 37 of the Act. It provides:37—Retail liquor merchant's licence(1) A retail liquor merchant's licence authorises the licensee—(a)to sell liquor on the licensed premises on any day except Good Friday and Christmas Day between the hours of 8 am and 9 pm, or over a continuous period authorised by the licensing authority, for consumption off the licensed premises (but a period authorised by the licensing authority must begin no earlier than 5 am, must end no later than midnight, and must not exceed 13 hours); and(ab)to sell liquor at any time through direct sales transactions (provided that, if the liquor is to be delivered to an address in this State, the liquor is despatched and delivered only between the hours of 8 am and 9 pm and not on Good Friday or Christmas Day); and(b)to sell or supply liquor by way of sample for consumption on a part of the licensed premises approved for the purposes by the licensing authority. (2) It is a condition of a retail liquor merchant's licence that the licensed premises must be devoted entirely to the business conducted under the licence and must be physically separate from premises used for other commercial purposes. Exceptions— 1Goods may be sold in the same premises if they are of the kind normally associated with, and incidental to, the sale of liquor (eg glasses, decanters, cheeses and pates). 2The licensing authority may grant an exemption from the above condition if satisfied that the demand for liquor in the relevant locality is insufficient to justify the establishment of separate premises or there is some other proper reason for granting the exemption.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the judge stated that he was exercising the s 53 discretion on the basis of his concern about a potential proliferation of special circumstances licences being issued to slightly modified retail liquor merchant’s businesses, in substance he took the same approach as I have adopted. That approach requires a licencing authority, when deciding whether to grant a special circumstances licence for a proposal that closely resembles an existing category of licence, to find good reason to depart from the ordinary statutory requirements for the grant of that category of licence. In Bottega Rotolo the particular features of the business provided good reason for departure. However, in this case the essence of the Costco model is a retail liquor merchant’s business. The preference of Costco for the particular features of its model does not provide good reason to depart from the physical separation requirement and nor is it good reason to disregard the demand test. That is not to suggest that the Costco model is a contrivance. Clearly it is not. The model operates at many stores in several countries. Conclusion Costco is not entitled to the grant of a special circumstances licence because it has not established under s 40(2)(a) that its proposed business would be substantially prejudiced if its trading rights were limited to those possible under a retail liquor merchant’s licence. I would grant permission for the respondents to amend the notice of alternative contention to include ground 4 and I would dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents conceded that Costco may be inconvenienced, but contended that its business would not be substantially prejudiced, if its trading rights were limited to those possible under a retail liquor merchant’s licence. They drew support for that contention from the reasons of Doyle CJ in Facac Pty Ltd v Talbot Hotel Group Pty Ltd as follows:[11]… the Licensing Court must also bear in mind that s 40 is not to be used simply to create a licence to meet an applicant’s wishes. If an existing class of licence will fit the proposed business, s 40 should not be used, unless the use of the existing class of licence would produce a result that “the proposed business would be substantially prejudiced.” The special circumstances licence is not, as I have said, to be created simply to meet an applicant’s wishes and proposal. The Court must consider whether another class of licence can and should be granted, even if requiring the applicant to trade under that licence imposes obligations that the applicant would rather not have, and even if that means that the applicant must prove a need for the grant of the licence.[11] (2001) 80 SASR 580 at [51].Consideration Three primary issues require consideration. The first issue is whether the judge erred in finding that a retail liquor merchant’s licence under s 37 could not adequately cover Costco’s business. The second issue is whether Costco could properly be granted a special circumstances licence under s 40. The third issue is whether the judge erred by exercising the general discretion under s 53 to refuse the Costco application.Retail liquor merchant’s licence As I have already noted, the judge found on two grounds that Costco’s proposed business model could not operate under a retail liquor merchant’s licence. One ground was that s 37(2) would preclude grant of such a licence. That was because the premises were not to be devoted entirely to the business conducted under the licence and nor were they to be physically separate from premises used for other commercial purposes. The second ground was that Costco would not satisfy the implied requirement that the holder of a retail liquor merchant’s licence must sell to the public generally. His Honour did not find it necessary to resolve whether Costco’s intention to stock only 300 lines would preclude the grant of a retail liquor merchant’s licence. Separation of business and premises Costco is unwilling to remodel its store to the extent necessary to satisfy the physical separation requirement. For that reason, unless the discretion referred to in the addendum to s 37(2) is exercised in favour of Costco so as to exempt it from the physical separation requirement, its unwillingness to re-arrange the layout of its store precludes the grant of a retail liquor merchant’s licence. I have found at paragraph 78 below that his Honour correctly concluded that a licensing authority would not exercise the s 37(2) discretion in favour of Costco. Whether sales are made to the public