SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court)
WOOLWORTHS LTD v DRASE COOSIT PTY LTD & ORS
[2010] SASC 13
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice White and The Honourable Justice Kourakis)
9 February 2010
LIQUOR LAW - LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR NEW LICENCE - HEARING OF APPLICATION - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION - REQUIREMENTS OF NEIGHBOURHOOD OR LOCALITY
Licensing Court dismissed an application for a retail liquor merchant's licence for a proposed bottle shop at a brand direct outlet centre - Judge held that the centre was not the relevant 'locality' for the purposes of s 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) - Judge held that applicant had not demonstrated the required demand under s 58(2) - appeal against dismissal of application.
HELD: applicant failed to show that visitors to the centre have an unmet demand for the supply of alcohol for "off premises" consumption - grant of a licence not necessary to satisfy the demand for liquor within the locality, even if the locality comprised only the centre - in any case, the fact that the centre is unique does not necessitate the conclusion that it is the locality for the purposes of s 58(2) - appeal dismissed.
Licensing Act 1967 (SA) s 47(a); Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) s 3, s 23(b), s 53, s 58(2), s 59, s 60, referred to.
Woolies Liquor Stores Pty Ltd v Seaford Rise Tavern (2000) 76 SASR 290, applied.
New York Bar and Grill Pty Ltd v West Paddock Pty Ltd [1998] SASC 7020, distinguished.
Hoban's Glynde Pty Ltd v Firle Hotel Pty Ltd (1973) 4 SASR 503; Lincoln Bottle Shop Pty Ltd v Hamden Hotel Pty Ltd (No 2) (1981) 28 SASR 458; Nepeor Pty Ltd v Liquor Licensing Commission (1987) 46 SASR 205; Woolies Liquor Stores Pty Ltd v Carleton Investments Pty Ltd (1998) 73 SASR 6, discussed.
WOOLWORTHS LTD v DRASE COOSIT PTY LTD & ORS
[2010] SASC 13Full Court: Doyle CJ, White and Kourakis JJ
DOYLE CJ: This is an appeal by leave against a decision of the Licensing Court dismissing an application for a retail liquor merchant’s licence for proposed premises, pursuant to s 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) (“the Act”). The applicant was Woolworths Ltd (“the appellant”). Drase Coosit Pty Ltd (“the respondent”) opposed the grant of the application. There were other objectors in the Licensing Court, who have been joined as respondents to this appeal. Those objectors took no active role in the appeal to this Court.
The appellant is the holder of a sub-underlease relating to a supermarket located within the Harbour Town Shopping Centre. The appellant proposes to establish a walk-in bottle shop separated from the supermarket premises. Although the supermarket is currently operational, modifications will have to be made to it to accommodate the proposed bottle shop. Accordingly, the appellant sought a certificate under s 59 of the Act for the proposed premises.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Woolworths Ltd v Drase Coosit Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] SASC 13
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether the proposed bottle shop was in the relevant locality for the purposes of section 58(2) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA), and whether Woolworths Ltd had demonstrated the required demand for the proposed bottle shop. The appeal hinged on the Court's interpretation of the relevant locality and whether the Court was correct in finding that there was no unmet demand for alcohol on the part of airport employees. The Court considered whether the Judge was entitled to use the absence of evidence of the needs of the employees at the Adelaide Airport to form a basis for a finding that there was no unmet demand on the part of airport employees for alcohol.
The Court of Appeal held that the Judge was right to refuse the application, even though there are no licensed premises in that locality. The Court emphasised that the identification of a locality can rarely be precise, and that the identification of the locality should not result in an artificial approach to the issues posed by section 58(2) of the Act and by its predecessors. The Court of Appeal held that the Judge was right to refuse the application, even though there are no licensed premises in that locality. The Court emphasised that the identification of a locality can rarely be precise, and that the identification of the locality should not result in an artificial approach to the issues posed by section 58(2) of the Act and by its predecessors.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal and affirmed the decision of the Licensing Court dismissing Woolworths Ltd's application for a retail liquor merchant's licence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Mr Walsh submits that, even if the Judge correctly identified the relevant locality, the Judge erred in para [42], which I have set out above. He submits that the Judge was not entitled to use the absence of evidence of the needs of the employees at the Adelaide Airport to form a basis for a finding that there was no unmet demand on the part of airport employees for alcohol. He points to evidence given by one of the needs witnesses called by the appellant that employees of the Adelaide Airport frequent a business that she owns situated in Harbour Town.Consideration of submissions Even if the locality is Harbour Town itself, the Judge was right to refuse the application, even though there are no licensed premises in that locality. The identification of the locality within which there is a demand for liquor, and a consideration of whether other premises in that locality adequately cater for the demand for liquor, have been a part of the process of deciding whether to grant an application for a licence since the enactment of the Licensing Act 1967 (SA) (“the 1967 Act”). But this Court has emphasised that the identification of a locality can rarely be precise, and that the identification of the locality should not result in an artificial approach to the issues posed by s 58(2) of the Act and by its predecessors. In Hoban’s Glynde Pty Ltd v Firle Hotel Pty Ltd (1973) 4 SASR 503 this Court considered the question of how one defines a locality in the context of s 47(a) of the 1967 Act, under which an applicant had to satisfy the Court that “… the licensing of the premises is required for the needs of the public having regard to the licensed premises existing in the locality in which the premises are to be situated”. On that question, in the passage often later referred to with approval, Bray CJ said at 512:I agree that the definition of the relevant locality for the purposes of s 47(a) is often a task of considerable difficulty and that it is impossible to define it by some rule of thumb applicable to all cases. But, after all, the subject of the inquiry is the needs of the public and it would obviously be wrong to consider the need for the proposed licence at the proposed site on the part of that section of the public dwelling in some particular area without also taking into account the ability to satisfy the needs of that section of the public at licensed premises nearer to that particular area than the proposed site. I am inclined to think that either the locality should have been more narrowly defined, in which case there may not have been any significant population increase to be considered, or else that the ability of the Paradise and Reservoir Hotels to cater for the population in the outer area of the locality should also have been taken into account. It cannot be right to define a locality so as to exclude licensed premises capable of serving it and then say that, as those licensed premises are not in the locality, no regard need be had to them. Even if certain licensed premises are not in the locality defined by the Court, their ability to satisfy the needs of that portion of the public which it is claimed need the proposed licence, or part of it, must be relevant to the questions raised by s 47(a). Indeed it may be that the word "locality" should be treated in a much looser and more cavalier fashion without necessarily requiring the definition of a precise area, but I do not pursue the question.