SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court)
MANDAMO PTY LTD & ANOR v CRYSTALCORP DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Justice Duggan, The Honourable Justice Besanko and The Honourable Justice Anderson)
2 July 2004
LIQUOR LAW - LICENSING - APPLICATION FOR NEW LICENCE - HEARING OF APPLICATION - MATTERS FOR CONSIDERATION - WHETHER REQUIRED FOR NEEDS OF PUBLIC
Appeal against grant of hotel licence – whether hotel required for the needs of the public having regard to existing licensed premises in the locality – s58(1) of Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) – whether relevant principles correctly applied – assessment of need against availability of residential licence under s33(1) – no warrant for interference with decision of specialist tribunal – appeal dismissed.
Liquor Licensing Act 1997 (SA) s58(1), s33(1), referred to.
Sailmaster Tavern and Ors v Nemo Nominees Pty Ltd, (Full Court, 20 October 1995, unreported); Nuriootpa Vine Inn and Anor v Licensing Court [1999] SASC 512, applied.
Angler's Inn Hotel/Motel v Taranto (1996) 188 LSJS 321; Cibolini Pty Ltd v Sullivans Hotels Pty Ltd [1999] SASC 326; Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Lindsey Cove Pty Ltd (2002) 81 SASR 337, distinguished.
Lovell v New World Supermarkets Pty Ltd and Anor (1990) 53 SASR 53, considered.
MANDAMO PTY LTD & ANOR v CRYSTALCORP DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
[2004] SASC 193Full Court: Duggan, Besanko and Anderson JJ
DUGGAN J I agree that the appeal should be dismissed for the reasons given by Anderson J. I also agree with the views expressed by Besanko J in his reasons for judgment.
BESANKO J In my opinion, this appeal should be dismissed and I agree with the reasons for judgment of Anderson J.
I wish to make some brief observations on the principal argument advanced by the appellant on the appeal. The appellant submitted that in considering whether an applicant has established that a hotel licence is necessary in order to provide for the needs of the public in the relevant locality, the licensing authority is required to consider if the needs of the public, or at least some of those needs, could be satisfied by the grant of a licence for which proof of need is not a necessary precondition. If at least some of the needs of the public can be satisfied by the grant of another licence, then the question is whether what remains in terms of need is sufficient to justify the granting of a hotel licence.
In this case, the appellant’s argument fails because the findings of the specialist tribunal justify the conclusion that the requirements of s 58(1) of the Liquor Licensing Act 1997 were satisfied. Those findings are set out in the reasons for judgment of Anderson J and I need not repeat them. In addition, I would wish to make the observation that the proposition that regard is to be had to whether the needs of the public, or at least some of those needs, can be satisfied by…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mandamo Pty Ltd v Crystalcorp Developments Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] SASC 193
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The appellant argued that the Licensing Court Judge failed to consider the discretionary principles against granting a licence, such as proliferation and protection from competition. The argument referenced comments made by Doyle CJ in Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Lindsey Cove Pty Ltd, but the court found these comments inapplicable as they were specific to an unusual case. The court emphasised that proliferation and competition would only be decisive factors if the licensing balance was likely to be adversely affected, which was not the case here. Additionally, the appellant suggested that the Licensing Court Judge disregarded evidence about planned upgrades to Angler’s Inn Hotel/Motel. However, the court found that the judge's comments were reasonable, as the upgrades were still in the early stages and no formal plans had been submitted to relevant authorities.
The court dismissed the appeal, concluding that the tribunal's decision was sound and that there was no basis for interfering with the specialist tribunal's assessment. The court upheld the grant of the hotel licence to Crystalcorp Developments Pty Ltd, finding that the existing principles and evidence adequately supported the tribunal's decision. This decision reinforces the importance of considering the totality of evidence and the context in which licensing decisions are made, particularly regarding public need and existing facilities.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: DUGGAN J,
I see nothing inconsistent with the comments made by Debelle J in Angler’s Inn Hotel/Motel and Bleby J in Cibolini. As indicated, I also believe that both those cases are clearly distinguishable from the present case.Proliferation and Protection – The Discretion The appellant also argued that the Licensing Court Judge failed to take into account the discretionary principles against the grant of a licence, being proliferation and protection from competition. It was suggested that the comments of Doyle CJ in Liquorland (Australia) Pty Ltd v Lindsey Cove Pty Ltd (2002) 81 SASR 337 (at 343) supported this argument. In paragraph 31 of that judgment Doyle CJ was rationalising the intention of s 58 in the current legislation. It must be remembered that any comments made by Doyle CJ were in the context of that case which was quite unusual. It was a case in which the operator of a hotel decided to close the bottle shop operation in the hotel to allow for poker machines and then, because there was no longer a bottle shop in the hotel, applied for a new one 200 metres down the road as a free standing retail liquor merchants licence. The comments made by Doyle CJ were made in his discussion of the discretion vested in the Licensing Court to prevent proliferation if the grant of a licence was contrary to the whole legislative scheme which controlled licensing in the State. In any event, those comments must be read having regard to the paragraphs which preceded it and the paragraph which immediately followed it. There is nothing in those comments which causes me to think they should be applied automatically as a final barrier for an applicant to overcome in every application. Clearly matters of proliferation and competition will, in appropriate cases, be an overriding factor in the exercise of a discretion if the balance within the licensing system is likely to be adversely affected. That is not the case here.Angler’s Inn Hotel/Motel – Proposal for Upgrading Mr Costello, counsel for the appellant, suggested that the learned Licensing Court Judge disregarded evidence given by the owners of Angler’s Inn Hotel/Motel as to the situation of their upgrading plans. We were directed by counsel to the learned Licensing Court Judge’s comments (at 3):“The Angler’s Inn Hotel is much better and younger and promises to be, in time, even better still but on my view of it, it currently appeals as a very average facility with quite nice dining and gaming facilities but with no quiet lounge area for a drink and the front bar, which has not been substantially upgraded for years, is quite unattractive. Some of the need witnesses commented likewise. It is not, in my opinion, to be regarded as the contemporary facility being sought by the subject public.” On first reading that passage might indicate that his Honour did not pay sufficient regard to evidence which showed that the owner of the hotel had in fact embarked on some plans to renovate the hotel. In fact some renovations had already taken place. However, the last section of the hotel which had not been attended to was the front bar and any upgrading was probably 12 months away at the time the owner gave evidence. Moreover no plans were actually produced to the court, as is quite often the case, to show how advanced the planned modernisation of that section of the hotel was. There was no application nor any plans which had been lodged with the council or the liquor licensing commissioner for approval. In that context therefore his Honour’s comments as set out above make perfect sense.