Leichhardt Municipal Council v Montgomery

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:    Leichhardt Municipal Council v. Montgomery [2005]  NSWCA 432

FILE NUMBER(S):
41190/04

HEARING DATE(S):             18 November 2005

JUDGMENT DATE:               08/12/2005

PARTIES:
Leichhardt Municipal Council - appellant
Leslie Montgomery - respondent

JUDGMENT OF:      Mason P Hodgson JA McColl JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:             District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):        DC6766/02

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:   Quirk DCJ

COUNSEL:
Mr. P. Garling SC with Mr. R. Sheldon for appellant
Mr. G. Miller QC with Mr. A. Reoch for respondent

SOLICITORS:
Phillips Fox, Sydney for appellant
Teakle Ormsby Conn, Sydney for respondent

CATCHWORDS:
NEGLIGENCE - Road authority's duty of care to pedestrians - Whether such duty is non-delegable when road authority undertakes work involving risk to road users
DAMAGES - Award of buffer - Whether available under s.13 of the Civil Liability Act - Whether primary judge's reasons adequate.

LEGISLATION CITED:
Civil Liability Act 2002, s.13

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 41190/04
DC    6766/02

MASON P
HODGSON JA
McCOLL JA

Thursday 8 December 2005

LEICHHARDT MUNICIPAL COUNCIL  V.  MONTGOMERY

Judgment

  1. MASON P:  I have the benefit of reading in draft the reasons of Hodgson JA.  I agree with them, adding the following comments.

  2. This is the highest “cushion” or “buffer” award that I have encountered.  I would not wish to encourage litigants and trial judges to go down this path in preference to the more difficult, yet exposed, path of reasoning towards an award in the more conventional manner.  From my experience, a buffer or cushion award is usually reserved to the situation where there is a smallish risk that otherwise secure employment prospects may come to an end, in consequence of the tort-related injury, at some distant time in the future.  The present case is not of that nature, although the facts are quite unusual.  They render computation according to the standard method particularly problematical and, from the appellant’s point of view, particularly difficult to challenge on appeal.

  3. An appellant who is unable to point to particular error affecting an assessment of damages for lost earning capacity faces a difficult, though not unsurmountable task (see State of New South Wales v Moss (2000) 54 NSWLR 536).

  4. I observe that the parties were agreed at first instance that it was appropriate for the trial judge to adopt this method of computing damages for future economic loss.  Furthermore, as Hodgson JA points out, a cursory look down the conventional path does not suggest that the award is excessive in its bottom line.

  5. HODGSON JA:  On 1 December 2004, Quirk DCJ gave judgment in proceedings in which the respondent (the plaintiff) had sued the appellant (the Council) and Roan Constructions Pty. Limited (Roan) in respect of injuries suffered from a fall into a pit in a footpath.  The plaintiff had compromised his action against Roan for $50,000.00 inclusive of costs, and the contested hearing had concerned only the plaintiff’s claim against the Council.  The primary judge…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Leichhardt Municipal Council v Montgomery and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 432
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of *Leichhardt Municipal Council v Montgomery*, the plaintiff, Mr. Montgomery, suffered injuries, particularly to his left knee, after falling due to a broken pit cover. The plaintiff alleged that the Leichhardt Municipal Council owed him a non-delegable duty of care as a road authority that had undertaken work involving a risk to road users, and that this duty had been breached. The primary judge found in favour of the plaintiff, determining that the Council was liable for the injuries sustained.

The legal issues before the court concerned whether the Council owed a non-delegable duty of care to pedestrians in relation to road works that posed a risk, and if so, whether that duty had been breached. Additionally, the court was required to consider the assessment of damages, specifically the adequacy of the primary judge's reasons regarding future economic loss and the application of section 13 of the *Civil Liability Act 2002* in determining such awards.

The primary judge found that the Council owed the plaintiff a non-delegable duty of care, relying on the precedent set in *Roads & Traffic Authority v. Scroop*. This duty was found to have been breached, and no contributory negligence was attributed to the plaintiff. In assessing damages, the primary judge found that the plaintiff's severe knee injury, including a ruptured anterior cruciate ligament and torn medial meniscus, was a direct result of the accident, not a subsequent work-related incident. The primary judge awarded damages for past economic loss based on various periods of incapacity and light duties, and addressed future economic loss by referencing section 13 of the *Civil Liability Act 2002*, which mandates that assumptions for future economic loss must accord with the claimant's most likely future circumstances and be adjusted for the percentage possibility of events occurring.

The appeal was dismissed, with the Court upholding the primary judge's decision and awarding costs to the respondent.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the accident, the plaintiff suffered injury particularly to his left knee. He was unable to walk without crutches for about three months, and he re-commenced work on 1 July 2001. He had further time off work between 2 October 2002 and 3 November 2002. He had a fall at work on 18 December 2002, and was off work from that time until 2 May 2003, undergoing a knee operation on 3 February 2003. He was on light duties until 6 October 2003. His work since his return after the knee operation has been restricted to clerical work. He was still working at the time of the trial. DECISION OF PRIMARY JUDGE The primary judge referred to the plaintiff’s evidence “that there was a piece of the pit cover missing”; and she found that it was most likely that the pit cover was broken at the time when Roan placed the carpet over it, and that “the carpet was covering the hole at the time that the plaintiff fell”. The primary judge found that the Council owed the plaintiff a non-delegable duty of care, following Roads & Traffic Authority v. Scroop (1998) 28 MVR 233; and she found that this duty was breached. She found no contributory negligence by the plaintiff. On damages, the primary judge noted there was no dispute that the plaintiff suffered a severe injury to his knee. She found he ruptured his anterior cruciate ligament and tore his medial meniscus; and she found that the surgery was required as a result of this injury, not the second work-related incident on 18 December 2002. She found the plaintiff had pain and discomfort and restrictions in his activities, which could only get worse in the future; and she assessed his non-economic loss as 30% of a most extreme case. As regards past-economic loss, she found the plaintiff was unable to return to work after the accident until 1 July 2001, and found he was again unable to work between 2 October 2002 and 3 November 2002 and between 18 December 2002 and 2 May 2003, and that he was on light duties from 2 May 2003 to 6 October 2003. She awarded damages at the rate of $750.00 per week for the first of these periods, $850.00 per week for the second, $1000.00 per week for the third and $500.00 per week for the fourth. Although apparently the plaintiff was paid workers’ compensation in respect of the period after 18 December 2002, the primary judge found that the need for surgery and thus the time off work after 18 December 2002 was due to the subject accident, and not the minor aggravation at work. As regards future economic loss, the primary judge referred to s.13 of the Civil Liability Act 2002, which is as follows:13 Future economic loss - claimant’s prospects and adjustments(1) A court cannot make an award of damages for future economic loss unless the claimant first satisfies the court that the assumptions about future earning capacity or other events on which the award is to be based accord with the claimant’s most likely future circumstances but for the injury.(2) When a court determines the amount of any such award of damages for future economic loss it is required to adjust the amount of damages for future economic loss that would have been sustained on those assumptions by reference to the percentage possibility that the events might have occurred but for the injury.(3) If the court makes an award for future economic loss, it is required to state the assumptions on which the award was based and the relevant percentage by which damages were adjusted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.