Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Fowler

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER v FOWLER

[2020] SASCFC 65

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Parker and The Honourable Justice Bleby)

2 July 2020

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES

Appeal against the order of a Judge of this Court allowing, subject to strict conditions, the respondent, who is a bankrupt, to continue to engage in legal practice as a principal and to hold trust monies.

The respondent provided notification of a show cause event constituted by the presentation of a Creditor’s Petition, pursuant to s 20AH(2)(a) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) (the Legal Practitioners Act). On the Supreme Court being notified of a show cause event it may, pursuant to s 20AI, amend, suspend or cancel a practising certificate if it is not satisfied that the practitioner is a fit and proper person to hold a practising certificate.

The appellant’s grounds of appeal can be summarised as follows:

1.  That the Judge erred by failing to impose conditions preventing the respondent from practising as a principal and from operating a trust account, and that the conditions imposed by the Judge were inadequate to protect the public and maintain public confidence (grounds 3.1.1, 3.1.2, 3.1.5 and 3.1.7).

2.  That the Judge reversed the onus of proof and erred in not requiring the respondent to discharge the onus of establishing that he was a fit and proper person to hold a practising certificate subject to conditions (ground 3.1.3).

3.  That the Judge did not have due regard to the role of the appellant and intervener in relation to the respondent’s notification of a show cause event (ground 3.1.4).

4.  That some of the conditions are unenforceable against the respondent and govern the conduct of third parties (ground 3.1.6).

5.  That the Judge failed to have due regard to ‘the previously consistent approach of this Court in relation to bankrupt legal practitioners and their access to control of trust accounts and trust money’ (ground 3.1.8).

6.  That the Judge gave insufficient weight to a number of considerations (ground 3.1.9).

7.  That the Judge erred in concluding that the respondent’s ‘honesty or dishonesty is a paramount consideration when assessing fitness to practise and future risk, thereby affording insufficient weight to other considerations, and in particular the … lack of candour in affidavit evidence presented to the Court’ (ground 3.1.10).

Held per Kourakis CJ (Parker and Bleby JJ agreeing), dismissing the appeal:

1. The power to amend a practising certificate pursuant to s 20AI of the Legal Practitioners Act is, or at least includes, a power to impose conditions if the Court ‘is satisfied that the practitioners would be a fit and proper person to practise in accordance with those conditions’.

2.  Grounds 3.1.1, 3.1.2, 3.1.5 and 3.1.7, because the appellant eschewed any complaint that the Judge’s exercise of discretion…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Fowler and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASCFC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner appealed a decision of a single judge who had granted Mr. Fowler, a legal practitioner, permission to continue practising with a trust account despite his bankruptcy. The dispute concerned whether Mr. Fowler was a fit and proper person to hold a practising certificate authorising him to operate a trust account, given his past financial difficulties and the circumstances surrounding the appointment of a supervisor to his trust account in 2009.

The court was required to determine whether the primary judge erred in finding that Mr. Fowler was a fit and proper person to practise with a trust account, notwithstanding his bankruptcy. Specifically, the appeal raised questions about whether the judge had given sufficient weight to the irregularities in Mr. Fowler's trust account management prior to his bankruptcy and whether Mr. Fowler had demonstrated sufficient candour in his dealings with the Law Society.

The Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia dismissed the appeal. The court reasoned that while dishonesty would have been a significant impediment to Mr. Fowler continuing to practise with a trust account, the judge had not found him to be dishonest. The court found that the judge had properly considered all relevant factors, including the past irregularities and Mr. Fowler's subsequent conduct, which included diligent adherence to trust accounting procedures and the absence of significant irregularities identified by auditors since 2011. The court also found that the judge had not drawn adverse inferences regarding Mr. Fowler's candour that were contended for by the Commissioner.

The appeal was dismissed, and permission to appeal was granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

A sequestration order was made on 5 June 2018.Background Mr Fowler was admitted to practise in 2001. He established his own practice in Port Lincoln on 1 July 2007, but closed that practice in March 2009. In May 2009, Mr Fowler admitted to an officer at the Law Society that he often failed to answer his telephone to avoid creditors, that his bank had frozen all of his accounts, and that he had lost his trust account cheque book. Following an exchange of emails between Mr Fowler and the Law Society on 15 May 2009, Mr Fowler consented to the appointment of a supervisor to the trust account of his practice. On 22 June 2009, the Council of the Law Society appointed a supervisor to Mr Fowler’s trust account. The information on which the Law Society acted is set out in a memorandum from an officer employed in its Professional Standards section dated 18 June 2009. From that memorandum, it appears that Mr Fowler notified Professional Standards on 16 March 2009 that he was closing his practice due to debts, and transferring his files to another firm. On 1 May 2009, Mr Fowler advised Professional Standards that his bank had frozen his accounts, and he mistakenly informed Professional Standards that they had also closed the trust account. However, he explained that he had continued to produce, electronically, trust cheques for payments to clients when required. In May and June 2009, some of Mr Fowler’s clients contacted the Law Society with queries about refunds of trust money. It was not known precisely what those queries were, and whether or not they were in the nature of complaints. The memorandum noted that it had not been possible to reconcile the trust account bank statement but, importantly, noted that ‘[i]t appeared that there was more money held in trust than had been accounted for – not a deficit’. The memorandum identified the following irregularities:·The latest trial balance on the trust account was dated 19 March 2009 but few trust account records had been maintained since that date even though the bank statements showed a number of transactions.·No reconciliation had been done since February.·There was an amount standing to the credit of the practice in the Legal Practitioners Combined Trust Account, but Mr Fowler was not aware of that.·Mr Fowler had mislaid the trust account cheque book and could therefore only generate cheques using an accounting program to which he had limited access (it later transpired that the cheque book had been packed into a packing box).·There had been an incomplete provision of trust account records to the solicitor who had taken over files.·It was not possible on the available records to reconcile the trust account. The memorandum noted that a manager of the practice was not required because the Professional Standards section of the Law Society was satisfied that the practitioner who had taken over the files was competent to do so. In the period of time in which Mr Fowler was closing down his office, some firm account cheques were dishonoured. However, it transpired that a reason for their dishonour was, as the memorandum of the Professional Standards section noticed, there was a surplus in the trust account because payments into Mr Fowler’s firm account, for work done, had not been made.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

If Mr Fowler had been shown to be dishonest, then it was almost inevitable that he would not be allowed to continue to practise with a trust account. The Judge was not suggesting the converse – that because Mr Fowler was not dishonest other considerations weighing against allowing him a trust account should be relegated to secondary considerations. The contention that the Judge gave insufficient weight to other considerations is, as I have explained on many occasions already, not a vitiating error. As to Mr Fowler’s alleged lack of candour, the Judge did not draw the inferences contended for by the Commissioner. I repeat my reasons in [66] above. This ground must be dismissed.Conclusion Insofar as permission is necessary, I would grant permission but I would dismiss the appeal. PARKER J: I would grant permission to appeal but would dismiss the appeal. I agree with the reasons of the Chief Justice. BLEBY J: For the reasons given by the Chief Justice, I would grant permission to appeal but dismiss the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Judge then summarised the position of Mr Fowler’s practice leading up to, and after, his bankruptcy:[11]·Mr Fowler terminated the employment of his two remaining staff in October 2017.·Mr Fowler paid out his residual practice debts by late 2018.·Mr Fowler continues to work from a home office in the central business district of Adelaide, but visits Port Lincoln on one day every two or three weeks and Port Augusta on one day during the weeks he is not visiting Port Lincoln.·Mr Fowler has paid close attention to the correct trust accounting procedures to be followed. The same auditor or external examiner has conducted trust account audits and examinations from and including the financial year ending 30 June 2011 and no irregularities of significance concerning the operation of and recording requirements relating to the trust account have been identified. ·Operating a trust account is of central importance to the viability of Mr Fowler’s practice which has embraced, since 1 July 2018, property law and conveyancing files (38 per cent), wills and estate planning files (22 per cent), family law files (11 per cent), general commercial files (11 per cent), deceased estates files (9 per cent) and civil disputes files (9 per cent). ·Mr Fowler’s forecast earnings for the 2018/2019 financial year are $48,575 based on an actual net profit to 2 February 2019 of $27,724. After taking into account significant one-off expenses, Mr Fowler’s estimate of net profit for that financial year is in the order of $75,000. Mr Fowler estimates his unpaid tax liability for the 2017/2018 financial year at zero and has deposed to being up to date with his Business Activity Statements payments. ·Mr Fowler’s estimated client income for the next 12 months is $158,709, non‑supervision practice expenses of $73,040 and supervision expenses of $28,344, leaving a net profit anticipated for the ensuing 12-month period of $57,325. This projection does not appear to have allowed for a taxation expense. If the net profit of $57,325 were to represent his taxable income for the next 12 months he would be left with an after-tax income of approximately $46,500.[12] ·The total estimated cost of the additional supervision is between $25,944 and $28,344 for the first year of operation and between $24,844 and $27,244 for the second year of operation. [11] The Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) Re Duncan James Fowler, A Practitioner [2019] SASC 64 at [43]-[50].[12] The Judge at [48] noted ‘This is to be compared with his current drawings of approximately $25,000 per annum which, as the intervenors submit, are extremely modest. It is questionable that the practitioner will be able to maintain such a level of austerity over the longer term’.Relevant considerations In Re Jenner, Debelle J explained the nature and purpose of the Court’s review of a bankrupt’s entitlement to practise:[13] [2]The jurisdiction of the court to permit a bankrupt to practise must be exercised with considerable circumspection. The overriding consideration must be the public interest, that is to say, the protection of the public. The public confidence in the administration of justice must be maintained. The court must have regard to the interests of those members of the public whose clients will consult the legal practitioner. The court must ensure so far as lies within its power that the practitioner is a fit and proper person to practise notwithstanding the bankruptcy or intended bankruptcy. There is another aspect of the public interest to consider. It is to do what is reasonably possible for the purpose of enabling the practitioner to earn an income so that the practitioner may be in a better financial position to discharge the debts due to creditors. …[3]… It is necessary, therefore, to examine the circumstances in which the person has become bankrupt for the purpose of determining whether those circumstances disclose conduct which is inconsistent with fitness to practise. The purpose of an inquiry under s 49 is not to discipline the practitioner. The Legal Practitioners Act makes separate provision for discipline of a legal practitioner. The purpose of an inquiry under s 49 is to determine whether, notwithstanding the bankruptcy or intended bankruptcy, the legal practitioner is a fit and proper person to practise.[4]… the court must take care not to rely unduly on conditions. It must first decide whether the applicant is, notwithstanding the bankruptcy, a fit and proper person. The primary consideration should be whether the legal practitioner has the qualities which equip the practitioner to provide sound legal advice and proper legal representation to members of the public. The conditions may relate to such issues as assistance or supervision of the legal practitioner in relation to his financial affairs or the management of his practice.[13] (2007) 250 LSJS 74 at [2]-[4].