Lind v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

LIND v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER

[2022] SASC 20

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Blue  

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - PRACTISING CERTIFICATES

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES - LAWYERS - QUALIFICATIONS AND ADMISSION - FIT AND PROPER PERSONS

The applicant filed affidavits in March 2016 giving notice and providing a written statement in respect of a show cause event under subsection 20AH(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA). The show cause event comprised 23 “tax offences” within the meaning of the Act, namely failing to lodge an income tax return in respect of the years ended 30 June 2009 to 30 June 2014 and failing to lodge a Business Activity Statement containing Goods and Services Tax (GST) information in respect of the quarters ended 31 December 2010 to 31 December 2014.

Between May 2017 and June 2021 there were a series of hearings during which the Court monitored, amongst other things, Ms Lind’s progress in relation to resolution of claims by the Australian Taxation Office for payment of tax and ongoing lodgement of income tax and BAS returns. Over much of this period the practitioner did not lodge BAS or income tax returns on time; the resolution of the tax debt claims by the practitioner was protracted; and the practitioner did not for various reasons comply on time with orders by the Court for filing material or providing information.

The question is whether the Court should make orders under section 20AI of the Act suspending or imposing conditions on the practitioner’s practising certificate.

Held:

1The practitioner is not a fit and proper person to practice under an unconditional practising certificate but is fit and proper to practise under a conditional practising certificate under conditions including that she practise only as a consultant to a law firm (at [96]).

2An order should be made under section 20AI imposing conditions on the practitioner’s practising certificate that she practise only as a consultant to Bellman Lawyers and on other conditions agreed between the parties in the event the Court were to make such an order (at [97]).

Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner v Fowler (2020) 136 SASR 252; The Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) re David Peter Andrew Moen [2018] SASC 136; The Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) Re Duncan James Fowler, A Practitioner [2019] SASC 64, considered.

LIND v LEGAL PROFESSION CONDUCT COMMISSIONER
[2022] SASC 20

  1. BLUE J: The applicant, Katrina Lind, filed affidavits in March 2016 giving notice and providing a written statement in respect of a show cause event under subsection 20AH(2) of the Legal Practitioners Act 1981 (SA) (the Act). The show cause event comprised 23 “tax offences” within the meaning of the Act, namely failing to lodge an income tax return in respect of the years ended 30 June 2009 to 30 June 2014[1] and failing to lodge a Business Activity Statement (BAS) containing Goods and Services Tax (GST) information in respect of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lind v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lind v Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner involved Ms Lind, a legal practitioner admitted in 1986, who faced allegations of unprofessional conduct that called into question her fitness to hold a practising certificate. The central issues were whether Ms Lind was a fit and proper person to hold a practising certificate and, if not, whether her certificate should be suspended or amended to impose conditions. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether conditions should be imposed on Ms Lind’s practising certificate that she practise only as a consultant.

The court evaluated Ms Lind’s history, which included delays in administering an estate, failure to lodge income tax returns for several years, and a lack of responsiveness to inquiries and complaints. These actions were deemed to reflect poorly on her fitness to practice law. The court found that while Ms Lind was not fit to hold an unconditional practising certificate, she could be fit to practice under conditions. It was concluded that imposing conditions on her practising certificate, including that she practise only as a consultant to Bellman Lawyers under a consultancy agreement, would be appropriate. This decision was based on the need to ensure public protection and maintain the integrity of the legal profession.

The court ordered that Ms Lind's practising certificate should be subject to conditions, including that she enter into an exclusive consultancy agreement with Ronald David Windevere Bellman of Bellman Lawyers. The conditions also included requirements for supervision, reporting, compliance with taxation obligations, and regular updates to regulatory bodies. Ms Lind was also required to notify the relevant authorities of the commencement and cessation of her consultancy agreement and to submit periodic reports on her practice. These measures were intended to ensure that Ms Lind's practice would be closely monitored and compliant with professional standards.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held:

1 The practitioner is not a fit and proper person to practice under an unconditional practising certificate but is fit and proper to practise under a conditional practising certificate under conditions including that she practise only as a consultant to a law firm (at [96]).

2 An order should be made under section 20AI imposing conditions on the practitioner’s practising certificate that she practise only as a consultant to Bellman Lawyers and on other conditions agreed between the parties in the event the Court were to make such an order (at [97]).

Background

Background to the litigation

The ultimate issues are whether:·Ms Lind has shown that she is a fit and proper person to hold a practising certificate and, if not, whether her practising certificate should be suspended or amended to impose conditions under subsection 20AI(1)(b) of the Act; and·conditions should be imposed on Ms Lind’s practising certificate that she practise only as a consultant under subsection 20AI(1a) of the Act.Background Ms Lind was born in 1962. She was admitted as a legal practitioner in 1986. She was then employed by Poveys and then successively in other legal firms. She specialised initially in commercial litigation and then also in family law. In about 1998 Ms Lind acquired an interest in a company operating a hotel in Port Adelaide, which she retained until 2013. At some stage she became a director of that company, which I infer continued until 2013. Ms Lind also had an interest in a property partnership that owned the hotel premises. Ms Lind apparently did not receive any income as a result of her interest in the hotel or land. She sustained losses either in respect of her interest in the hotel or land or in a subsequent hotel referred to at [27] below. The losses were able to be carried forward for tax purposes. In 1999 Ms Lind and Ronald Bellman commenced practising as solicitors in partnership under the name Windevere Bellman. Ms Lind practised in family law, wills and estates and commercial matters. The partnership continued until it was dissolved with effect on 30 June 2010 as a result of disciplinary proceedings that by then had been brought against Ms Lind (referred to below). In 2000 a person who had worked as a legal secretary at Poveys when Ms Lind had been employed at Poveys died. The secretary named Ms Lind as an executor in her will. Probate was not obtained for 14 months. This was because Ms Lind gave priority to other work. Thereafter, Ms Lind took very few steps to administer the estate. She ultimately instituted a misguided action on behalf of the estate against a builder and then took few steps to advance that action. Solicitors for the secretary’s father wrote letters to Ms Lind, to which she did not reply. The father complained to the Legal Practitioners Conduct Board, which wrote letters to Ms Lind, to many of which she did not reply. In 2010 the Conduct Board laid a charge of unprofessional conduct against Ms Lind in the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal. After dissolution of the partnership with Mr Bellman in June 2010, Ms Lind commenced practising as a sole practitioner from her home. In general, she only had a limited number of files and worked less than 40 hours per week. Ms Lind has since about 2006 retained a firm of accountants, Bentleys, to lodge her income tax returns. Her income tax return for the year ended 30 June 2009 was due for lodgement in the first half of 2010. She failed to lodge this return (or provide instructions and information to Bentleys to do so) and thereafter over the next five years she failed to lodge a tax return for the years up to and including the year ended 30 June 2014.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is appropriate to make an order that conditions be imposed on Ms Lind’s practising certificate in the terms agreed between the parties in the event the Court were to determine that conditions should be imposed. Those conditions are set out in the proposed order below.Conclusion Ms Lind has not demonstrated that she is a fit and proper person to hold an unlimited unconditional practising certificate. However, she has demonstrated that she is a fit and proper person to hold a conditional practising certificate containing the conditions set out below. Subject to hearing the parties, I will make the following orders:1The Practitioner shall within fourteen (14) days from the date of this order enter into an exclusive consultancy agreement with Ronald David Windevere Bellman, Principal of Bellman Lawyers (Consultancy Agreement). 2From the date of this order until further order conditions are imposed upon the Practitioner’s current practising certificate, and on any subsequent certificate that is issued to her, as follows:(a)The Practitioner may practise only as a consultant to Bellman Lawyers within the terms of the Consultancy Agreement, which shall be exclusive as between the Practitioner and Bellman Lawyers. (b)In her practice as a consultant pursuant to the Consultancy Agreement the Practitioner will be subject to supervision by legal practitioner, Ronald David Windevere Bellman. (c)The Practitioner must notify the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and the Law Society of South Australia in writing of the commencement of the Consultancy Agreement and of the Consultancy Agreement coming to an end or ceasing to operate, such notification to be provided within seven (7) days of the commencement or cessation of the Consultancy Agreement.(d)The Practitioner must comply with all taxation obligations, including but not limited to the filing of Business Activity Statements and Income Tax Returns with the Australian Taxation Office.(e)The Practitioner must provide to the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and the Law Society of South Australia proof of lodgement of all Business Activity Statements and Income Tax Returns within seven (7) days of lodgement together with reasons for any delay in lodgement.(f)The Practitioner must provide such information in relation to her practice of the law as may be reasonably required from time to time by the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner or the Law Society of South Australia. (g)The Practitioner must provide to the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and to the Law Society of South Australia by no later than 8 September 2022, and thereafter at intervals of 6 months, a written report from Ronald David Windevere Bellman about the Practitioner’s practice during the reporting period including:(i) details of the areas of law in which the Practitioner has practised;(ii) the number of client matters that the Practitioner has conducted, or assisted with, including any matters in which the Practitioner has acted as a mentor or supervisor to another legal practitioner;(iii) the average number of hours that the Practitioner has reported to Mr Bellman as having worked each week;(iv) details of any complaints about delay by the Practitioner made either to the Practitioner directly or to Bellman Lawyers; and (v) any concerns that Mr Bellman has, or has had, as Principal of Bellman Lawyers, regarding the Practitioner’s conduct of client matters or of any issues that have impacted on the Practitioner’s ability to practise and/or to comply with her professional obligations.(h)Within fourteen (14) days of the termination of the Consultancy Agreement Ronald David Windevere Bellman provide to the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and to the Law Society of South Australia a final report about the Practitioner’s practice since the previous report, if any, and incorporating the matters identified at paragraphs (g)(i) to (v) above. 3Any application by the Practitioner to discharge or vary the conditions imposed by this order, including but not limited to an application to practise other than in accordance with the Consultancy Agreement, must be made with notice to the Legal Profession Conduct Commissioner and to the Law Society of South Australia and must be supported by affidavit. 4Liberty to the parties to apply.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.